FeedbackOnly wrote: »If 100 people get banned or more a human should be notified. This isn't the first time AI incorrectly banned people.
spartaxoxo wrote: »Finedaible wrote: »Lets play roulette then. Certainly our odds are good, right?
... Right?
Zenimax is not playing roulette. They would be looking for specific behavior to determine who they banned up front.
They literally stated that they unbanned a ton of people because it was determined they had not met their criteria.
That is not the same as playing Russian roulette. Far from it. They set criteria in their search to grab accounts that might be involved and yes, it grabbed some that were not but had similar behavior. Russian roulette is nothing but a shot in the dark, a completely random gamble which is hardly the case here.
FeedbackOnly wrote: »If 100 people get banned or more a human should be notified. This isn't the first time AI incorrectly banned people.
There seems to be this thing where people assume no human was involved with this prior to the initial ban wave. Some automated tool did this. I am curious why people think that, as no evidence that I have seen that suggests that.
Besides, if there was an actual AI involved, and I can't see ZOS being on the edge of that blade, the fault is still with the human that did the training work, especially if they did not check the results for bias or hallucinations.
Krymsyn_Panda wrote: »I don't even want to be caught in a temp ban. I don't pay attention to Seals of Endeavor, but now I have to keep any eye on them to avoid losing the game time I pay for?
I would rather not play then play while afraid I'll get even a temp ban for something out of my control and perfectly within ZoS's control.
EmilyElizabethESO wrote: »Krymsyn_Panda wrote: »I don't even want to be caught in a temp ban. I don't pay attention to Seals of Endeavor, but now I have to keep any eye on them to avoid losing the game time I pay for?
I would rather not play then play while afraid I'll get even a temp ban for something out of my control and perfectly within ZoS's control.
[snip] Hopefully they investigate first and then ban this time around instead of the other way.
Hi everyone, before the weekend starts, we want to provide an update on the current issue where daily Endeavors are sometimes resetting more often than intended. We are aware this is happening, and we are currently investigating solutions for this. While the investigation continues, we would like to remind everyone they should not exploit this issue. While we understand some people will unknowingly run into this through normal play, we will be monitoring and banning those who take extreme advantage and exploit it. Once we have additional information on a fix, we’ll follow up on those next steps. Thank you for your understanding here.
Hi all. Just wanted to follow up here based on some of the feedback. Our intention with highlighting the Endeavor reset issue is to be proactive with the community, noting we are aware of the issue and working toward a solution.
We do not expect players to be monitoring their endeavors in fear of accidentally encountering the exploit, and we'd like to highlight the Endeavor resetting is not a widespread issue and is pretty rare to trigger. In addition, we have a better understanding of the issue and have set up systems on our side to see when someone is specifically exploiting. So if you accidentally run into the issue, you don’t need to worry about having your account actioned.
We are not looking to punish anyone who accidentally stumbles into this, but rather inform the community about an issue we discovered and warn that we will take action on those who take extreme advantage of it (which, again, is not accidental.) We hope this helps to clear up any concerns here. Thanks for your patience and understanding regarding this.
the Endeavor resetting is not a widespread issue and is pretty rare to trigger. In addition, we have a better understanding of the issue and have set up systems on our side to see when someone is specifically exploiting. So if you accidentally run into the issue, you don’t need to worry about having your account actioned.
How 'rare' is rare? 1 in 10 000? 1 in 1000? 1 in 100? 1 in 10? ....? This is far too ambiguous a statement when any player's account could be banned either temporarily or permanently.
Personally, I don't give a rat's rear for seals of endeavour and rarely notice when they accrue but, if this bug is across all platforms, the first I'm going to know about it, judging from these non-statements, is if my account is banned.
While I appreciate the attempt at communication I think all you've succeeded in doing thus far is create a lot of concern, uncertainty and fear. It would really help alleviate those concerns if you just switched off the broken system NOW until its fixed and tell us you're doing that - that's the only way to guarantee that players don't accidentally accrue seals or try to 'exploit' it and alleviate all those uncertainties and concerns already mentioned.
the Endeavor resetting is not a widespread issue and is pretty rare to trigger. In addition, we have a better understanding of the issue and have set up systems on our side to see when someone is specifically exploiting. So if you accidentally run into the issue, you don’t need to worry about having your account actioned.
How 'rare' is rare? 1 in 10 000? 1 in 1000? 1 in 100? 1 in 10? ....? This is far too ambiguous a statement when any player's account could be banned either temporarily or permanently.
Personally, I don't give a rat's rear for seals of endeavour and rarely notice when they accrue but, if this bug is across all platforms, the first I'm going to know about it, judging from these non-statements, is if my account is banned.
While I appreciate the attempt at communication I think all you've succeeded in doing thus far is create a lot of concern, uncertainty and fear. It would really help alleviate those concerns if you just switched off the broken system NOW until its fixed and tell us you're doing that - that's the only way to guarantee that players don't accidentally accrue seals or try to 'exploit' it and alleviate all those uncertainties and concerns already mentioned.
I think they key point is the part you did not highlight... "if you accidentally run into the issue, you don’t need to worry about having your account actioned."
I’ve lost everything because of this bug. I am being treated like I don’t even exist. Ticket waiting for agent for 2 days now. People are allowed to say the most heinous things in zone chat and do not get banned. I did my daily crafting writs at the wrong time in the wrong city and I’m still banned.
I will leave my ticket here though for any chance to get this fixed
[230802-005013] Initial ban
[230805-000750] This one I made a day ago on another account because I’m not getting any updates on my initial one and I can’t log into support on that account to even view if it’s closed or pending or what unfortunately
I will leave my ticket here though for any chance to get this fixed
[230802-005013] Initial ban
[230805-000750] This one I made a day ago on another account because I’m not getting any updates on my initial one and I can’t log into support on that account to even view if it’s closed or pending or what unfortunately
For future reference... one ticket only per issue. For whatever reason, new tickets on the same subject reset your position to the end of the line. Hopefully, ZOS_Kevin was able to pass along your frustration to the Customer Service team.
Hi everyone, before the weekend starts, we want to provide an update on the current issue where daily Endeavors are sometimes resetting more often than intended. We are aware this is happening, and we are currently investigating solutions for this. While the investigation continues, we would like to remind everyone they should not exploit this issue. While we understand some people will unknowingly run into this through normal play, we will be monitoring and banning those who take extreme advantage and exploit it. Once we have additional information on a fix, we’ll follow up on those next steps. Thank you for your understanding here.
Hi all. Just wanted to follow up here based on some of the feedback. Our intention with highlighting the Endeavor reset issue is to be proactive with the community, noting we are aware of the issue and working toward a solution.
We do not expect players to be monitoring their endeavors in fear of accidentally encountering the exploit, and we'd like to highlight the Endeavor resetting is not a widespread issue and is pretty rare to trigger. In addition, we have a better understanding of the issue and have set up systems on our side to see when someone is specifically exploiting. So if you accidentally run into the issue, you don’t need to worry about having your account actioned.
We are not looking to punish anyone who accidentally stumbles into this, but rather inform the community about an issue we discovered and warn that we will take action on those who take extreme advantage of it (which, again, is not accidental.) We hope this helps to clear up any concerns here. Thanks for your patience and understanding regarding this.
No, it won't. Or if it does, it's only in the short term. Just wait until the next ban wave and the forum explodes again saying they need to change things (and knowing ZOS won't change). For reference, ZOS has a history now of seemingly randomly banning people over crown trading (early days TCE EU and Crown Exchange lost a lot of sellers because of this), gold duplicating because an addon was automatically taking gold from mail (but the gold wasn't actually being duplicated), and now this. And let's not forget the people who have been banned in the past for reporting bugs. I understand that it's one of the parts to the mail saying that they want to verify the contribution, but why is it ban first and ask questions later? What don't bots get banned this fast?FeedbackOnly wrote: »You did good. This will addresses community concerns.
ZOS made a formal apology over the gold duplicating problem where many, if not all, of the affected people had all their gold removed on top of being forced out of the game for anything up to a week. They owned that mistake and apologised, which seemed like it would be a good line going forward.
Now we're back here again. Why no apology? Yes, it's perfectly understandable that innocent accounts are going to occasionally get swept up as false positives, but the least they can do is apologise. A statement that they wrongfully banned people is meaningless without being followed up by an actual apology.
They've admitted it's a bug. The only action needed was to do a cleanup during the next maintenance to remove superfluous endeavours, with a public statement saying as such so people could be pointed to it when they invariably come to the forum to complain about their loss of endeavours. Very simple, very easy, no threats, no bans, no stress. How is any of what we got acceptable? The only professional thing to do at this point is to apologise for the wrongdoing having already acknowledged it, and maybe a little something for the people affected to take the sting out of all the stress/anxiety they've been through thinking they've lost their account.
And one would have to be extremely naive to think there will never be another ban wave. Once this one is finally over, what will the next big ban wave be? Maybe you'll be on the chopping block in the next one? Never say never.
FeedbackOnly wrote: »If 100 people get banned or more a human should be notified. This isn't the first time AI incorrectly banned people.
There seems to be this thing where people assume no human was involved with this prior to the initial ban wave. Some automated tool did this. I am curious why people think that, as no evidence that I have seen that suggests that.
If there was an actual AI involved, and I can't see ZOS being on the edge of that blade, the fault is still with the human that did the training work, especially if they did not check the results for bias or hallucinations.
VaranisArano wrote: »spartaxoxo wrote: »Finedaible wrote: »Lets play roulette then. Certainly our odds are good, right?
... Right?
Zenimax is not playing roulette. They would be looking for specific behavior to determine who they banned up front.
They literally stated that they unbanned a ton of people because it was determined they had not met their criteria.
That is not the same as playing Russian roulette. Far from it. They set criteria in their search to grab accounts that might be involved and yes, it grabbed some that were not but had similar behavior. Russian roulette is nothing but a shot in the dark, a completely random gamble which is hardly the case here.
In this analogy, Players are playing roulette with Endeavors now, not ZOS.
The bullet: Is this the glitched Endeavor that, in conjunction with my normal gameplay, makes it look like I exploited if I don't notice?
Now, it sounds like ZOS has increased their threshold for temp bans so they're less likely to ban a whole bunch of people for doing normal gameplay in a major crafting hub...but I cannot blame players for worrying.
Hi all. Just wanted to follow up here based on some of the feedback. Our intention with highlighting the Endeavor reset issue is to be proactive with the community, noting we are aware of the issue and working toward a solution.
We do not expect players to be monitoring their endeavors in fear of accidentally encountering the exploit, and we'd like to highlight the Endeavor resetting is not a widespread issue and is pretty rare to trigger. In addition, we have a better understanding of the issue and have set up systems on our side to see when someone is specifically exploiting. So if you accidentally run into the issue, you don’t need to worry about having your account actioned.
We are not looking to punish anyone who accidentally stumbles into this, but rather inform the community about an issue we discovered and warn that we will take action on those who take extreme advantage of it (which, again, is not accidental.) We hope this helps to clear up any concerns here. Thanks for your patience and understanding regarding this.