MMO's in part survive on the content being repeated. Account wide achievements take away from that. We say we hate having to do all that fun stuff again but truth be told it is what keeps many of us playing. If we could just hop on a new character and it is pretty much ready to go with little game play we would quickly find little reason to log in.
Endgame is what keeps MMO alive. You can repeat content all day, but it is the Endgame that keeps people around. Majority of ESO players Burn through the content and gear up a person so they can do Endgame Trials and PvP. Doing the same repetition of quest on different characters is what will drive people away.
End game is part of it. But that is still repeating content. PvP is unique as players changing strategies can help keep that fresh. For PvE repeating content and new content are needed. That is why the RNG system is what it is and why good armor for PvP can be found in PvE content and some good PvE skills are found only in PvP. It is healthy for the game if players do a variety of content and repeat it.
I would also argue with your majority of players burn through the content so they can do endgame. I'm not sure the majority of players have any real interest in end game content. I do know people that will grind like their life depended on it to get a new character to max level then grind for the needed gear with PvP and vet trials in mind. I also know people that only care about the stories and do those over and over. Most players are somewhere in the middle. They aren't going to do all the quests but they aren't going to hit the grind spots either.
Those middle ground players repeating content is what keeps the game alive and fluid. There would be less incentive to do some of the content on new characters if achievements were account wide. Human nature, we like the bells and whistles.
What is interesting is none of this has anything to do with a reason why there should not be account wide achievements. Not a single word of it addresses that.
I will agree it went off on a tangent but if you follow the entire string leading to that response you will see it does have to do with achievements and why they should be character bound. It is all about repeated content being good for the long term health of the game.
Then again there are players who have spent the time to get all the lines maxed on multiple characters.
But they didn't do that for the achievements per se, they did it for the master writs which get better with more achievements (per character).
I would know, i did the same thing. 4 of my 5 mains now have every single craft maxed at 50.
ZOS could easily adjust the writ logic so those of us who have leveled crafts on multiple chars can still benefit, even if achievements are made account wide.
None of this is rocket surgery ...
Sirona_Starr wrote: »Androconium wrote: »I know this dead horse has been beaten a lot, (1) but it needs a few more whacks. Account wide Achievements is a must. With the skyshard sharing in the crown store it seems like Zos is heading in the right direction with making this game alt friendly.
I do not see why it has no been done soon. Now I know there are some out there that will just say no, but let me convince you with debunking arguments against it.
No MMO does this - False. There are many out there that do have account wide Achievements including WoW which is the biggest.
Your character didn't earn it your other one did so no. It ruins the RPG aspect - True, but the same could be said about your alts having access to the mounts, collectibles, houses, costumes, skins, and dyes(which is a form of shared Achievements) that it did not earn. So what makes Achievements so different that they have to be excluded?
It will ruin the game and make it where you would not want to make another character. - False if anything it would promote growth of the game and encourage players to make more toons.
As for myself I have earned these Achievements and I think that my Alternate characters deserve to benefit from (2) the time and work I put into the game. Just this one players opinion.
What do you think? Should we have account wide Achievements? Please vote and let the developers know. Maybe than we can get a definitive yes or no from them and put this horse to bed.
(1) No it doesn't.
(2) Time is money. I keep saying this because ZOS are not really that interested in saving you time. This concept has been demonstrated many time when ZOS have made changes to extend your game play time. The removal of the fourth Trait Research path is where I first noticed this.
If you prefer WoW's gameplay, then go back and play it. Please stop wasting our time here
This conversation is not a waste of time. It is about Achievements, and not skills. My main character is my achievement toon - because I have NO interest in repeating Master Angler, as an example - so whatever achievements that are possible, I do on her, and by no means, as a healer, can she do all of them. She is also my crafter because why have every toon craft? What's the point of that? So in fact, aside from the starter quests for xp, none of my alt toons pursue crafting. I currently have 18 toons, don't care about getting achievements on any of them, but I do on the one.
HOWEVER, if you take a look at Eidetic Memory - some of those books are unobtainable if you missed a pick up during the quest, or if you played in a group. My main is missing some that alt toons have, and she cannot get now in this game. THAT DRIVES ME NUTS!!!!!! This is the ONE category that should be account wide, for the above stated reason. Master Angler, given it's entirely RNG based, certainly should also be account wide. I am fairly confident no one seeks to achieve it on all of their toons. Master Crafter as well...... So, ZOS thinking "Uh, they will play up to 18 toons to pursue Master Angler," as an example, is a false notion, because no, they will not, and it will not keep someone in the game longer to do so. Why would it be so awful to have all the toons have access to that Achievement and Title? It's not like it affects anyone else in the game, just makes the person who got the achievement happy to be able to wear that title, if chosen, on different toons?
For those that say no, to Achievements (NOT SKILLS, LET'S BE CLEAR), then it should be consistent. Your other toons should not be able to wear your skins, your costumes, polymorphs, use your VMA weapons, wear gear from trials that they didn't go in and get and so forth. Saying no to title sharing, while enjoying the aforementioned sharing is completely hypocritical.
MMO's in part survive on the content being repeated. Account wide achievements take away from that. We say we hate having to do all that fun stuff again but truth be told it is what keeps many of us playing. If we could just hop on a new character and it is pretty much ready to go with little game play we would quickly find little reason to log in.
Endgame is what keeps MMO alive. You can repeat content all day, but it is the Endgame that keeps people around. Majority of ESO players Burn through the content and gear up a person so they can do Endgame Trials and PvP. Doing the same repetition of quest on different characters is what will drive people away.
End game is part of it. But that is still repeating content. PvP is unique as players changing strategies can help keep that fresh. For PvE repeating content and new content are needed. That is why the RNG system is what it is and why good armor for PvP can be found in PvE content and some good PvE skills are found only in PvP. It is healthy for the game if players do a variety of content and repeat it.
I would also argue with your majority of players burn through the content so they can do endgame. I'm not sure the majority of players have any real interest in end game content. I do know people that will grind like their life depended on it to get a new character to max level then grind for the needed gear with PvP and vet trials in mind. I also know people that only care about the stories and do those over and over. Most players are somewhere in the middle. They aren't going to do all the quests but they aren't going to hit the grind spots either.
Those middle ground players repeating content is what keeps the game alive and fluid. There would be less incentive to do some of the content on new characters if achievements were account wide. Human nature, we like the bells and whistles.
What is interesting is none of this has anything to do with a reason why there should not be account wide achievements. Not a single word of it addresses that.
I will agree it went off on a tangent but if you follow the entire string leading to that response you will see it does have to do with achievements and why they should be character bound. It is all about repeated content being good for the long term health of the game.
Funny how in a game that had account wide achievements I still repeated content. While I have looked at my achievements score and sometimes what a new achievement I did not expect was about I, like many do not look to achievements for reasons to play the game. It is very much a secondary aspect.
The argument is false for the main reason most do not play to rack up achievements. Even those who clear vet HM trials are more interesting in enjoying the game with those they play with an getting good scores. Some do for no death speed run achievements but they would be repeating the content regardless to get the better scores.
Further, having account side achievements does nothing to take away from the group of players who are driven to play the game for achievements as it does not take away character based achievements.
It literally does not hurt anyone.
@kargen27
May I ask why you are against Account wide Titles? I mean if I did the content and got the title I do not see any reason why my Alts can not have it? Why should I have to GRIND out the title for each character? It just seems redundant. I don't see where it would hurt anyone or cause any game breaking issues.
@ZOS_GinaBruno please look at this poll and help us reach makers at Zenimax
barney2525 wrote: »I dislike positions based on half truths.
There is No game that gives ALL the achievements of a single character to ALL other characters - ie. to the Account.
Some games give Some specific achievements to the account, but that is not what you are asking. And you are also, very conveniently, not giving Any actual examples of the achievements other games give.
Equating Costumes and mounts with Achievements is also not an honest comparison. What your mount "looks like" is a cosmetic and many can simply be bought with cash- depending on the time of year and the event in progress. So BUYING something cosmetic for the Account has nothing to do with "Earning" anything.
Master Crafter requires level 50 in all crafting. Explain to me how you are going to Give that achievement to ALL my characters when they do NOT have the level 50's required.
And this is the crux of the entire argument against. The new character does NOT have Any of the requirements that are needed for that Achievement. Does not matter which Achievement you are talking about. Achievements are specific to the Character. They are what makes each character Unique.
You put the time in on ONE character. That character has most of the Achievements. Your other characters have Not had the time put in.
Achievements are for the CHARACTER.
And you can't receive an Achievement if you Don't earn it.
There are specific ACCOUNT rewards for the first time a character hits specific Achievements. Dyes, non-combat pets, costumes, etc. Those are for the Account.
A Character does Not deserve an "Achievement" that the Character did not earn.
IMHO
World of Warcraft has all Achievements and rewards unlock for all characters. There is your proof
@ZOS_GinaBruno please look at this poll and help us reach makers at Zenimax
You do realize these forums represent a very small percentage of players in the game? Might as well have flipped a coin 204 times and posted those results.
@ZOS_GinaBruno please look at this poll and help us reach makers at Zenimax
You do realize these forums represent a very small percentage of players in the game? Might as well have flipped a coin 204 times and posted those results.
Shouldn't be lazy.
@ZOS_GinaBruno please look at this poll and help us reach makers at Zenimax
You do realize these forums represent a very small percentage of players in the game? Might as well have flipped a coin 204 times and posted those results.
funny how I see posts like here everytime when 1 side in something see its losing war not only in % of votes but in just logic reasoning
@ZOS_GinaBruno please look at this poll and help us reach makers at Zenimax
You do realize these forums represent a very small percentage of players in the game? Might as well have flipped a coin 204 times and posted those results.
you're the only one yelling not to do the change, i've seen many of your posts.
Shouldn't be lazy.
tell me how lazy I need to be having not very much time to play but having 30k achievs on character which took very veryy looong to get on single character and not having just time to repeat it even on just 2nd alt...
small reminder...few months agon on those forums someone posted he finally get literally every achievement in this game after playing since beta...so it took him good 5 years of achievs hunting for single character mainly because every next patch there are added more achievs to game
so how Im supposed to gather again on other character 30k+ achievs in short time to have more fun of playing different character than main which will give me also more willing to repeat some more content which currently I dont even mind as how it works for now
PVP ranks, titles, research, skyshards, lorebooks etc. should be definitely character-wide. But all achievements gained on account should be shown in the one window, IMO.
Nowadays, for example, it is very difficult to make warden or necromancer the new "main", having about 30k of achievement points on nightblade. Do Master Angler, thieves achievements, resource gathering achievements, trophy achievements again? No, thanks.
Account-wide achievements will greatly stimulate to play another classes in high-end content.
Shouldn't be lazy.
tell me how lazy I need to be having not very much time to play but having 30k achievs on character which took very veryy looong to get on single character and not having just time to repeat it even on just 2nd alt...
small reminder...few months agon on those forums someone posted he finally get literally every achievement in this game after playing since beta...so it took him good 5 years of achievs hunting for single character mainly because every next patch there are added more achievs to game
so how Im supposed to gather again on other character 30k+ achievs in short time to have more fun of playing different character than main which will give me also more willing to repeat some more content which currently I dont even mind as how it works for now
Why do you need them all on your other characters? What specifically do they give you that you can't manage without on secondary characters?
Shouldn't be lazy.
tell me how lazy I need to be having not very much time to play but having 30k achievs on character which took very veryy looong to get on single character and not having just time to repeat it even on just 2nd alt...
small reminder...few months agon on those forums someone posted he finally get literally every achievement in this game after playing since beta...so it took him good 5 years of achievs hunting for single character mainly because every next patch there are added more achievs to game
so how Im supposed to gather again on other character 30k+ achievs in short time to have more fun of playing different character than main which will give me also more willing to repeat some more content which currently I dont even mind as how it works for now
Why do you need them all on your other characters? What specifically do they give you that you can't manage without on secondary characters?
its is giving me possibility to have completed them all
there is content you cant complete on every character/class - for example trials like vAS+2 or vCR+3 but even on jsut vCR+0 most endgame groups dont want stamina players here as how designed is this content - and there are magic dps's that pathetic so noone want to take it at all - magden, magdk which is even on melee spot like stamina dps
not always I want or have even willing to play on my main because jsut on this class etc
for example I was playing for 3+ years since beta with my main as stamnb, got few months break to return in nb meta near summerset release time and guess what? I even wasnt happy by nb meta...I just got sick of nb class and Im not the only person who would want to have now different class as main for those achievs but we cant
I have got 28k+ achievs with morrowind on my main and almost 3k lorebooks on it and well..because its my nb and I still dont want to play....it is just left as daily crafter and magazine with no use of it while I had and still have much more fun playing with stamplar which is *** on pve at all but I dont have anymore willing to try get literally any new achievs besides those with skin/personality on accountwide etc
if I had option with accountwide achievs I would have still willing to play literally every content and even repeat much more on different chars while now II dont mind do any of this whilere there is also no option for class change
so in shortcut from this as I stopped playing my main and stopped to care about acheivements...I stopped to play that much time in ESO like I was playing only my main...I jsut play less in ESO because I dont have point to play more as this is just nonsense how it currently works with achievs
Shouldn't be lazy.
tell me how lazy I need to be having not very much time to play but having 30k achievs on character which took very veryy looong to get on single character and not having just time to repeat it even on just 2nd alt...
small reminder...few months agon on those forums someone posted he finally get literally every achievement in this game after playing since beta...so it took him good 5 years of achievs hunting for single character mainly because every next patch there are added more achievs to game
so how Im supposed to gather again on other character 30k+ achievs in short time to have more fun of playing different character than main which will give me also more willing to repeat some more content which currently I dont even mind as how it works for now
Why do you need them all on your other characters? What specifically do they give you that you can't manage without on secondary characters?
its is giving me possibility to have completed them all
there is content you cant complete on every character/class - for example trials like vAS+2 or vCR+3 but even on jsut vCR+0 most endgame groups dont want stamina players here as how designed is this content - and there are magic dps's that pathetic so noone want to take it at all - magden, magdk which is even on melee spot like stamina dps
not always I want or have even willing to play on my main because jsut on this class etc
for example I was playing for 3+ years since beta with my main as stamnb, got few months break to return in nb meta near summerset release time and guess what? I even wasnt happy by nb meta...I just got sick of nb class and Im not the only person who would want to have now different class as main for those achievs but we cant
I have got 28k+ achievs with morrowind on my main and almost 3k lorebooks on it and well..because its my nb and I still dont want to play....it is just left as daily crafter and magazine with no use of it while I had and still have much more fun playing with stamplar which is *** on pve at all but I dont have anymore willing to try get literally any new achievs besides those with skin/personality on accountwide etc
if I had option with accountwide achievs I would have still willing to play literally every content and even repeat much more on different chars while now II dont mind do any of this whilere there is also no option for class change
so in shortcut from this as I stopped playing my main and stopped to care about acheivements...I stopped to play that much time in ESO like I was playing only my main...I jsut play less in ESO because I dont have point to play more as this is just nonsense how it currently works with achievs
Again, what is stopping you from playing on characters that don't have all the achievements that another character has earned? What can you not do with those characters? Which achievements do you not have that prevent you from playing those characters?
Shouldn't be lazy.
tell me how lazy I need to be having not very much time to play but having 30k achievs on character which took very veryy looong to get on single character and not having just time to repeat it even on just 2nd alt...
small reminder...few months agon on those forums someone posted he finally get literally every achievement in this game after playing since beta...so it took him good 5 years of achievs hunting for single character mainly because every next patch there are added more achievs to game
so how Im supposed to gather again on other character 30k+ achievs in short time to have more fun of playing different character than main which will give me also more willing to repeat some more content which currently I dont even mind as how it works for now
Why do you need them all on your other characters? What specifically do they give you that you can't manage without on secondary characters?
its is giving me possibility to have completed them all
there is content you cant complete on every character/class - for example trials like vAS+2 or vCR+3 but even on jsut vCR+0 most endgame groups dont want stamina players here as how designed is this content - and there are magic dps's that pathetic so noone want to take it at all - magden, magdk which is even on melee spot like stamina dps
not always I want or have even willing to play on my main because jsut on this class etc
for example I was playing for 3+ years since beta with my main as stamnb, got few months break to return in nb meta near summerset release time and guess what? I even wasnt happy by nb meta...I just got sick of nb class and Im not the only person who would want to have now different class as main for those achievs but we cant
I have got 28k+ achievs with morrowind on my main and almost 3k lorebooks on it and well..because its my nb and I still dont want to play....it is just left as daily crafter and magazine with no use of it while I had and still have much more fun playing with stamplar which is *** on pve at all but I dont have anymore willing to try get literally any new achievs besides those with skin/personality on accountwide etc
if I had option with accountwide achievs I would have still willing to play literally every content and even repeat much more on different chars while now II dont mind do any of this whilere there is also no option for class change
so in shortcut from this as I stopped playing my main and stopped to care about acheivements...I stopped to play that much time in ESO like I was playing only my main...I jsut play less in ESO because I dont have point to play more as this is just nonsense how it currently works with achievs
Again, what is stopping you from playing on characters that don't have all the achievements that another character has earned? What can you not do with those characters? Which achievements do you not have that prevent you from playing those characters?
stoppings me is this as Im jsut completionist in every game which I play, when its possible I want to have everything on 100% even if it will take insane amount of time like jsut years, in ESO its possible if you play single char....
so when I play on alt.....I jsut see how empty is achiev log and I cry, I had that much completed, I coult still have to complete many more newest etc....but I dont have point to do it on alt which is empty at all and Im not gonna to repeat that many which I have done after few years only because I wanted to play different class
with it the best at me is that every this new character which I create in different clas to play...looks literally same as my main...and only difference between those chars is colours of fur and their class....where in every other TES game you could be everything on single character, there we cant, we are split now between 6 different classes and we wont have willing to always play this one class which is our main on which we want to have everything achieved which we jsut cant are we are enslaved into this whish is reason of losing fun of playing this game
Shouldn't be lazy.
tell me how lazy I need to be having not very much time to play but having 30k achievs on character which took very veryy looong to get on single character and not having just time to repeat it even on just 2nd alt...
small reminder...few months agon on those forums someone posted he finally get literally every achievement in this game after playing since beta...so it took him good 5 years of achievs hunting for single character mainly because every next patch there are added more achievs to game
so how Im supposed to gather again on other character 30k+ achievs in short time to have more fun of playing different character than main which will give me also more willing to repeat some more content which currently I dont even mind as how it works for now
Why do you need them all on your other characters? What specifically do they give you that you can't manage without on secondary characters?
its is giving me possibility to have completed them all
there is content you cant complete on every character/class - for example trials like vAS+2 or vCR+3 but even on jsut vCR+0 most endgame groups dont want stamina players here as how designed is this content - and there are magic dps's that pathetic so noone want to take it at all - magden, magdk which is even on melee spot like stamina dps
not always I want or have even willing to play on my main because jsut on this class etc
for example I was playing for 3+ years since beta with my main as stamnb, got few months break to return in nb meta near summerset release time and guess what? I even wasnt happy by nb meta...I just got sick of nb class and Im not the only person who would want to have now different class as main for those achievs but we cant
I have got 28k+ achievs with morrowind on my main and almost 3k lorebooks on it and well..because its my nb and I still dont want to play....it is just left as daily crafter and magazine with no use of it while I had and still have much more fun playing with stamplar which is *** on pve at all but I dont have anymore willing to try get literally any new achievs besides those with skin/personality on accountwide etc
if I had option with accountwide achievs I would have still willing to play literally every content and even repeat much more on different chars while now II dont mind do any of this whilere there is also no option for class change
so in shortcut from this as I stopped playing my main and stopped to care about acheivements...I stopped to play that much time in ESO like I was playing only my main...I jsut play less in ESO because I dont have point to play more as this is just nonsense how it currently works with achievs
Again, what is stopping you from playing on characters that don't have all the achievements that another character has earned? What can you not do with those characters? Which achievements do you not have that prevent you from playing those characters?
stoppings me is this as Im jsut completionist in every game which I play, when its possible I want to have everything on 100% even if it will take insane amount of time like jsut years, in ESO its possible if you play single char....
so when I play on alt.....I jsut see how empty is achiev log and I cry, I had that much completed, I coult still have to complete many more newest etc....but I dont have point to do it on alt which is empty at all and Im not gonna to repeat that many which I have done after few years only because I wanted to play different class
with it the best at me is that every this new character which I create in different clas to play...looks literally same as my main...and only difference between those chars is colours of fur and their class....where in every other TES game you could be everything on single character, there we cant, we are split now between 6 different classes and we wont have willing to always play this one class which is our main on which we want to have everything achieved which we jsut cant are we are enslaved into this whish is reason of losing fun of playing this game
That's because every other TES game is a single-player offline game, while ESO is a multiplayer online game.
While I understand that some people suffer from a completionist obsession, I don't believe that game developers should structure their games around that. You are still able to accomplish all the achievements that are available to each of your characters, and there is no indication that the failure to gain any particular achievement will prejudice your playing of your characters in any practical way. The only achievements that it could be argued make a practical difference to a character's development relate to skill points and sadly you can now buy them for your other characters with real money - which is the same way all other achievements will be made account-wide if people aren't careful what they wish for.
maltinkilic wrote: »It would be funny and absurd to see a lvl 3 character with "flawless conqueror" or "master angler" title. Yes the titles are directly related to achievement and if they are accountwide all alts will have all the titles.
@ZOS_GinaBruno please look at this poll and help us reach makers at Zenimax
You do realize these forums represent a very small percentage of players in the game? Might as well have flipped a coin 204 times and posted those results.
What do you think? Should we have account wide Achievements? Please vote and let the developers know. Maybe than we can get a definitive yes or no from them and put this horse to bed.
barney2525 wrote: »I dislike positions based on half truths.
There is No game that gives ALL the achievements of a single character to ALL other characters - ie. to the Account.
Some games give Some specific achievements to the account, but that is not what you are asking. And you are also, very conveniently, not giving Any actual examples of the achievements other games give.
Equating Costumes and mounts with Achievements is also not an honest comparison. What your mount "looks like" is a cosmetic and many can simply be bought with cash- depending on the time of year and the event in progress. So BUYING something cosmetic for the Account has nothing to do with "Earning" anything.
Master Crafter requires level 50 in all crafting. Explain to me how you are going to Give that achievement to ALL my characters when they do NOT have the level 50's required.
And this is the crux of the entire argument against. The new character does NOT have Any of the requirements that are needed for that Achievement. Does not matter which Achievement you are talking about. Achievements are specific to the Character. They are what makes each character Unique.
You put the time in on ONE character. That character has most of the Achievements. Your other characters have Not had the time put in.
Achievements are for the CHARACTER.
And you can't receive an Achievement if you Don't earn it.
There are specific ACCOUNT rewards for the first time a character hits specific Achievements. Dyes, non-combat pets, costumes, etc. Those are for the Account.
A Character does Not deserve an "Achievement" that the Character did not earn.
IMHO
barney2525 wrote: »I dislike positions based on half truths.
There is No game that gives ALL the achievements of a single character to ALL other characters - ie. to the Account.