Sure. Teso needs to let players kill NPCs and other player(when they accept duel).MornaBaine wrote: »Do you feel ESO should implement a duel function? Yes or no? Feel free to elaborate. Also, if they are actually planning to implement a duel function, I'd love to know!
Yeah yeah...but....the question is.....
Should people who want to duel be allowed to. Regardless of what you think its worth is would adding the option benefit the game?
Yes it would because some people like doing it and it doesn't detract from those that don't (if done correctly)
Anything that adds content has to be a good thing if its can be ignored by those that don't want to do it. I can't see how duelling, or any other kind of content added to the game can be a bad thing.
And duelling does help any kind of PvP. The hardest thing for a PvE'er to get to grips with in PvP is not panicking and being able to think logicality about what they need to do instead of mashing any ability they can reach. Controlled duelling with people who are trying to teach you is great for that. I learned so much from my area buddies in wow but the main thing was not to panic. Dying while all sweaty with your heart racing is still dying so if you are gonna die you might as well do it calmly
Blackwidow wrote: »I see dueling as a mockery of PVP. In PVP you don't always get to choose your fights, you don't always have time to be prepared, you don't always have assurances of a fair fight. Dueling provides those who are scared to be beaten on terms not their own a way to seek self validation on a video game, more often than not. Training is irrelevant. PVP has and always will be on the job training.
Right now there is no logical reason to not have dueling, other than selfish people who don't want others to have a feature that would make a lot of players happy and not effect your game at all.
There is no logical reason to have it. If by selfish people you mean ZOS then okay. Outside all the reasons I could provide you why it's not needed, and would be counter productive to further evolving game mechanics, the only reason ZOS needs to state is "no".
And they've clearly taken the "no" stance on the issue. This is evident by the complete absence of a mechanic that is relatively easy to add. Clearly it is part of their design choice for the game.
The reason I disagree completely with adding it, for the most part, it perpetuates a serious flaw in MMO's that developers should work to address. You and others in support would say, it's a common feature in MMO's which means ESO is silly not to have it. This leads to further homogenization of the genre, which I am vehemently against. As players, we should support design decisions that fall outside the norm, even when they are not our personal preference, not stifle them and seek to stamp them out wherever they exist. You're telling the developers that you want more of the same, I'm telling them we do not.
And for the most part, you're the biggest part of the problem why we have seen no evolution in this genre for as many years as it has been around, and what little we've seen has been in the opposite direction. ESO is not exactly my cup of tea, besides things I like about it. But it has potential. And I would rather see the game move further torwards unique gameplay, as a means to bring players back, then focus design decisions on what 90% of the games on the market have.
We don't need a gear check E-Peen ego rub mechanic in the game, we need something that encourages players to do things that they don't normally take part in, and make it fun, like PVP. Duels are bland, pointless, and further alienate the player base from PVPers by misrepresenting who PVPers are. And it's great that ESO doesn't have it.
Fuzzylumpkins wrote: »
Duels are a pointless waste of time that draw in a very specific personality that has the need to feel gratified with some sort of bragging right for participating in a completely consequence free and controlled combat. Much like arenas. You know when it is going to happen and against how many, you even get the heads up of knowing who your opponent is going to be.
What a load of bull!
Duels help you work out counters for other classes. Most duelling happens between friends who want to improve their gameplay.
There is a lot of people here who seem to want to limit the game to their own ver specific requirements. That won't work as an MMO.
ALL MMO's have to cater for a wide verity of people who enjoy a wide verity of game play. You have to have stuff for the hardcore raiders, the l33t PvP'ers, the casual gamers, the RP'ers....
No one of these populations is enough to keep a MMO alive, especially not a sub charging MMO
Blackwidow wrote: »I see dueling as a mockery of PVP. In PVP you don't always get to choose your fights, you don't always have time to be prepared, you don't always have assurances of a fair fight. Dueling provides those who are scared to be beaten on terms not their own a way to seek self validation on a video game, more often than not. Training is irrelevant. PVP has and always will be on the job training.
Right now there is no logical reason to not have dueling, other than selfish people who don't want others to have a feature that would make a lot of players happy and not effect your game at all.
There is no logical reason to have it. If by selfish people you mean ZOS then okay. Outside all the reasons I could provide you why it's not needed, and would be counter productive to further evolving game mechanics, the only reason ZOS needs to state is "no".
And they've clearly taken the "no" stance on the issue. This is evident by the complete absence of a mechanic that is relatively easy to add. Clearly it is part of their design choice for the game.
The reason I disagree completely with adding it, for the most part, it perpetuates a serious flaw in MMO's that developers should work to address. You and others in support would say, it's a common feature in MMO's which means ESO is silly not to have it. This leads to further homogenization of the genre, which I am vehemently against. As players, we should support design decisions that fall outside the norm, even when they are not our personal preference, not stifle them and seek to stamp them out wherever they exist. You're telling the developers that you want more of the same, I'm telling them we do not.
And for the most part, you're the biggest part of the problem why we have seen no evolution in this genre for as many years as it has been around, and what little we've seen has been in the opposite direction. ESO is not exactly my cup of tea, besides things I like about it. But it has potential. And I would rather see the game move further torwards unique gameplay, as a means to bring players back, then focus design decisions on what 90% of the games on the market have.
We don't need a gear check E-Peen ego rub mechanic in the game, we need something that encourages players to do things that they don't normally take part in, and make it fun, like PVP. Duels are bland, pointless, and further alienate the player base from PVPers by misrepresenting who PVPers are. And it's great that ESO doesn't have it.
There a PLENTY of 'logical' reasons for a duel arena, which have been thoroughly stated throughout this thread.
Some of the more obverse reasons include: Battling friends/Guild mates and Optimizing your build for pvp's.
Plus the fact people generally get over the zerg fest that is Cyrodiil and simply want some controlled 1v1 where you can properly pit yourself against your opponent, in a fair fight, without interruptions and gankers, for a true test of skill. Converse to the current 'numbers game' where everyone runs in a herd and spams the same spell.
It doesn't have to be an arena. Any manifestation of a controlled 1v1 area would be loved and appreciated by a LARGE portion of the players.
P.S I found your reasoning regarding 'Arena's preventing the 'evolution' of games' laughable.
Oh trust me, I find this carebear notion that duels or arena combat is in anyway related to PVP a joke. You almost made me spill my beer once or twice. But I managed to save it, whereas a duelist would've choked. But I think you sorely misunderstood the comment, and I can't be bothered explaining it.
I'm still waiting for good reasoning as to how duels can prepare you for PVP though, I haven't heard anyone address that, other than it helps them "min max". If you were half decent you wouldn't need duels for that. How to fight against a certain class. Oh I dunno, there's four whole classes in ESO. If you need time to write an elaborate guide, you aren't going to be winning many 1vs1's anyways.
1vs1 in a controlled environment is not a fair fight, it's a gear/template check, and takes away too many key elements from PVP to be valid. If I can kill you and your friend because I'm better at PVP, I don't think it rightly matters who can win out of the two of you in a duel.
There's plenty of ways to get small scale PVP in Cyrodiil. Nobody ever accused the zerg of requiring any skill. I think you're confusing PVP with "objectives". Again, there's plenty of funny to go around.
Oh trust me, I find this carebear notion that duels or arena combat is in anyway related to PVP a joke. You almost made me spill my beer once or twice. But I managed to save it, whereas a duelist would've choked. But I think you sorely misunderstood the comment, and I can't be bothered explaining it.
I'm still waiting for good reasoning as to how duels can prepare you for PVP though, I haven't heard anyone address that, other than it helps them "min max". If you were half decent you wouldn't need duels for that. How to fight against a certain class. Oh I dunno, there's four whole classes in ESO. If you need time to write an elaborate guide, you aren't going to be winning many 1vs1's anyways.
1vs1 in a controlled environment is not a fair fight, it's a gear/template check, and takes away too many key elements from PVP to be valid. If I can kill you and your friend because I'm better at PVP, I don't think it rightly matters who can win out of the two of you in a duel.
There's plenty of ways to get small scale PVP in Cyrodiil. Nobody ever accused the zerg of requiring any skill. I think you're confusing PVP with "objectives". Again, there's plenty of funny to go around.
The pomposity is great in this one
I'm still waiting for good reasoning as to how duels can prepare you for PVP though, I haven't heard anyone address that, other than it helps them "min max". If you were half decent you wouldn't need duels for that. How to fight against a certain class. Oh I dunno, there's four whole classes in ESO. If you need time to write an elaborate guide, you aren't going to be winning many 1vs1's anyways.
Tannakaobi wrote: »Where does this rubbish that people use dueling as a way to spam people come from?
The pomposity is great in this one
Tannakaobi wrote: »I'm still waiting for good reasoning as to how duels can prepare you for PVP though, I haven't heard anyone address that, other than it helps them "min max". If you were half decent you wouldn't need duels for that. How to fight against a certain class. Oh I dunno, there's four whole classes in ESO. If you need time to write an elaborate guide, you aren't going to be winning many 1vs1's anyways.
OK, if it really needs to be spelt out to you.
1) It allows you to test skills against other skills and how they react. For a really simple and basic example: Burning talons, is annoying you in PVP. So you find your DK friend and ask him to keep casting it on you while you test different skill and see how they react.
2) You can test skills that you have not yet tried and would be uncomfortable to place on your skill bar in PVP.
3) It allows you to see how players use there skills in a controlled situation.
Lets not forget that some people just find dueling FUN!
Tannakaobi wrote: »I'm still waiting for good reasoning as to how duels can prepare you for PVP though, I haven't heard anyone address that, other than it helps them "min max". If you were half decent you wouldn't need duels for that. How to fight against a certain class. Oh I dunno, there's four whole classes in ESO. If you need time to write an elaborate guide, you aren't going to be winning many 1vs1's anyways.
OK, if it really needs to be spelt out to you.
Tannakaobi wrote: »Where does this rubbish that people use dueling as a way to spam people come from?
In every MMO that has come out in the last 10 years, that apparently you havent played.
Far too hard to take your post seriously when you start it off with such an obvious oversight of any underleveled players run of the mill trip to the bank vault in any of mentioned MMO's.
Pretty infantile argument all around. Removing the trees? Serious?
The pomposity is great in this one
Nah, I just know what I'm talkin about mate. I've played games like DF and AoC on the full PVP server, even in noob areas it was FFA.
You would be uninstalling those right quick, no doubt.
Anyone who puts up duels so much just has no credibility when talking about PVP, they're not even related topics.
Tannakaobi wrote: »I'm still waiting for good reasoning as to how duels can prepare you for PVP though, I haven't heard anyone address that, other than it helps them "min max". If you were half decent you wouldn't need duels for that. How to fight against a certain class. Oh I dunno, there's four whole classes in ESO. If you need time to write an elaborate guide, you aren't going to be winning many 1vs1's anyways.
OK, if it really needs to be spelt out to you.
1) It allows you to test skills against other skills and how they react. For a really simple and basic example: Burning talons, is annoying you in PVP. So you find your DK friend and ask him to keep casting it on you while you test different skill and see how they react.
2) You can test skills that you have not yet tried and would be uncomfortable to place on your skill bar in PVP.
3) It allows you to see how players use there skills in a controlled situation.
Lets not forget that some people just find dueling FUN!
Tannakaobi wrote: »Tannakaobi wrote: »Where does this rubbish that people use dueling as a way to spam people come from?
In every MMO that has come out in the last 10 years, that apparently you havent played.
Far too hard to take your post seriously when you start it off with such an obvious oversight of any underleveled players run of the mill trip to the bank vault in any of mentioned MMO's.
Pretty infantile argument all around. Removing the trees? Serious?
Examples?
like I said, It isn't something I have 'seen' first hand, if you read my whole post I mentioned how I could see how it 'could be', I also offered a very simple solution.
'Infantile argument all around. Removing the trees?'
Aye, it was intended to be so, just like the arguments against duels!
Now it has to be said that I absolutely don't care whether or not duals are coming. Won't affect me in the slightest.
What I do question though is when a game pops up that's different from the norm, why do people put so much effort into making it just like every other game on the market, and move on, doing exactly the same thing over and over again until all the games are the same.
An example is people saying this needs duals. This needs Chat Bubbles. This needs an Auction House etcetera.
Familiarity does breed contempt, after all.
Now it has to be said that I absolutely don't care whether or not duals are coming. Won't affect me in the slightest.
What I do question though is when a game pops up that's different from the norm, why do people put so much effort into making it just like every other game on the market, and move on, doing exactly the same thing over and over again until all the games are the same.
An example is people saying this needs duals. This needs Chat Bubbles. This needs an Auction House etcetera.
Familiarity does breed contempt, after all.
We would never have guessed you were 14. Not with such convincing, reasoned logic. You win the internet.
Fairydragon3 wrote: »
Uhoh......he said his age is 14 ish.....this wont end well
We would never have guessed you were 14. Not with such convincing, reasoned logic. You win the internet.
So you have to resort to being an ageist and using straw man arguments,=.
Clearly I'm winning something, and it's not a duel, perhaps you're just bad.
Tannakaobi wrote: »Tannakaobi wrote: »Where does this rubbish that people use dueling as a way to spam people come from?
In every MMO that has come out in the last 10 years, that apparently you havent played.
Far too hard to take your post seriously when you start it off with such an obvious oversight of any underleveled players run of the mill trip to the bank vault in any of mentioned MMO's.
Pretty infantile argument all around. Removing the trees? Serious?
Examples?
like I said, It isn't something I have 'seen' first hand, if you read my whole post I mentioned how I could see how it 'could be', I also offered a very simple solution.
'Infantile argument all around. Removing the trees?'
Aye, it was intended to be so, just like the arguments against duels!
Actually there were some pretty well thought out arguments against it, some for, but mainly against it, on the first few pages. Just because you completely disregard it, doesn't matter.
All it took was you and a few others inexperienced and clueless PVE duel-lite types to start polluting this thread with your complete lack of knowledge for it to completely go downhill. You're just repeating the same very weak arguments of how you personally benefited from duels, when you're simply being told regardless of how you think you've benefited it isn't real PVP, for many many reasons which have already been explained to you, ad nauseam. And on the basis of those arguments you clearly should talk about something you DO know something about, rather than going around grabbing bulls by the horns.