See that's where you lose me, IIRC they have stated explicitly no less than 3 times over the last year that this is not intended and they have been working on a fix. edit: if I get some time, I'll back that statement up with a source. at work atm.@Recremen I can't sell you historic context. However, you could provide it here by citing any sort of official reference (ESO live, forum post, etc.) to where this was described to be an intended mechanic. It would put a little substance behind your argument.You're serious? like really? can we get off the "Zeni put it there so I ccan use it". It's ridiculous. And quite frankly ruinous to the game. My suggestion, don't make yourself a part of the problem, be a part of a solution.The_Outsider wrote: »Wait really tho, question: Do you guys report people who get into towers for exploiting?
Didn't even occur to me that people might get reported for this.
For me that sounds pretty silly. 'Oh, I am going to report you because you used your ability as the game allows you too without using any special code or cheat...'
Zenimax is aware this is happening, they were made aware of it in the PTS, they didn't cared and released the game with the bug... Why should players avoid using this if the Devs them selves couldn't care less?
Infinite trap damage and infinite backlash damage were/are there too, should we all just accept it as intended as go craxy with the stuff? gtfoh
Except those abilities were actually functioning aberrantly due to a bug in the code, whereas leap is working exactly as intended with no bugs and people have retroactively decided it should not work in one specific circumstance.
Go back and re-read Jessica's statement again please. This is not intended. Wtb reading comprehension.
@Cuyler
WTB historic context. DK have done this for ages and we're only now hearing that it's "unintended". I highly doubt this was always the case.
EDIT: Historically, I don't recall them ever stating anything other than this is not intended.
There was no explicit statement, but years of silence on the matter speaks volumes.
Other's people game experience is all.......not much right? Don't be selfish, play be the rules.DaveMoeDee wrote: »Wow, this is not even close to permaban bad. It may be an exploit, but what does it really impact? Not much.
Perma ban some zeni programmers better they knew about that since PTS ....right? They did nothing to fix it like always and then we blame the "exploiters" Blame zeni not the gamers
Molag_Crow wrote: »Why should players get permabanned for in-game faulty mechanics? they can get up a wall by using class abilities and not 3rd party programs, so.. they don't deserve any punishment.
Of course this should be addressed and fixed ASAP, but you know...
@CuylerSee that's where I'm confused, IIRC they have stated so less than 3 times over the last year that this is not intended and they have been working on a fix. edit: if I get some time, I'll back that statement up with a source. at work atm.@Recremen I can't sell you historic context. However, you could provide it here by citing any sort of official reference (ESO live, forum post, etc.) to where this was described to be an intended mechanic. It would put a little substance behind your argument.You're serious? like really? can we get off the "Zeni put it there so I ccan use it". It's ridiculous. And quite frankly ruinous to the game. My suggestion, don't make yourself a part of the problem, be a part of a solution.The_Outsider wrote: »Wait really tho, question: Do you guys report people who get into towers for exploiting?
Didn't even occur to me that people might get reported for this.
For me that sounds pretty silly. 'Oh, I am going to report you because you used your ability as the game allows you too without using any special code or cheat...'
Zenimax is aware this is happening, they were made aware of it in the PTS, they didn't cared and released the game with the bug... Why should players avoid using this if the Devs them selves couldn't care less?
Infinite trap damage and infinite backlash damage were/are there too, should we all just accept it as intended as go craxy with the stuff? gtfoh
Except those abilities were actually functioning aberrantly due to a bug in the code, whereas leap is working exactly as intended with no bugs and people have retroactively decided it should not work in one specific circumstance.
Go back and re-read Jessica's statement again please. This is not intended. Wtb reading comprehension.
@Cuyler
WTB historic context. DK have done this for ages and we're only now hearing that it's "unintended". I highly doubt this was always the case.
EDIT: Historically, I don't recall them ever stating anything other than this is not intended.
There was no explicit statement, but years of silence on the matter speaks volumes.
Other's people game experience is all.......not much right? Don't be selfish, play be the rules.DaveMoeDee wrote: »Wow, this is not even close to permaban bad. It may be an exploit, but what does it really impact? Not much.
I agree however the initial infraction, as other's have stated can be argued with a "i didn't know" argument, a warning seems fair enough.
2nd infraction, well, still not necessarily "hacking" the game, but you clearly knew it was an exploitable bug and deliberately chose and pre-meditated it's use. One would no longer be able to use the "i didn't know card", temp-ban seems fair enough. Hopefully, said person learns their lesson that there is consequences and is smart enough to not continue it's use deliberately.
3rd infraction, well, game over. You've been warned, reprimanded and it's time to pay the piper as they say. Serial exploiters are a plague to online games.
edit: sp.
Molag_Crow wrote: »Why should players get permabanned for in-game faulty mechanics? they can get up a wall by using class abilities and not 3rd party programs, so.. they don't deserve any punishment.
Of course this should be addressed and fixed ASAP, but you know...
Because it's against the TOS that you agreed to. Because ZOS came into the forums and specifically stated it was against the rules. It doesn't matter if you reported it on the PTS. It doesn't matter if they left it in the game. You don't knowingly break the rules and not call it cheating. You cheat and you get banned. Pure and simple.
@ZOS_GinaBruno It's time to ban the people who knowingly exploit. If you can't do this, then what you're telling us all, is that you don't care about the innate fairness of your game. ZOS created this mess. Now police it, fix it, or just tell us you don't care and that we can do what we want.
As the great man once said, "The buck stops here."
DaveMoeDee wrote: »Molag_Crow wrote: »Why should players get permabanned for in-game faulty mechanics? they can get up a wall by using class abilities and not 3rd party programs, so.. they don't deserve any punishment.
Of course this should be addressed and fixed ASAP, but you know...
Because it's against the TOS that you agreed to. Because ZOS came into the forums and specifically stated it was against the rules. It doesn't matter if you reported it on the PTS. It doesn't matter if they left it in the game. You don't knowingly break the rules and not call it cheating. You cheat and you get banned. Pure and simple.
@ZOS_GinaBruno It's time to ban the people who knowingly exploit. If you can't do this, then what you're telling us all, is that you don't care about the innate fairness of your game. ZOS created this mess. Now police it, fix it, or just tell us you don't care and that we can do what we want.
As the great man once said, "The buck stops here."
There is nothing about this that makes it obvious that people should not do it. Intuitively, it feels like something people should try to do based on how skills work.
Your argument relies on it being clear that this "exploit" is an exploit. That isn't clear.
I think it's intended. And it's a fun feature for small scale pvp! I really hope they don't remove it, and make pvp even more lame.
Somebody call a waaaaaambulance...
Lol. You really gonna play that card smolt? You gonna claim ignorance after Zos has stated its not intended? You've been playing this game long enough to know what's a bug and what's not. Your not new or a noob. Any shred of credibility is shot. Go back the sewers and gank lowbies cause that's all you do anyways.
That statement has been quoted in this thread. It's not very long, yet...I think it's intended. And it's a fun feature for small scale pvp! I really hope they don't remove it, and make pvp even more lame.
Somebody call a waaaaaambulance...
Lol. You really gonna play that card smolt? You gonna claim ignorance after Zos has stated its not intended? You've been playing this game long enough to know what's a bug and what's not. Your not new or a noob. Any shred of credibility is shot. Go back the sewers and gank lowbies cause that's all you do anyways.
Lol do I know you? And I've never discriminated against max level players, equal opportunity ganker here and I barely touch the sewers anymore... besides the daedra need protection. #daedriclivesmatter
Not sure what your petty personal attacks have do with leaping onto keep walls though. I've never seen any official statement by some declaring it to be an exploit, just forum warriors crying about it. I've never heard of anyone getting warned, banned, or suspended for it either and it's been there since the beginning.
That statement has been quoted in this thread. It's not very long, yet...I think it's intended. And it's a fun feature for small scale pvp! I really hope they don't remove it, and make pvp even more lame.
Somebody call a waaaaaambulance...
Lol. You really gonna play that card smolt? You gonna claim ignorance after Zos has stated its not intended? You've been playing this game long enough to know what's a bug and what's not. Your not new or a noob. Any shred of credibility is shot. Go back the sewers and gank lowbies cause that's all you do anyways.
Lol do I know you? And I've never discriminated against max level players, equal opportunity ganker here and I barely touch the sewers anymore... besides the daedra need protection. #daedriclivesmatter
Not sure what your petty personal attacks have do with leaping onto keep walls though. I've never seen any official statement by some declaring it to be an exploit, just forum warriors crying about it. I've never heard of anyone getting warned, banned, or suspended for it either and it's been there since the beginning.
So what happens if I'm new to the game, don't use forums and I'm leaping on top of keeps, should I be banned?Yeah you have to look at it like this:
Its a bug that crit charge is activating within z axis.
People are exploiting that bug to get into keeps and towers beyond intended ways.
Its a bug that ambush allows you to travel through doors recently traveled by antother player.
People are exploiting that bug to get into keeps and towers beyond intended ways
Its a bug that allows people to walk through a wall to get into opposing players faction bases/bank in IC
People are exploiting that bug to kill people without being attacked and gaining illegitimate rewards.
The concept of bug != exploit is strange to me, because every one of these 'exploits' are people using bugs to do things they are not supposed to.
So yes crit charge currently is bugged and it allows you do things it normally should not, the choice to do those things is the exploit.
That statement has been quoted in this thread. It's not very long, yet...I think it's intended. And it's a fun feature for small scale pvp! I really hope they don't remove it, and make pvp even more lame.
Somebody call a waaaaaambulance...
Lol. You really gonna play that card smolt? You gonna claim ignorance after Zos has stated its not intended? You've been playing this game long enough to know what's a bug and what's not. Your not new or a noob. Any shred of credibility is shot. Go back the sewers and gank lowbies cause that's all you do anyways.
Lol do I know you? And I've never discriminated against max level players, equal opportunity ganker here and I barely touch the sewers anymore... besides the daedra need protection. #daedriclivesmatter
Not sure what your petty personal attacks have do with leaping onto keep walls though. I've never seen any official statement by some declaring it to be an exploit, just forum warriors crying about it. I've never heard of anyone getting warned, banned, or suspended for it either and it's been there since the beginning.
"The trouble with internet quotes is that it's very difficult to verify their authenticity". -Abraham Lincoln
So what happens if I'm new to the game, don't use forums and I'm leaping on top of keeps, should I be banned?Yeah you have to look at it like this:
Its a bug that crit charge is activating within z axis.
People are exploiting that bug to get into keeps and towers beyond intended ways.
Its a bug that ambush allows you to travel through doors recently traveled by antother player.
People are exploiting that bug to get into keeps and towers beyond intended ways
Its a bug that allows people to walk through a wall to get into opposing players faction bases/bank in IC
People are exploiting that bug to kill people without being attacked and gaining illegitimate rewards.
The concept of bug != exploit is strange to me, because every one of these 'exploits' are people using bugs to do things they are not supposed to.
So yes crit charge currently is bugged and it allows you do things it normally should not, the choice to do those things is the exploit.
Of course people are going to try and justify it because really it's a grey area.That statement has been quoted in this thread. It's not very long, yet...I think it's intended. And it's a fun feature for small scale pvp! I really hope they don't remove it, and make pvp even more lame.
Somebody call a waaaaaambulance...
Lol. You really gonna play that card smolt? You gonna claim ignorance after Zos has stated its not intended? You've been playing this game long enough to know what's a bug and what's not. Your not new or a noob. Any shred of credibility is shot. Go back the sewers and gank lowbies cause that's all you do anyways.
Lol do I know you? And I've never discriminated against max level players, equal opportunity ganker here and I barely touch the sewers anymore... besides the daedra need protection. #daedriclivesmatter
Not sure what your petty personal attacks have do with leaping onto keep walls though. I've never seen any official statement by some declaring it to be an exploit, just forum warriors crying about it. I've never heard of anyone getting warned, banned, or suspended for it either and it's been there since the beginning.
"The trouble with internet quotes is that it's very difficult to verify their authenticity". -Abraham Lincoln
Bull. You know it. I know it. That quote is genuine and readily searchable on this forum. There is no pin head to try and shove a ton of dancing angels on here. It's an exploit and you know it. Quit trying to justify your actions.
Of course ignorance is an excuse, this is a game, real life rules do not apply here to some extent, stop warping your mind that this game reflects to real life scenarios and rules.So what happens if I'm new to the game, don't use forums and I'm leaping on top of keeps, should I be banned?Yeah you have to look at it like this:
Its a bug that crit charge is activating within z axis.
People are exploiting that bug to get into keeps and towers beyond intended ways.
Its a bug that ambush allows you to travel through doors recently traveled by antother player.
People are exploiting that bug to get into keeps and towers beyond intended ways
Its a bug that allows people to walk through a wall to get into opposing players faction bases/bank in IC
People are exploiting that bug to kill people without being attacked and gaining illegitimate rewards.
The concept of bug != exploit is strange to me, because every one of these 'exploits' are people using bugs to do things they are not supposed to.
So yes crit charge currently is bugged and it allows you do things it normally should not, the choice to do those things is the exploit.
Ignorance is no excuse in the eyes of the law. A short suspension along with a warning of a future permaban would be the correct procedure.
Roehamad_Ali wrote: »50 shades of grey area forum PvP .
grey areas. Contribute to our Open Dictionary. a situation in which the rules are not clear, or in which you are not sure what is right or wrong. that grey area between legitimate protest and illegal disruption.
No don't change this to a specific group, that is a different scenario and I agree with you. But we are talking about as a whole here, in which case that does not apply in my opinionWhen you have video of an entire group misusing the skill, then you already know that they're exploiting on purpose and deserve the ban hammer. If someone makes a YouTube video showing themselves doing it, and especially a how-to video, then break out that hammer. A modicum of common sense, please.
Roehamad_Ali wrote: »50 shades of grey area forum PvP .grey areas. Contribute to our Open Dictionary. a situation in which the rules are not clear, or in which you are not sure what is right or wrong. that grey area between legitimate protest and illegal disruption.
So what happens if I'm new to the game, don't use forums and I'm leaping on top of keeps, should I be banned?Yeah you have to look at it like this:
Its a bug that crit charge is activating within z axis.
People are exploiting that bug to get into keeps and towers beyond intended ways.
Its a bug that ambush allows you to travel through doors recently traveled by antother player.
People are exploiting that bug to get into keeps and towers beyond intended ways
Its a bug that allows people to walk through a wall to get into opposing players faction bases/bank in IC
People are exploiting that bug to kill people without being attacked and gaining illegitimate rewards.
The concept of bug != exploit is strange to me, because every one of these 'exploits' are people using bugs to do things they are not supposed to.
So yes crit charge currently is bugged and it allows you do things it normally should not, the choice to do those things is the exploit.
Ignorance is no excuse in the eyes of the law. A short suspension along with a warning of a future permaban would be the correct procedure.
Of course ignorance is an excuse, this is a game, real life rules do not apply here to some extent, stop warping your mind that this game reflects to real life scenarios and rules.So what happens if I'm new to the game, don't use forums and I'm leaping on top of keeps, should I be banned?Yeah you have to look at it like this:
Its a bug that crit charge is activating within z axis.
People are exploiting that bug to get into keeps and towers beyond intended ways.
Its a bug that ambush allows you to travel through doors recently traveled by antother player.
People are exploiting that bug to get into keeps and towers beyond intended ways
Its a bug that allows people to walk through a wall to get into opposing players faction bases/bank in IC
People are exploiting that bug to kill people without being attacked and gaining illegitimate rewards.
The concept of bug != exploit is strange to me, because every one of these 'exploits' are people using bugs to do things they are not supposed to.
So yes crit charge currently is bugged and it allows you do things it normally should not, the choice to do those things is the exploit.
Ignorance is no excuse in the eyes of the law. A short suspension along with a warning of a future permaban would be the correct procedure.
If a new player, or any player for that matter is playing and accidentally uses an in game bug, there is absolutely no way you can justify those actions to receive a suspension. It makes the company look bad for punishing people for their incapability of providing a polished service. A game will always have bugs in it.
The correct procedure would be to give warnings, you get 3 you get banned.
I really would like to see you running an MMO
No don't change this to a specific group, that is a different scenario and I agree with you. But we are talking about as a whole here, in which case that does not apply in my opinionWhen you have video of an entire group misusing the skill, then you already know that they're exploiting on purpose and deserve the ban hammer. If someone makes a YouTube video showing themselves doing it, and especially a how-to video, then break out that hammer. A modicum of common sense, please.
magnusthorek wrote: »Bugs are there to be exploited... BY TESTERS! If you found a bug and are intentionally exploiting it in the Live server you MUST be punished.
ZOS can't simply just pat your back saying that's wrong and you falsely promise you won't do it again.
If you exploited a known (or even an unknown) bug to your benefit YOU... ARE... A CHEATER!
No excuses, nothing more, nothing less, I done with my arguments, Your Honor
That's fine Chaos, I don't mind losing my forum acct if it means another exploiter is brought out from the toxic underbelly of the game. I don't need to continue either and you've sufficiently made everyone aware of your intentions here.Reporting @Cuyler for being mean and making personal attacks.
Many people as well as myself have been leaping into keeps since the beginning of the game, nothings changed, and never will. See you on the inside of your keep tonight sweet cheeks!
P.S
Is it really exploiting if ZOS intentionally put it in the game after knowing full well that it worked this way?
j/k your opinion doesn't matter, it was a rhetorical question.
P.S. grow up
@Cuyler
If I host an Alcoholics Anonymous meeting, and provide a 60oz of Whiskey for all my members to drink, is it the fault of the AA members for drinking it? Or mine for bringing that whiskey?
If ZOS hosts a game and provides faulty mechanics that originally worked, is it the fault of players for using the new mechanics that ZOS deemed fit, even though they could've kept the old ones in place
DaveMoeDee wrote: »Molag_Crow wrote: »Why should players get permabanned for in-game faulty mechanics? they can get up a wall by using class abilities and not 3rd party programs, so.. they don't deserve any punishment.
Of course this should be addressed and fixed ASAP, but you know...
Because it's against the TOS that you agreed to. Because ZOS came into the forums and specifically stated it was against the rules. It doesn't matter if you reported it on the PTS. It doesn't matter if they left it in the game. You don't knowingly break the rules and not call it cheating. You cheat and you get banned. Pure and simple.
@ZOS_GinaBruno It's time to ban the people who knowingly exploit. If you can't do this, then what you're telling us all, is that you don't care about the innate fairness of your game. ZOS created this mess. Now police it, fix it, or just tell us you don't care and that we can do what we want.
As the great man once said, "The buck stops here."
There is nothing about this that makes it obvious that people should not do it. Intuitively, it feels like something people should try to do based on how skills work.
Your argument relies on it being clear that this "exploit" is an exploit. That isn't clear.
Other than ZOS saying that it's not allowed?
When you have video of an entire group misusing the skill, then you already know that they're exploiting on purpose and deserve the ban hammer. If someone makes a YouTube video showing themselves doing it, and especially a how-to video, then break out that hammer. A modicum of common sense, please.