Maintenance for the week of February 23:
· [COMPLETE] NA megaservers for maintenance – February 23, 4:00AM EST (9:00 UTC) - 12:00PM EST (17:00 UTC)
· [COMPLETE] EU megaservers for maintenance – February 23, 9:00 UTC (4:00AM EST) - 17:00 UTC (12:00PM EST)
· [COMPLETE] ESO Store and Account System for maintenance – February 23, 4:00AM EST (9:00 UTC) - 12:00PM EST (17:00 UTC)

I'm afraid that the BOTS and empty dungeons have ruined this game for me.

  • Cyphron
    Cyphron
    Soul Shriven
    resources vanish before your eyes because there are bots under the ground looting them before you can, they are using every movement hack in the book and they are removing a huge part of the fun of questing.

    And I thought that was a bug watching that Jute Node disappearing. For about one hour I didnt find a single jute in that area outside of the starter zone.

    Hopefully Zenimax will implement serverside algorithms soon that detect non human movement patterns and input schemes.

    But honestly, the game is awesome and I dont know whats worse. A bot stuttering through the cave wall carrying MY Iron or a player sprinting and overtaking me to be the first at the iron node.
  • Mister_Crowley
    They are still outside Daggerfall, where the ghosts are. At least they were yesterday. I counted at least 5 different bot trains with no less than 4 bots per a train. Had a heck of a time even getting the ONE HIT needed to do the quests for that area. I'd see the ghost, go towards it and... it was dead before my attack could go off.

    Zenimark can say they're "working on it," all they want, but until I stop seeing so many bots flying through the air, tunneling under the ground, and running in trains, I won't believe it. Having a GM come on and announce they are there is like turning on the light in a questionable motel room... the cockroaches just vanish until the lights go off again.

    Temporary fix for kill quests: Get a resto staff and put a point into the lowest heal skill. Nine times out of ten, you'll get credit. Downside is you'll feel dead inside knowing you contributed in some small way to organized crime. Interesting trade-off, no?
  • Thalmar
    Thalmar
    ✭✭✭✭
    To understand the importance of the problem people need to play an alt. Especially starting places as the nods, mobs spawn rate is far faster than higher level zones infested with bots. Flying, underground, 10s of them in a 40 yard range, it is unbelievable, never saw that many in my life including wow where PvP, especially bgs, are infested with them.

    I believe ZOS is doing many stuff to prevent bots, in front of my eyes a GM literally killed 10s of them yesterday and this was the one reason i didn't cancel my subscription yesterday. I love the game, but just can not tolerate this many bots. If they don't give us a radical solution will cancel and come back when it is inside a tolerable conditions.

    ZOS have to do something against bots very radically not some temporary solutions, because people who stays for 12 men raids are not comparable with the people who will leave because of the bots. Bots have to be the one and only priority right now rather than adding new content, with full team finding solutions even considering changing clients, server what ever can prevent bots.
  • drkfrontiers
    drkfrontiers
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Cyphron wrote: »

    But honestly, the game is awesome and I dont know whats worse. A bot stuttering through the cave wall carrying MY Iron or a player sprinting and overtaking me to be the first at the iron node.

    1000% this.

    What was so awesome about Oblivion and Skyrim was the threatening setting of dungeons and the wilds. You just never knew what was around the next corner and it involved careful planning.

    I don't know if the combat options improve, but just having 5 abilities really sux.
    Edited by drkfrontiers on May 17, 2014 12:07PM
    "One must still have chaos in oneself to be able to give birth to a dancing star."
    ~ Friedrich Nietzsche
  • Affrayer
    Affrayer
    ✭✭✭
    Stonefalls is infested with bots! =o
    Pffffff
  • YourNameHere
    YourNameHere
    ✭✭✭
    Epona222 wrote: »
    First off, I do love the game. Just wanted to get that straight.
    But when bots are running rampant through a quest area killing all the mobs meaning there is no impediment to doing the quest, you're walking from A to B and then back again, it renders it somewhat meaningless. When you know there should be mobs between you and your objective, but there's a bot-train running them all down. Robbing you of fun, use of tactics, and XP from dealing with mobs between A and B when you're questing.

    Here's the thing.

    There are trains of bots AND trains of multiboxers doing the same thing in areas. You can kinda tell the difference. Either way they do ruin fun since they just wipe everything out quickly.

    I still report every train I see. The bots have disappeared in dungeons (as I have not seen one which is amazing, when I would find them crawling all over dungeons) but now I just go in there for skyshards and the achievement anyway.

    But it's normal human behaviour. Can't do one thing, move someplace else. So in essence they were forced onto the surface.

    The bot problem here is just how it was in FF14:ARR when it first came out. There were tons who focuses on harvesting crystals mainly and made the prices on the market go insane. Thankfully after constant work from Square Enix, they were really taken down. Most they do now is spam in shouts and tells.

    I can't tell people what to do, but honestly, if 'you' quit a game over this, that is kinda sad. There is so much more to do out there. Yes it is frustrating, I've had numerous quests and areas knocked out from bots and multiboxers, but I just moved on and did other things.

    ZoS needs to make a way for people to switch shards/instances at a wayshrine. You know those games where you click something near the map and it's a dropdown menu of all the open shards. It's not perfect, but it might help some.

    Also, report them. There is an add-on out there that can help with this. Complaining about the bot problem yet not actively reporting them is like complaining about a politician but 'you' never vote. Yes it takes like, 2 minutes out of your time, and I've reported more people than I care to count, but I do it in hopes that they get stopped.

    ~~~~~

    Here is an add-on that was suggested to me by another forum user.

    I got it, and it works wonderfully.

    http://www.esoui.com/downloads/info181-FastReport.html

    If you haven't already, get the addon client used Minion: http://minion.mmoui.com/

    Then you can search there for FastReport by thelegendaryof

    Once you install that in Minion, go into TESO then go to settings. You'll need to set up the report key (I used F5 in the key bindings).

    So when you hover over someone, it will save the last name you captured, even if they disappear quickly. Hitting the key you chose for the report will bring up two windows, as shown in the screenshot http://cdn.eso.mmoui.com/preview/pvw554.jpg

    Highlight and CTRL + C the information on the left hand window into the report window on the right hand side, then fill in the rest of what you saw, making sure to click from the drop down menu.

    Hope this helps!
    NA Megaserver / RPer
    Alinyssa Gaethar - AD || Raahni-do - AD || Wind-In-Tree's-Shadow - DC
  • ausmack2014
    ausmack2014
    ✭✭✭
    Epona222 wrote: »
    First off, I do love the game. .....
    Also, report them. There is an add-on out there that can help with this. Complaining about the bot problem yet not actively reporting them is like complaining about a politician but 'you' never vote. Yes it takes like, 2 minutes out of your time, and I've reported more people than I care to count, but I do it in hopes that they get stopped.

    I have reported many many bots, but I don't want to stand around reporting bot after bot. I paid my sub to play, not spend half an hour of my paid time reporting bots. I appreciate that doing so may (and I say may with a degree of doubt) help the situation, but after reporting so many and seeing no reduction. it gets a bit disheartening.
  • YourNameHere
    YourNameHere
    ✭✭✭
    Epona222 wrote: »

    I have reported many many bots, but I don't want to stand around reporting bot after bot. I paid my sub to play, not spend half an hour of my paid time reporting bots. I appreciate that doing so may (and I say may with a degree of doubt) help the situation, but after reporting so many and seeing no reduction. it gets a bit disheartening.

    Who says there is no reduction? You do realize a report doesn't automatically ban them, right? There are protocols to look into things to make sure.

    I've seen days with no bots, and days with tons. I guess since I've played MMOs since 2001 I'm a bit more jaded. I don't let one little thing ruin my fun. I've been through the FF14 bot fiasco (which was just as bad as here with many innocents being caught in a net, banned for over 2 weeks etc) so I know things start getting ironed out after time.

    Please don't get me wrong, I dislike bots too. But I also won't lose sleep or let it ruin my enjoyment of such a lore rich game.

    Edited by YourNameHere on May 17, 2014 1:38PM
    NA Megaserver / RPer
    Alinyssa Gaethar - AD || Raahni-do - AD || Wind-In-Tree's-Shadow - DC
  • reggielee
    reggielee
    ✭✭✭✭
    yes, there comes a time when you tire of working for zen when they could easily hire some temps to man each area and zone and ban away or do their own reporting and intel gathering.

    they are working on it and after each update I see a reduction and change in bot behavior which tells me that what they are doing is working. However, for immediate customer impact and morale, they need to start being seen more on landscape combating this, they need to be more verbal about acknowledging their efforts and successes (not what tactic they are using but just some numbers would go a long way for morale)
    Mama always said the fastest way to a man's heart is through his chest.
  • the.dzeneralb16_ESO
    It's funny because when the bot thing started everyone was demanding that GM's come online and ban them. What did ZoS do? They sent GM's online to those locations and banned them. What are they doing now? Same thing + more.

    You got what you wanted, and it was a temporary fix. They're working on a more permanent solution. It's not just a simple "On/Off" button to fix this.
  • Dita
    Dita
    ✭✭✭
    reggielee wrote: »
    ...they are working on it and after each update I see a reduction and change in bot behavior which tells me that what they are doing is working...

    They (bots) adapting, like Borgs in Star Trek. Resistance is futile.
    Edited by Dita on May 17, 2014 1:44PM
    "Begun the Bot Wars has"
  • Beesting
    Beesting
    ✭✭✭✭
    There is one out of the box solution, that sprung to mind yesterday

    Because the goldfarmers will always go for the easiest and most lazy way to earn gold.

    Put something in the game that normal players do not need, but sells for a lot to the vendor,
    That way the bots will all go for it, normal players will not find it anywhere and still not miss it.

    And then put all the bots who harvest said material in a few quarantine zones, so no one can see them.

    That balances out the whole game, the goldsellers are happy and so are we, the normal players.

    I recently had some level 7 and 10 players join our guild and they did not know how to get iron, when i started playing in march the iron nodes were everywhere.

    So maybe it is time to think outside the box :-)
    Beesting, Bosmer Magica DK, AD EU, crafter
    Slager, Dunmer Magica DK, DC EU, pvp
    Farmer, Dunmer Magica DK, AD EU, trials build

    Every major patch looks like the end of the world but somehow i just cannot stop playing.
  • j.frank.nicholsb14_ESO
    I can't tell people what to do, but honestly, if 'you' quit a game over this, that is kinda sad. There is so much more to do out there.

    Yes, there are other things to do out there - lets see. We could roll a new toon - except, it would have to play in pajamas since we can't get any iron ore to make them armor.

    The fact is we should not have to sit around trying to think of things to do - the bots have RUINED the game.

    We have played since the early betas, and we love(d) the game even with all the bugs.
    Yes it is frustrating, I've had numerous quests and areas knocked out from bots and multiboxers, but I just moved on and did other things.

    Tell you what, you send me $15/month and I will setup a server where you can "move on" and "do other things".
    ZoS needs to make a way for people to switch shards/instances at a wayshrine. You know those games where you click something near the map and it's a dropdown menu of all the open shards. It's not perfect, but it might help some.

    No, ZOS does not need to provide more tools for us to do their job. ZOS needs to provide the game we are paying for.
    Also, report them. There is an add-on out there that can help with this. Complaining about the bot problem yet not actively reporting them is like complaining about a politician but 'you' never vote. Yes it takes like, 2 minutes out of your time, and I've reported more people than I care to count, but I do it in hopes that they get stopped.

    At 2 minutes per bot, you have reported more than you care to count - so you have spent "countless" hours reporting bots and you are having fun doing that? At 2 minutes per bot reporting 30 bots takes an hour, an hour that we should be playing.

    We both reported bots constantly for weeks - and finally gave up when we saw no results, received no feedback and saw the bots remaining present after being reported and so basically lost interest in "we are working on it - trust us". We are here to roleplay Elder Scrolls, not to work for free for ZOS.
    Here is an add-on that was suggested to me by another forum user.

    I got it, and it works wonderfully.

    http://www.esoui.com/downloads/info181-FastReport.html

    If you haven't already, get the addon client used Minion: http://minion.mmoui.com/

    Then you can search there for FastReport by thelegendaryof

    I have FastReport - I don't want more tools to report the BOTS - there is NO EVIDENCE at all that reporting bots has done any good what so ever. NO FEEDBACK, NO REDUCTION in the number of bots, REPORTED BOTS and spammers continue to be present.

    Maybe if there was some feedback indicating that SOMETHING/ANYTHING was being accomplished - but without that there is no evidence that it is doing anything. Not my idea of fun that I want to pay for.
    Hope this helps!

    No, it doesn't help at all - not even a little bit. What would help would be a status report by EOS indicating what progress is being made and when we can expect visible in game results. But, instead we get comments about not compromising game security - uh, excuse me, look around, there is NO security, from all appearances the bots have won.
  • Oevaag_Bur
    Oevaag_Bur
    ✭✭
    I have to ask. Is this a bigger issue on the US servers than the EU ones ? Personally I hardly ever see bot's. I have seen some but not anywhere near "the sky is falling" quantities that are being mentioned here by others.
  • j.frank.nicholsb14_ESO
    Oevaag_Bur wrote: »
    I have to ask. Is this a bigger issue on the US servers than the EU ones ? Personally I hardly ever see bot's. I have seen some but not anywhere near "the sky is falling" quantities that are being mentioned here by others.

    I play both servers, and it is bad on both servers. Step outside Davons Watch with the spirits and watch for 5 minutes at all the bot trains killing quest npcs.

    Try to gather enough resources to outfit your band new toon and watch it disappear as an under ground bot mines it in front of you. Stand in the market square and watch a bot stand for "hours" and notice that bot has the same name as the gold spammer in zone chat (I did report it.)



  • kellemdros
    Epona222 wrote: »

    I have reported many many bots, but I don't want to stand around reporting bot after bot. I paid my sub to play, not spend half an hour of my paid time reporting bots. I appreciate that doing so may (and I say may with a degree of doubt) help the situation, but after reporting so many and seeing no reduction. it gets a bit disheartening.

    Who says there is no reduction? You do realize a report doesn't automatically ban them, right? There are protocols to look into things to make sure.

    I've seen days with no bots, and days with tons. I guess since I've played MMOs since 2001 I'm a bit more jaded. I don't let one little thing ruin my fun. I've been through the FF14 bot fiasco (which was just as bad as here with many innocents being caught in a net, banned for over 2 weeks etc) so I know things start getting ironed out after time.

    Please don't get me wrong, I dislike bots too. But I also won't lose sleep or let it ruin my enjoyment of such a lore rich game.

    Yeah men, but...

    Tons, an i mean tons of bots harvesting (and now in dungeons again) (even at vr levels), this ruins game experience...

    plus...half of the *** skills in the game bugged totally or in part....

    plus... rush to throw new content while soooo much bugs still out there....

    I really want to stick to it, but right now its pointles... maybe wen they release the console version....
    If they dont close this beta then.... XD
  • Lucifah
    Lucifah
    They're working on a more permanent solution. It's not just a simple "On/Off" button to fix this.

    See that's the problem I have... Do they? I haven't seen a lot of official backup for this theory. There was a manual ban wave in April, a couple of weeks ago. Things got worse since. A lot. And the best we see from ZOS staff now is a generic reply suggesting that the reporting tool in-game should be used so that a GM can show up, ban a bunch, and as soon as they leave, everything is back to (ab)normal.

    Guess what, I, and many others, have done that. Didn't help. We need something from official sources to back up what everybody is hoping for: A proper solution; the sooner the better.

    We know there's a lot of issues in ESO, and that can be expected. It's still early days in a fantastic and promising game, and no MMO launch has ever been without problems. GW2 for example suffered a serious bot infestation too. They finally managed it. (Not sure how it's nowadays, because GW2 wasn't good enough to keep my attention for an extended period of time)

    But the point is, something has to happen as a matter of topmost priority. People will consider their options come subscription renewal. Communication could make a difference. But there's none to speak of.

    The main issue is that we see lots of bots and only half-arsed measures to tackle them, at best. We do not know what's really going on. ZOS, please do enlighten us.

    (If I missed official announcements, which are less than two weeks old AND contain more than the usual blah blah, do share! I'd really love to stand corrected on this one!)

  • j.frank.nicholsb14_ESO
    Lucifah wrote: »
    Communication could make a difference. But there's none to speak of.

    The main issue is that we see lots of bots and only half-arsed measures to tackle them, at best. We do not know what's really going on. ZOS, please do enlighten us.

    (If I missed official announcements, which are less than two weeks old AND contain more than the usual blah blah, do share! I'd really love to stand corrected on this one!)

    Exactly, more and more people are saying the same thing - we can live with the bugs, we can even live with the bots, we can not live with the stone wall of silence and no evidence or feedback that anything we have been asked to do (reporting?) is having any affect.

  • Dita
    Dita
    ✭✭✭
    Lucifah wrote: »
    Communication could make a difference. But there's none to speak of.
    ... we can not live with the stone wall of silence and no evidence or feedback that anything we have been asked to do (reporting?) is having any affect.

    Its because they ALL bots.
    Edited by Dita on May 17, 2014 2:35PM
    "Begun the Bot Wars has"
  • KhajiitiLizard
    KhajiitiLizard
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Perhaps Zenimax isn't saying what they are doing to take care of the bots because these forums are public (even if you can't post you can still read them). Botters could see what Zenimax is doing and change accordingly. If Zenimax keeps it secret the bots won't know what to do. Though if Zenimax just took the game down for maintenance for a few weeks perhaps the bots would leave. I wouldn't mind not being able to play for a few weeks if it meant no more bots.
  • drkfrontiers
    drkfrontiers
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Anyway cancelled my subscription. Logged in this afternoon and 2 minutes into my game fighting, a bot train shows-up. LOL Exactly the same place I disconnected in frustration the day before.
    "One must still have chaos in oneself to be able to give birth to a dancing star."
    ~ Friedrich Nietzsche
  • steveb16_ESO46
    steveb16_ESO46
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    It's still here. sigh... It spams the forums 24-7 with attention seeking posts about bots and about how it's quitting, but still it continues to troll and attention seek on the forums...? has it nothing better to do with it's life? :s
    anyway, seeing as it's looking for "lols" and "agrees" I'll leave it an agree and hope it makes it's day, enjoy.

    I dunno. just like I don't know if you have anything better to do with your life than insult other posters.
  • j.frank.nicholsb14_ESO
    Perhaps Zenimax isn't saying what they are doing to take care of the bots because these forums are public (even if you can't post you can still read them). Botters could see what Zenimax is doing and change accordingly. If Zenimax keeps it secret the bots won't know what to do. Though if Zenimax just took the game down for maintenance for a few weeks perhaps the bots would leave. I wouldn't mind not being able to play for a few weeks if it meant no more bots.

    I don't know of anyone that is asking for details of what ZOS is doing to combat the bots. We are saying there is no real communications at all. Things like:

    "As a result of your reporting of bots we were able to ban xxx accounts in the past week - up xxx from the previous week, keep up the good work and thank you for your help."

    or

    "as a result of all the information we are gathering based on customers reporting of bots we now expect to have the initial steps in solving this problem online within xx weeks (months, years, centuries), and you should begin seeing reductions in the bots and the issues around that time."

    or

    "we are announcing today the establishment of a Department of Tamriel Security. A team of specialists from around the globe is being put together to help contain and eliminate the spreading bot menace."...
  • Dita
    Dita
    ✭✭✭
    @j.frank.nicholsb14_ESO They can't report it - because they got nothing to report, they overwhelmed by bots, and they don't have a slightest idea, what to do about it.
    "Begun the Bot Wars has"
  • Reevster
    Reevster
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    What makes me madder then bots is people calling for nerfs ie, bosses spawn/loot as a way to "fix" the problem, so now they Nerfed dungeons bosses and it ruins it for the players who like to farm a bit , now dungeons are boring as heck and I just want to leave as fast as i can, most of the whiners likely have stopped playing now , so we are stuck with the results.

    Fix the bot issue but dont ruin it for the players who remain paying the subs or we will leave too because of all the nerf batting.Surly there is a better way to deal with it then to nerf everything.
  • Writer
    Writer
    ✭✭
    Perhaps Zenimax isn't saying what they are doing to take care of the bots because these forums are public (even if you can't post you can still read them). Botters could see what Zenimax is doing and change accordingly. If Zenimax keeps it secret the bots won't know what to do. Though if Zenimax just took the game down for maintenance for a few weeks perhaps the bots would leave. I wouldn't mind not being able to play for a few weeks if it meant no more bots.

    The thing is that they do not need to give specifics on what they are doing to combat bots. I don't think anyone would want that. Xenimax should not remain silent, however. To bolster their customer's confidence for the company, they should give an announcement like they did in April about banning X number of bots.
    Cyras - Ebonheart Dragonknight - Sanguine's Tester
    Artist | Crafter | Heavy RPer | PvE | Writer
    There is nothing to writing. All you do is sit down at a typewriter and bleed. - Ernest Hemingway
  • raudfsfolley
    raudfsfolley
    ✭✭✭
    I'd love to see a running kill count for bot and bot runners. They don't have to tell us how they are doing it. Just give us at least the feeling they are visibly trying.
  • Bromburak
    Bromburak
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Wait. There's bots? In the freaking game?

    Why have there been no posts about this???

    They are busy with QQ about Vet Content, solo quests and armor decay. B)
  • redwoodtreesprite
    redwoodtreesprite
    ✭✭✭
    A token 15 min visit from a GM is meaningless. And many have posted that the bots they reported were never banned. They still see them sometimes weeks later in same places. The number of bots just keeps increasing. Right now on Bleakrock Isle, it is so bad that in one area the nodes don't even finish loading before they are instantly harvested. Seems to be a bot underground dedicated to each node there.

    I gave up on the early areas for Daggerfall weeks ago. I don't even consider making a new character in that faction. Bots are swarming all over the place. Only area I can gather any low level resources is the first AD island. There only because there are mobs at many node spawn spots. So the teleport and flyer ones don't collect those. But even there it is getting really barren, crafting mat wise.

    Only thing I can still collect is hide scraps from mobs. As much as I like heavy armor, I am considering having my characters switch to medium armor with one piece of heavy armor so the skill can go up.


    Originally I was thinking that the bot farmers were doing all this just to get gold to sell. But now I think their plan is to deliberately strip almost all resources so players will feel like they have to buy gold from them. Evil indeed. Thing is, most players will just stop subbing eventually instead due to this. It hurts the game so much, all these botters and gold sellers. I have been waiting so long for an ES MMO. And I fear this one will fail if something isn't done very soon. :(
    Edited by redwoodtreesprite on May 17, 2014 7:11PM
  • Arsvita
    Arsvita
    ✭✭✭
    shaiten wrote: »
    resources vanish before your eyes because there are bots under the ground looting them before you can

    still trying to figure out how people know bots are underground doing this ... maybe they are just invisible :)

    5mfdyif1ngmb.bmp
    Sometimes if you look down, you find a name included.
    tfxe9ae7bu6x.bmp
    Reporting them has become harder now too as the speedbots that traverse through all manner of ground, rock outcrops, air, and do disappear are too quick for me to get a screenshot for the name.

    Before you say to use "F" realize that even that has become more difficult, as per another thread, due to "targeting" issues. Although you can get plenty of traveling traders and critters names to show from leagues around.

    I also am very sure that there are no names whatsoever that are visible in any screenshots to protect the innocent real player that may actually get a short notice in chat and to protect the gold farmers from shame (a program can feel shame?).
Sign In or Register to comment.