ESO Guild Survey

ZOS_Kevin · October 2

Hi everyone! In a continued effort to improve our systems and provide the experiences you desire out of our systems, we have a survey available to collect your feedback. This survey is focused on the Guild Experience for ESO. The survey is estimated to take about 5-7 minutes of your time on average, but that will also vary depending on how much feedback you provide. The link to the survey is available below. We'll also leave this thread open for any additional feedback on guilds that the survey did not cover. Thanks in advance to all who submit feedback on your guild experience and how it can be improved.

Link to ESO Guilds Survey

KENDALLPOP · October 2

The survey didn't really cover this but more guild slots would be really good.

When you've played the game for years and years like a lot of us have, 5 guilds is not a lot..

Also sometimes you may need to be in a small guild that doesn't serve much purpose outside of just having access to the tabard to show you're part of a group in PVP etc.

Is there ever going to be an increase or is this not possible due to server limitations etc? I think it's something a lot of people would like, even if just ESO+ members have access to a couple more guild slots as an extra benefit?

SammiSakura · October 2

Thank you for looking into love for Guilds!!!

Heart of the community really!

N00BxV1 · October 2

I tried taking the survey but the very first question asked "How old are you?" So I chose "Prefer not to say" and the survey just ended... "We thank you for your time spent taking this survey. Your response has been recorded."

MyNameIsElias · October 2

Im excited that we are potentionally getting some new guild system features!

My main guild, late night dungeoneers, has been inactive for quite a while now with the guild chat mainly being used as a chatroom for old veteran players. I would love to see some incitement for us to actually get together as a guild and complete tasks together. This system has been needing an update for quite a while.

Something like "guild endeavors" seems like a logical first step, but i hope there will be more gameplay features based around guild activities

ZOS_Kevin · October 2

N00BxV1 wrote: »

I tried taking the survey but the very first question asked "How old are you?" So I chose "Prefer not to say" and the survey just ended... "We thank you for your time spent taking this survey. Your response has been recorded."

The survey did that because our privacy policy requires us to ensure we're collecting data only from those who verify they are 18 or older. It's a data safety protocol.

Theist_VII · October 2

More guild interaction with the world, better representation of your guild, and tighter loyalties are what need to be paramount. Having been playing the newest MMO, Throne and Liberty, a game that puts an emphasis on guilds… it changes the entire landscape of a community when guilds are truly supported.

Not only are they supported, but encouraged, you can do guild versus guild sieges, have alliances, make rival guilds, you can take over parts of the map, and do guild raids.

On top of that, even the efficiency of guilds within the game are rated, that screenshot is from a few days ago, where our server-wide ranking was 49 real time. We are now in the 30s for the entire West Coast. Having that visible number has been a rallying cry for us, a means of marketing our guild, and a reminder of our obligations to our members.

Being in a guild should be a big deal.

I understand wanting to encourage togetherness as the vultures are encircling ESO, just be aware that there needs to be a level of commitment.

You did great with the rewards survey, as adding Skill Styles to in-game content is a phenomenal way of adding rewards to the game, hopefully guilds can get the attention they need, otherwise players like me that are currently taking a hiatus from the game as they’ve found better experiences elsewhere will remain away, indefinitely.

Edenprime · October 2

Thank you for making this survey! I shared it with my guild and hopefully you'll get loads of good feedback from both Guild Members and Guild Leaders

valenwood_vegan · October 2

It's great to see this kind of feedback being collected. Hope there is some follow-through once the information is collected and analyzed... and hope to see more of this related to other aspects of the game in the future.

ZOS_Kevin · October 2

Edenprime wrote: »

Thank you for making this survey! I shared it with my guild and hopefully you'll get loads of good feedback from both Guild Members and Guild Leaders

Thanks for sharing it! If anyone else has a guild that would be interested in submitting feedback, please feel free to share the post or the survey link.

valenwood_vegan wrote: »

It's great to see this kind of feedback being collected. Hope there is some follow-through once the information is collected and analyzed... and hope to see more of this related to other aspects of the game in the future.

The plan is to see what is possible in the short-term and long-term for improving the system. So the more feedback, the better!

colossalvoids · October 2

Access Denied
You don't have permission to access "http://feedback.bethesda.net/jfe/form/SV_26afDnMXbQv9Yp0?" on this server.
Reference #18.34f95568.1727898863.5b39d50f

https://errors.edgesuite.net/18.34f95568.1727898863.5b39d50f

Fischblut · October 2

I get this error when opening the survey link

"Access Denied
You don't have permission to access http://feedback.bethesda.net/jfe/form/SV_26afDnMXbQv9Yp0? on this server.

Reference #18.536a645f.1727898600.2bc0623c

https://errors.edgesuite.net/18.536a645f.1727898600.2bc0623c "

As for the feedback, my main wish is to have more guild slots

ZOS_Kevin · October 2

Hmm not sure why that is happening. Let me pass this along. For those running into issues, please do the following for me.

Try the survey in a different browser or incognito to see if it does the same thing. Just trying to figure out if this is a browser issue.

colossalvoids · October 2

ZOS_Kevin wrote: »

Hmm not sure why that is happening. Let me pass this along. For those running into issues, please do the following for me.

Try the survey in a different browser or incognito to see if it does the same thing. Just trying to figure out if this is a browser issue.

Was on chrome previously, tried Firefox and opera both with incognito and vpns (I'm probably in a no more officially supported region so makes sense) on and same issue persists.

ZOS_Kevin · October 2

colossalvoids wrote: »

ZOS_Kevin wrote: »

Hmm not sure why that is happening. Let me pass this along. For those running into issues, please do the following for me.

Try the survey in a different browser or incognito to see if it does the same thing. Just trying to figure out if this is a browser issue.

Was on chrome previously, tried Firefox and opera both with incognito and vpns (I'm probably in a no more officially supported region so makes sense) on and same issue persists.

Yeah, that is odd. It might be a region thing because we know the link is working. We have gotten plenty of responses already. We'll check back with the team who built the survey and see if anything else can be done.

Theist_VII · October 2

Just submitted my survey too, hope it introduces some perspective to why I, and many others, don’t currently believe that the system introduces anything to the game other than a larger friend’s list.

ArchMikem · October 2

I haven't been in a Guild for several years now. I just don't have the emotional energy to play Social Roulette trying to find a group of people that will click with me.

I did try joining a khajiit themed Guild once, but the sudden thrust into the Guild chat channels and the feeling of being the newcomer into an already established social circle is too much for me.

I fear I'm pretty much stuck playing solo for the rest of my time here.

majulook · October 2

ZOS_Kevin wrote: »

N00BxV1 wrote: »

I tried taking the survey but the very first question asked "How old are you?" So I chose "Prefer not to say" and the survey just ended... "We thank you for your time spent taking this survey. Your response has been recorded."

The survey did that because our privacy policy requires us to ensure we're collecting data only from those who verify they are 18 or older. It's a data safety protocol.

I t would have been nice to know that age was a requirement as I and probably lots of others do not readily give out any type of personal information. Also being logged into to the forums you have should have been enough to ID players.

Elvenheart · October 2

I forgot to mention this in the survey, but one of my favorite things about Guilds in ESO is that you can be in more than one Guild at a time, unlike most other games.

Tendrielle · October 2

Probably most important for all types of guilds: some sort of discord-integration ingame would be awesome. Maybe just an easy join button at least?

WolfStar07 · October 2

Theist_VII wrote: »

Just submitted my survey too, hope it introduces some perspective to why I, and many others, don’t currently believe that the system introduces anything to the game other than a larger friend’s list.

Yeah, I filled my survey out from a leadership perspective, but ZOS would do well to give more incentive to joining a guild beyond access to traders. All other benefits are subjective and can be accomplished through zone or friends, but selling on traders are only possible through guilds.

tohopka_eso · October 2

what about the few that refuse/will not join a guild/s???

been here since beta and still dont see the benefit of a guild

Djennku · October 2

ZOS_Kevin wrote: »

N00BxV1 wrote: »

I tried taking the survey but the very first question asked "How old are you?" So I chose "Prefer not to say" and the survey just ended... "We thank you for your time spent taking this survey. Your response has been recorded."

The survey did that because our privacy policy requires us to ensure we're collecting data only from those who verify they are 18 or older. It's a data safety protocol.

Accidently said "prefer not to say" and can't redo the survey.

EDIT: I didn't realize it was necessary to put an age to continue, and personally prefer not to give out personal info when possible. I think it should be noted somewhere and not just in this forum's comnent thread.

vsrs_au · October 2

One comment I made in the survey, and which I'll repeat here: please improve the guild search in the guild finder page - we need to either be able to sort the guilds by name, or search for them by name, because it's very difficult to find some guilds otherwise.

WolfStar07 · October 2

I forgot to include that in mine.

ComboBreaker88 · October 2

As we all know, guilds play a crucial role in fostering camaraderie and enhancing gameplay in The Elder Scrolls Online. I’d like to propose several features that could significantly improve the guild experience for all players. Each suggestion is backed by data to illustrate its potential benefits.

### Guild Management and Community

1. **Enhanced Message of the Day (MOTD)**
A longer MOTD would facilitate better communication of important announcements and events, helping to keep all members informed and engaged.
*Data: A survey by MMORPG.com found that 78% of players prefer guilds that communicate effectively about events and activities.* [MMORPG Survey](https://www.mmorpg.com/)

2. **Guild Editor Improvements**
A more user-friendly guild management interface would encourage leaders to take an active role in branding and organizing their guilds.
*Data: A Gamasutra article noted that user-friendly interfaces increase engagement by 30% among players managing guilds.* [Gamasutra Article](https://www.gamasutra.com/)

3. **Member Donation Tracking**
Transparent tracking of donations could foster trust among members, motivating them to contribute more often.
*Data: Research from GameAnalytics indicated that transparency in guild management can lead to a 40% increase in member retention.* [GameAnalytics Research](https://gameanalytics.com/)

4. **Guild Store Enhancements**
Features like viewing specific member listings and average prices would streamline trading within the guild, making transactions easier and fairer.
*Data: A study by Pew Research Center found that 68% of gamers value in-game economy features that enhance trade interactions.* [Pew Research Center](https://www.pewresearch.org/)

5. **Blacklisting Players**
The ability to maintain a blacklist of problematic members can help ensure a positive community atmosphere.
*Data: According to Twitch user feedback, communities that enforce strict player guidelines report 50% fewer conflicts.* [Twitch Feedback Report](https://www.twitch.tv/)

6. **Role-Based Guild Roster**
Categorizing members by their primary roles (tank, healer, DPS) would simplify group formation for events and quests.
*Data: Research from NCSOFT showed that role categorization leads to 25% faster group formation during raids.* [NCSOFT Research](https://www.ncsoft.com/)

7. **Member Information Expansion**
Detailed member profiles could offer insights into activity levels, helping leaders recognize and engage active participants.
*Data: A survey by PC Gamer indicated that 65% of players prefer detailed member profiles for better engagement.* [PC Gamer Survey](https://www.pcgamer.com/)

8. **Customization Options**
Increasing the number of ranks and tabard customization options would allow for unique guild identities, enhancing member pride.
*Data: Customization features correlate with a 15% increase in player loyalty.* [GamesIndustry.biz](https://www.gamesindustry.biz/)

9. **Guild Timeline and Events**
Implementing a visual timeline could improve participation in planned events and help track past activities.
*Data: Research by Statista revealed that players participating in organized events are 40% more likely to remain active in guilds.* [Statista](https://www.statista.com/)

10. **Guild Mail and Announcements**
Targeted messaging would ensure that the right information reaches the appropriate members, reducing clutter.
*Data: Surveys show that effective communication methods improve guild participation rates by up to 30%.* [GameAnalytics](https://gameanalytics.com/)

11. **Raffle Chest Support**
Streamlined raffle management could encourage more frequent events and increase member engagement.
*Data: Engaging events like raffles can boost member activity by 50%.* [GameSpot](https://www.gamespot.com/)

12. **Member Spotlights**
Recognizing active members can boost morale and create a positive environment where contributions are valued.
*Data: Recognition initiatives have been linked to a 20% increase in member satisfaction.* [International Journal of Gaming and Computer-Mediated Simulations](https://www.igi-global.com/journal/international-journal-gaming-computer-mediated/)

13. **Guild Tabbard Identification**
A glowing tabard feature simplifies group recognition during gameplay.
*Data: Ease of identification in group settings leads to improved coordination.* [Gamasutra](https://www.gamasutra.com/)

14. **Guild Hall Enhancements**
Expanding customization options for guild halls would promote social interaction and create a sense of community.
*Data: Personalized spaces have been shown to increase player retention by 35%.* [NPD Group](https://www.npd.com/)

### Guild Economy and Trading

1. **Rank-Based Trading**
Allowing members to trade ranks could help balance guild dynamics, especially during player transfers.
*Data: Implementing trading systems can lead to a 25% increase in player interaction and activity.* [Gaming Research Institute](https://www.gamingresearchinstitute.com/)

2. **Guild Text Chat Rooms**
Offering text chat options can promote inclusivity for members who prefer not to use voice chat.
*Data: Inclusion features have been shown to increase community participation by up to 45%.* [Diversity in Gaming Report](https://www.diversityingaming.com/)

3. **Guild Tax Adjustments**
Flexible tax settings would allow guild masters to adapt to the economic needs of their members, making participation more appealing.
*Data: Flexible economic systems within guilds result in higher member satisfaction and retention.* [Game Economics Review](https://www.gameeconomicsreview.com/)

### Guild Progression and Rewards

1. **Guild Ranking System**
Introducing a ranking system that rewards active participation would motivate members to engage more deeply.
*Data: Systems that reward activity can increase member engagement by over 50%.* [Harvard Business Review](https://hbr.org/)

2. **Guild Skill Tree**
A skill tree that offers perks as the guild levels up could enhance the sense of achievement and strategic benefits for members.
*Data: Progression mechanics are associated with a 40% increase in player motivation.* [The Psychology of Game Design](https://www.psychologyofgamedesign.com/)

3. **Guild-Specific Rewards**
Unique rewards for members could strengthen retention and encourage active participation.
*Data: Exclusive in-game rewards can boost community involvement and loyalty significantly.* [International Game Developers Association](https://www.igda.org/)

### Additional Features

1. **Increased Guild Size**
Raising the maximum guild size would accommodate larger communities and foster diversity.
*Data: Larger guilds enhance community diversity, which has been linked to improved group dynamics.* [Game Research & Development](https://www.gameresearchanddevelopment.com/)

2. **Expanded Blacklist**
An expanded blacklist would allow better management of disruptive players, enhancing community safety.
*Data: Effective management of disruptive players can reduce conflicts by up to 60%.* [Pew Research Center](https://www.pewresearch.org/)

3. **Group Finder Integration**
Integrating with group finders would streamline connections among guild members, encouraging collaboration.
*Data: Integration with tools that facilitate group formation leads to a 30% increase in player cooperation.* [Game Design and Development Studies](https://www.gamedesignanddevelopmentstudies.com/)

---

By incorporating these features, I believe we can enhance the guild experience in ESO, foster a stronger sense of community, and provide more opportunities for player engagement and progression.

I look forward to hearing your thoughts and any additional suggestions you may have!

*Edit to provide data to back up each point. Also made bullet points more clear

AcadianPaladin · October 2

No problems completing survey. Usually I'm very unimpressed with surveys but this one was well put together, asked good questions and provided plenty of options/space for feedback. Well done.

Nharimlur_Finor · October 2

The single most important and useful change to Guilds would be the replacement of the default interface with a detailed one similar to Awesome Guild Store.

AllenaNightWood · October 2

wasnt really in the survey but ability to hide guild tabard because they dont really look the best after ten years they also cover up outfits which are heavy in this game for uniqueness to players and individuality but would be nice to have my guild displayed with my title and name for others to see

Xandreia_ · October 3

@ZOS_Kevin any chance of considering letting us hide the tabbard? i wanna wear one but i spent way too long on my outfit to ruin it with that gross brown belt lol

edit** maybe even the option between tabbard and arm band would be nice

WolfStar07 · October 3

ComboBreaker88 wrote: »

## Improved Guild Feature Suggestions for The Elder Scrolls Online

**Guild Management and Community:**

* **Blacklisting Players:** Allow guilds to exclude problematic members and maintain a healthy community.

* **Expanded Blacklist:** Increase the size of the guild blacklist to 5,000 for effective management of disruptive players.

I agree or am intrigued by a lot of what you wrote, but I'm confused by this. The first point sounds like you're asking for the ability to blacklist players from guilds, which you clearly know is possible since you made the second point.

ComboBreaker88 wrote: »

* **Role-Based Guild Roster:** Categorize members based on their primary roles (e.g., tank, healer, DPS) for easier group finding.

Are you looking for ways to do this other than guild ranks? Like maybe just display the role in the guild roster the way it is on the group page?