Do you need more guild slots? (Poll)

kelly.medleyb14_ESO

Five guild slots is not enough for me, I am just wondering what everyone else's experience is.

SteveCampsOut

No I am fine

Good gravy no! You can't serve two masters and five is already too many! What we need are larger membership rolls in each guild.

kelly.medleyb14_ESO

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

Well I have 3 toons in 2 factions and 2 toons in another faction. With the promise of decent PvE content incoming this means I would like 3 separate PvE guilds for each faction.

I am in an alliance of guilds that is necessary for trading effectively.

I will need 3 separate PvP guilds.

I will need 3 separate Trade guilds.

So try to look at it from this perspective, if it doesn't affect you then why would you want to hinder me?

Ffastyl

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

I feel either more guild slots or a single guild slot are the way to go. As it stands, there are multiple guilds of various types I wish to join and leaving a guild I am already in goes against my code of honor.
On the flipside, I have experienced a one-guild system, and the bonds formed in that guild are strong. With five guilds to interact in, the connections are divided; as one post put them, they are "message boards." If one guild chat yields no responses, move to the next one.

The_Man_From_Stygia

No I am fine

No, they're guilds, not pokemon

Forestd16b14_ESO

What is a guild?

I wanna know what happened to being apart of just one guild and bearing there banner proudly. Now you can be apart of 5 and most only use them for trade or crafting.

The_Man_From_Stygia

No I am fine

Forestd16b14_ESO wrote: »

I wanna know what happened to being apart of just one guild and bearing there banner proudly. Now you can be apart of 5 and most only use them for trade or crafting.

They're like sponsors now, you have to stamp their logos on your armor to advertise for them while you go into battle.

Forestd16b14_ESO

What is a guild?

The_Man_From_Stygia wrote: »

Forestd16b14_ESO wrote: »

I wanna know what happened to being apart of just one guild and bearing there banner proudly. Now you can be apart of 5 and most only use them for trade or crafting.

They're like sponsors now, you have to stamp their logos on your armor to advertise for them while you go into battle.

Yea that how is suppost to work have your guild on your armor not 5 diffrent ones. All those emblems on your colorful armor makes ya look like a race car.

kelly.medleyb14_ESO

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

Forestd16b14_ESO wrote: »

I wanna know what happened to being apart of just one guild and bearing there banner proudly. Now you can be apart of 5 and most only use them for trade or crafting.

That went out the door with the 500 guild limit. If they remove the limit I will be more than happy to expand my guild to cover all areas as it is, 500 is FAR to few to do this. I have to be very picky about who I invite.

Darlgon

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

Yes, unless they enacted a global auction hall. Then I would only need three.

Forestd16b14_ESO

What is a guild?

kelly.medleyb14_ESO wrote: »

Forestd16b14_ESO wrote: »

I wanna know what happened to being apart of just one guild and bearing there banner proudly. Now you can be apart of 5 and most only use them for trade or crafting.

That went out the door with the 500 guild limit. If they remove the limit I will be more than happy to expand my guild to cover all areas as it is, 500 is FAR to few to do this. I have to be very picky about who I invite.

That also brings up another question. What happen to recruiting friends and all that. Now and no offeance now it's jsut spamming zone chat and inviteing any one one who wants in. I remeber when you had to prove your self to get into guild. ( AKA runescape days)

failkiwib16_ESO

No I am fine

I PRESSED WRONG ((((
I do want more guildslots, 10-15 more for trading guilds since this game's economy really sucks.

kelly.medleyb14_ESO

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

Forestd16b14_ESO wrote: »

kelly.medleyb14_ESO wrote: »

Forestd16b14_ESO wrote: »

I wanna know what happened to being apart of just one guild and bearing there banner proudly. Now you can be apart of 5 and most only use them for trade or crafting.

That went out the door with the 500 guild limit. If they remove the limit I will be more than happy to expand my guild to cover all areas as it is, 500 is FAR to few to do this. I have to be very picky about who I invite.

That also brings up another question. What happen to recruiting friends and all that. Now and no offeance now it's jsut spamming zone chat and inviteing any one one who wants in. I remeber when you had to prove your self to get into guild. ( AKA runescape days)

Anyone can run their guild any way they want, why would you want to put artificial restrictions on others that doesn't even affect you?

failkiwib16_ESO wrote: »

I PRESSED WRONG ((((
I do want more guildslots, 10-15 more for trading guilds since this game's economy really sucks.

LOL I wonder if you can change it

ItsGlaive

No I am fine

kelly.medleyb14_ESO wrote: »

Well I have 3 toons in 2 factions and 2 toons in another faction. With the promise of decent PvE content incoming this means I would like 3 separate PvE guilds for each faction.

I am in an alliance of guilds that is necessary for trading effectively.

I will need 3 separate PvP guilds.

I will need 3 separate Trade guilds.

So try to look at it from this perspective, if it doesn't affect you then why would you want to hinder me?

So you're the only player in any of those guilds with a toon on another faction? Sounds like an argument on the face of it, but the reality is that most guilds are cross-faction anyway, so no, you shouldn't need that many

kelly.medleyb14_ESO

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

Xabien wrote: »

So you're the only player in any of those guilds with a toon on another faction? Sounds like an argument on the face of it, but the reality is that most guilds are cross-faction anyway, so no, you shouldn't need that many

False. I have 2 guild invites in my notifications right now, one is AD PvE ONLY and the other is DC PvP ONLY. Your anecdotal wishful thinking is incorrect.

Looks like about 40% of the population would benefit from this increase in guild slots ZoS please make it so. TY

SFBryan18

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

I would love to double my store space by joining 10 trading guilds.

Ffastyl

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

failkiwib16_ESO wrote: »

10-15 more for trading guilds since this game's economy really sucks.

Darlgon wrote: »

Yes, unless they enacted a global auction hall. Then I would only need three.

Look at RuneScape's Grand Exchange, the high level items' prices skyrocket every day, exceeding millions of gold to purchase. Average players cannot scrap together that much gold in a few days, perhaps a few weeks time.

ESO's localized economy keeps prices lower by preventing a small group of rich players from controlling the market (by buying/selling from/to each other). Tempering Alloy sold for 1.5k before guild stores, and now it is approaching 4k.
The more global the economy gets, the more inflation will occur.

Darlgon

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

Ffastyl wrote: »

ESO's localized economy keeps prices lower by preventing a small group of rich players from controlling the market (by buying/selling from/to each other). Tempering Alloy sold for 1.5k before guild stores, and now it is approaching 4k.
The more global the economy gets, the more inflation will occur.

Keep deluding yourself on that. Deflation on over-priced items will also occur when people realize some ... is charging too much for his useless junk. Besides, most of the guild stores I see, people want 25 gold per racial 1-9 material. People dont have a sense of what things are worth with the current system. Your example, come to think if it, shows that inflation occurs under the current system too.

MornaBaine

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

Forestd16b14_ESO wrote: »

I wanna know what happened to being apart of just one guild and bearing there banner proudly. Now you can be apart of 5 and most only use them for trade or crafting.

That's actually kind of the problem. Trade guilds used to eat up 3 of my slots. Now I'm down to one but I sorely miss the other 2. They need to come up with a separate mechanism that allows people who do NOT want to be part of a trade guild to STILL sell their items. You should be able to go to any guild owned trader kiosk and list your items for sale...with a healthy cut of the profits going to the guild who then acts as middleman for you. MEMBERS of the guild should still be able to sell at the original cost for listing their items.

I'm in 3 RP guilds, not because I play my characters as part of any of those guilds (save one, my own guild), but so I can maintain communication with the members of those guilds so our guilds can more smoothly interact. When what they should REALLY do is give us CUSTOM CHAT CHANNELS!!!! Then we wouldn't NEED to be IN multiple guilds just to maintain communication!

CodexMMO

More Guild Slots, or Guilds of Unlimited Size, or Global Auction House.

Fi'yra

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

I would like more Guild slots honestly, it would allow me to be more social and not just stick to 5 or have to remove 1 because a better option comes along.
Even if it's buffed up 1 - 2 it leaves me at a better position than 5.

SFBryan18

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

Darlgon wrote: »

Ffastyl wrote: »

ESO's localized economy keeps prices lower by preventing a small group of rich players from controlling the market (by buying/selling from/to each other). Tempering Alloy sold for 1.5k before guild stores, and now it is approaching 4k.
The more global the economy gets, the more inflation will occur.

Keep deluding yourself on that. Deflation on over-priced items will also occur when people realize some ... is charging too much for his useless junk. Besides, most of the guild stores I see, people want 25 gold per racial 1-9 material. People dont have a sense of what things are worth with the current system. Your example, come to think if it, shows that inflation occurs under the current system too.

It's pretty simple really... You're both right.

Both inflation and deflation would happen in a global auction house.

Super rare items would be extremely expensive because the seller would know that someone out there wants it and will pay a really high price.

Super common items would be dirt cheap because everyone has them so everyone would undercut each other.

I think the biggest problem would be maintaining good drop rates so items have value. It's easier for them to just leave it alone and let us search the kiosks. It's also more immersive since eBay doesn't exist in Tamriel.

Forestd16b14_ESO

What is a guild?

MornaBaine wrote: »

Forestd16b14_ESO wrote: »

I wanna know what happened to being apart of just one guild and bearing there banner proudly. Now you can be apart of 5 and most only use them for trade or crafting.

That's actually kind of the problem. Trade guilds used to eat up 3 of my slots. Now I'm down to one but I sorely miss the other 2. They need to come up with a separate mechanism that allows people who do NOT want to be part of a trade guild to STILL sell their items. You should be able to go to any guild owned trader kiosk and list your items for sale...with a healthy cut of the profits going to the guild who then acts as middleman for you. MEMBERS of the guild should still be able to sell at the original cost for listing their items.

I'm in 3 RP guilds, not because I play my characters as part of any of those guilds (save one, my own guild), but so I can maintain communication with the members of those guilds so our guilds can more smoothly interact. When what they should REALLY do is give us CUSTOM CHAT CHANNELS!!!! Then we wouldn't NEED to be IN multiple guilds just to maintain communication!

Like I understand were some players are coming from the whole cap at 500 is small and that the NPC trading does suck. Just call me old fashion cause old guild systems I remember when they had like 2000 members with all sorts of players trades, RPers, PvPers, and so on. Like maybe if they raise the pop lock then amybe we wouldn't need 5 or more guild slots.

kelly.medleyb14_ESO

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

CodexMMO wrote: »

More Guild Slots, or Guilds of Unlimited Size, or Global Auction House.

Interesting propositions and I would agree to 1 or 2 but not 3, 3 would destroy the wonderful part of ESO economy they have created, it really speaks to the depth they are willing to sacrifice to maintain.

The individual shop keepers are one of the things that inspires me to continue having faith in ZoS' decision making.

That said, perhaps a compromise of 3 trade guilds 3 PvP guilds and 3 PvE guilds and perhaps 1 any type guilds (for those who want a friends only club or an alliance guild that really doesn't have a purpose other than maintaining easy communication. (I have heard this option put forth a few times by various people in TS)

If ZoS decided to raise the guild size limit to unlimited or 1500 I think this would alleviate some of the problem but then I think the listing items number would have to go up also perhaps to 90.

I know of a few guilds that REQUIRE its members to use 3 of their slots just to be in their guild because of the 500 limit.

My main issue is that I have 2 pending invites in my box that I REALLY want to accept but can't see myself letting go of any of the other great guilds I am in.

Bouvin

No I am fine

No, but I'd like to see guilds have more than 500 members.

Slurg

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

Its probably not possible, but I wish guilds were set up by character not by account. My characters have different interests and are in different factions and would benefit by being able to join different guilds based on that.

kelly.medleyb14_ESO

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

Slurg wrote: »

Its probably not possible, but I wish guilds were set up by character not by account. My characters have different interests and are in different factions and would benefit by being able to join different guilds based on that.

It would be possible and probably a good idea. I could go for having 40 guilds

Well ZoS at least 40% of your player base would like to see more guild slots added please make it so.

nalimoleb14_ESO

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

Between Crafting guilds, Raid guilds, RP guilds, etc., yes, more guild slots would be very helpful.

Jaxsun

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

SteveCampsOut wrote: »

Good gravy no! You can't serve two masters and five is already too many! What we need are larger membership rolls in each guild.

If you mean more than 500 per guild then yes.

Jaxsun

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

I would like more access to guild banks. Without having to run all over Tamriel looking for them. In fact, we should just have server wide auction houses and *** can the guild stores alltogether...

Jaxsun

Yes I would like 5 more guild slots or more.

Slurg wrote: »

Its probably not possible, but I wish guilds were set up by character not by account. My characters have different interests and are in different factions and would benefit by being able to join different guilds based on that.

It was possible to have different toons in different guilds in Star War Galaxies and that came out in '02 or '03 I think. So I don't see why it's not possible in ESO.