I don't know who or what you are defending to be honest. My suggestion in the OP keeps the game open and free for all, gives everyone a chance, and deters camping. Doesn't get better than that.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Ban botters, let farmers do what they want. As long as you are at the keyboard and killing what they're doing is not wrong, it's a normal part of mmo's.
jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Ban botters, let farmers do what they want. As long as you are at the keyboard and killing what they're doing is not wrong, it's a normal part of mmo's.
@DMuehlhausen If you're exploring public dungeons to see what they can tell you about the game world, the fact that there are other sources of loot is irrelevant. ESO has a diverse fanbase and for many of us a nugget of lore is more exciting than most of what I've looted in ESO. Interesting idea, OP.
You farmers ruin dungeons for the rest of us ok. So I hope ZOS implements my suggestion or something similar so that this ends. If you want mats go around the world exploring and collect.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »What you call camping, I call legitimate farming for items to break down for crafting mats and trait research. As long as you are at the keyboard there is no problem killing a mob repeatedly in an open world environment.
Mob density needs to be greatly increased for this. But a good bump to mob density would fix it. But you'd then have everyone complaining that the game was to hard.Publius_Scipio wrote: »You farmers ruin dungeons for the rest of us ok. So I hope ZOS implements my suggestion or something similar so that this ends. If you want mats go around the world exploring and collect.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »What you call camping, I call legitimate farming for items to break down for crafting mats and trait research. As long as you are at the keyboard there is no problem killing a mob repeatedly in an open world environment.
I don't understand what the issue is here with you. My suggestion keeps the game open for all and allows the movement of players so that everyone gets their fair shot without the circus standing around the boss spawn. You enter the dungeon kill the boss (can't kill him for another hour) so you move along. Same will go for me and everyone else.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Mob density needs to be greatly increased for this. But a good bump to mob density would fix it. But you'd then have everyone complaining that the game was to hard.Publius_Scipio wrote: »You farmers ruin dungeons for the rest of us ok. So I hope ZOS implements my suggestion or something similar so that this ends. If you want mats go around the world exploring and collect.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »What you call camping, I call legitimate farming for items to break down for crafting mats and trait research. As long as you are at the keyboard there is no problem killing a mob repeatedly in an open world environment.
My issue is that this won't end. Lets say you get your way here. People looking to farm will then find a high density area to farm. These will likely be mobs needed for a quest of one type or another. The complaints will continue and nothing will change but location. This is an mmo people farm, they need to farm because there is a grind factor in all mmo's that last. Complaining about the farming gets no where. Ban botters, ban dupers, ban any other type of exploiter, but realize that actual farming is a core mechanic in all mmo's.Publius_Scipio wrote: »I don't understand what the issue is here with you. My suggestion keeps the game open for all and allows the movement of players so that everyone gets their fair shot without the circus standing around the boss spawn. You enter the dungeon kill the boss (can't kill him for another hour) so you move along. Same will go for me and everyone else.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Mob density needs to be greatly increased for this. But a good bump to mob density would fix it. But you'd then have everyone complaining that the game was to hard.Publius_Scipio wrote: »You farmers ruin dungeons for the rest of us ok. So I hope ZOS implements my suggestion or something similar so that this ends. If you want mats go around the world exploring and collect.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »What you call camping, I call legitimate farming for items to break down for crafting mats and trait research. As long as you are at the keyboard there is no problem killing a mob repeatedly in an open world environment.
I appreciate your insight and opinion but I am failing to understand what you are trying to explain. If you kill a boss and a timer kicks in and you can't kill it again for an hour or more those players will move on. Everyone will have a turn as far as I can see it panning out.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »My issue is that this won't end. Lets say you get your way here. People looking to farm will then find a high density area to farm. These will likely be mobs needed for a quest of one type or another. The complaints will continue and nothing will change but location. This is an mmo people farm, they need to farm because there is a grind factor in all mmo's that last. Complaining about the farming gets no where. Ban botters, ban dupers, ban any other type of exploiter, but realize that actual farming is a core mechanic in all mmo's.Publius_Scipio wrote: »I don't understand what the issue is here with you. My suggestion keeps the game open for all and allows the movement of players so that everyone gets their fair shot without the circus standing around the boss spawn. You enter the dungeon kill the boss (can't kill him for another hour) so you move along. Same will go for me and everyone else.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Mob density needs to be greatly increased for this. But a good bump to mob density would fix it. But you'd then have everyone complaining that the game was to hard.Publius_Scipio wrote: »You farmers ruin dungeons for the rest of us ok. So I hope ZOS implements my suggestion or something similar so that this ends. If you want mats go around the world exploring and collect.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »What you call camping, I call legitimate farming for items to break down for crafting mats and trait research. As long as you are at the keyboard there is no problem killing a mob repeatedly in an open world environment.
Publius_Scipio wrote: »I appreciate your insight and opinion but I am failing to understand what you are trying to explain. If you kill a boss and a timer kicks in and you can't kill it again for an hour or more those players will move on. Everyone will have a turn as far as I can see it panning out.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »My issue is that this won't end. Lets say you get your way here. People looking to farm will then find a high density area to farm. These will likely be mobs needed for a quest of one type or another. The complaints will continue and nothing will change but location. This is an mmo people farm, they need to farm because there is a grind factor in all mmo's that last. Complaining about the farming gets no where. Ban botters, ban dupers, ban any other type of exploiter, but realize that actual farming is a core mechanic in all mmo's.Publius_Scipio wrote: »I don't understand what the issue is here with you. My suggestion keeps the game open for all and allows the movement of players so that everyone gets their fair shot without the circus standing around the boss spawn. You enter the dungeon kill the boss (can't kill him for another hour) so you move along. Same will go for me and everyone else.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Mob density needs to be greatly increased for this. But a good bump to mob density would fix it. But you'd then have everyone complaining that the game was to hard.Publius_Scipio wrote: »You farmers ruin dungeons for the rest of us ok. So I hope ZOS implements my suggestion or something similar so that this ends. If you want mats go around the world exploring and collect.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »What you call camping, I call legitimate farming for items to break down for crafting mats and trait research. As long as you are at the keyboard there is no problem killing a mob repeatedly in an open world environment.
Ok I'll try to explain again, because you aren't understanding. So lets say you get what you want and that suggestion happens. Farmers then find a high mob density area. Areas of high mob density usually have a quest associated with those mobs for killing the mobs. So then instead of thread titles of "End Boss Camping" you get thread titles of "End (quest mob x) farming in (zone name here)". You don't fix anything, you just move the spot that people are farming to somewhere else, and this continues over and over again.Publius_Scipio wrote: »I appreciate your insight and opinion but I am failing to understand what you are trying to explain. If you kill a boss and a timer kicks in and you can't kill it again for an hour or more those players will move on. Everyone will have a turn as far as I can see it panning out.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »My issue is that this won't end. Lets say you get your way here. People looking to farm will then find a high density area to farm. These will likely be mobs needed for a quest of one type or another. The complaints will continue and nothing will change but location. This is an mmo people farm, they need to farm because there is a grind factor in all mmo's that last. Complaining about the farming gets no where. Ban botters, ban dupers, ban any other type of exploiter, but realize that actual farming is a core mechanic in all mmo's.Publius_Scipio wrote: »I don't understand what the issue is here with you. My suggestion keeps the game open for all and allows the movement of players so that everyone gets their fair shot without the circus standing around the boss spawn. You enter the dungeon kill the boss (can't kill him for another hour) so you move along. Same will go for me and everyone else.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Mob density needs to be greatly increased for this. But a good bump to mob density would fix it. But you'd then have everyone complaining that the game was to hard.Publius_Scipio wrote: »You farmers ruin dungeons for the rest of us ok. So I hope ZOS implements my suggestion or something similar so that this ends. If you want mats go around the world exploring and collect.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »What you call camping, I call legitimate farming for items to break down for crafting mats and trait research. As long as you are at the keyboard there is no problem killing a mob repeatedly in an open world environment.
Ok, good explanation. My suggestion allows special game characters to be protected from camping. Random NPC's can be farmed or whatever.Nox_Aeterna wrote: »Publius_Scipio wrote: »I appreciate your insight and opinion but I am failing to understand what you are trying to explain. If you kill a boss and a timer kicks in and you can't kill it again for an hour or more those players will move on. Everyone will have a turn as far as I can see it panning out.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »My issue is that this won't end. Lets say you get your way here. People looking to farm will then find a high density area to farm. These will likely be mobs needed for a quest of one type or another. The complaints will continue and nothing will change but location. This is an mmo people farm, they need to farm because there is a grind factor in all mmo's that last. Complaining about the farming gets no where. Ban botters, ban dupers, ban any other type of exploiter, but realize that actual farming is a core mechanic in all mmo's.Publius_Scipio wrote: »I don't understand what the issue is here with you. My suggestion keeps the game open for all and allows the movement of players so that everyone gets their fair shot without the circus standing around the boss spawn. You enter the dungeon kill the boss (can't kill him for another hour) so you move along. Same will go for me and everyone else.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Mob density needs to be greatly increased for this. But a good bump to mob density would fix it. But you'd then have everyone complaining that the game was to hard.Publius_Scipio wrote: »You farmers ruin dungeons for the rest of us ok. So I hope ZOS implements my suggestion or something similar so that this ends. If you want mats go around the world exploring and collect.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »What you call camping, I call legitimate farming for items to break down for crafting mats and trait research. As long as you are at the keyboard there is no problem killing a mob repeatedly in an open world environment.
His point is quite simple , if you cant farm the boss , then you go farm something else that is worth your time.
For an example , lets use another thread in the forums , lets say vampires became the target , because they also give good loot.
People would complain , because everyone would then hunt every single vampire down for loot , and then nobody would be able to turn.
That is just an example , he mean farmers will just focus certain quests mobs , which would make harder for people to complete certain quests.
In the end , people farm.
Special NPC's should be protected like my suggestion would provide. For example, if a quest has you clear out a pack of wolves, protect those wolves from spawn camping. Don't protect random wolves out in the field no one particularly needs. Want to camp those wolves be my guest.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Ok I'll try to explain again, because you aren't understanding. So lets say you get what you want and that suggestion happens. Farmers then find a high mob density area. Areas of high mob density usually have a quest associated with those mobs for killing the mobs. So then instead of thread titles of "End Boss Camping" you get thread titles of "End (quest mob x) farming in (zone name here)". You don't fix anything, you just move the spot that people are farming to somewhere else, and this continues over and over again.Publius_Scipio wrote: »I appreciate your insight and opinion but I am failing to understand what you are trying to explain. If you kill a boss and a timer kicks in and you can't kill it again for an hour or more those players will move on. Everyone will have a turn as far as I can see it panning out.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »My issue is that this won't end. Lets say you get your way here. People looking to farm will then find a high density area to farm. These will likely be mobs needed for a quest of one type or another. The complaints will continue and nothing will change but location. This is an mmo people farm, they need to farm because there is a grind factor in all mmo's that last. Complaining about the farming gets no where. Ban botters, ban dupers, ban any other type of exploiter, but realize that actual farming is a core mechanic in all mmo's.Publius_Scipio wrote: »I don't understand what the issue is here with you. My suggestion keeps the game open for all and allows the movement of players so that everyone gets their fair shot without the circus standing around the boss spawn. You enter the dungeon kill the boss (can't kill him for another hour) so you move along. Same will go for me and everyone else.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Mob density needs to be greatly increased for this. But a good bump to mob density would fix it. But you'd then have everyone complaining that the game was to hard.Publius_Scipio wrote: »You farmers ruin dungeons for the rest of us ok. So I hope ZOS implements my suggestion or something similar so that this ends. If you want mats go around the world exploring and collect.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »What you call camping, I call legitimate farming for items to break down for crafting mats and trait research. As long as you are at the keyboard there is no problem killing a mob repeatedly in an open world environment.
Publius_Scipio wrote: »Special NPC's should be protected like my suggestion would provide. For example, if a quest has you clear out a pack of wolves, protect those wolves from spawn camping. Don't protect random wolves out in the field no one particularly needs. Want to camp those wolves be my guest.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Ok I'll try to explain again, because you aren't understanding. So lets say you get what you want and that suggestion happens. Farmers then find a high mob density area. Areas of high mob density usually have a quest associated with those mobs for killing the mobs. So then instead of thread titles of "End Boss Camping" you get thread titles of "End (quest mob x) farming in (zone name here)". You don't fix anything, you just move the spot that people are farming to somewhere else, and this continues over and over again.Publius_Scipio wrote: »I appreciate your insight and opinion but I am failing to understand what you are trying to explain. If you kill a boss and a timer kicks in and you can't kill it again for an hour or more those players will move on. Everyone will have a turn as far as I can see it panning out.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »My issue is that this won't end. Lets say you get your way here. People looking to farm will then find a high density area to farm. These will likely be mobs needed for a quest of one type or another. The complaints will continue and nothing will change but location. This is an mmo people farm, they need to farm because there is a grind factor in all mmo's that last. Complaining about the farming gets no where. Ban botters, ban dupers, ban any other type of exploiter, but realize that actual farming is a core mechanic in all mmo's.Publius_Scipio wrote: »I don't understand what the issue is here with you. My suggestion keeps the game open for all and allows the movement of players so that everyone gets their fair shot without the circus standing around the boss spawn. You enter the dungeon kill the boss (can't kill him for another hour) so you move along. Same will go for me and everyone else.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Mob density needs to be greatly increased for this. But a good bump to mob density would fix it. But you'd then have everyone complaining that the game was to hard.Publius_Scipio wrote: »You farmers ruin dungeons for the rest of us ok. So I hope ZOS implements my suggestion or something similar so that this ends. If you want mats go around the world exploring and collect.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »What you call camping, I call legitimate farming for items to break down for crafting mats and trait research. As long as you are at the keyboard there is no problem killing a mob repeatedly in an open world environment.
Yes, definitely ban the botters, but dont you think the OP's idea is a brilliant one? The way i see it, this idea could change the entire world of mmos for the better. Maybe it should've been addressed as a major issue in multiple mmos in the past.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Ban botters, let farmers do what they want. As long as you are at the keyboard and killing what they're doing is not wrong, it's a normal part of mmo's.
Thank you.xDJ_DUBST3Px wrote: »Yes, definitely ban the botters, but dont you think the OP's idea is a brilliant one? The way i see it, this idea could change the entire world of mmos for the better. Maybe it should've been addressed as a major issue in multiple mmos in the past.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Ban botters, let farmers do what they want. As long as you are at the keyboard and killing what they're doing is not wrong, it's a normal part of mmo's.
No because it would change make the grind way way more difficult especially with how he wants to protect mobs used for quests now too. That means that you will not be able to farm, which means they'll have to eliminate the grind. Without some level of grind players don't play long. With players not playing long, developers lose money, when developers lose money servers close.xDJ_DUBST3Px wrote: »Yes, definitely ban the botters, but dont you think the OP's idea is a brilliant one? The way i see it, this idea could change the entire world of mmos for the better. Maybe it should've been addressed as a major issue in multiple mmos in the past.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Ban botters, let farmers do what they want. As long as you are at the keyboard and killing what they're doing is not wrong, it's a normal part of mmo's.
Mostly single, have played some MMO's. I see what you are saying but my suggestion allows the circulation of players. Campers won't stand around waiting to kill a boss for long periods of time.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Publius_Scipio wrote: »Special NPC's should be protected like my suggestion would provide. For example, if a quest has you clear out a pack of wolves, protect those wolves from spawn camping. Don't protect random wolves out in the field no one particularly needs. Want to camp those wolves be my guest.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Ok I'll try to explain again, because you aren't understanding. So lets say you get what you want and that suggestion happens. Farmers then find a high mob density area. Areas of high mob density usually have a quest associated with those mobs for killing the mobs. So then instead of thread titles of "End Boss Camping" you get thread titles of "End (quest mob x) farming in (zone name here)". You don't fix anything, you just move the spot that people are farming to somewhere else, and this continues over and over again.Publius_Scipio wrote: »I appreciate your insight and opinion but I am failing to understand what you are trying to explain. If you kill a boss and a timer kicks in and you can't kill it again for an hour or more those players will move on. Everyone will have a turn as far as I can see it panning out.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »My issue is that this won't end. Lets say you get your way here. People looking to farm will then find a high density area to farm. These will likely be mobs needed for a quest of one type or another. The complaints will continue and nothing will change but location. This is an mmo people farm, they need to farm because there is a grind factor in all mmo's that last. Complaining about the farming gets no where. Ban botters, ban dupers, ban any other type of exploiter, but realize that actual farming is a core mechanic in all mmo's.Publius_Scipio wrote: »I don't understand what the issue is here with you. My suggestion keeps the game open for all and allows the movement of players so that everyone gets their fair shot without the circus standing around the boss spawn. You enter the dungeon kill the boss (can't kill him for another hour) so you move along. Same will go for me and everyone else.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »Mob density needs to be greatly increased for this. But a good bump to mob density would fix it. But you'd then have everyone complaining that the game was to hard.Publius_Scipio wrote: »You farmers ruin dungeons for the rest of us ok. So I hope ZOS implements my suggestion or something similar so that this ends. If you want mats go around the world exploring and collect.jdkorreckpreub18_ESO wrote: »What you call camping, I call legitimate farming for items to break down for crafting mats and trait research. As long as you are at the keyboard there is no problem killing a mob repeatedly in an open world environment.
With the grind factor in mmo's that will kill the game and send it f2p because you'll be trying to keep people from farming.
Honest question are you primarily a single player gamer before now?
I'll keep it simple for you so you don't come back with sarcasm. Boss camping is clown activity. Other players want to explore and have a boss fight. Is that ok with you? All are entitled to that boss fight. My suggestion makes it so that since you can't slam the boss every 2 minutes, you exit and head somewhere else. That gives Bobby Turnbuckles a chance to fight a boss and walk away with the satisfying experience.Midgardian wrote: »"My suggestion keeps the game open for all "
This has got to be one of the most overblown uses of rhetoric I've seen on these forums. Farming public dungeon bosses is closing the game?
What exactly is the problem? I've been in a public dungeon where 10-15 people were farming the boss, and I had no problem killing the boss multiple times and getting useful items. If you aren't happy, do something else.
The only way I can see this changing for the positive is if quests and random world mobs give better loot. Overall, the quest rewards are pretty lacking in this game, making it necessary to farm mobs.
I find the public dungeons fun when there are a lot of people in them.
Publius_Scipio wrote: »I'll keep it simple for you so you don't come back with sarcasm. Boss camping is clown activity. Other players want to explore and have a boss fight. Is that ok with you? All are entitled to that boss fight. My suggestion makes it so that since you can't slam the boss every 2 minutes, you exit and head somewhere else. That gives Bobby Turnbuckles a chance to fight a boss and walk away with the satisfying experience.Midgardian wrote: »"My suggestion keeps the game open for all "
This has got to be one of the most overblown uses of rhetoric I've seen on these forums. Farming public dungeon bosses is closing the game?
What exactly is the problem? I've been in a public dungeon where 10-15 people were farming the boss, and I had no problem killing the boss multiple times and getting useful items. If you aren't happy, do something else.
The only way I can see this changing for the positive is if quests and random world mobs give better loot. Overall, the quest rewards are pretty lacking in this game, making it necessary to farm mobs.
I find the public dungeons fun when there are a lot of people in them.
You think your quest for loot or xp or whatever else it is should hamper the rest of our experiences?
Yes big boss man. Your ability to loot and ravage bosses has to stay because you say it has to. Does not matter that others want to go in there and have a real fight. Because your explanation of "fighting" the boss is getting one swing off as 10 others pummel it also and it dies literally within 3 seconds of spawn.Midgardian wrote: »Publius_Scipio wrote: »I'll keep it simple for you so you don't come back with sarcasm. Boss camping is clown activity. Other players want to explore and have a boss fight. Is that ok with you? All are entitled to that boss fight. My suggestion makes it so that since you can't slam the boss every 2 minutes, you exit and head somewhere else. That gives Bobby Turnbuckles a chance to fight a boss and walk away with the satisfying experience.Midgardian wrote: »"My suggestion keeps the game open for all "
This has got to be one of the most overblown uses of rhetoric I've seen on these forums. Farming public dungeon bosses is closing the game?
What exactly is the problem? I've been in a public dungeon where 10-15 people were farming the boss, and I had no problem killing the boss multiple times and getting useful items. If you aren't happy, do something else.
The only way I can see this changing for the positive is if quests and random world mobs give better loot. Overall, the quest rewards are pretty lacking in this game, making it necessary to farm mobs.
I find the public dungeons fun when there are a lot of people in them.
You think your quest for loot or xp or whatever else it is should hamper the rest of our experiences?
I didn't use sarcasm.
There are plenty of things for you to do in the game. You can fight the boss. I've never had problems fighting the boss. People are camping it, so they are obviously killing it.
No one is hampering your experience. You can fight the boss. You can quest. You can still play the game. You are the one asking to change a fundamental mechanic just so you can "fight" a pointless boss.
Publius_Scipio wrote: »I'll keep it simple for you so you don't come back with sarcasm. Boss camping is clown activity. Other players want to explore and have a boss fight. Is that ok with you? All are entitled to that boss fight. My suggestion makes it so that since you can't slam the boss every 2 minutes, you exit and head somewhere else. That gives Bobby Turnbuckles a chance to fight a boss and walk away with the satisfying experience.Midgardian wrote: »"My suggestion keeps the game open for all "
This has got to be one of the most overblown uses of rhetoric I've seen on these forums. Farming public dungeon bosses is closing the game?
What exactly is the problem? I've been in a public dungeon where 10-15 people were farming the boss, and I had no problem killing the boss multiple times and getting useful items. If you aren't happy, do something else.
The only way I can see this changing for the positive is if quests and random world mobs give better loot. Overall, the quest rewards are pretty lacking in this game, making it necessary to farm mobs.
I find the public dungeons fun when there are a lot of people in them.
You think your quest for loot or xp or whatever else it is should hamper the rest of our experiences? And I can say with some deal of certainty that ZOS sides with those who want those thrilling boss fights. You have your chance for loot and xp just the way I do and the rest do. But you farming the boss hurts my game experience and others. You follow me now?