Maintenance for the week of April 3:
• PC/Mac: No NA megaserver maintenance – April 3
• PC/Mac: EU megaserver for maintenance – April 3, 8:00PM EDT (April 4, 00:00 UTC) – April 4, 10:00AM EDT (14:00 UTC)

Wood Elf/ Bosmer losing stealth passive, An open letter.

  • anadandy
    anadandy
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Slytherin - totally the house of unicorns and rainbows now.
  • Cundu_Ertur
    Cundu_Ertur
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    Ravenclaws have always been the jocks who 'pants' the nerds.
    Taking stealth away from the Bosmer is like taking magic away from the Altmer, making Nords allergic to mead, or making Orcs pretty.
  • Ogou
    Ogou
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Ogou wrote: »
    Ogou wrote: »
    DenMoria wrote: »
    Seraphayel wrote: »
    DenMoria wrote: »
    Seraphayel wrote: »
    DenMoria wrote: »
    Seraphayel wrote: »
    Seraphayel wrote: »
    BlueRaven wrote: »
    Hopefully by this time tomorrow we will know if the passives will change.

    No they won't and you already knew this when the racials went live.

    Oh, it's everybody knowledge that racials won't be revisited in nearest couple of years. This thread and those Q&A is just a reminder not to put a single cent in this game. (though i put a lot before and regularly, literally buying anything i like)

    Well then punish ZOS with your wallet.

    Why? And what punishment? You're just one person and/or a small group.

    The rest of us don't have a problem.

    If you want to "punish" a multi-billion corporation by not giving them chump change, go for it.

    Most of us play and subscribe and don't really care about much other than server issues, lag time and "bots".

    Racial passives and minor adjustments to skills just aren't that important in the grand scheme of things.

    What I want is unlimited Health, Magicka and Stamina. Nothing less. At level 2 as a perk, of course.

    You missed the mark. I have absolutely no problem. It's the Bosmer crowd in this thread that can't accept what's reality now.

    Touche and I apologize if I misread.

    Thank you for setting me straight.

    I do love my bosmers though.

    They're short, they're cute and they're awesome with a bow.

    I don't really care otherwise.

    It's all about the looks to me.

    You might be able to tell that I'm not very good at PvP. :)

    Well my comment was just an answer to another guy who said he quit his ESO+.
    ______

    And they have antlers! That's the best about Bosmer.

    That's a shame. He'll be back though. We always come back. :)

    OMG, it was nothing about ESO+, you can't cancel it if it is already running. I just said that i don't want to spend any additional money on game where devs are not listening to players. It's not only about stealth, it's about overall ignorance, poor performance, lack of variety. This case with stealth is just bright example of how they listen and how they preserve lore. I never played MMORPGs before, only reason why I came here was Morrowind and Skyrim. Unfortunately, ESO is not compatible with them, it's spin-off, parallel reality which won't end in 3rd Era which majority of players prefer:
    https://forums.elderscrollsonline.com/en/discussion/458118/favourite-era

    I still continue to play mostly because of friends in game, and I spend 90% of time in group content and other 10% are writs and surveys. I have "3rd era" ESO running in parallel in my mind, and since group content is just a small stories which doesn't contradict original game atmosphere, I'm fine with them. Remove of stealth just cut last part of my immersion which was keeping me in overland, so one less reason to play it, and one less reason to buy Elsweyr. I don't think about it as "sacrifice" or "voting with wallet". I simply don't want to buy it, no point to.

    What do you mean it won't end the 3rd era? Where else would it go?

    Well, we know that in 3rd era argonians are slaves of dunmers, nords and dunmers despise and hate each other as race and nationality, and of course bosmers are stealthy and "night eye" is khajiit's perk. Imperials in 3rd era is actually basement of civilization and not some villains who just want to destroy all neighboring kingdoms . So obviously ESO is parallel reality.
    I specially checked 2nd era timeline in UESP some time ago, and ESO consequences vanish without trace very fast. Maybe it's all dealings of imperial scribes who changed history to their needs, but given that characters and world in TES3-5 are immersive and in ESO majority of them are generic and not trustworthy, my conscience is with single-player TES games.

    So main thing in ESO for me is gameplay and cosmetics, unfortunately ZOS makes everything to ruin my immersive builds with every patch, but I still find new ways to adapt and play the way I like, not like ZOS pigeonholes me. From new patchnote I see that they ruin most interesting and skill-based ability in the game to draw people attention to necromancer.. ok, maybe I need to switch my magblade dps to pvp healer and re-build breton templar from healer to dps, something like that..

    -Telvanni and Dres still have argonian and khajiiti slaves.
    -An ancient Nord ghost with a passionate hatred of the Dunmer being at the head of the empire would definitely revive old hatred. The tribunal having to bow down and surrender the Numidium probably didn't help either.
    -gameplay =/= lore
    -There's that dude called Tiber Septim who unified the Imperials and led them in a conquest of the entire continent of Tamriel. That might have helped with the importance of the Imperials.

    So which part exactly vanished without a trace?

    I mean. You can have whatever headcanon you want but, as far as both Bethesda and ZOS are concerned, ESO is indeed canon:


    Anybody may write anything in twitter, it doesn't change facts. You may even find some small notification of planemeld in some manuscript somewhere etc, but no single NPC in Morrowind and Skyrim will never mention that someday nords and dunmers were in alliance, but they remember battles of nords and chimers (i.e. dunmers) which were before ESO.

    Well, according to that logic, the battle of Red Mountain is not canon because it wasn't mentioned before Morrowind, Miraak isn't canon because he wasn't mentioned before Skyrim, the Alessian rebellion didn't happen because it wasn't mentioned before Oblivion. We knew nothing of the Interregnum before ESO, at least none of it is on the same level as changing a whole region's climate (see Cyrodiil).
    Lore and more importantly lore shown in dialog, architecture, people interaction in previous games is solid and immersive. In ESO it's more like another fantasy novel published each year where authors turn things inside out to keep reader interested. Elsweyr: "Oh yeah, dragon attacking because somebody unleashed them from cave". Summerset: "Return of the Psijics and Sea Sload!". I'm not saying that Summerset story is bad, I liked it. But compare it to Skyrim, where dragon attacks to save Jarl and then follows connection to Tiber Septim, to Blades, Thalmor and so on.. and even main story of Skyrim which is considered realtively bad in comparison to side quests and guild quests.. even this main story outshines ESO greatly.. not but plot twists, but by depth and immersion.

    Even if any of that was true how does that make ESO not canon?
    You may say that those are single-player games, they are always better cause they are not limited by MMO gameplay. Ok, let's look at books:
    Just compare this, how flawless and connected is all the writing and which describes a lot about bosmers through small nuances. You can't write something like that if you don't perceive Tamriel as a whole world:
    https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Lore:Words_and_Philosophy

    And this, where it's just list of facts of what bosmers without deep lore connection.
    https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Lore:The_Green_Pact_and_the_Dominion

    When ESO was created ZOS was thinking.. hmm... we need to gave some story to fill 3 zones and which will be memorable. Ok, let's make bosmers anti-veggie cannibals, why not.

    You're really comparing am interview with a war pamphlet? Besides, Bosmer have been anti-veggie cannibals since TESIII: Morrowind.
  • BlueRaven
    BlueRaven
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
  • Ratzkifal
    Ratzkifal
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    BlueRaven wrote: »

    Yeah, but didn't he mention there was "a big mistake" there? I would like to know what that was about and if ZOS is aware or not.

    I'd like to see someone from ZOS define Bosmer in three words. I'm quite convinced nobody in the combat team will use the word "stealth". Unless they say "anti-stealth" perhaps.
    This Bosmer was tortured to death. There is nothing left to be done.
  • BlueRaven
    BlueRaven
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Ratzkifal wrote: »
    BlueRaven wrote: »

    Yeah, but didn't he mention there was "a big mistake" there? I would like to know what that was about and if ZOS is aware or not.

    I'd like to see someone from ZOS define Bosmer in three words. I'm quite convinced nobody in the combat team will use the word "stealth". Unless they say "anti-stealth" perhaps.

    If I could give you an “agree” and “awesome” at the same time I would.
  • anadandy
    anadandy
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Ratzkifal wrote: »
    I also want to shout out to @max_only and verbally hug him for making this thread and because I think he could use a hug or two right now.

    Hear, hear! *tips virtual mug*

    *makes a lot of noise and immediately gets spotted by a guard* Dang it!! ;)
    Edited by anadandy on March 29, 2019 11:14AM
  • wedgebert
    wedgebert
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Don't sweat it, bro, all guards are Bosmer now. Bosmer have always been guards. We've always been at war with Eastasia.

    It's just a shame we're not very good guards. Instead of being alerted to the enemy by the arrow sticking out of our neck, Bosmer can detect the enemy by the arrow sticking out of our neck because the majority of stealth attacks are from range!
  • BlueRaven
    BlueRaven
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    KMarble wrote: »
    DenMoria wrote: »
    Seraphayel wrote: »
    Seraphayel wrote: »
    BlueRaven wrote: »
    Hopefully by this time tomorrow we will know if the passives will change.

    No they won't and you already knew this when the racials went live.

    Oh, it's everybody knowledge that racials won't be revisited in nearest couple of years. This thread and those Q&A is just a reminder not to put a single cent in this game. (though i put a lot before and regularly, literally buying anything i like)

    Well then punish ZOS with your wallet.

    Why? And what punishment? You're just one person and/or a small group.

    The rest of us don't have a problem.

    If you want to "punish" a multi-billion corporation by not giving them chump change, go for it.
    This game makes the parent company money 3 ways:
    - shares
    - sales of the game itself
    - and the one that truly keeps the servers up and running : subscriptions and expansions

    Sale of shares is the reason why there are events - events generate traffic to old areas and retains a residual population after events are over. The company can then show those numbers to investors as evidence that the game is alive and well.

    Sales of the game itself are not only a gamble (some expansions might not be well received), they don't keep the game going. Unlike a single player game, the economic model for a MMO isn't based on the initial purchase because, unlike a single player game, they need to keep the servers (and the people who work in the game) paid.

    Subscriptions and to an extent expansions are what keeps the game alive and running. I hope, for the sake of all of us who play this game, that the people in charge don't think like you and go "oh, well. It's just one person and/or small group". That is a good way to destroy their business.

    BlueRaven wrote: »
    Well I have been playing since beta on the pc/Mac. I am not sure if you understand the controversy over the racial changes made to bosmers or not, but the changes to their stealth passive (or rather their lack of a stealth passive) is what many of us are upset about. And the subject of this thread.

    Yes, Tamriel unlimited was a great change, but that’s a different subject entirely.
    They're trying to deflect (also I'd like to thank them for, once again, bumping the thread). Truth is, even the few who posted here telling us to shut up, can't come up with an argument - mind you, I'm not even say a good argument - that addresses the subject of this thread.
    anadandy wrote: »
    And there it is. I'm laying money down that this is the planned "open stealth to all" idea that was the reason Bosmer got the shaft.

    Vesture of Darloc Brae (Overland Elsweyr set)
    Set bonus
    (2 items) Adds 129 Magicka Recovery
    (3 items) Adds 129 Stamina Recovery
    (4 items) Reduces the radius you can be detected while sneaking by 2 meters. Reduces the cost of sneak by 10%.
    (5 items) While crouching, you restore 647 Magicka and Stamina and heal for 698 every second.

    Source

    They gutted the race to pimp a new set. (yes, overly dramatic)

    I will be trying this set on both a wood elf and a Khajiit when the PTS goes live. As I've pointed before, the original idea was for Khajiit to have a 5 meters radius, but it had to be taken back to 3 meters. Unless my math was completely wrong, there was only a 1 meter leeway from playable to broken.

    We have 14 slots total, one of the sets that already exists only needs 3 pieces to reduce the radius, the other requires 5 pieces, which will still allow player to wear this new set and have 2 slots for something else.

    This set effectively gives Khajiits back the 2 meters that were taken away from their passive.

    I was under the impression that Bethesda was a private company. What stock are they traded under?
  • Cundu_Ertur
    Cundu_Ertur
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    Still private so far as I can tell, so no ticker. Zenimax Media would be the parent company.
    Taking stealth away from the Bosmer is like taking magic away from the Altmer, making Nords allergic to mead, or making Orcs pretty.
  • DenMoria
    DenMoria
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    BlueRaven wrote: »
    KMarble wrote: »
    DenMoria wrote: »
    Seraphayel wrote: »
    Seraphayel wrote: »
    BlueRaven wrote: »
    Hopefully by this time tomorrow we will know if the passives will change.

    No they won't and you already knew this when the racials went live.

    Oh, it's everybody knowledge that racials won't be revisited in nearest couple of years. This thread and those Q&A is just a reminder not to put a single cent in this game. (though i put a lot before and regularly, literally buying anything i like)

    Well then punish ZOS with your wallet.

    Why? And what punishment? You're just one person and/or a small group.

    The rest of us don't have a problem.

    If you want to "punish" a multi-billion corporation by not giving them chump change, go for it.
    This game makes the parent company money 3 ways:
    - shares
    - sales of the game itself
    - and the one that truly keeps the servers up and running : subscriptions and expansions

    Sale of shares is the reason why there are events - events generate traffic to old areas and retains a residual population after events are over. The company can then show those numbers to investors as evidence that the game is alive and well.

    Sales of the game itself are not only a gamble (some expansions might not be well received), they don't keep the game going. Unlike a single player game, the economic model for a MMO isn't based on the initial purchase because, unlike a single player game, they need to keep the servers (and the people who work in the game) paid.

    Subscriptions and to an extent expansions are what keeps the game alive and running. I hope, for the sake of all of us who play this game, that the people in charge don't think like you and go "oh, well. It's just one person and/or small group". That is a good way to destroy their business.

    BlueRaven wrote: »
    Well I have been playing since beta on the pc/Mac. I am not sure if you understand the controversy over the racial changes made to bosmers or not, but the changes to their stealth passive (or rather their lack of a stealth passive) is what many of us are upset about. And the subject of this thread.

    Yes, Tamriel unlimited was a great change, but that’s a different subject entirely.
    They're trying to deflect (also I'd like to thank them for, once again, bumping the thread). Truth is, even the few who posted here telling us to shut up, can't come up with an argument - mind you, I'm not even say a good argument - that addresses the subject of this thread.
    anadandy wrote: »
    And there it is. I'm laying money down that this is the planned "open stealth to all" idea that was the reason Bosmer got the shaft.

    Vesture of Darloc Brae (Overland Elsweyr set)
    Set bonus
    (2 items) Adds 129 Magicka Recovery
    (3 items) Adds 129 Stamina Recovery
    (4 items) Reduces the radius you can be detected while sneaking by 2 meters. Reduces the cost of sneak by 10%.
    (5 items) While crouching, you restore 647 Magicka and Stamina and heal for 698 every second.

    Source

    They gutted the race to pimp a new set. (yes, overly dramatic)

    I will be trying this set on both a wood elf and a Khajiit when the PTS goes live. As I've pointed before, the original idea was for Khajiit to have a 5 meters radius, but it had to be taken back to 3 meters. Unless my math was completely wrong, there was only a 1 meter leeway from playable to broken.

    We have 14 slots total, one of the sets that already exists only needs 3 pieces to reduce the radius, the other requires 5 pieces, which will still allow player to wear this new set and have 2 slots for something else.

    This set effectively gives Khajiits back the 2 meters that were taken away from their passive.

    I was under the impression that Bethesda was a private company. What stock are they traded under?

    They're not. ZOS is a private company that owns any number of studios including all of the Bethesda variations.

    They, of course, have their own stockholders, but is most definately not public.

    I don't think Linda Carter would allow that. :)
  • BlueRaven
    BlueRaven
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    DenMoria wrote: »
    BlueRaven wrote: »
    KMarble wrote: »
    DenMoria wrote: »
    Seraphayel wrote: »
    Seraphayel wrote: »
    BlueRaven wrote: »
    Hopefully by this time tomorrow we will know if the passives will change.

    No they won't and you already knew this when the racials went live.

    Oh, it's everybody knowledge that racials won't be revisited in nearest couple of years. This thread and those Q&A is just a reminder not to put a single cent in this game. (though i put a lot before and regularly, literally buying anything i like)

    Well then punish ZOS with your wallet.

    Why? And what punishment? You're just one person and/or a small group.

    The rest of us don't have a problem.

    If you want to "punish" a multi-billion corporation by not giving them chump change, go for it.
    This game makes the parent company money 3 ways:
    - shares
    - sales of the game itself
    - and the one that truly keeps the servers up and running : subscriptions and expansions

    Sale of shares is the reason why there are events - events generate traffic to old areas and retains a residual population after events are over. The company can then show those numbers to investors as evidence that the game is alive and well.

    Sales of the game itself are not only a gamble (some expansions might not be well received), they don't keep the game going. Unlike a single player game, the economic model for a MMO isn't based on the initial purchase because, unlike a single player game, they need to keep the servers (and the people who work in the game) paid.

    Subscriptions and to an extent expansions are what keeps the game alive and running. I hope, for the sake of all of us who play this game, that the people in charge don't think like you and go "oh, well. It's just one person and/or small group". That is a good way to destroy their business.

    BlueRaven wrote: »
    Well I have been playing since beta on the pc/Mac. I am not sure if you understand the controversy over the racial changes made to bosmers or not, but the changes to their stealth passive (or rather their lack of a stealth passive) is what many of us are upset about. And the subject of this thread.

    Yes, Tamriel unlimited was a great change, but that’s a different subject entirely.
    They're trying to deflect (also I'd like to thank them for, once again, bumping the thread). Truth is, even the few who posted here telling us to shut up, can't come up with an argument - mind you, I'm not even say a good argument - that addresses the subject of this thread.
    anadandy wrote: »
    And there it is. I'm laying money down that this is the planned "open stealth to all" idea that was the reason Bosmer got the shaft.

    Vesture of Darloc Brae (Overland Elsweyr set)
    Set bonus
    (2 items) Adds 129 Magicka Recovery
    (3 items) Adds 129 Stamina Recovery
    (4 items) Reduces the radius you can be detected while sneaking by 2 meters. Reduces the cost of sneak by 10%.
    (5 items) While crouching, you restore 647 Magicka and Stamina and heal for 698 every second.

    Source

    They gutted the race to pimp a new set. (yes, overly dramatic)

    I will be trying this set on both a wood elf and a Khajiit when the PTS goes live. As I've pointed before, the original idea was for Khajiit to have a 5 meters radius, but it had to be taken back to 3 meters. Unless my math was completely wrong, there was only a 1 meter leeway from playable to broken.

    We have 14 slots total, one of the sets that already exists only needs 3 pieces to reduce the radius, the other requires 5 pieces, which will still allow player to wear this new set and have 2 slots for something else.

    This set effectively gives Khajiits back the 2 meters that were taken away from their passive.

    I was under the impression that Bethesda was a private company. What stock are they traded under?

    They're not. ZOS is a private company that owns any number of studios including all of the Bethesda variations.

    They, of course, have their own stockholders, but is most definately not public.

    I don't think Linda Carter would allow that. :)

    I knew Bethesda was owned by ZOS, but many people use the ZOS and Bethesda monikers interchangeably (as do I).

    I looked up to see if they were a private company years ago, I just wanted to know if anything had changed.
  • IwakuraLain42
    IwakuraLain42
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    DenMoria wrote: »
    They're not. ZOS is a private company that owns any number of studios including all of the Bethesda variations.

    They, of course, have their own stockholders, but is most definately not public.

    I don't think Linda Carter would allow that. :)

    Actually it's Zenimax Media that holds both Bethesda Softworks and Zenimax Online. And yes, they are privately traded.

    If you want to know how they are making money you only need to look at the stuff that ZOS works on and how they present themself. As noted the sources of income are:
    • Selling new copies of the game
    • Subscriptions
    • Cash Store

    The main reason for each Chapter and the reason they are marketed as standalone content is that they want to sell as many copies each year as possible. That's the reason they rode the nostalgica train Morrowind so hard and why they choosed Summerset last year (never seen in Tamriel content before). And that's also the reason why we have Elswyr this year. Apparently the last chapter wasn't so successful, so they had to had another joker from ES content this year: Dragons !

    Combine this with one of the most predatory cash shops I've seen in any game and you know where they earn their money. Keeping players by keeping them content or by fixing the game have a very low priority. Heck, it took them five years to implement something as basic as a search function for their trading system.
  • luizpaulom17
    luizpaulom17
    ✭✭✭
    Stop crying m8... U just want that passive back so U can keep using cloak and snipe on BGs, like most elves and Cats used tu do... Get over it...

    I hated losing my cat 8% crit, was crying on forums for it... and when changes came to Live got 2k more DPS on first try... They did a good job over all, ony orc now seems a bit OP, but still its more balanced.

    Actually my ability to use cloak and snipe is completely unaffected, so you lose there.
    What the gankers would complain about was the loss of the 10% damage boost out of stealth, which we haven't complained about at all, so you lose there.
    We've already addressed this multiple times, so you lose there.

    kthnxbye

    Wood Elves lost their passives, so U lost there. U guys kept crying here everyday and ZOS still doesnt really care, so U lost there. One monte after new patch came to live, ZOS is focus on necro, U keep crying here and nothing has changed, so U lost there!

    The same guys are comenting here in this post tô keep it loud and on top... Just give up, its gone guys, get over!
  • Ogou
    Ogou
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    BlueRaven wrote: »
    Btw, the rumor of what class changes might be gets two responses.

    https://forums.elderscrollsonline.com/en/discussion/465659/where-were-the-upcoming-class-changes-officially-released-at/p1

    Here, 45+ pages, nothing.

    The way I see it there's no way for ZOS to give an answer here that will do less harm than just not saying anything.

    So this is just a tug of war between the people in this thread and ZOS. The first side to let go loses. Though I really wonder how long ZOS can keep this up.
This discussion has been closed.