Maintenance for the week of September 8:
• [IN PROGRESS] PC/Mac: EU megaserver for maintenance – September 9, 22:00 UTC (6:00PM EDT) - September 10, 16:00 UTC (12:00PM EDT)

Console text chat discussion

  • Adam_Chattaway
    Adam_Chattaway
    ✭✭✭✭
    Why has this not been added yet? i mean the outcry for this is huge, if this (the most requested feature) is not added to console ESO it shows the devs DO NOT care about making a great game for the player they're just cash milking the crown store on console players, and i mean that with 100% seriousness .

    Me playing FFXIV on PS4 with a chat box...
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WRxRGsvMXAA
    Edited by Adam_Chattaway on July 1, 2015 6:29PM
  • Sallington
    Sallington
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭
    Why has this not been added yet? i mean the outcry for this is huge, if this (the most requested feature) is not added to console ESO it shows the devs DO NOT care about making a great game for the player they're just cash milking the crown store on console players, and i mean that with 100% seriousness .

    Me playing FFXIV on PS4 with a chat box...
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WRxRGsvMXAA

    I forgot what we were talking about, but now I know that ESO needs hot tubs.
    Daggerfall Covenant
    Sallington - Templar - Stormproof - Prefect II
    Cobham - Sorcerer - Stormproof - First Sergeant II
    Shallington - NightBlade - Lieutenant |
    Balmorah - Templar - Sergeant ||
  • Adam_Chattaway
    Adam_Chattaway
    ✭✭✭✭
    ;D
  • Milktray
    Milktray
    ✭✭✭
    You never know, ppl may actually bother to learn to speak in game again
    ZoS please understand everyone thinks and pronounces things differently, so please add to your 'rules' that things get removed if the Mod doesn't actually quite understand phrasing
  • Vanduur
    Vanduur
    Soul Shriven
    Ever since I switched to ps4 I've felt muted. Having to stand outside a dungeon dancing for 20 minutes hoping someone will invite me is a drag. I'm never comfortable using mics to communicate with people I've never met, and the lack of text chat just kills any communal sense I felt playing pc. RIP zone chat.

    Gold spam > screaming kids, phone conversations, and burp/fart noises

  • Merkabeh
    Merkabeh
    ✭✭✭
    Milktray wrote: »
    You never know, ppl may actually bother to learn to speak in game again

    I speak in game constantly; with my friends and guild mates. Much rather avoid all the annoying of Area Chat though.
    Crusader of The Knights of the Alessian Order

    Anything useful that players are wanting added into the game all fall under the category of "Yer ruinin my 'mersion!" - Sallington

    #CommunicationEquality
  • Milktray
    Milktray
    ✭✭✭
    Merkabeh wrote: »
    Milktray wrote: »
    You never know, ppl may actually bother to learn to speak in game again

    I speak in game constantly; with my friends and guild mates. Much rather avoid all the annoying of Area Chat though.

    I must admit, some ppl in Area Chat you just want to chase their toon down and *** it repeatadly about the head
    ZoS please understand everyone thinks and pronounces things differently, so please add to your 'rules' that things get removed if the Mod doesn't actually quite understand phrasing
  • Merkabeh
    Merkabeh
    ✭✭✭
    Milktray wrote: »
    Merkabeh wrote: »
    Milktray wrote: »
    You never know, ppl may actually bother to learn to speak in game again

    I speak in game constantly; with my friends and guild mates. Much rather avoid all the annoying of Area Chat though.

    I must admit, some ppl in Area Chat you just want to chase their toon down and *** it repeatadly about the head

    You know, instead of text chat, I'd take world PvP...lol...even if I lose, it would be cathartic to attack the annoying people...lol...
    Crusader of The Knights of the Alessian Order

    Anything useful that players are wanting added into the game all fall under the category of "Yer ruinin my 'mersion!" - Sallington

    #CommunicationEquality
  • Caad
    Caad
    Soul Shriven
    I'm going to cast my vote for text chat on consoles. I usually never post in discussion forums, but I think this important enough to voice my opinion.

    Voice chat has the potential to be great if used properly, but I've found the lack of text chat to be a hindrance for a variety of in-game activity, including trade and grouping up for quests. Also, I tend to chat with friends in the PS4 party chat, so I'm not able to use the in-game voice chat without swapping back and forth. One final (and very important, imo) reason for text chat is to provide accessibility for the hearing impaired. Having a relative who is deaf has made me realize that accessibility is an important thing to consider in entertainment and gaming.

    Don't remove the voice chat, but please consider adding the text chat to the game. Thanks for providing a place for me to express my opinion on this matter.
  • J2JMC
    J2JMC
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Sallington wrote: »

    "Immersion"

    Ruining ESO since day 1.

    If an optional text box ruins your 'mersion, then I think your imagination is worse than you think it is.



    He literally says in the first sentence he supports it if it is optional.

    Edit: I'm positive my comment is outside of the quote box but I guess...
    Edited by J2JMC on July 1, 2015 7:57PM
    Knee Jerk, L2P, Obtuse, Casual, Entitled, All The Best, unnecessary mention of CoD

    Battle leveling for pve content defeats the idea of progression. Remove CP

    "Apparently the players are more informed than we are"-Richard Lambert

  • WynonaStealth
    WynonaStealth
    ✭✭
    O ya, We NEED text chat on consoles! I'm a PC transfer as well and I'm sorry but this game is GREAT as a social experience, and I would MAYBE be O K with voice chat ONLY IF AND ONLY IF people used their damn mics! But they don't! Barley anyone uses their mic so it might as well be a single player game. On PC, with text chat, you feel like your in the world with others, you speak to others and watch others speaking to each other, you sell your wares in chat, you find groups in chat. We NEED chat! I really want to stay on console but this game just isn't the same and the enjoyment of using a controller is fading quickly. I miss being able to talk to people while i play, sel my items and just generally feel like the game and the world I'm playing in is lived in and right now I just feel like I'm playing a slightly watered down Elder Scrolls game! How long do you think that will last ZOS? Think about it, YA a lot of new console only players might not be saying anything because they don't know what it's like but I GAURENTEE they will like the game much more if they know there's others in the world with them. In fact in also playing neverwinter on Xbone, and that game kinda sucks but I think I like to play it simply because there is text chat, again, I feel like I'm playing a game with a bunch of other people I don't feel lonely when I play neverwinter but I Definetly feel lonely playing ESO on console, this just won't do for me
  • chaosngn_ESO
    chaosngn_ESO
    ✭✭✭
    Definitely going into my review. I can't even communicate with my guild. If they aren't in chat, there's no way to talk to, broadcast to, or email everyone. This is ridiculous.

    They've basically turned an MMO into a single player game.
  • Zensonar
    Zensonar
    ✭✭✭
    This thread is still going...

    Your all acting like a bunch of kids who don't understand a simple two letter word...


    "No"

    43 pages so far, move on with your life, learn to adapt or fall behind.
    No.

  • Adam_Chattaway
    Adam_Chattaway
    ✭✭✭✭
    Definitely going into my review. I can't even communicate with my guild. If they aren't in chat, there's no way to talk to, broadcast to, or email everyone. This is ridiculous.

    They've basically turned an MMO into a single player game.

    amen, even trying to ask your guild for a group is insanely hard, please excuse the upcoming caps

    ZOS HOW THE HECK DID YOU LET THIS HAPPEN? DOES NO ONE AT ZOS EVEN PLAY AN MMO? I SERIOUSLY DOUBT IT BECAUSE EVEN THE MOST AMATURE MMO GAMER KNOWS THE IMPORTANCE OF TEXT CHAT!

    Rant over, caps lock recharging.

    p.s OMG the head in England right now, i'm melting urgh hands sweating 24/7
  • King Bozo
    King Bozo
    ✭✭✭
    Not having text chat is destroying the immersion I could have by playing the game. Looking for more for DSA gamertag gravebelly. I am on the AD alliance and can play any role xbox one.
  • Varicite
    Varicite
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Milktray wrote: »
    You never know, ppl may actually bother to learn to speak in game again

    That really doesn't have any bearing on the conversation at all...
  • King Bozo
    King Bozo
    ✭✭✭
    I sat in group finder from 9am to about 2pm looking for only 1 more today for dsa. I never found that 4th person for group. Should I have had access to chat I could have found that 4th person. I could have ask in different zones by text chat and got the 4th person today. This is an immersion killer to me. So with nothing left to do pvp and melt faces.
    Edited by King Bozo on July 1, 2015 9:52PM
  • Siniztor
    Siniztor
    ✭✭✭
    Definitely going into my review. I can't even communicate with my guild. If they aren't in chat, there's no way to talk to, broadcast to, or email everyone. This is ridiculous.

    They've basically turned an MMO into a single player game.

    agree 100% with out the option to send a simple /whisper to guide mates not in chat is nuts..and no i dont wanna hear send them a ps mail..cause guess what 90% of players have notifcations shut off ..so thats out the window #NEEDTEXTCHAT
  • SocialAssassin
    SocialAssassin
    ✭✭✭
    And the one's that want "text chat" are the spammers anyways. And the thing is you Can't turn of text chat as a rule. The PC version already has text chat, problem solved. Is it our fault, you don't even try using VC? That answer would be no. And sure it sucks being legally deaf. So what about a close caption option?

    I have seen other mmo games , absolutly ruined by text chat! Again , I say NO! to text chat. IF you want text chat, then simply go play the PC version because it already has text chat. I think that's a simple solution , don't you? I do.
    So personally I'm good without text chat, and I'm a console gamer.
    “I’m The Best There Is At What I Do. But What I Do Isn't Very Nice…” - Wolverine/Logan/James Howlett
  • SocialAssassin
    SocialAssassin
    ✭✭✭
    Siniztor wrote: »
    Definitely going into my review. I can't even communicate with my guild. If they aren't in chat, there's no way to talk to, broadcast to, or email everyone. This is ridiculous.

    They've basically turned an MMO into a single player game.

    agree 100% with out the option to send a simple /whisper to guide mates not in chat is nuts..and no i dont wanna hear send them a ps mail..cause guess what 90% of players have notifcations shut off ..so thats out the window #NEEDTEXTCHAT

    Review ? So do you actually work for a game company , do you own your own gaming website ? Or is it just your opinion , when it comes to game review. Do you know , how to be non biased. Personally I Can't wait, to read your "review"
    “I’m The Best There Is At What I Do. But What I Do Isn't Very Nice…” - Wolverine/Logan/James Howlett
  • Varicite
    Varicite
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    And the one's that want "text chat" are the spammers anyways. And the thing is you Can't turn of text chat as a rule. The PC version already has text chat, problem solved. Is it our fault, you don't even try using VC? That answer would be no. And sure it sucks being legally deaf. So what about a close caption option?

    I have seen other mmo games , absolutly ruined by text chat! Again , I say NO! to text chat. IF you want text chat, then simply go play the PC version because it already has text chat. I think that's a simple solution , don't you? I do.
    So personally I'm good without text chat, and I'm a console gamer.

    There seem to be a number of misconceptions in your post, so I'll go ahead and clear those up.

    1) Yes, you can turn off text chat as a rule, even on the PC version which does not yet have built-in VOIP. It's really pretty simple.

    2) Many people do use VOIP on PC through 3rd party software, such as Mumble, TS, etc. VOIP is great for certain things, such as when already grouped in Cyrodiil or dungeons, or just hanging out w/ your friends. Text is better for other things, such as reaching a much larger number of players w/out being intrusive when looking for groups, recruiting for guilds, selling items outside of guild kiosks, etc.

    3) Which MMOs have been "absolutely ruined by text chat"? Because I can not think of any that have shuttered their doors due to the inclusion of text chat, and I've been playing MMOs for as long as the genre has existed.

    4) While I will not speak for everybody who is requesting text chat, I personally play on PC and PS4. I have a console that I play on (because much like VOIP, consoles are better for certain types of gaming experiences and my TV is much larger than my monitor), I am a gamer, thus I am a console gamer.

    I wish text chat to be included because, as I've stated many times before, the experience on consoles is hampered by the lack of it due to many of the in-game systems having been designed around text chat's inclusion. W/out it, those things that text chat excels at have become clunky and obtuse to use. It's not as smooth an experience as it was designed to be and paying the same price for an inferior experience is simply unfair to those on consoles.

    5) You make the assumption that many of us who are asking for this feature either A) do not even use the voice chat provided by the game and B ) would not use the voice chat during group activities where it clearly outshines its counterpart. You are wrong on both counts, unfortunately.

    Voice chat and text-based chat are simply different tools, and we would like to use the best tool for the job instead of constantly trying to force the square peg into the round hole and being told that's how it should work. It's not.
  • Siniztor
    Siniztor
    ✭✭✭
    And the one's that want "text chat" are the spammers anyways. And the thing is you Can't turn of text chat as a rule. The PC version already has text chat, problem solved. Is it our fault, you don't even try using VC? That answer would be no. And sure it sucks being legally deaf. So what about a close caption option?

    I have seen other mmo games , absolutly ruined by text chat! Again , I say NO! to text chat. IF you want text chat, then simply go play the PC version because it already has text chat. I think that's a simple solution , don't you? I do.
    So personally I'm good without text chat, and I'm a console gamer.

    I want text chat and am in no way a spammer..And if you read most of these post you see with text chat.. 90% say the option to turn it off should be there for those who don't want it..

    As i pointed out in another thread i spent the last 3 days going to all 3 faction zones checking ever guild trader and saying in area chat i was buying a certian flower..3 days multi trips and 1 person responed he didnt have any..I got alot of %$(*^ you and music and static..

    Trying to get the attention of guild mates who are grouped in group chat sucks no text chat...the in game mail only updates right away if you log out and back in and most people have there notifacations turned off on there consoles so there not spamed..

    as far as pc has it...guess what this was supose to be a stright port to console not a differnt game..

    If you just playing with your little click i guess you might not want text chat..trying to play a mmo it be nice if it had the basic form of comucation..but selling buying grouping is all hindered


  • SocialAssassin
    SocialAssassin
    ✭✭✭
    Ok, you want "text chat", then I think you should have to pay extra or separately. Why? because I simply don't want to pay for your addiction , for text chat. It's kinda like cable tv, Dish, Direct tv, I am not a sports fan. But yet as a subscriber, I have to pay extra for channels I don't really care about. And since you want "text chat" so bad , you can literary taste it. I think YOU , should have to pay for it.

    Again , the solution for legally deaf ppl is close captioning or sub titles. But for anyone to use that as a platform or excuse, that is so unethical. Unless your legally deaf.
    “I’m The Best There Is At What I Do. But What I Do Isn't Very Nice…” - Wolverine/Logan/James Howlett
  • Varicite
    Varicite
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Ok, you want "text chat", then I think you should have to pay extra or separately. Why? because I simply don't want to pay for your addiction , for text chat. It's kinda like cable tv, Dish, Direct tv, I am not a sports fan. But yet as a subscriber, I have to pay extra for channels I don't really care about. And since you want "text chat" so bad , you can literary taste it. I think YOU , should have to pay for it.

    Again , the solution for legally deaf ppl is close captioning or sub titles. But for anyone to use that as a platform or excuse, that is so unethical. Unless your legally deaf.

    We did pay for it. It's actually in the game files. It's just not enabled currently.

    And the console version costs exactly the same as the PC version, which will soon have both VOIP and text chat. We are simply asking for the same experience for the same price.

    You, who do not want to use it, don't have to. You can turn it off, just like you already can on the PC.

    Also, you don't "have to" pay for anything. You don't even have to subscribe, that's your choice, and you do so for the monthly crowns, XP / inspiration boosts, and access to future DLC. That's what your sub is buying, nothing more.

    To act like you are being forced to pay for features you won't use when you are not actually forced to pay anything at all beyond the cost of the box is simply asinine. Especially when you are receiving the full benefit of your subscription, as detailed above.

    Edited by Varicite on July 1, 2015 10:26PM
  • Siniztor
    Siniztor
    ✭✭✭
    Ok, you want "text chat", then I think you should have to pay extra or separately. Why? because I simply don't want to pay for your addiction , for text chat. It's kinda like cable tv, Dish, Direct tv, I am not a sports fan. But yet as a subscriber, I have to pay extra for channels I don't really care about. And since you want "text chat" so bad , you can literary taste it. I think YOU , should have to pay for it.

    Again , the solution for legally deaf ppl is close captioning or sub titles. But for anyone to use that as a platform or excuse, that is so unethical. Unless your legally deaf.

    again ill point out this was a port from PC to console not a NEW game..Text chat is in the game they just disabled it...you notice we have to TYPE for mail and its not voice mail

    IF your paying for my addiction.. I think you owe me some money ...cause ive payed for my sub up to nov plus spent another $100 not to mention the $70 on the imp edition..

    I am allowed to voice my opnion its no more or less important then yours ..
  • Ace_of_Destiny
    Ace_of_Destiny
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Varicite wrote: »
    And the one's that want "text chat" are the spammers anyways. And the thing is you Can't turn of text chat as a rule. The PC version already has text chat, problem solved. Is it our fault, you don't even try using VC? That answer would be no. And sure it sucks being legally deaf. So what about a close caption option?

    I have seen other mmo games , absolutly ruined by text chat! Again , I say NO! to text chat. IF you want text chat, then simply go play the PC version because it already has text chat. I think that's a simple solution , don't you? I do.
    So personally I'm good without text chat, and I'm a console gamer.


    Voice chat and text-based chat are simply different tools, and we would like to use the best tool for the job instead of constantly trying to force the square peg into the round hole and being told that's how it should work. It's not.

    .
    Using Voice Chat to organize a Guild is like using a Hammer to cut your toenails!


    .
    EQUALIZE ALL PLATFORMS!
    IF ONE HAS IT...ALL SHOULD HAVE IT!
    !

    )==================================================(
    ~MegaServer~>PS4 (NA) ~PSN~>Ace-of-Destiny
    )===================================================(
    I don't care what platform it is on...an MMORPG without Text Chat is NOT an MMORPG!
  • Varicite
    Varicite
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Ace-2112 wrote: »
    Varicite wrote: »
    And the one's that want "text chat" are the spammers anyways. And the thing is you Can't turn of text chat as a rule. The PC version already has text chat, problem solved. Is it our fault, you don't even try using VC? That answer would be no. And sure it sucks being legally deaf. So what about a close caption option?

    I have seen other mmo games , absolutly ruined by text chat! Again , I say NO! to text chat. IF you want text chat, then simply go play the PC version because it already has text chat. I think that's a simple solution , don't you? I do.
    So personally I'm good without text chat, and I'm a console gamer.


    Voice chat and text-based chat are simply different tools, and we would like to use the best tool for the job[/size] instead of constantly trying to force the square peg into the round hole and being told that's how it should work. It's not.
    Using Voice Chat to organize a Guild is like using a Hammer to cut your toenails![/size]

    I didn't say to "organize" a guild, I only said to help recruit for one in-game w/out resorting to forums outside of the game.

    However, if you'd care to elaborate on your viewpoint as to why you believe this, I'm willing to listen. : )
  • SocialAssassin
    SocialAssassin
    ✭✭✭
    Siniztor wrote: »
    And the one's that want "text chat" are the spammers anyways. And the thing is you Can't turn of text chat as a rule. The PC version already has text chat, problem solved. Is it our fault, you don't even try using VC? That answer would be no. And sure it sucks being legally deaf. So what about a close caption option?

    I have seen other mmo games , absolutly ruined by text chat! Again , I say NO! to text chat. IF you want text chat, then simply go play the PC version because it already has text chat. I think that's a simple solution , don't you? I do.
    So personally I'm good without text chat, and I'm a console gamer.

    I want text chat and am in no way a spammer..And if you read most of these post you see with text chat.. 90% say the option to turn it off should be there for those who don't want it..

    As i pointed out in another thread i spent the last 3 days going to all 3 faction zones checking ever guild trader and saying in area chat i was buying a certian flower..3 days multi trips and 1 person responed he didnt have any..I got alot of %$(*^ you and music and static..

    Trying to get the attention of guild mates who are grouped in group chat sucks no text chat...the in game mail only updates right away if you log out and back in and most people have there notifacations turned off on there consoles so there not spamed..

    as far as pc has it...guess what this was supose to be a stright port to console not a differnt game..

    If you just playing with your little click i guess you might not want text chat..trying to play a mmo it be nice if it had the basic form of comucation..but selling buying grouping is all hindered


    Ok, if was an actual option to turn it off. But I have yet to see a console version of an mmo actually do that yet? And as a rule, I don't do "cliques" so don't assume that's my reasoing. Mostly it's because of trolls, and if there was text chat, they would abuse the absolute hell out of it. Look I get it , your in the minority that's not a spammer. Fair enough, but what about the 99.9 % that are trolls , spammers , flamers etc. And it would be a different matter, IF the mods , volunteers would police this game religiously. But allot of these mods, have taught themselves to tune it out. IF I was a mod, volunteer etc._ I would be like one of these old time sheriffs , keeping the peace and cleaning up the town. So to speak, I won't even get into the fact their often "payed". Were already having issues with voice chat and harrasment, do we really need to add to it? Here is another thing to consider okay , gamers complaining about imersion in the game. Well , text chat would literary kill off any imersion that was left in ESOTU. You know how ppl, hate ads on YouTube . Just imagine , how annoying that would be in game. I agrre their should be a forum to trade stuff, and a place you could get to know others allot better. But we already have things like this, and it's called social networking. I also get those that have social anxiety , because I have as well. Look your points are valid , but so are others. And personally find it a real ***** to use text chat, I'm not going to "plug a keyboard in my PS4 so I can type. Right, like I want a bunch of idiots always correcting my spelling. Let's put it this way, chatboxes literary breed chatholes.
    “I’m The Best There Is At What I Do. But What I Do Isn't Very Nice…” - Wolverine/Logan/James Howlett
  • Ace_of_Destiny
    Ace_of_Destiny
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Varicite wrote: »
    Ace-2112 wrote: »
    Varicite wrote: »
    And the one's that want "text chat" are the spammers anyways. And the thing is you Can't turn of text chat as a rule. The PC version already has text chat, problem solved. Is it our fault, you don't even try using VC? That answer would be no. And sure it sucks being legally deaf. So what about a close caption option?

    I have seen other mmo games , absolutly ruined by text chat! Again , I say NO! to text chat. IF you want text chat, then simply go play the PC version because it already has text chat. I think that's a simple solution , don't you? I do.
    So personally I'm good without text chat, and I'm a console gamer.


    Voice chat and text-based chat are simply different tools, and we would like to use the best tool for the job[/size] instead of constantly trying to force the square peg into the round hole and being told that's how it should work. It's not.
    Using Voice Chat to organize a Guild is like using a Hammer to cut your toenails![/size]

    I didn't say to "organize" a guild, I only said to help recruit for one in-game w/out resorting to forums outside of the game.

    However, if you'd care to elaborate on your viewpoint as to why you believe this, I'm willing to listen. : )

    Um...Dude...it was just a colorful way of saying I agree with "the right tool for the right job".
    I even posted the same sentiment way back around page 3. (lol)

    As it is right now, if you want to talk to every member of your guild that is ingame at the moment, you have to jump into "room 1" say what you need and wait for replies, then jump into "room 2" and wait for replies....etc.
    And the tooltip for VC even says; "Guilds get their own Voice Channels. The larger the Guild the more channels they get."
    So, our "reward" for building a large/successful guild is to have our ability to communicate with them hampered to an extreme.
    EQUALIZE ALL PLATFORMS!
    IF ONE HAS IT...ALL SHOULD HAVE IT!
    !

    )==================================================(
    ~MegaServer~>PS4 (NA) ~PSN~>Ace-of-Destiny
    )===================================================(
    I don't care what platform it is on...an MMORPG without Text Chat is NOT an MMORPG!
  • SocialAssassin
    SocialAssassin
    ✭✭✭
    It does have a chat system , although you may not particularly like it or care for it. It does have one. What about having your text chat through the xbone or PS4 party system? And you can chat and, possibly end up with carpal tunnel? To your hearts content. I'm guessing nothihg will be good enough , until you get your text chat right. Well okay say that Zenimax caves, then you can count on a couple of things 1. This game will go 100% toxic after that . 2. the fanbase will drop off , considerably myself included. And of course all those "self entitled gamers" would really care less. Because their only solution , is for allot of us to go play another game. Which is allot easier said then done, especially if your not a fanboy gamer. And all you do is play the same exact 3 games , a billion times.

    Batman Arkham Knight, was a complete bust. So until Deception IV, later this month it's back to ESOTU for a bit.
    “I’m The Best There Is At What I Do. But What I Do Isn't Very Nice…” - Wolverine/Logan/James Howlett
This discussion has been closed.