How exactly is changing one's race "lore-breaking", anyway?
Explorer's Pack exists. I'm already an Argonian in the Covenant. I'm already a Redguard in the Pact. I'm already a Breton in the Dominion.
How is race-changing any more lore-breaking than what is already currently in the game?
It's certainly not "pay to win", as none of the racials are game-breakingly powerful at all.
The choice of one's race comes at the character creation screen, when one is generally the least informed of what they are doing. If, after having invested many hours and learning much more about the game, a player comes to think that they made an error, or simply do not enjoy looking at their character, I don't believe it's any issue to rectify that problem.
Would I change my race? No, probably not, I roll multiples of a lot of the classes. Do I expect every other player to do exactly what I do, because that's the way that I did it? No, I don't.
The explorers pack isn't lore breaking because there will always be enemy races in each alliance. It's the simple fact that no matter what not everyone is a bad guy even in real life you have people considered bad guys and we live with the same race with no problems. We can use a real life example, most of the world is dealing with certain terrorist groups who are Muslims, meanwhile a lot of Muslims live among the U.S and U.K with no issue. So just because you are fighting with a specific group of people doesn't mean all of that race agrees with them. In the daggerfall covenant I see a lot of races that are in other alliances and they give you quests and I'm sure it's the same in the other factions.
So going with your reason of "none of the racials are game-breakingly powerful" why then are you and so many others pushing for it? If you don't think you made the right race choice then that must have a reason behind it. I think that reason is a way for you to change to the more powerful race of the moment otherwise known as the flavor of the month. In all honesty I don't see any reason why someone would change to another race after playing for so long as their race unless they have some sneaky reason for it. It would be pay to win for that very reason.
vyndral13preub18_ESO wrote: »How exactly is changing one's race "lore-breaking", anyway?
Explorer's Pack exists. I'm already an Argonian in the Covenant. I'm already a Redguard in the Pact. I'm already a Breton in the Dominion.
How is race-changing any more lore-breaking than what is already currently in the game?
It's certainly not "pay to win", as none of the racials are game-breakingly powerful at all.
The choice of one's race comes at the character creation screen, when one is generally the least informed of what they are doing. If, after having invested many hours and learning much more about the game, a player comes to think that they made an error, or simply do not enjoy looking at their character, I don't believe it's any issue to rectify that problem.
Would I change my race? No, probably not, I roll multiples of a lot of the classes. Do I expect every other player to do exactly what I do, because that's the way that I did it? No, I don't.
The explorers pack isn't lore breaking because there will always be enemy races in each alliance. It's the simple fact that no matter what not everyone is a bad guy even in real life you have people considered bad guys and we live with the same race with no problems. We can use a real life example, most of the world is dealing with certain terrorist groups who are Muslims, meanwhile a lot of Muslims live among the U.S and U.K with no issue. So just because you are fighting with a specific group of people doesn't mean all of that race agrees with them. In the daggerfall covenant I see a lot of races that are in other alliances and they give you quests and I'm sure it's the same in the other factions.
So going with your reason of "none of the racials are game-breakingly powerful" why then are you and so many others pushing for it? If you don't think you made the right race choice then that must have a reason behind it. I think that reason is a way for you to change to the more powerful race of the moment otherwise known as the flavor of the month. In all honesty I don't see any reason why someone would change to another race after playing for so long as their race unless they have some sneaky reason for it. It would be pay to win for that very reason.
Have you ever changed equipment, even though they both have the same stats? What was the reasoning? Was it sneaky? Or did you perhaps just like the way one looked better? Or did you ever wear a certain piece of armor long enough, that you changed simply to look different, because you were tired of the way you looked? And when you did, did you feel sneaky about it? Because in all honesty I don't see any reason why someone would change their armor after wearing it for so long unless they had a sneaky reason for it.
vyndral13preub18_ESO wrote: »How exactly is changing one's race "lore-breaking", anyway?
Explorer's Pack exists. I'm already an Argonian in the Covenant. I'm already a Redguard in the Pact. I'm already a Breton in the Dominion.
How is race-changing any more lore-breaking than what is already currently in the game?
It's certainly not "pay to win", as none of the racials are game-breakingly powerful at all.
The choice of one's race comes at the character creation screen, when one is generally the least informed of what they are doing. If, after having invested many hours and learning much more about the game, a player comes to think that they made an error, or simply do not enjoy looking at their character, I don't believe it's any issue to rectify that problem.
Would I change my race? No, probably not, I roll multiples of a lot of the classes. Do I expect every other player to do exactly what I do, because that's the way that I did it? No, I don't.
The explorers pack isn't lore breaking because there will always be enemy races in each alliance. It's the simple fact that no matter what not everyone is a bad guy even in real life you have people considered bad guys and we live with the same race with no problems. We can use a real life example, most of the world is dealing with certain terrorist groups who are Muslims, meanwhile a lot of Muslims live among the U.S and U.K with no issue. So just because you are fighting with a specific group of people doesn't mean all of that race agrees with them. In the daggerfall covenant I see a lot of races that are in other alliances and they give you quests and I'm sure it's the same in the other factions.
So going with your reason of "none of the racials are game-breakingly powerful" why then are you and so many others pushing for it? If you don't think you made the right race choice then that must have a reason behind it. I think that reason is a way for you to change to the more powerful race of the moment otherwise known as the flavor of the month. In all honesty I don't see any reason why someone would change to another race after playing for so long as their race unless they have some sneaky reason for it. It would be pay to win for that very reason.
Have you ever changed equipment, even though they both have the same stats? What was the reasoning? Was it sneaky? Or did you perhaps just like the way one looked better? Or did you ever wear a certain piece of armor long enough, that you changed simply to look different, because you were tired of the way you looked? And when you did, did you feel sneaky about it? Because in all honesty I don't see any reason why someone would change their armor after wearing it for so long unless they had a sneaky reason for it.
Honestly no I haven't because I really don't care if I look pretty. If I like how my character looks when I make him, it doesn't matter if he's the ugliest or the prettiest or anything in between I will take it. No I have not switched armor because I was bored with how I looked, I switch because I have better armor which to me anyway is more important then looking pretty. There is nothing sneaky about changing armor at all unlike race changing which is basically you trying to be the flavor of the month.
Ok lets go through this one at a time.
1 I doubt someone who is into RP would use a race change option that clearly breaks most RPers immersion.
2 I can understand someone misreading descriptions, but most people would realize their mistake pretty soon after and if they are that lazy and unwilling to reroll something that would take them 15 minutes then that's their fault.
3 If they can't stand looking at their "kitty cat man" why make it in the first place?
4 Again if they don't think their toon is pretty then they shouldn't have finished character creation until they thought he was.
5 As for the "lizard twins" as sucky as that situation may be I do not see a reason why relationship issues should be a reason to add a race change to the game. That would be on the same level as people who get a tattoo of their significant others name and then they break up.
6 That's the beauty of this game you can change your style on one character. This isn't any other mmo where if you choose a style you have to stick with it and not do anything that doesn't work with it.
It breaks lore that's why it effects me and a lot of other people. If it didn't break lore I wouldn't have an issue with it. This isn't WoW or any other mmo, this game is based on a franchise that specializes in lore.
vyndral13preub18_ESO wrote: »vyndral13preub18_ESO wrote: »How exactly is changing one's race "lore-breaking", anyway?
Explorer's Pack exists. I'm already an Argonian in the Covenant. I'm already a Redguard in the Pact. I'm already a Breton in the Dominion.
How is race-changing any more lore-breaking than what is already currently in the game?
It's certainly not "pay to win", as none of the racials are game-breakingly powerful at all.
The choice of one's race comes at the character creation screen, when one is generally the least informed of what they are doing. If, after having invested many hours and learning much more about the game, a player comes to think that they made an error, or simply do not enjoy looking at their character, I don't believe it's any issue to rectify that problem.
Would I change my race? No, probably not, I roll multiples of a lot of the classes. Do I expect every other player to do exactly what I do, because that's the way that I did it? No, I don't.
The explorers pack isn't lore breaking because there will always be enemy races in each alliance. It's the simple fact that no matter what not everyone is a bad guy even in real life you have people considered bad guys and we live with the same race with no problems. We can use a real life example, most of the world is dealing with certain terrorist groups who are Muslims, meanwhile a lot of Muslims live among the U.S and U.K with no issue. So just because you are fighting with a specific group of people doesn't mean all of that race agrees with them. In the daggerfall covenant I see a lot of races that are in other alliances and they give you quests and I'm sure it's the same in the other factions.
So going with your reason of "none of the racials are game-breakingly powerful" why then are you and so many others pushing for it? If you don't think you made the right race choice then that must have a reason behind it. I think that reason is a way for you to change to the more powerful race of the moment otherwise known as the flavor of the month. In all honesty I don't see any reason why someone would change to another race after playing for so long as their race unless they have some sneaky reason for it. It would be pay to win for that very reason.
Have you ever changed equipment, even though they both have the same stats? What was the reasoning? Was it sneaky? Or did you perhaps just like the way one looked better? Or did you ever wear a certain piece of armor long enough, that you changed simply to look different, because you were tired of the way you looked? And when you did, did you feel sneaky about it? Because in all honesty I don't see any reason why someone would change their armor after wearing it for so long unless they had a sneaky reason for it.
Honestly no I haven't because I really don't care if I look pretty. If I like how my character looks when I make him, it doesn't matter if he's the ugliest or the prettiest or anything in between I will take it. No I have not switched armor because I was bored with how I looked, I switch because I have better armor which to me anyway is more important then looking pretty. There is nothing sneaky about changing armor at all unlike race changing which is basically you trying to be the flavor of the month.
Honestly, then I can see why you have the opinion you have. If you honestly just take whatever armor shows up first with the best stats, never trying to make it match or look good then it is easy to understand why you have a difficult time understanding why someone might want to change the way they look, because you don't care about how you look.
at the cost of the lore.
vyndral13preub18_ESO wrote: »vyndral13preub18_ESO wrote: »How exactly is changing one's race "lore-breaking", anyway?
Explorer's Pack exists. I'm already an Argonian in the Covenant. I'm already a Redguard in the Pact. I'm already a Breton in the Dominion.
How is race-changing any more lore-breaking than what is already currently in the game?
It's certainly not "pay to win", as none of the racials are game-breakingly powerful at all.
The choice of one's race comes at the character creation screen, when one is generally the least informed of what they are doing. If, after having invested many hours and learning much more about the game, a player comes to think that they made an error, or simply do not enjoy looking at their character, I don't believe it's any issue to rectify that problem.
Would I change my race? No, probably not, I roll multiples of a lot of the classes. Do I expect every other player to do exactly what I do, because that's the way that I did it? No, I don't.
The explorers pack isn't lore breaking because there will always be enemy races in each alliance. It's the simple fact that no matter what not everyone is a bad guy even in real life you have people considered bad guys and we live with the same race with no problems. We can use a real life example, most of the world is dealing with certain terrorist groups who are Muslims, meanwhile a lot of Muslims live among the U.S and U.K with no issue. So just because you are fighting with a specific group of people doesn't mean all of that race agrees with them. In the daggerfall covenant I see a lot of races that are in other alliances and they give you quests and I'm sure it's the same in the other factions.
So going with your reason of "none of the racials are game-breakingly powerful" why then are you and so many others pushing for it? If you don't think you made the right race choice then that must have a reason behind it. I think that reason is a way for you to change to the more powerful race of the moment otherwise known as the flavor of the month. In all honesty I don't see any reason why someone would change to another race after playing for so long as their race unless they have some sneaky reason for it. It would be pay to win for that very reason.
Have you ever changed equipment, even though they both have the same stats? What was the reasoning? Was it sneaky? Or did you perhaps just like the way one looked better? Or did you ever wear a certain piece of armor long enough, that you changed simply to look different, because you were tired of the way you looked? And when you did, did you feel sneaky about it? Because in all honesty I don't see any reason why someone would change their armor after wearing it for so long unless they had a sneaky reason for it.
Honestly no I haven't because I really don't care if I look pretty. If I like how my character looks when I make him, it doesn't matter if he's the ugliest or the prettiest or anything in between I will take it. No I have not switched armor because I was bored with how I looked, I switch because I have better armor which to me anyway is more important then looking pretty. There is nothing sneaky about changing armor at all unlike race changing which is basically you trying to be the flavor of the month.
Honestly, then I can see why you have the opinion you have. If you honestly just take whatever armor shows up first with the best stats, never trying to make it match or look good then it is easy to understand why you have a difficult time understanding why someone might want to change the way they look, because you don't care about how you look.
I never said that I've never done it before only that I haven't done it in this game, but you are right that I don't care how I look as much as some people. Being that I have dabbled in mixing and matching before I understand why some people like to do that, but not by adding in a race change option at the cost of the lore.
Ok lets go through this one at a time.
1 I doubt someone who is into RP would use a race change option that clearly breaks most RPers immersion.
If they want to completely change their character w/out completely doing all of the VR content, which is extremely tedious, a race change would be an option.2 I can understand someone misreading descriptions, but most people would realize their mistake pretty soon after and if they are that lazy and unwilling to reroll something that would take them 15 minutes then that's their fault.
You assume a lot w/ this statement. Tooltips in this game are extremely misleading, and a great deal of the mechanics are hidden to most players, unless they thoroughly research forums. Even in these forums, you will most likely find far more misinformation than actual data.
If you are such a savvy player that you can not only unlock all of a character's racials w/in 15 minutes, but also thoroughly test them w/out even knowing that they need to be tested, very likely w/out the aid of essential addons for testing like combat logs and DPS meters, then you should probably be doing something more substantial w/ your time. : P3 If they can't stand looking at their "kitty cat man" why make it in the first place?
I don't think you understand how bi-polar and other mental illnesses work...4 Again if they don't think their toon is pretty then they shouldn't have finished character creation until they thought he was.
When I was a kid, side ponytails and slap bracelets were all the rage. Obviously people who wore these styles should never have updated their look, even though it's now 2014.5 As for the "lizard twins" as sucky as that situation may be I do not see a reason why relationship issues should be a reason to add a race change to the game. That would be on the same level as people who get a tattoo of their significant others name and then they break up.
It's not "relationship issues", it's any number of personal reasons that may lead to a person wishing to change their race. The true culprit here is the tedium of VR content.
I have multiple VR-level toons, and while I may enjoy grinding sometimes, I'm not one to attempt to force everybody else to play my way.6 That's the beauty of this game you can change your style on one character. This isn't any other mmo where if you choose a style you have to stick with it and not do anything that doesn't work with it.
And some people simply can't stomach the fact that they should have made a different choice 5 months ago. The nagging feeling that "man, I really wish I had made a Redguard, but now I'm VR12 and geared to the teeth, I don't want to do it all over again..." can weigh on some more than others.It breaks lore that's why it effects me and a lot of other people. If it didn't break lore I wouldn't have an issue with it. This isn't WoW or any other mmo, this game is based on a franchise that specializes in lore.
I enjoy the lore as well, and I don't find a race change to be lore-breaking in the slightest. It's a mechanical thing, not a lore thing.
This is like saying that having an action bar is breaking the lore of the game, or seeing a chat window is breaking immersion. Some things are mechanical elements that aren't really included in the game's lore overall, and I would include this among that list.
I can hit an enemy w/ a 656 damage white swing. There, I just broke everybody's immersion.
The action bar is not lore breaking, race changing is. Having hundreds of people changing their race messes with the lore to much. I've said it repeatedly in this thread that only wood elves can change race and only into monsters.
Having hundreds of people changing their race messes with the lore to much. I've said it repeatedly in this thread that only wood elves can change race and only into monsters.
tordr86b16_ESO wrote: »The action bar is not lore breaking, race changing is. Having hundreds of people changing their race messes with the lore to much. I've said it repeatedly in this thread that only wood elves can change race and only into monsters.
Are you keeping tabs on everyone? you must be some creepy stalker then.
Having hundreds of people changing their race messes with the lore to much. I've said it repeatedly in this thread that only wood elves can change race and only into monsters.
Elaborate.
You are not physically watching somebody change their race, like some kind of shapeshifter.
The change takes place behind the scenes entirely. You would have literally no idea if somebody changed their race, unless it was somebody close to you.
You'd never know if somebody playing an Orc used to be a Nord, or vice versa. The Orc is not polymorphing into a Nord...
Having hundreds of people changing their race messes with the lore to much. I've said it repeatedly in this thread that only wood elves can change race and only into monsters.
Elaborate.
You are not physically watching somebody change their race, like some kind of shapeshifter.
The change takes place behind the scenes entirely. You would have literally no idea if somebody changed their race, unless it was somebody close to you.
You'd never know if somebody playing an Orc used to be a Nord, or vice versa. The Orc is not polymorphing into a Nord...
I've already told you how it's breaking the lore. In the lore wood elves are the only race that can change their race and only into monsters. It is not behind the scenes if it's happening in the game where everyone nearby can see.
It is not behind the scenes if it's happening in the game where everyone nearby can see.
philip.ploegerb16_ESO wrote: »It probably would be a lot easier, if Zenimax balanced the different races and gave every race decent bonuses.
Still, the people against race-change are mostly not understandeable for me, they either don't present any arguments at all, or they come with arguments that I don't understand, so I assume it's simply hate.
Arguments of the people favouring a race change service are clear and understandeable though, as they present game situations how they currently are in the game. They made me aware though, that race-change should have a decent cost though, because changing from Dunmer to Altmer just because of a Vampire nerf should not happen, then Zenimax could leech out the money from people wanting to be 100% competetive.
Race change should have a cost, where one is willing to pay it once and after very good consideration, but not multiple times always adjusting to the current patch-state.
You know I may be a bit off on this however it seems to me that the main reason people want a race change service is that they are to lazy to put in the effort starting from scratch with a new character. I'm not saying that's a bad thing (but it really is) Heaven forbid anyone actually put forth some effort. Most young video game players grew up with cheat codes and used them so they could win without any real work on their part. They expect to load up a game and be able to dominate it in a few hours......
This is why I am against race change service. If you don't like your race re roll it will be character building for you to do the extra work to get exactly what you want.
tordr86b16_ESO wrote: »All you're doing is making stuff up to suit your own needs.Having hundreds of people changing their race messes with the lore to much. I've said it repeatedly in this thread that only wood elves can change race and only into monsters.
Elaborate.
You are not physically watching somebody change their race, like some kind of shapeshifter.
The change takes place behind the scenes entirely. You would have literally no idea if somebody changed their race, unless it was somebody close to you.
You'd never know if somebody playing an Orc used to be a Nord, or vice versa. The Orc is not polymorphing into a Nord...
I've already told you how it's breaking the lore. In the lore wood elves are the only race that can change their race and only into monsters. It is not behind the scenes if it's happening in the game where everyone nearby can see.
How does my Char changing race break the frickin lore? Dont argument with that crap.
AlexDougherty wrote: »the Ehlnofey Changed themselves into the Earth-bones to prevent Transformational magic.
Bleakraven wrote: »No, I'll just be happy with a hairstylist.
.philip.ploegerb16_ESO wrote: »It probably would be a lot easier, if Zenimax balanced the different races and gave every race decent bonuses.
Still, the people against race-change are mostly not understandeable for me, they either don't present any arguments at all, or they come with arguments that I don't understand, so I assume it's simply hate.
Arguments of the people favouring a race change service are clear and understandeable though, as they present game situations how they currently are in the game. They made me aware though, that race-change should have a decent cost though, because changing from Dunmer to Altmer just because of a Vampire nerf should not happen, then Zenimax could leech out the money from people wanting to be 100% competetive.
Race change should have a cost, where one is willing to pay it once and after very good consideration, but not multiple times always adjusting to the current patch-state.
As I stated earlier paid race change is laziness!
You know I may be a bit off on this however it seems to me that the main reason people want a race change service is that they are to lazy to put in the effort starting from scratch with a new character. I'm not saying that's a bad thing (but it really is) Heaven forbid anyone actually put forth some effort. Most young video game players grew up with cheat codes and used them so they could win without any real work on their part. They expect to load up a game and be able to dominate it in a few hours......
This is why I am against race change service. If you don't like your race re roll it will be character building for you to do the extra work to get exactly what you want.
tordr86b16_ESO wrote: »Having hundreds of people changing their race messes with the lore to much. I've said it repeatedly in this thread that only wood elves can change race and only into monsters.
Elaborate.
You are not physically watching somebody change their race, like some kind of shapeshifter.
The change takes place behind the scenes entirely. You would have literally no idea if somebody changed their race, unless it was somebody close to you.
You'd never know if somebody playing an Orc used to be a Nord, or vice versa. The Orc is not polymorphing into a Nord...
I've already told you how it's breaking the lore. In the lore wood elves are the only race that can change their race and only into monsters. It is not behind the scenes if it's happening in the game where everyone nearby can see.
Unless you keep tabs on everyone, which you don't ( ? ). As he stated above, your arguments are invalid. All you're doing is making stuff up to suit your own needs.
What breaks lore?
Logging into the game?
Interface (Resources, Actionbar etc)?
Opening a magical interface with all kind of fuzzy things?
Magically being transported to Cyrodiil?
Horse magically popping out of your pockets?
These are necessities and has nothing to do with lore and neither does the race change service. These are mechanical aspects, without these, you wouldn't be able to play the game.
Lore is not set in stone. It can be changed or more can be added. If they want "lore" behind the race change service then by all means, they can knock themselves out. The DLC for Skyrim added the Face Sculptor which allowed you to pay some dude to change your looks. So you see, nothing is impossible.