The thread that prompted the 1.4.4 "fixes" to cloak included a video with OP resting against NPCs. GaryA came into the thread and said it was not working correctly. Jessica then updated several times saying they were narrowing down the cause. I'm looking for the video now.Joy_Division wrote: »Alright, I made just a quick sneak peek on what is wrong with stealth/cloak at the moment. I plan on doing more in-depth video on all different skills later on and with enemy players using them (not NPCs), but this is how things generally work atm:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JtIXiRmB-y0&feature=youtu.beJoy_Division wrote: »
If you mean cloak, that gets broken by everything under the sun, then think again. That thing is a waste of magicka, and no competitive player would slot it in its current stance.
I hear this all the time.
I rolled a NB and didn't bother to even level up the cloak skill.
When I got to Cyrodiil at level 15 or so, I forgot how powerful vr14 gear is and I kept dying to residual fire ballista damage and other DoTs. One of my guildmates heard my frustrations and told me to slot cloak because it's not just a vanish button but removes the stuff that is killing me. I told him what you quoted above. He basically said that is way overstated, cloak works the vast majority of the time, most good players all slot and use it, and the times it doesn't work is typically by design (it's not a foolproof invisibility or invulnerability).
I then selected the cloak skill and started using it to eliminate negative effects and try to vanish from other players. Ever since, my experience with the skill has been quite positive...I am wearing 5 light armor, I don't have any stealth passives or gear, and I still reliably vanish from enemies I wish not to see/pursue me (and it also cleanses the stuff that is killing me).
I don't doubt there may have been times when NBs have had frustrating experiences with this skill. All I can say for now is that from the times that I have used it that I am glad I had a guildmate who was smart to actually not trust the "cloak sucks" narrative that is so popular on these forums.
Yes, you can use Dark Cloak for purging still, but even for that there are (arguably) better options, such as Efficient Purge/Cleanse.
Your tests are against NPCs. I don't agree with the game's philosophy, but from my experience NPCs can auto-detect stealthers.
I am unsure of the relationship between invisibility and damaging opponents. Most RPGs do not like this combination and I am curious as to what the developers have said about it.
I also will say I do not use Dark cloak for purge, but I use it for its intended function: to escape. More often than not, it succeeds. Not all the time, but most of it. A NB that cloaks 20 meters away from a human target will reliably evade detection. The only other class that can evade determines pursuit is the sorcerer because of bolt escape.
That being said, if a NB tries to cloak when she is 5 meters away from me in flat, featureless terrain, then the expectations for success are noticeably less. Much less so if I am part of a posse of 4-6 players determined to find them. But is this because cloak is a "waste of magicka," or because I can immediately investigate the potential hiding places via magelight, detection pots, or random AoEs?
Joy_Division wrote: »I am unsure of the relationship between invisibility and damaging opponents. Most RPGs do not like this combination and I am curious as to what the developers have said about it.
Joy_Division wrote: »I am unsure of the relationship between invisibility and damaging opponents. Most RPGs do not like this combination and I am curious as to what the developers have said about it.
RPGs such as... ?
I've been playing RPGs & MMOs for 13 years now, and never have I felt so punished for trying to play a rogue character as in ESO.
1Joy_Division wrote: »I am unsure of the relationship between invisibility and damaging opponents. Most RPGs do not like this combination and I am curious as to what the developers have said about it.
RPGs such as... ?
I've been playing RPGs & MMOs for 13 years now, and never have I felt so punished for trying to play a rogue character as in ESO.
have you tried watching Sypher's videos on how to dodge roll and use cloak? It may help you.
Fixed.1Joy_Division wrote: »I am unsure of the relationship between invisibility and damaging opponents. Most RPGs do not like this combination and I am curious as to what the developers have said about it.
RPGs such as... ?
I've been playing RPGs & MMOs for 13 years now, and never have I felt so punished for trying to play a rogue character as in ESO.
have you tried watching Sypher's videos on how to dodge roll and use cloak? It may help you.
And have you watched my videos? I might know a thing or two about that already.
And is Sypher playing a rogue character? No, he's playing a magicka NB.
Find me a good stamina NB video & we'll talk (no S&B dmg shield/heal bs please effective styles of play please).
Fixed.1Joy_Division wrote: »I am unsure of the relationship between invisibility and damaging opponents. Most RPGs do not like this combination and I am curious as to what the developers have said about it.
RPGs such as... ?
I've been playing RPGs & MMOs for 13 years now, and never have I felt so punished for trying to play a rogue character as in ESO.
have you tried watching Sypher's videos on how to dodge roll and use cloak? It may help you.
And have you watched my videos? I might know a thing or two about that already.
And is Sypher playing a rogue character? No, he's playing a magicka NB.
Find me a good stamina NB video & we'll talk (no S&B dmg shield/heal bs please effective styles of play please).
Dear Zos, the way I want to play is broken thus nightblades suck, ignore the fact they are super powerful in a variety of other playstyles.
kelly.medleyb14_ESO wrote: »Blocking is a very unique part of ESO combat and part of what makes it so great. Block casting is just a gives the combat depth and removing that would make the game more shallow.
LOL what? How come block casting gives such deep combat depth? You just hold block and spam 1-1-1.
I don't think taking it away adds anything, so what's your point? A shield will block the same whether you're wearing any kind of armor TBH. Problem isn't that 1h/s is adding too much mitigation, it's that heavy armor doesn't add enough. I leveled to VR10 with heavy armor because that's how I wanted to play, but had to discard it after realizing the survivability was the same in light armor. Everyone's hate is really misplaced here.
Also people use more than one spell. Not one player in this game uses only one spell, and if a player does it's a healer like me in pvp where 75% or more of my casts are breath of life.
Geez dude, step back and think for a sec, block casting is really a gamebreaking mechanic, as it is now you might as well have permablock on... like a toggle.. so i dont hurt my finger while holding down mousebutton (depth to combat? please.. )
How about adding a blockbreak... like the bash, now that would add actual skill to combat and penalizing those permablockers!
I have thought about it. Block casting will be a thing unless they rework how pve content works, or make shield mitigation passive and not activated. People think it's only a pvp issue. What if your trial tank needs to cast taunt, and the boss hits him with a crit attack and one shots him while his shield is down to cast the taunt? Should the tank let the boss kill someone else to avoid being hit by the attack while taunting?
Even so, in pvp it's going to be impossible to permablock in 1.6. You all will just have to wait and see the patch notes or hope it gets mentioned in this thread... The direction they're going in is the right direction imo.
Are you a girl?Fixed.1Joy_Division wrote: »I am unsure of the relationship between invisibility and damaging opponents. Most RPGs do not like this combination and I am curious as to what the developers have said about it.
RPGs such as... ?
I've been playing RPGs & MMOs for 13 years now, and never have I felt so punished for trying to play a rogue character as in ESO.
have you tried watching Sypher's videos on how to dodge roll and use cloak? It may help you.
And have you watched my videos? I might know a thing or two about that already.
And is Sypher playing a rogue character? No, he's playing a magicka NB.
Find me a good stamina NB video & we'll talk (no S&B dmg shield/heal bs please effective styles of play please).
Dear Zos, the way I want to play is broken thus nightblades suck, ignore the fact they are super powerful in a variety of other playstyles.
Fixed.1Joy_Division wrote: »I am unsure of the relationship between invisibility and damaging opponents. Most RPGs do not like this combination and I am curious as to what the developers have said about it.
RPGs such as... ?
I've been playing RPGs & MMOs for 13 years now, and never have I felt so punished for trying to play a rogue character as in ESO.
have you tried watching Sypher's videos on how to dodge roll and use cloak? It may help you.
And have you watched my videos? I might know a thing or two about that already.
And is Sypher playing a rogue character? No, he's playing a magicka NB.
Find me a good stamina NB video & we'll talk (no S&B dmg shield/heal bs please effective styles of play please).
Dear Zos, the way I want to play is broken thus nightblades suck, ignore the fact they are super powerful in a variety of other playstyles.
kelly.medleyb14_ESO wrote: »Blocking is a very unique part of ESO combat and part of what makes it so great. Block casting is just a gives the combat depth and removing that would make the game more shallow.
LOL what? How come block casting gives such deep combat depth? You just hold block and spam 1-1-1.
I don't think taking it away adds anything, so what's your point? A shield will block the same whether you're wearing any kind of armor TBH. Problem isn't that 1h/s is adding too much mitigation, it's that heavy armor doesn't add enough. I leveled to VR10 with heavy armor because that's how I wanted to play, but had to discard it after realizing the survivability was the same in light armor. Everyone's hate is really misplaced here.
Also people use more than one spell. Not one player in this game uses only one spell, and if a player does it's a healer like me in pvp where 75% or more of my casts are breath of life.
Geez dude, step back and think for a sec, block casting is really a gamebreaking mechanic, as it is now you might as well have permablock on... like a toggle.. so i dont hurt my finger while holding down mousebutton (depth to combat? please.. )
How about adding a blockbreak... like the bash, now that would add actual skill to combat and penalizing those permablockers!
I have thought about it. Block casting will be a thing unless they rework how pve content works, or make shield mitigation passive and not activated. People think it's only a pvp issue. What if your trial tank needs to cast taunt, and the boss hits him with a crit attack and one shots him while his shield is down to cast the taunt? Should the tank let the boss kill someone else to avoid being hit by the attack while taunting?
Even so, in pvp it's going to be impossible to permablock in 1.6. You all will just have to wait and see the patch notes or hope it gets mentioned in this thread... The direction they're going in is the right direction imo.
Sigh... the comment quality here is potato.
1Joy_Division wrote: »I am unsure of the relationship between invisibility and damaging opponents. Most RPGs do not like this combination and I am curious as to what the developers have said about it.
RPGs such as... ?
I've been playing RPGs & MMOs for 13 years now, and never have I felt so punished for trying to play a rogue character as in ESO.
have you tried watching Sypher's videos on how to dodge roll and use cloak? It may help you.
And have you watched my videos? I might know a thing or two about that already.
And is Sypher playing a rogue character? No, he's playing a magicka NB.
Find me a good stamina NB video & we'll talk (no S&B dmg shield/heal bs please).
1Joy_Division wrote: »I am unsure of the relationship between invisibility and damaging opponents. Most RPGs do not like this combination and I am curious as to what the developers have said about it.
RPGs such as... ?
I've been playing RPGs & MMOs for 13 years now, and never have I felt so punished for trying to play a rogue character as in ESO.
have you tried watching Sypher's videos on how to dodge roll and use cloak? It may help you.
And have you watched my videos? I might know a thing or two about that already.
And is Sypher playing a rogue character? No, he's playing a magicka NB.
Find me a good stamina NB video & we'll talk (no S&B dmg shield/heal bs please).
...your bs...
1Joy_Division wrote: »I am unsure of the relationship between invisibility and damaging opponents. Most RPGs do not like this combination and I am curious as to what the developers have said about it.
RPGs such as... ?
I've been playing RPGs & MMOs for 13 years now, and never have I felt so punished for trying to play a rogue character as in ESO.
have you tried watching Sypher's videos on how to dodge roll and use cloak? It may help you.
And have you watched my videos? I might know a thing or two about that already.
And is Sypher playing a rogue character? No, he's playing a magicka NB.
Find me a good stamina NB video & we'll talk (no S&B dmg shield/heal bs please).
I find your exclusion of my 2hand NB because of its SnB offbar disturbing.
And I had so many videos for you
Pancake-Tragedy wrote: »
1Joy_Division wrote: »I am unsure of the relationship between invisibility and damaging opponents. Most RPGs do not like this combination and I am curious as to what the developers have said about it.
RPGs such as... ?
I've been playing RPGs & MMOs for 13 years now, and never have I felt so punished for trying to play a rogue character as in ESO.
have you tried watching Sypher's videos on how to dodge roll and use cloak? It may help you.
And have you watched my videos? I might know a thing or two about that already.
And is Sypher playing a rogue character? No, he's playing a magicka NB.
Find me a good stamina NB video & we'll talk (no S&B dmg shield/heal bs please).
I find your exclusion of my 2hand NB because of its SnB offbar disturbing.
And I had so many videos for you
Please by all means link them (or pm, there are enough video links as is imo).
I enjoy watching other peoples' videos, even if they aren't playing a rogue type character, and the more diversity of builds there are out in Cyrodiil, the happier I am. I'm not sure I can say the same about everyone commenting here.
Pancake-Tragedy wrote: »1Joy_Division wrote: »I am unsure of the relationship between invisibility and damaging opponents. Most RPGs do not like this combination and I am curious as to what the developers have said about it.
RPGs such as... ?
I've been playing RPGs & MMOs for 13 years now, and never have I felt so punished for trying to play a rogue character as in ESO.
have you tried watching Sypher's videos on how to dodge roll and use cloak? It may help you.
And have you watched my videos? I might know a thing or two about that already.
And is Sypher playing a rogue character? No, he's playing a magicka NB.
Find me a good stamina NB video & we'll talk (no S&B dmg shield/heal bs please).
I find your exclusion of my 2hand NB because of its SnB offbar disturbing.
And I had so many videos for you
Please by all means link them (or pm, there are enough video links as is imo).
I enjoy watching other peoples' videos, even if they aren't playing a rogue type character, and the more diversity of builds there are out in Cyrodiil, the happier I am. I'm not sure I can say the same about everyone commenting here.
What the...? Dude you've been arguing what is considered a "rogue" for the past few pages in this thread.
Pancake-Tragedy wrote: »1Joy_Division wrote: »I am unsure of the relationship between invisibility and damaging opponents. Most RPGs do not like this combination and I am curious as to what the developers have said about it.
RPGs such as... ?
I've been playing RPGs & MMOs for 13 years now, and never have I felt so punished for trying to play a rogue character as in ESO.
have you tried watching Sypher's videos on how to dodge roll and use cloak? It may help you.
And have you watched my videos? I might know a thing or two about that already.
And is Sypher playing a rogue character? No, he's playing a magicka NB.
Find me a good stamina NB video & we'll talk (no S&B dmg shield/heal bs please).
I find your exclusion of my 2hand NB because of its SnB offbar disturbing.
And I had so many videos for you
Please by all means link them (or pm, there are enough video links as is imo).
I enjoy watching other peoples' videos, even if they aren't playing a rogue type character, and the more diversity of builds there are out in Cyrodiil, the happier I am. I'm not sure I can say the same about everyone commenting here.
What the...? Dude you've been arguing what is considered a "rogue" for the past few pages in this thread.
No, I haven't been arguing.
I have been giving facts, backed up by factual evidence in the form of an opinion.
Considering how fast you're commenting, I doubt you've even bothered to read them.
Some people just cant accept being wrong...
Since you must be new to gaming, here's a couple of examples.
is exactly how I play my Nightblade. Ask the people that send me rage tells after I kill them in less than 3 seconds (no bow attacks). Somebody posted a video of a dude raging because I killed him in three moves (unfortunately the dude took it off his Twitch page & ZOS deleted the thread).It is about playing in a certain way, as a DPS focused on CC, stealth & burst damage.
Since you must be new to gaming, here's a couple of examples.
Since you must be a condescending prick, I will flat out tell you that my "rogue-like" build does not use a shield or damage shields. In fact, the criteria you listed:is exactly how I play my Nightblade. Ask the people that send me rage tells after I kill them in less than 3 seconds (no bow attacks). Somebody posted a video of a dude raging because I killed him in three moves (unfortunately the dude took it off his Twitch page & ZOS deleted the thread).It is about playing in a certain way, as a DPS focused on CC, stealth & burst damage.
Again, I'm sorry you haven't figured it out, but it IS possible. I'm pretty sure your situation is best described as PEBKAC.
xsorusb14_ESO wrote: »I like how we still have people saying that a magicka nb isn't a true rogue class even though it has virtually the same gameplay as a stamina one. Like really the only difference is the ranged weapon setup