This is only true if you buy your materials. If you farm them, there is not cost to your supply. Both scenarios, writs or straight sale, still would give a farmer pure 100% profit.anitajoneb17_ESO wrote: »imnotanother wrote: »I make money doing writs, more than it cost. (See list and definition above)
Crafting writs have NEVER rewarded more materials than it took to complete the quest.
I feel like I might be the only one that gets it.
No, I understand you. But Vangy has a point.
Depending on the state of the market for mats, it might or might not be more profitable to do the crafting writs or to sell the mats directly. When mats are cheap like now, it's possibly more profitable to do writs. When mats prices are high, it's definitely a loss.
You also have a very good point : crafting writs for equipment have NEVER been a way to gather mats, nor have they ever been meant to. It's merely a sink for extra mats for people who enjoy farming mats.
In short, if you have extra mats stocked up, you can choose between selling them directly or do writs. But if you don't have extra mats and you need to buy them to complete writs, you're better off not doing them at all.
imnotanother wrote: »prof·itimnotanother wrote: »imnotanother wrote: »imnotanother wrote: »Get off your butts and farm the mats. 100% profit.
"There is no such thing as a free lunch. "
.......
Except the whole point of crafting dailies is to help u get mats that you need to craft..... The gold mats are just icing.... Right now its costing me mats.... Id rather just farm mats and NOT do the dailies for an even bigger profit.... Or is simple math a little hard for you to comprehend.... When something costs you more than what you get in return, its not a 100% profit.. Its a LOSS...... In this case a pretty sizeable one...
Simmer down
How is it not 100% profit? You farm mats, take said mats and craft writs, turn in writs and you are rewarded with gold, upgrade materials(able to be sold), gear (able to be sold/decon) glass frags(able to be sold), and surveys (where you can farm mats).
The process cost 0 gold. Using simple math... You make a 100% profit.
But go ahead and continue to be close minded and ignorant to common sense.
....................... Wow im really going to have to explain this step by step arent I.......
1. Farm mats.
2. Refine mats for gold tempers waxes etc
3. Sell refined mats
More profit than doing crafting dailies for equipment writs. Is this really so complex to understand? So educate me again on how you arrived at your 100% profit result?
It is in the quote. It is simple. You are making it hard.
1. Wrothgar, Hews Bane, and Gold Coast have mats...they are free to pick up. (Free)
2. Pick up writ quest. Make gear with free mats you farmed. (Free)
3. Turn in writs. (Free)
4. Open reward packages. (Free)
5. Receive XP, gold, glass frags,Gold upgrades, gear, and surveys. (Profit)
6. Sell upgrades/glass (profit)
7. Sell/decon gear (profit)
8. Farm surveys (free)
9. Refine mats (free)
10. Sell mats/ upgrades (profit)
11. Repeat
Where are you having a hard time understanding my point?
Crafting writs are not a source of gaining materials (considering it cost materials); it is a source to earn gold, XP, glass frags, gold upgrades.
No one argued that farming mats isn't a great way to make money either. Crafting writs are just another source.
Yikes, still doesn't get it.
ˈpräfət/
noun
1.
a financial gain, especially the difference between the amount earned and the amount spent in buying, operating, or producing something.
I make money doing writs, more than it cost. (See list and definition above)
Crafting writs have NEVER rewarded more materials than it took to complete the quest.
I feel like I might be the only one that gets it.
imnotanother wrote: »@Taia
What are you trying to say? I see you are struggling with the vocabulary and the concept. Can you point out where a gold loss is suffered when completing writs? When do you lose money?
Materials.... Yes you will use them to complete the quest but you make a profit...
If I farm/refine 100 ingots then use 50 to complete the writ, I still have 50. The 100 were free. I used 50 to make gear and was paid to make it. Where is the loss in gold?
Where is your logic? Please explain instead of quoting me.
CHIMCHIMCheree wrote: »imnotanother wrote: »@Taia
What are you trying to say? I see you are struggling with the vocabulary and the concept. Can you point out where a gold loss is suffered when completing writs? When do you lose money?
Materials.... Yes you will use them to complete the quest but you make a profit...
If I farm/refine 100 ingots then use 50 to complete the writ, I still have 50. The 100 were free. I used 50 to make gear and was paid to make it. Where is the loss in gold?
Where is your logic? Please explain instead of quoting me.
You start with having no assets. Then you farm materials, now you have some assets and those assets have a certain value in gold. Say the assets you farm have a gold value of 10k. Your net worth is now 10k.
Then you do a crafting writ. You exchange 5k in assets for the crafting writ rewards.
The crafting writ rewards are worth 2k, let's say. This is a lower value than the investment you made. You have lost 3k in this transaction. If you are contesting the argument that writ rewards have lower value than the required materials do, your experience is inconsistent with that of other players.
Your argument appears to be "but you started with nothing!". Sure, that's true. But then you worked to acquire something and if you hadn't participated in the broken crafting writ transaction you would have been better off.
As such, the crafting writ transaction disadvantages you and isn't worth doing.
In your example, the 100 ingots you farm were not free. They cost time. If instead of farming 100 ingots and doing a crafting writ you had instead only farmed 50 ingots, you would come out with the same number of ingots but with less time invested, making not doing the crafting writ a better choice financially.
imnotanother wrote: »@Taia
What are you trying to say? I see you are struggling with the vocabulary and the concept. Can you point out where a gold loss is suffered when completing writs? When do you lose money?
Materials.... Yes you will use them to complete the quest but you make a profit...
If I farm/refine 100 ingots then use 50 to complete the writ, I still have 50. The 100 were free. I used 50 to make gear and was paid to make it. Where is the loss in gold?
Where is your logic? Please explain instead of quoting me.
BruhItsOver9000 wrote: »I have a better way of getting gold mats. Farm old orsinium for rubedo. Get a stack of 650, Now refine, sell the rubedo, buy gold mats, profit.
imnotanother wrote: »@Vangy @CHIMCHIMCheree
But you never suffer a loss in gold. That is my point. You always profit in both situations.
You assume your materials will sell. It is not a guarantee. Crafting writs are a guarantee.
When farming you literally have 0 expense. Your time and Labor are free.
Gross revenue - expenses =
Net profit.
CHIMCHIMCheree wrote: »You seem like the kind of person who finds $20 on the ground, then exchanges it for $10 and feels awesome about that sweet sweet $10 profit.
Haha I get it man. I really do but you never lose anything. You might make less...but never lose anything.imnotanother wrote: »@Vangy @CHIMCHIMCheree
But you never suffer a loss in gold. That is my point. You always profit in both situations.
You assume your materials will sell. It is not a guarantee. Crafting writs are a guarantee.
When farming you literally have 0 expense. Your time and Labor are free.
Gross revenue - expenses =
Net profit.
@imnotanother
Have you tried selling v15 mats? They sell like hot cakes lol. Especially the unrefined ones. Put them on any legit guild trader and they are gone by the end of the day as long as you post them for reasonable prices.......
My friend I am trying to help you here. If you want to refuse the help I understand but the fact still stands, that you are LOSING your precious gold by doing these writs. SAVE YOURSELF WHILE YOU CAN.
P.S -> Jesus..... Labor and time free.... If you tried this in the real world you would be behind bars......
imnotanother wrote: »Haha I get it man. I really do but you never lose anything. You might make less...but never lose anything.imnotanother wrote: »@Vangy @CHIMCHIMCheree
But you never suffer a loss in gold. That is my point. You always profit in both situations.
You assume your materials will sell. It is not a guarantee. Crafting writs are a guarantee.
When farming you literally have 0 expense. Your time and Labor are free.
Gross revenue - expenses =
Net profit.
@imnotanother
Have you tried selling v15 mats? They sell like hot cakes lol. Especially the unrefined ones. Put them on any legit guild trader and they are gone by the end of the day as long as you post them for reasonable prices.......
My friend I am trying to help you here. If you want to refuse the help I understand but the fact still stands, that you are LOSING your precious gold by doing these writs. SAVE YOURSELF WHILE YOU CAN.
P.S -> Jesus..... Labor and time free.... If you tried this in the real world you would be behind bars......
And thank you for your "help."
Just an FYI, I am an owner of a successful business. I am quite aware of real world economics.
imnotanother wrote: »Haha I get it man. I really do but you never lose anything. You might make less...but never lose anything.imnotanother wrote: »@Vangy @CHIMCHIMCheree
But you never suffer a loss in gold. That is my point. You always profit in both situations.
You assume your materials will sell. It is not a guarantee. Crafting writs are a guarantee.
When farming you literally have 0 expense. Your time and Labor are free.
Gross revenue - expenses =
Net profit.
@imnotanother
Have you tried selling v15 mats? They sell like hot cakes lol. Especially the unrefined ones. Put them on any legit guild trader and they are gone by the end of the day as long as you post them for reasonable prices.......
My friend I am trying to help you here. If you want to refuse the help I understand but the fact still stands, that you are LOSING your precious gold by doing these writs. SAVE YOURSELF WHILE YOU CAN.
P.S -> Jesus..... Labor and time free.... If you tried this in the real world you would be behind bars......
And thank you for your "help."
Just an FYI, I am an owner of a successful business. I am quite aware of real world economics.
Sure thing. Hopefully your successful buisness dosent involve slave trading cos that's illegal ya know. Its the only place that I know of where worker's labour and time aren't paid for...... I KID I KID =X
imnotanother wrote: »imnotanother wrote: »Haha I get it man. I really do but you never lose anything. You might make less...but never lose anything.imnotanother wrote: »@Vangy @CHIMCHIMCheree
But you never suffer a loss in gold. That is my point. You always profit in both situations.
You assume your materials will sell. It is not a guarantee. Crafting writs are a guarantee.
When farming you literally have 0 expense. Your time and Labor are free.
Gross revenue - expenses =
Net profit.
@imnotanother
Have you tried selling v15 mats? They sell like hot cakes lol. Especially the unrefined ones. Put them on any legit guild trader and they are gone by the end of the day as long as you post them for reasonable prices.......
My friend I am trying to help you here. If you want to refuse the help I understand but the fact still stands, that you are LOSING your precious gold by doing these writs. SAVE YOURSELF WHILE YOU CAN.
P.S -> Jesus..... Labor and time free.... If you tried this in the real world you would be behind bars......
And thank you for your "help."
Just an FYI, I am an owner of a successful business. I am quite aware of real world economics.
Sure thing. Hopefully your successful buisness dosent involve slave trading cos that's illegal ya know. Its the only place that I know of where worker's labour and time aren't paid for...... I KID I KID =X
My god...
I hope you get the "awesomes" and "agrees" you are so desperately chasing.
Good night
FloppyTouch wrote: »I seem to make really good gold doing the writs 100k+ a week and I farm all the mats so it's all free
imnotanother wrote: »This is only true if you buy your materials. If you farm them, there is not cost to your supply. Both scenarios, writs or straight sale, still would give a farmer pure 100% profit.anitajoneb17_ESO wrote: »imnotanother wrote: »I make money doing writs, more than it cost. (See list and definition above)
Crafting writs have NEVER rewarded more materials than it took to complete the quest.
I feel like I might be the only one that gets it.
No, I understand you. But Vangy has a point.
Depending on the state of the market for mats, it might or might not be more profitable to do the crafting writs or to sell the mats directly. When mats are cheap like now, it's possibly more profitable to do writs. When mats prices are high, it's definitely a loss.
You also have a very good point : crafting writs for equipment have NEVER been a way to gather mats, nor have they ever been meant to. It's merely a sink for extra mats for people who enjoy farming mats.
In short, if you have extra mats stocked up, you can choose between selling them directly or do writs. But if you don't have extra mats and you need to buy them to complete writs, you're better off not doing them at all.
The OP's point was saying it is not profitable to do writs and that is a false statement.
My point ha been that farming mats is free. Selling them in any form is pure profit.
imnotanother wrote: »Haha I get it man. I really do but you never lose anything. You might make less...but never lose anything.
imnotanother wrote: »Haha I get it man. I really do but you never lose anything. You might make less...but never lose anything.imnotanother wrote: »@Vangy @CHIMCHIMCheree
But you never suffer a loss in gold. That is my point. You always profit in both situations.
You assume your materials will sell. It is not a guarantee. Crafting writs are a guarantee.
When farming you literally have 0 expense. Your time and Labor are free.
Gross revenue - expenses =
Net profit.
@imnotanother
Have you tried selling v15 mats? They sell like hot cakes lol. Especially the unrefined ones. Put them on any legit guild trader and they are gone by the end of the day as long as you post them for reasonable prices.......
My friend I am trying to help you here. If you want to refuse the help I understand but the fact still stands, that you are LOSING your precious gold by doing these writs. SAVE YOURSELF WHILE YOU CAN.
P.S -> Jesus..... Labor and time free.... If you tried this in the real world you would be behind bars......
And thank you for your "help."
Just an FYI, I am an owner of a successful business. I am quite aware of real world economics.
Sure thing. Hopefully your successful buisness dosent involve slave trading cos that's illegal ya know. Its the only place that I know of where worker's labour and time aren't paid for...... I KID I KID =X
imnotanother wrote: »Ok everyone, I jumped on the game to do my writs. From the 3 equipment writs, this is the rewards:
792g, 1 dreugh wax, 1 temp alloy, 2 repair kits, 2 trait stones, an axe that sells for 280%, 2 Glass fragments, and a Clothing survey. Plus mats from survey. 44 of silk and void each.
Collected survey and refined mats. Got another wax.
Lets add what I can sell: 792 + 281 (axe)+ 3,000 (2 frags)+ 15,000 (temp alloy) + 16,000 (2 wax) = 35,073 gold.
That is a profit.
imnotanother wrote: »Haha I get it man. I really do but you never lose anything. You might make less...but never lose anything.
imnotanother wrote: »Ok everyone, I jumped on the game to do my writs. From the 3 equipment writs, this is the rewards:
792g, 1 dreugh wax, 1 temp alloy, 2 repair kits, 2 trait stones, an axe that sells for 280%, 2 Glass fragments, and a Clothing survey. Plus mats from survey. 44 of silk and void each.
Collected survey and refined mats. Got another wax.
Lets add what I can sell: 792 + 281 (axe)+ 3,000 (2 frags)+ 15,000 (temp alloy) + 16,000 (2 wax) = 35,073 gold.
That is a profit.
Good now that you have come close to understanding basic economics now we can get to work trying to make you understand RNG. (you still need to compare how much material you used relative to how much you got from the surveys). If you are doing void writs, then its a non-issue. We are discussing end game writs so I think maybe u have a typo in there. Those waxes and tempers you got are RNG. More often than not, you wont get gold mats from equipment writs. Same applies for surveys. So on most days, you will be making a loss.
And 15k for a temper??? and 8k per wax???? Wow ps4 pricing is insane....... Keep doing these writs and tabulate the results like I have done over the past week. You will eventually come to the same conclusion as me as long as you dont forget to account for the usage of mats and the influx of mats from surveys.
imnotanother wrote: »prof·itimnotanother wrote: »imnotanother wrote: »imnotanother wrote: »Get off your butts and farm the mats. 100% profit.
"There is no such thing as a free lunch. "
.......
Except the whole point of crafting dailies is to help u get mats that you need to craft..... The gold mats are just icing.... Right now its costing me mats.... Id rather just farm mats and NOT do the dailies for an even bigger profit.... Or is simple math a little hard for you to comprehend.... When something costs you more than what you get in return, its not a 100% profit.. Its a LOSS...... In this case a pretty sizeable one...
Simmer down
How is it not 100% profit? You farm mats, take said mats and craft writs, turn in writs and you are rewarded with gold, upgrade materials(able to be sold), gear (able to be sold/decon) glass frags(able to be sold), and surveys (where you can farm mats).
The process cost 0 gold. Using simple math... You make a 100% profit.
But go ahead and continue to be close minded and ignorant to common sense.
....................... Wow im really going to have to explain this step by step arent I.......
1. Farm mats.
2. Refine mats for gold tempers waxes etc
3. Sell refined mats
More profit than doing crafting dailies for equipment writs. Is this really so complex to understand? So educate me again on how you arrived at your 100% profit result?
It is in the quote. It is simple. You are making it hard.
1. Wrothgar, Hews Bane, and Gold Coast have mats...they are free to pick up. (Free)
2. Pick up writ quest. Make gear with free mats you farmed. (Free)
3. Turn in writs. (Free)
4. Open reward packages. (Free)
5. Receive XP, gold, glass frags,Gold upgrades, gear, and surveys. (Profit)
6. Sell upgrades/glass (profit)
7. Sell/decon gear (profit)
8. Farm surveys (free)
9. Refine mats (free)
10. Sell mats/ upgrades (profit)
11. Repeat
Where are you having a hard time understanding my point?
Crafting writs are not a source of gaining materials (considering it cost materials); it is a source to earn gold, XP, glass frags, gold upgrades.
No one argued that farming mats isn't a great way to make money either. Crafting writs are just another source.
Yikes, still doesn't get it.
ˈpräfət/
noun
1.
a financial gain, especially the difference between the amount earned and the amount spent in buying, operating, or producing something.
I make money doing writs, more than it cost. (See list and definition above)
Crafting writs have NEVER rewarded more materials than it took to complete the quest.
I feel like I might be the only one that gets it.