Help! We need more guild management tools!

Artemiisia

In the year I have been playing this game, I sadly witness over 3 times myself, that there are a few people that likes to destroy the game for others, by ripping the whole guild bank.

I think I have read over 30 threads where this has been happing to others as well, it is really truly sad, there aint any real trust system for guild banks.

Like if you been a member of the guild for a month u get 3 withdraws a day, two months 6 and so on

I was in a guild where we made a trust system, where we had like 3-4 trading officers that would withdraw to the rest of the guild, and you could put in yourself, the way it worked was, if you didn't contributed to the guild bank, you wont get anything in return, this though is seriously hard work for the trading officers, one of them actually had to make a excel document to keep track on the history, so where is the fun in that?

In the end, I agree we really need more guild management tools, not only for guild bank, but all the other thing that would ease the workload of the guild masters and officers

snowsong

ElfFromSpace wrote: »

@snowsong I just posted a revised and updated version of this list of suggestions:

http://forums.elderscrollsonline.com/en/discussion/163928/guild-improvements-master-list

The reply button SHOULD be in game, but you can get one by installing MailR addon which is pretty critical

@ElfFromSpace, thank you so much for the additional info. You have some great ideas and i will definitely go check out your updated master list you linked to us too.

rootimus

Well, judging from the lastest AUA session, it doesn't look like we can expect anything any time soon.

ashlee17

Praying for news on better guild tools at E3

AzraelKrieg

ashlee17 wrote: »

Praying for news on better guild tools at E3

There wasn't anything sadly Except a hype teaser for Dark Brotherhood.

Kat_Cnaa

WillhelmBlack wrote: »

Linking would be nice for Teamspeak. Are we ever getting free in-game communication like the consoles get?

Being able to copy any text from the game into a text file would be useful. Having to juggle windows to copy out the link to a guild page, teamspeak server or any other guild/information page is >.< inducing. Linking to a TS3 would be fabulous.

ashlee17

Now that eso has landed on console, I hope all console eso guild leaders and fans join this call for better guild tools for us all!

ashlee17

A huge Congrats to @ZOS_RichLambert on your promotion to Creative Director!

I hate to load you up with work so early in your promotion but please please please.....

LURK HERE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Give the hardworking Guild Leaders of guilds thoughout tamriel some hope that our jobs may soon be made easier!

Please read and implement some of the wonderful feedback we have provided here!

Aeradon

Gidorick wrote: »

After dumping a bunch of stuff into a guild bank I decided to just use the Guild Store... at least there I get paid for my stuff.

Even then, it's a mystery when it comes to which specific item was sold, unless of course, add-ons. It's either you solve that mystery by going through your listed items, or break immersion by installing add-ons. #ToughLifeChoices #Immersion4Life

Farseer_Macleod

I've just created a guild recently and after thinking about it I decided to allow the use of the bank for everyone in our small guild. While small we don't have a large bank content yet so there's not much to steal atm, but I am aware of just how easy it would be for someone to raid it.

A simple system allowing the guild leaders to rank types of item (Materials, Weapons, Armour, etc...) to be graded with some sort of tier system and then choose who is able to access which type.

That way if someone wants something from a tier higher than their own the lower ranks would just need to find someone with access to it and ask for it, or have someone promote them to the approriate rank for a temporary time.

Also a way to summerise the roster would be nice as well, so you can view who is on of a certain rank rather than having to scroll through the names to find out what rank someone is.

HypnoticChronic1

Personally I find the guild bank system a mess I would like to see them add tabs to the bank for the various items and give us the ability to set permissions for the various tabs so non trusted players can access basic materials while the trusted players can access the "vault" so to speak with the valuable materials and items.

dylanslcruchelowb14a_ESO

OMG as a large guild leader, PLEASE

Athas24

HypnoticChronic1 wrote: »

Personally I find the guild bank system a mess I would like to see them add tabs to the bank for the various items and give us the ability to set permissions for the various tabs so non trusted players can access basic materials while the trusted players can access the "vault" so to speak with the valuable materials and items.

a better method for Searching would be nice too.

ashlee17

Athas24 wrote: »

HypnoticChronic1 wrote: »

Personally I find the guild bank system a mess I would like to see them add tabs to the bank for the various items and give us the ability to set permissions for the various tabs so non trusted players can access basic materials while the trusted players can access the "vault" so to speak with the valuable materials and items.

a better method for Searching would be nice too.

Yes please!! After Orsinium Please help us Zos!

BennyButton

me too

UltimaJoe777

If you're going to necro a thread try adding some updated input...

BennyButton

ok will do, thank you

mmstf

I fully support tabbed access with individual permissions for ranks i think that is just abut all as if you get too complex the harder it is to get what you want.

fryguy822005

The console's deff need some tools. I'm currently trying to start a guild and it's so much micro managing everything. I want a real guild and not just a 500 page of players that never do anything. Most guild master have to make Facebook pages or websites. Guilds are a huge thing in MMOs and their not give is what we need

Athas24

I totally Agree fryguy822005! There needs to be some sweet in game application for guild postings, something that shows their tabard or symbol/ colors on an open forum sort of like a job posting board. Guilds could even be integrated to post LF xyz items or players or things about their store or something. Anything to integrate it more than just a bunch of numbers who sometimes chit chat or group.

Auldjohn

As Co-Founder and Master Sage (leader) of The Elder Sages' Guild, founded as one of the first permanent player guilds August 31, 2013 during Closed Beta, I still find Guild Management Tools lacking. This is not a deal breaker but does require extensive micromanagement. Granularity based on Guild Member 'Rank' would also be extremely useful.

From the earliest days of Closed Beta, the in-game social community has been an important feature of ESO, though often overlooked by the Dev Team, (with the notable exception of Build 6.)

Search by Guild Member is sorely missing in the still needs improvement LFG Tool.

Add Send to Guild Members to the in-game Mail tool, to enhance existing Guild group chat function which only works for members currently online.

TESG has Guild branches on NA, EU, and PTS and we fully welcome console players though we do not yet have branches on XB1 or PS4.

IMO, this thread should remain active and not be considered a "Necro". Full disclosure: To the best of my knowledge, no members of TESG are Necromancers.

Thanks and Kudos to Ash Egan (@ashlee17), of More Than Fair (ESO) for starting this useful thread.

sungaze

damn man, FİRST MAKE GUILD FINDER TOOLS. I DONT HAVE EVEN A GUILD. even i searched all google i see noobish guilds that are no events or less crowded.

SteveCampsOut

sungaze wrote: »

damn man, FİRST MAKE GUILD FINDER TOOLS. I DONT HAVE EVEN A GUILD. even i searched all google i see noobish guilds that are no events or less crowded.

Dude, All you have to do is listen to zone chat in the starter zones and you'll see Guild Invite spam every 5 minutes or so. There is also an entire section of the forums here dedicated to guild recruitment. If you can't find a guild, you're just not trying!

sungaze

SteveCampsOut wrote: »

sungaze wrote: »

damn man, FİRST MAKE GUILD FINDER TOOLS. I DONT HAVE EVEN A GUILD. even i searched all google i see noobish guilds that are no events or less crowded.

Dude, All you have to do is listen to zone chat in the starter zones and you'll see Guild Invite spam every 5 minutes or so. There is also an entire section of the forums here dedicated to guild recruitment. If you can't find a guild, you're just not trying!

we dont have a text chat i m on ps4 mate...

waterfairy

ashlee17 wrote: »

I dream of a day where guild bank access is not all or nothing and guild members can sleep well knowing that what they donate to the guild bank is acessable to those that need it but safe from greed and theft.

So you dream of changing human beings into honest, trustworthy beings capable of pooling resources respectfully? That's way beyond ZOS power to patch.

fryguy822005

Vigarr wrote: »

ashlee17 wrote: »

I dream of a day where guild bank access is not all or nothing and guild members can sleep well knowing that what they donate to the guild bank is acessable to those that need it but safe from greed and theft.

So you dream of changing human beings into honest, trustworthy beings capable of pooling resources respectfully? That's way beyond ZOS power to patch.

They could make it so guild master can control how many items the can withdraw in a certain time period and have it so it's based on certain level range. And if it's not you level range you can hit a button that request for you to withdraw the item, then it's can get approved by a officer. THERE PROBLEM SOLVED

Kat_Cnaa

fryguy822005 wrote: »

Vigarr wrote: »

ashlee17 wrote: »

I dream of a day where guild bank access is not all or nothing and guild members can sleep well knowing that what they donate to the guild bank is acessable to those that need it but safe from greed and theft.

So you dream of changing human beings into honest, trustworthy beings capable of pooling resources respectfully? That's way beyond ZOS power to patch.

They could make it so guild master can control how many items the can withdraw in a certain time period and have it so it's based on certain level range. And if it's not you level range you can hit a button that request for you to withdraw the item, then it's can get approved by a officer. THERE PROBLEM SOLVED

Have there been any fixes? I see the discussion of guild banks flaring in 2015, then nothing this year. Was it fixed or did people just give up and leave?

fryguy822005

Nothing's been fixed yet

Auldjohn

Kat_Cnaa wrote: »

Have there been any fixes? I see the discussion of guild banks flaring in 2015, then nothing this year. Was it fixed or did people just give up and leave?

Sadly, since Update 6 last year Guild Bank functionality has changed little. The ZOS Devs seem to have left Guild Bank and Guild Store enhancements (e.g., filtering, sorting, stack splitting, etc.) to Add-On community developers. That community has produced some very useful Add-Ons. However ZOS has not addressed Guild Bank/Store management tools. Guild Management overall may be outside of the scope of the ESO API , likely for security reasons.

By keeping this thread alive we, the Guildmasters, may be able to call attention of these issues to ZOS. Post your Guild Management Wishlist and constructive suggestions here. Thanks again to @ashlee17 for initiating this thread.

Kat_Cnaa

I suspected they didn't change anything. That is sad. And frustrating.