leepalmer95 wrote: »Then you have people like @starkerealm who starts out ok but then quickly turn to responses like 'you don't know about pve'.
leepalmer95 wrote: »@ZOS_JessicaFolsom @ZOS_GinaBruno
Can we close this thread please? I was actually productive earlier on but it seems to be no longer the case as all the pve' warriors have appeared, i'm not getting actual answers anymore, just sarcasm and exaggerated facts. They are just out of actual valid responses.
ObsidianMichi wrote: »leepalmer95 wrote: »Oh so you mean a click heal like say? Vigor which every other tank uses on it's own just fine?
Or another source of healing such a crit surge? Which is just as good as vigor.
You know those heals?
Every Tank uses Vigor? Every Tank? All of them? Are you absolutely and utterly sure?
It's not like anyone's ever heard of Green Dragon Blood. Templars with Repentance slotted are definitely using Vigor. And Crit Surge is now equal to Vigor? I guess everyone should slot that then.
You know what Crit Surge doesn't give you? Stamina.
You know what Tanks need a lot of in dungeons? Stamina.
Green Dragon Blood. Repentance. Dark Deal.
All three allow you to take your magicka bar that you're not using and fuel your stamina. Yay.
Vigor costs Stamina. Boo.
We need Stamina to block and bash.
Whee.
Or we die.
Oh noes.
leepalmer95 wrote: »@ZOS_JessicaFolsom @ZOS_GinaBruno
Can we close this thread please? I was actually productive earlier on but it seems to be no longer the case as all the pve' warriors have appeared, i'm not getting actual answers anymore, just sarcasm and exaggerated facts. They are just out of actual valid responses.
We gave you valid reasons and responses but since they were not agreeing with you, apparently they didn't count.
While you may be entitled to an opinion, it does not make it fact.
starkerealm wrote: »leepalmer95 wrote: »Then you have people like @starkerealm who starts out ok but then quickly turn to responses like 'you don't know about pve'.
It took me two days to lower my standards to the point where I started to suspect you don't understand PvE. If that's your definition of "quickly," I can start to see why the cast time on Dark Deal could be causing you problems.
leepalmer95 wrote: »Yeah seems super important. Or is that people just can't handle the game being even very minuscule harder. You really won't notice the difference, you spam dark deal for stamina. If you need a heal you'd block cast vigor and ask the healer. Why would anyone drop their 70% dmg reduction block for a 8800 tooltip heal? In pve where your getting 4k-5k vigor ticks and 4-5k surge ticks.
leepalmer95 wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »leepalmer95 wrote: »Then you have people like @starkerealm who starts out ok but then quickly turn to responses like 'you don't know about pve'.
It took me two days to lower my standards to the point where I started to suspect you don't understand PvE. If that's your definition of "quickly," I can start to see why the cast time on Dark Deal could be causing you problems.
I see still no proper explanation still? . Just small insults now?
starkerealm wrote: »leepalmer95 wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »leepalmer95 wrote: »Then you have people like @starkerealm who starts out ok but then quickly turn to responses like 'you don't know about pve'.
It took me two days to lower my standards to the point where I started to suspect you don't understand PvE. If that's your definition of "quickly," I can start to see why the cast time on Dark Deal could be causing you problems.
I see still no proper explanation still? . Just small insults now?
No, I gave you an explanation. If it went over your head, I'm not sure I can simplify it any further.
Hand_Bacon wrote: »leepalmer95 wrote: »Yeah seems super important. Or is that people just can't handle the game being even very minuscule harder. You really won't notice the difference, you spam dark deal for stamina. If you need a heal you'd block cast vigor and ask the healer. Why would anyone drop their 70% dmg reduction block for a 8800 tooltip heal? In pve where your getting 4k-5k vigor ticks and 4-5k surge ticks.
So as a sorc tank I have to lose block to use Dark Deal. So you want me to have a snare on top of losing block? I use Dark Deal to get back stamina and as a heal, since I'm vulnerable during that time it makes sense. But you want me to use Dark Deal for Stamina and then use slightly less than half of that gained stamina to block cast a stamina based heal? I'll net about 3000 stamina, use a considerable portion of my magicka all while being vulnerable without block and then snared? If I have to break free or any number of other actions which demand my stamina greater than usual and I have to recoup some, I have to dark deal (max 4 times before mana gone) and then if my crit surge is up...well that's too bad I guess, I temporarily lose that other heal you say I have.
Its a balance and I think its fine at the moment. I'm sure there are others who have learned to deal with stam sorcs in pvp. I know I have more than my fair share of deaths. I've never used the quip git gud, but maybe...
leepalmer95 wrote: »Yes i know you need stamina, but the point he made was how important dark deal was for a click heal when it wasn't
And yes any 'end game' tank uses vigor. It's not a question it's a must the same as them using warhorn.
Why would you waste magicka on dragon blood when you get stamina back via igneous? Yes all TANKS will use vigor for a self heal if they want a self heal. Yes crit surge heals a lot especially in pve, it's on any crit and with skill's hurricane/ dots/ heavy attacks or even taunting the boss it procs a lot..
Try reading before you develop into a sarcastic post, it's not as effective if the first point you made was because you failed to read.
leepalmer95 wrote: »lol fml the 1k is such a difference. Not it isn't. We both know you'd still cast it so why lie?
Now your just being fussy. The fact is it will hardly effect you at all. You won't even notice the difference and as a tank you should never get yourself that low to the point where that 1k makes a difference.
The truth is my balance request for a skill for pvp won't effect you much in pve at all.
But because it's a request for pvp you feel the need to to keep pushing about the pve because 'all pvp'ers do is moan and get pve nerfed'.
Now it's very obvious it won't effect pve anything noticeable anyway. So if your done nitpicking can the discussion get back on track to what it was intended for? The skill's strength in pvp, if you have nothing to add to the pvp discussion move on.
1k has to have some worth if you feel it is so important to remove.
Considering the whole point in Min/Maxing is to well. max, this idea is counter productive.
Also considering that prior changes to abilities have not been confined to PVP, your request would impact more then pvp.
Those who use the ability are impacted, and it is very short sighted to dismiss everyone who doesn't PVP to just accept your proposal.
The reason people are against the idea is because we do not like it.
It does not need to cost more, risk to use, be interruptible, or any of that.
Personally i would prefer to have the cast time removed and the numbers restored is increased.
Why? Because more is better, i like buffs and i like my build as is.
leepalmer95 wrote: »That change would make it better for pvp and change 100% nothing in pve. Yet you said no for what reason? Because it'll make pvp better?
leepalmer95 wrote: »
What exactly are you planning to do with boss agro when casting dark deal? Out pace the boss? Run around so your dd lose dmg because the boss moves out of ground aoe's? If the boss is ranged a cast snare won't change anything. If it's not then be a bit smart about using it, it's main use is stamina sustain.
leepalmer95 wrote: »
Why would you need to block cast a vigor for a sudden heal if you've already took the chance of dropping the 70% dmg reduction of block to get a dark deal heal.
leepalmer95 wrote: »If your hit hard by someone and are low on hp why would you drop block? Why not just block cast a heal and use dark deal for sustain when you have chances? When the boss is pushed into phases, when it's only doing basic attacks and you hot's or healer will outheal it's damage easy.
Your also gonna get templar shards or repentance as well.in case you use more stamina than your used too, call out for them.
Did you read quoted message?leepalmer95 wrote: »lol fml the 1k is such a difference. Not it isn't. We both know you'd still cast it so why lie?
Now your just being fussy. The fact is it will hardly effect you at all. You won't even notice the difference and as a tank you should never get yourself that low to the point where that 1k makes a difference.
The truth is my balance request for a skill for pvp won't effect you much in pve at all.
But because it's a request for pvp you feel the need to to keep pushing about the pve because 'all pvp'ers do is moan and get pve nerfed'.
Now it's very obvious it won't effect pve anything noticeable anyway. So if your done nitpicking can the discussion get back on track to what it was intended for? The skill's strength in pvp, if you have nothing to add to the pvp discussion move on.
1k has to have some worth if you feel it is so important to remove.
Considering the whole point in Min/Maxing is to well. max, this idea is counter productive.
Also considering that prior changes to abilities have not been confined to PVP, your request would impact more then pvp.
Those who use the ability are impacted, and it is very short sighted to dismiss everyone who doesn't PVP to just accept your proposal.
The reason people are against the idea is because we do not like it.
It does not need to cost more, risk to use, be interruptible, or any of that.
Personally i would prefer to have the cast time removed and the numbers restored is increased.
Why? Because more is better, i like buffs and i like my build as is.
You do realise that the lead game designer said that this skill is all about risk/reward right? I know that u want i win buttons but thats not how balance works.
leepalmer95 wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »leepalmer95 wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »leepalmer95 wrote: »Then you have people like @starkerealm who starts out ok but then quickly turn to responses like 'you don't know about pve'.
It took me two days to lower my standards to the point where I started to suspect you don't understand PvE. If that's your definition of "quickly," I can start to see why the cast time on Dark Deal could be causing you problems.
I see still no proper explanation still? . Just small insults now?
No, I gave you an explanation. If it went over your head, I'm not sure I can simplify it any further.
Your explanation was dark deal is needed as a 1 click (1s delay) heal. Come one we both know that just isn't true. What about your response to the other changes?
Giles.floydub17_ESO wrote: »So sDK have a way to sustain itself with igneous shield. It also provides minor shield and major mending.
NB can use siphoning attacks. sTemp have repentance. So jeah, let's just scr*w sSorc. Remove dark deal, self sustain should be forbidden for that class.
You forgot the huge heal and restored stats the DK gets when dropping an ult.
What is wrong with you? It is 2016 almost 2017 and the update is 2.6. For 200 ultimate you restore 35% from your resources. The heal is reduced by battle spirit. So you receive 18% from your max health.
Giles.floydub17_ESO wrote: »Giles.floydub17_ESO wrote: »So sDK have a way to sustain itself with igneous shield. It also provides minor shield and major mending.
NB can use siphoning attacks. sTemp have repentance. So jeah, let's just scr*w sSorc. Remove dark deal, self sustain should be forbidden for that class.
You forgot the huge heal and restored stats the DK gets when dropping an ult.
What is wrong with you? It is 2016 almost 2017 and the update is 2.6. For 200 ultimate you restore 35% from your resources. The heal is reduced by battle spirit. So you receive 18% from your max health.
It's 70%
Might want to dbl check that. Thx.
What you mean like the ability to spam an instant cast, block castable shield and get what 4 or 5% if your max stam back bidding time time till you have enough Ultimate saved up to top yourself off.
Or
You know get extra magic and stamina back on every attack with a chance to earn even more. Or a magic, stam, and health back.
Or
The ability to repent any corpse even pets proc chance resource generator and NPCs for a massive AOE heal and stamina return.
You mean like those, with the OP nerf all of those bring back something we didn't like back than and begged you change. We were wrong please help us
DK has scales talons etc that help holding their ground
Band Camp statements: To state "But this one time I saw X doing X... so that justifies X" Refers to the Band camp statement.
Coined by Maxwell
My god, if you cant stand the fire get out if the kitchen.
You started this, now you want them to close the thread. Why?
Because people are not agreeing with you.
The thread hasnt been derailed, or flamed, its not a duplicate(technically it is because you started one 2 wks ago but thatd be a necro since it died after people didnt give you the responses you wanted).
It has been a valid discussion, just not with the aggreement you sought. So you want it closed?
Please dont do that mods. This is like a train wreck, we just cant look away.
I am fairly certain the devs have learned to immediately and unequivocally disregard any changes @leepalmer95 requests by this point.
I suggest starting under a new forum name. But you can tell a tiger by its stripes, and it wouldnt be long before you show your true colors.
Your ignorant, arrogant colors.
sneakymitchell wrote: »Compare to a Stam DK and stam sorc. DKs need all the magicka for thier buffs some of them are just weak and stam sorc rarely needs magicka for buffs.
Giles.floydub17_ESO wrote: »Giles.floydub17_ESO wrote: »So sDK have a way to sustain itself with igneous shield. It also provides minor shield and major mending.
NB can use siphoning attacks. sTemp have repentance. So jeah, let's just scr*w sSorc. Remove dark deal, self sustain should be forbidden for that class.
You forgot the huge heal and restored stats the DK gets when dropping an ult.
What is wrong with you? It is 2016 almost 2017 and the update is 2.6. For 200 ultimate you restore 35% from your resources. The heal is reduced by battle spirit. So you receive 18% from your max health.
It's 70%
Might want to dbl check that. Thx.
No, Battle Roar does not restore 70% of your resources.
starkerealm wrote: »So, Lee, what you're saying is, you have no idea how to tank as a Sorc.
I have been wondering the same exact thing...leepalmer95 wrote: »What is wrong with some people in this thread.
leepalmer95 wrote: »i'm sure you elite end game tanks can handle everything just fine. You'll adapt it's not hard to do as a tank. Heavy attack more, run more cost reduction etc... you'll learn, nothing much would actualyl change despite the whole end of the world reaction the pve hero's are doing.
I have been wondering the same exact thing...leepalmer95 wrote: »What is wrong with some people in this thread.
Everyone acting like all stam sorc tanks will die with this change. Your all acting like pve tanking is actually hard. It's really not.leepalmer95 wrote: »i'm sure you elite end game tanks can handle everything just fine. You'll adapt it's not hard to do as a tank. Heavy attack more, run more cost reduction etc... you'll learn, nothing much would actualyl change despite the whole end of the world reaction the pve hero's are doing.
When did you become the one to choose how the rest should play and get to determine what is important for everyone?
The reality is your one voice, one of which i refuse to let speak for me.
leepalmer95 wrote: »I refuse to let people like you even have opinions in threads i make. Since you said you hate pvp and you'll refuse any suggestion even if it doesn't effect pve if it betters pvp. That right there made you irrelevant to the thread. That made your posts and opinions just invalid overall.
leepalmer95 wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »So, Lee, what you're saying is, you have no idea how to tank as a Sorc.
No i'm saying it no where near as hard as your making it out to be. I'm saying pve tanking isn't difficult unless vet maw.
leepalmer95 wrote: »I'm now also saying i literally don't care about a pve sorc tank anymore either.
leepalmer95 wrote: »But hey your the 'expert' on pve stam sorc tanking i guess.