Billium813 wrote: »
how does people having fun with oakensoul and lightning staves affect your fun that you clearly like to have in a different way?
Billium813 wrote: »
how does people having fun with oakensoul and lightning staves affect your fun that you clearly like to have in a different way?
This is not a single player game, even though a lot of people seem to think it is, and for the record if oakensoul were to get the pale order treatment that would be a solution but as long as we have it in group content where it is giving an unfair advantage to people, then people will continue complaining.
i never said it was a single player game? oakensoul has made it easier for me to do harder content group content and solo content.
and i thought higher damage was desirable in group content?
Don't worry guys, the new mythic that gets rid of LAs this time is going to kill Oakensoul... by being much more broken than it.
I don't think you understand how buffs work... Dreugh king is a trash set as it gives an easily available buff that can be obtained with potions, oaken soul, skills etc... Also it's not 20% increased damage, it's 20% increased spell and weapon damage, which in turn are stats used to calculate the skills damage but in reality it's not actually a 20% increase.
Billium813 wrote: »
how does people having fun with oakensoul and lightning staves affect your fun that you clearly like to have in a different way?
This is not a single player game, even though a lot of people seem to think it is, and for the record if oakensoul were to get the pale order treatment that would be a solution but as long as we have it in group content where it is giving an unfair advantage to people, then people will continue complaining.
i never said it was a single player game? oakensoul has made it easier for me to do harder content group content and solo content.
and i thought higher damage was desirable in group content?
I believe the mention of gorup content here comes into play as it removes some of the interactions between players and essentially grants single-player experience in a group setting.
Perhaps you encountered such groups yourself: Where instead of a singular unit you have 4 soloplayers doing the content at their own pace.
Skullstachio wrote: »Just my 2 cents from an apocryphal standpoint.
It would seem that "A" problem is not entirely just the combination of Storm Master and Sergeant's mail combed together, but with the 100% empower uptime from the oakensoul ring (the ring is also not the problem) it would be this: Empower needs to be slightly dialed back a bit.
I honestly wouldn't mind it being reduced to 50% but at the same time, this buff is also even more dangerous when taking "off-balance" into account which increases the targets heavy attack damage taken by another whopping 70% which pushes the numbers through the roof (especially with certain CP Skill allocations such as master at arms and others.)
So one plausible solution would be to reduce the empower buffs heavy attack damage boost from 80% to 50%, but increase heavy attack damage done to "off-balance" targets from 70% to 100% (maybe 90% as a balance safety net.).
It is a good idea as off-balance only lasts a short time and once expired, the target becomes immune to being off-balance for a long time like it does already, that way all builds regardless of armor sets are on somewhat equal footing surrounding this situation, the empower buff gets pulled back a bit, and oakensoul doesn't have to get shafted.(again.)
FrancisCrawford wrote: »Billium813 wrote: »
how does people having fun with oakensoul and lightning staves affect your fun that you clearly like to have in a different way?
This is not a single player game, even though a lot of people seem to think it is, and for the record if oakensoul were to get the pale order treatment that would be a solution but as long as we have it in group content where it is giving an unfair advantage to people, then people will continue complaining.
i never said it was a single player game? oakensoul has made it easier for me to do harder content group content and solo content.
and i thought higher damage was desirable in group content?
I believe the mention of gorup content here comes into play as it removes some of the interactions between players and essentially grants single-player experience in a group setting.
Perhaps you encountered such groups yourself: Where instead of a singular unit you have 4 soloplayers doing the content at their own pace.
I'm trying to think of one case in which I've done a dungeon and relied on a buff that I can't now get from Oakensoul instead. I'm drawing a blank. DEBUFFS in my experience are commonly achieved through teamwork, e.g. Major Breach, Minor Breach, Minor Magickasteal and others. But buffs? Whether I'm PUGging or duoing, that doesn't happen .. except perhaps for the buffs specifically left out of Oakensoul, such as the class-specific Minors, or Major Force.
There are a couple of cases of buffs I handed out myself -- but I'd generally stopped with those anyway. E.g., Oakensoul conflicts with the buffs from Combat Prayer. But I'd pretty much stopped using Combat Prayer in dungeons after the Minor Berserk nerf. It's also been a long time since I tried giving a group Major Resolve via the Warden skill.
I don't think you understand how buffs work... Dreugh king is a trash set as it gives an easily available buff that can be obtained with potions, oaken soul, skills etc... Also it's not 20% increased damage, it's 20% increased spell and weapon damage, which in turn are stats used to calculate the skills damage but in reality it's not actually a 20% increase.
I think, perhaps you might be unaware of how people like or choose to use buffs. Dreugh King is very much not trash for certain play. I don't like wasting a pot slot for savagery so I prefer other means. I've been known to wear Dreugh King so i can guzzle unstoppable pots with health which work better for me. And I like that bit of expedition for free. Much like I prefer rattlecage over camo hunter. This is not zero sum. Its what suits the individual player.
It is the new OP overshadowing the old. But bombing a forest fire wont preserve the tree's.
FrancisCrawford wrote: »Billium813 wrote: »
how does people having fun with oakensoul and lightning staves affect your fun that you clearly like to have in a different way?
This is not a single player game, even though a lot of people seem to think it is, and for the record if oakensoul were to get the pale order treatment that would be a solution but as long as we have it in group content where it is giving an unfair advantage to people, then people will continue complaining.
i never said it was a single player game? oakensoul has made it easier for me to do harder content group content and solo content.
and i thought higher damage was desirable in group content?
I believe the mention of gorup content here comes into play as it removes some of the interactions between players and essentially grants single-player experience in a group setting.
Perhaps you encountered such groups yourself: Where instead of a singular unit you have 4 soloplayers doing the content at their own pace.
I'm trying to think of one case in which I've done a dungeon and relied on a buff that I can't now get from Oakensoul instead. I'm drawing a blank. DEBUFFS in my experience are commonly achieved through teamwork, e.g. Major Breach, Minor Breach, Minor Magickasteal and others. But buffs? Whether I'm PUGging or duoing, that doesn't happen .. except perhaps for the buffs specifically left out of Oakensoul, such as the class-specific Minors, or Major Force.
There are a couple of cases of buffs I handed out myself -- but I'd generally stopped with those anyway. E.g., Oakensoul conflicts with the buffs from Combat Prayer. But I'd pretty much stopped using Combat Prayer in dungeons after the Minor Berserk nerf. It's also been a long time since I tried giving a group Major Resolve via the Warden skill.
That sort of aligns with my initial statement of ongoing simplification in the game, I would say wouldnt it?
But your right the TLDR is buffs are to be ignored entire and debuffs are still somewhat relevant - that is to say that mostly pen debuffs are still relevant and in the advent of the new patch and mythic's that comes with it ESO sways further in the direction of dumbing things down as depending on tuning the next mythic will remove the relevance of pen-debuffs.
Ignoring the dps site, can someone that defends oalensoul come up with a reason why a dps player should get all the different tank buffs? This is really the biggest strength of oakensoul. The empower you can just get from mages guild. I can tank vet trials doing 100k dps atm.
Ignoring the dps site, can someone that defends oalensoul come up with a reason why a dps player should get all the different tank buffs? This is really the biggest strength of oakensoul. The empower you can just get from mages guild. I can tank vet trials doing 100k dps atm.
Accesibility!
Not the noob/bad player one. The ppl with disabilities one. And for them a bit more defense is crucial. Dead players do no damage..
Microsoft bought zenimax. And MS is pretty hardcore on accessibility. They have website and believe even hotline for it.
Just count the nunber of accessivikity improvements that got added UI and otherwise since the vuyout. Not a coincidence.
Directive came from up top. Like above boss zos top. And every top level end game player quitting wont change it. Neither will thousandss of posts in this and other threads...
Company policy. Best make peace with it.
here is a great example
vSCP HM SOLO
Do you really think someone who isn't already good at the game can just throw on an oaken build and do this?
Vet SCP HM solo is not specifically tied to one bar builds. Two bar setup is actually doing better job there since it offers more tools to Your disposal and ring of the pale order is better there than oakensoul anyway and dungeon itself is not that hard. If I remember correctly @luchtt even soloed trifecta there with two bar setup.
Fact that SPC can be soloed with oakensoul really doesn't bring anything into one bar heavy attack builds discossion.
that's my point. people who can do crazy things like 3 minute vAS HM clears with oakensoul can already do 3 minute vAS HM clears.
people who can't clear vAS HM won't suddenly be able to just master all the mechanics because of oakensoul. for anyone who can already do 100k dps on a dummy it's going to make almost no difference. for those who can't it'll help, but they still need to master the mechanics.
it's not giving out free IR or godslayer runs.
There is a very, very small subset of people who have the reflexes and ability to do HM mechanics but don't have the ability to master dps rotations.
Anyone who gets 75k on a two bar build who suddenly gets 85k on a HA build isn't going to magically learn the skills and disciple to get into flare and drop hoarfrost and not wipe the group in vCR+3.
I don't see how it devalues any of the current content or achivements.
I believe you are missunderstanding - you dont need reflexes to do the mechanics as you are tanky enough to ignore them for the most part. And yes it is absolutely giving out free titles. Those people who are adequatly prepared to do the raid without setup have to put in a far grander amount of effort to achiev the same or lesser results. Lots of the people that now clear with the time you mentioned have infact not done it with that time before. A simple check on the consistency of their representation on the scoreboard will back up my argument here.
Ignoring the dps site, can someone that defends oalensoul come up with a reason why a dps player should get all the different tank buffs? This is really the biggest strength of oakensoul. The empower you can just get from mages guild. I can tank vet trials doing 100k dps atm.
Accesibility!
Not the noob/bad player one. The ppl with disabilities one. And for them a bit more defense is crucial. Dead players do no damage..
Microsoft bought zenimax. And MS is pretty hardcore on accessibility. They have website and believe even hotline for it.
Just count the nunber of accessivikity improvements that got added UI and otherwise since the vuyout. Not a coincidence.
Directive came from up top. Like above boss zos top. And every top level end game player quitting wont change it. Neither will thousandss of posts in this and other threads...
Company policy. Best make peace with it.
Thats not it. It is not an accesibility feature as the sum total of the setup is an accident.
nokturnihs wrote: »here is a great example
vSCP HM SOLO
Do you really think someone who isn't already good at the game can just throw on an oaken build and do this?
Vet SCP HM solo is not specifically tied to one bar builds. Two bar setup is actually doing better job there since it offers more tools to Your disposal and ring of the pale order is better there than oakensoul anyway and dungeon itself is not that hard. If I remember correctly @luchtt even soloed trifecta there with two bar setup.
Fact that SPC can be soloed with oakensoul really doesn't bring anything into one bar heavy attack builds discossion.
that's my point. people who can do crazy things like 3 minute vAS HM clears with oakensoul can already do 3 minute vAS HM clears.
people who can't clear vAS HM won't suddenly be able to just master all the mechanics because of oakensoul. for anyone who can already do 100k dps on a dummy it's going to make almost no difference. for those who can't it'll help, but they still need to master the mechanics.
it's not giving out free IR or godslayer runs.
There is a very, very small subset of people who have the reflexes and ability to do HM mechanics but don't have the ability to master dps rotations.
Anyone who gets 75k on a two bar build who suddenly gets 85k on a HA build isn't going to magically learn the skills and disciple to get into flare and drop hoarfrost and not wipe the group in vCR+3.
I don't see how it devalues any of the current content or achivements.
I believe you are missunderstanding - you dont need reflexes to do the mechanics as you are tanky enough to ignore them for the most part. And yes it is absolutely giving out free titles. Those people who are adequatly prepared to do the raid without setup have to put in a far grander amount of effort to achiev the same or lesser results. Lots of the people that now clear with the time you mentioned have infact not done it with that time before. A simple check on the consistency of their representation on the scoreboard will back up my argument here.
Those of us with disabilities have to put in far more effort than those "adequately prepared" individuals you mentioned just to meaningfully participate harder content to begin with. The question is which group should receive new disadvantages in the form of nerfs? Do neither deserve them? Why is that so threatening to some of the player base?
Ignoring the dps site, can someone that defends oalensoul come up with a reason why a dps player should get all the different tank buffs? This is really the biggest strength of oakensoul. The empower you can just get from mages guild. I can tank vet trials doing 100k dps atm.
Accesibility!
Not the noob/bad player one. The ppl with disabilities one. And for them a bit more defense is crucial. Dead players do no damage..
Microsoft bought zenimax. And MS is pretty hardcore on accessibility. They have website and believe even hotline for it.
Just count the nunber of accessivikity improvements that got added UI and otherwise since the vuyout. Not a coincidence.
Directive came from up top. Like above boss zos top. And every top level end game player quitting wont change it. Neither will thousandss of posts in this and other threads...
Company policy. Best make peace with it.
Thats not it. It is not an accesibility feature as the sum total of the setup is an accident.
Sure is not an accident...
Ignoring the dps site, can someone that defends oalensoul come up with a reason why a dps player should get all the different tank buffs? This is really the biggest strength of oakensoul. The empower you can just get from mages guild. I can tank vet trials doing 100k dps atm.
Accesibility!
Not the noob/bad player one. The ppl with disabilities one. And for them a bit more defense is crucial. Dead players do no damage..
Microsoft bought zenimax. And MS is pretty hardcore on accessibility. They have website and believe even hotline for it.
Just count the nunber of accessivikity improvements that got added UI and otherwise since the vuyout. Not a coincidence.
Directive came from up top. Like above boss zos top. And every top level end game player quitting wont change it. Neither will thousandss of posts in this and other threads...
Company policy. Best make peace with it.
Ignoring the dps site, can someone that defends oalensoul come up with a reason why a dps player should get all the different tank buffs? This is really the biggest strength of oakensoul. The empower you can just get from mages guild. I can tank vet trials doing 100k dps atm.
Accesibility!
Not the noob/bad player one. The ppl with disabilities one. And for them a bit more defense is crucial. Dead players do no damage..
Microsoft bought zenimax. And MS is pretty hardcore on accessibility. They have website and believe even hotline for it.
Just count the nunber of accessivikity improvements that got added UI and otherwise since the vuyout. Not a coincidence.
Directive came from up top. Like above boss zos top. And every top level end game player quitting wont change it. Neither will thousandss of posts in this and other threads...
Company policy. Best make peace with it.
Your prolly right, they are not willing to listen to their consumers and Iam likely shouting into the void. But as Dylan Thomas said "Do not go gently into that good night, .... , Rage, rage against the dying of the light.
Ragnarok0130 wrote: »Ignoring the dps site, can someone that defends oalensoul come up with a reason why a dps player should get all the different tank buffs? This is really the biggest strength of oakensoul. The empower you can just get from mages guild. I can tank vet trials doing 100k dps atm.
Accesibility!
Not the noob/bad player one. The ppl with disabilities one. And for them a bit more defense is crucial. Dead players do no damage..
Microsoft bought zenimax. And MS is pretty hardcore on accessibility. They have website and believe even hotline for it.
Just count the nunber of accessivikity improvements that got added UI and otherwise since the vuyout. Not a coincidence.
Directive came from up top. Like above boss zos top. And every top level end game player quitting wont change it. Neither will thousandss of posts in this and other threads...
Company policy. Best make peace with it.
Accessibility is not a reason to upend the game balance. One also cannot make it so only disabled people use the "accessibility option" even if it was for disabilities so it would inevitably tank the game balance as we've seen since a large numbers of players will use the easy button if given the option resulting in inevitable nerfs to that accessibility option as the devs struggle to re-establish balance so they do not lose players. An imbalanced game loses players and money which goes directly against Microsoft's first priority - making its investors money. So losing players is not a viable course of action for ZoS or MS as any executive who does lose money pursuing such endeavors will be replaced and a more competent executive hired to make money since neither ZoS nor MS are charities.
That being said accessibility as ZoS uses in its communications to the players is not specific to disabilities it's specific to ease of access to content for all players. I'm also curious as to what your sources are for the claims you made in the second portion of your post, are you a Microsoft or ZoS employee, did it come from press releases as I've been a Microsoft enthusiast between PC gaming and Xbox gaming for 25 years and haven't seen such specific statements about upending game balance for accessibility policies?
Ragnarok0130 wrote: »Ignoring the dps site, can someone that defends oalensoul come up with a reason why a dps player should get all the different tank buffs? This is really the biggest strength of oakensoul. The empower you can just get from mages guild. I can tank vet trials doing 100k dps atm.
Accesibility!
Not the noob/bad player one. The ppl with disabilities one. And for them a bit more defense is crucial. Dead players do no damage..
Microsoft bought zenimax. And MS is pretty hardcore on accessibility. They have website and believe even hotline for it.
Just count the nunber of accessivikity improvements that got added UI and otherwise since the vuyout. Not a coincidence.
Directive came from up top. Like above boss zos top. And every top level end game player quitting wont change it. Neither will thousandss of posts in this and other threads...
Company policy. Best make peace with it.
Accessibility is not a reason to upend the game balance. One also cannot make it so only disabled people use the "accessibility option" even if it was for disabilities so it would inevitably tank the game balance as we've seen since a large numbers of players will use the easy button if given the option resulting in inevitable nerfs to that accessibility option as the devs struggle to re-establish balance so they do not lose players. An imbalanced game loses players and money which goes directly against Microsoft's first priority - making its investors money. So losing players is not a viable course of action for ZoS or MS as any executive who does lose money pursuing such endeavors will be replaced and a more competent executive hired to make money since neither ZoS nor MS are charities.
That being said accessibility as ZoS uses in its communications to the players is not specific to disabilities it's specific to ease of access to content for all players. I'm also curious as to what your sources are for the claims you made in the second portion of your post, are you a Microsoft or ZoS employee, did it come from press releases as I've been a Microsoft enthusiast between PC gaming and Xbox gaming for 25 years and haven't seen such specific statements about upending game balance for accessibility policies?
upend game balance?
exagerating much? top dogs before are still top dogs.. by quite a margin..