Does anyone know if Kari's Hitlist still gives thieves guild rep? As I recall getting all the achievements got you up to rank 4. Need to know if I should blitz it out on all my live characters before it's gone. I would imagine not, if so we could use a thieves guild rep buff alongside Undaunted.
Does anyone know if Kari's Hitlist still gives thieves guild rep? As I recall getting all the achievements got you up to rank 4. Need to know if I should blitz it out on all my live characters before it's gone. I would imagine not, if so we could use a thieves guild rep buff alongside Undaunted.
If memory serves, some people tried it last week and weren't able to do Kari's hit list on alts.
etchedpixels wrote: »Associate Zanon has a conversation with that Nord tinkering with his factotum outside the gates to the dangerous part of the Brass Fortress on a fresh alt. To my knowledge this conversation should only occur after completion of the precursor maker questline, which I had the achievement for on another character.
I was hitting this all over the place in the older PTS - being thanked for saving people I hadn't and freeing places I'd never been. Seems all the background NPC comments are tied to achivements that are now shared not to completions. Was very glaring and I only played fairly briefly on my alt account.
Elvenheart wrote: »
Precursor is finished as soon as you get the quest for it (notice, there is a pre-quest you have to do to get the real one)
edit:
We missed a huge chance here to make "Elderic memories" accountwide (not mage guild books, just the notes and memories!), which would fix 90% of the bugged books in the game ("You missed to read that book at a specific quest-step? Just read it with another char") for the past, the present and all the future.
The last patches didnt made any bugfixes for the books, but each story dlc implements new bugged books. Each single one.
I believe not one single player would dislike accountwide memories and notes and people are asking for it for the same long time as for achievments.
Yet you leave the books alone and implement only achievments in such a bad way, that even most of the people who likes it, have complaints/concerns.
Please rethink about it a bit more before you implement them like on pts shown right now. I'm afraid it will open pandoras box, and there is not Dr. Who inside this time, but many bugs we dont think of right now and it will hunt us a long time, if not forever (see bugged memories).
Does this mean every one of our characters can get a Precursor furnishing or that we can only get it once? I’d be perfectly fine finding all the parts just one time, and then from then on every time one of my alts gets that quest they automatically finish it and get the reward. Same for that music box quest. And I agree with the part about the other books, not the mage ones, being accountwide, that’s a great idea.
You can't get more than one music box on the PTS right now. So if you want multiple music boxes, you have to start hunting for them now before the update drops. Otherwise, your alts will be locked out of the quest once the game detects you have finished the quest once before on another character.
silvereyes wrote: »Elvenheart wrote: »
Precursor is finished as soon as you get the quest for it (notice, there is a pre-quest you have to do to get the real one)
edit:
We missed a huge chance here to make "Elderic memories" accountwide (not mage guild books, just the notes and memories!), which would fix 90% of the bugged books in the game ("You missed to read that book at a specific quest-step? Just read it with another char") for the past, the present and all the future.
The last patches didnt made any bugfixes for the books, but each story dlc implements new bugged books. Each single one.
I believe not one single player would dislike accountwide memories and notes and people are asking for it for the same long time as for achievments.
Yet you leave the books alone and implement only achievments in such a bad way, that even most of the people who likes it, have complaints/concerns.
Please rethink about it a bit more before you implement them like on pts shown right now. I'm afraid it will open pandoras box, and there is not Dr. Who inside this time, but many bugs we dont think of right now and it will hunt us a long time, if not forever (see bugged memories).
Does this mean every one of our characters can get a Precursor furnishing or that we can only get it once? I’d be perfectly fine finding all the parts just one time, and then from then on every time one of my alts gets that quest they automatically finish it and get the reward. Same for that music box quest. And I agree with the part about the other books, not the mage ones, being accountwide, that’s a great idea.
You can't get more than one music box on the PTS right now. So if you want multiple music boxes, you have to start hunting for them now before the update drops. Otherwise, your alts will be locked out of the quest once the game detects you have finished the quest once before on another character.
I just tested this, and there is a way to get multiple music boxes, but only if you have already started the quest on multiple characters before turning it in for the reward.
Test conditions:
1. 1 character did the opening quest to get the lute, and turned in all but one of the other instruments.
2. 1 character did the opening quest to get the lute, and turned in the one remaining instrument.
3. 1 character only did the opening quest to get the lute.
4. 1 character collected none and did not start the quest.
Results:
- Characters 1, 2, and 3 were all able to do the final quest to place handbills and then receive music boxes
- Character 4 was not able to start the quest or get any music box.
I did not test that, unfortunately. I'd only thought of that test case after already completing the achievement, so I can't test it any longer.What about a character who started but did not complete the quest to turn in the lute?
I disagree. This is totally a bug in my opinion. Boss respawn timers should only be reset when a boss is actually killed. They shouldn't be reset by discovering the delve or entering the delve on any character.HumbleThaumaturge wrote: »As I said in other post: This is probably not a “bug.” I probably just don’t understand the mechanics. Hope I come to a correct understanding of the mechanics after this goes "live." These tests were with my EU characters. If there is a chance to test update again with my North American characters before update goes "live," I'll do some more testing.
On the PTS, I have gone through the entirety of the Dark Heart of Skyrim yearlong chapter on a newly created alt.
Western Skyrim, Markarth, end Epilogue quests.
To clarify, I already had the global achievements unlocked because I had previously done this on my main.
Here is a non-spoilery breakdown of the results:
1. The Bard Quest Giver does indeed show up to the Western Skyrim afterparty, even though I could not do his quest on the alt. This suggests that the game considers the quest “permanently complete”. Even on a brand new character.
2. . ….No. The character at the end of the story epilogue does NOT show up in Arkthzand Cavern if you already have the achievement “Taking up the Mantle”. You can never see this ending part of the story ever again if you completed it once.
Here is the spoilery info:Verandis is supposed to appear one last time to give the final epilogue in Arkthzand Cavern after the quest “Second Chances”: If you already completed this achievement ("Taking Up the Mantle" Achievement), he does not appear. So you don’t get his final thoughts and conversation ever again. I absolutely loved this conversation; it was short, it was sweet, and it added reflection and thought to the whole story that you had just gone through. It was distressing to not see him show up at all at the balcony.
I have also included below why I think this is happening and a possible fix/solution:For the NPC who appears for that last dialogue at the end of the storyline: this suggests to me that this “ending dialogue” is directly tied to the achievement itself, much like Melina Cassel’s dialogue was directly attached to the achievement itself.
The game is using these achievements to determine whether or not a particular character has “met” you before. For “wandering NPCs”, such as Melina Cassel and the Adoring Fan, the game checks the achievement. If you have 1/5 on the achievement, for example, the game determines that you have met them before and progresses immediately to their second set of dialogue. The game makes no distinction whether the character you were currently using is the same one as before, so the result is that you can progress the conversation without the NPC distinguishing between different player characters.
In this particular case that I tested (with the yearlong Skyrim/Markarth chapter), the game is using the achievement to determine whether this character has given your particular toon his final goodbyes. And the game makes no distinction that your alt is a completely different person from the toon you used to get the achievement. Even if you went through the entire storyline a second time, you will never again get this complete ending epilogue for the yearlong chapter.
Considering that questline dialogue seems to be intact (as far as I can tell), I would guess that dialogue for quests are tied directly to the quest system and not the achievement system. So a very easy way to fix these story problems would be to simply detach these dialogues from achievements and attach them to the quest system in some manner. We’ve had quests that literally only involved running around and talking to people before, so it is not so unusual (the quest “Second Chances” itself is literally just running around talking to people).
silvereyes wrote: »Elvenheart wrote: »
Precursor is finished as soon as you get the quest for it (notice, there is a pre-quest you have to do to get the real one)
edit:
We missed a huge chance here to make "Elderic memories" accountwide (not mage guild books, just the notes and memories!), which would fix 90% of the bugged books in the game ("You missed to read that book at a specific quest-step? Just read it with another char") for the past, the present and all the future.
The last patches didnt made any bugfixes for the books, but each story dlc implements new bugged books. Each single one.
I believe not one single player would dislike accountwide memories and notes and people are asking for it for the same long time as for achievments.
Yet you leave the books alone and implement only achievments in such a bad way, that even most of the people who likes it, have complaints/concerns.
Please rethink about it a bit more before you implement them like on pts shown right now. I'm afraid it will open pandoras box, and there is not Dr. Who inside this time, but many bugs we dont think of right now and it will hunt us a long time, if not forever (see bugged memories).
Does this mean every one of our characters can get a Precursor furnishing or that we can only get it once? I’d be perfectly fine finding all the parts just one time, and then from then on every time one of my alts gets that quest they automatically finish it and get the reward. Same for that music box quest. And I agree with the part about the other books, not the mage ones, being accountwide, that’s a great idea.
You can't get more than one music box on the PTS right now. So if you want multiple music boxes, you have to start hunting for them now before the update drops. Otherwise, your alts will be locked out of the quest once the game detects you have finished the quest once before on another character.
I just tested this, and there is a way to get multiple music boxes, but only if you have already started the quest on multiple characters before turning it in for the reward.
Test conditions:
1. 1 character did the opening quest to get the lute, and turned in all but one of the other instruments.
2. 1 character did the opening quest to get the lute, and turned in the one remaining instrument.
3. 1 character only did the opening quest to get the lute.
4. 1 character collected none and did not start the quest.
Results:
- Characters 1, 2, and 3 were all able to do the final quest to place handbills and then receive music boxes
- Character 4 was not able to start the quest or get any music box.
The thieves guild 'museum' no longer gives reputation for completing the respective achievements after you made them character specific. This makes levelling that skill line significantly slower and more painful for alts.
tomofhyrule wrote: »The thieves guild 'museum' no longer gives reputation for completing the respective achievements after you made them character specific. This makes levelling that skill line significantly slower and more painful for alts.
Good point. I'd been thinking about Antiquities having the same issue, but I didn't think to look at the TG line. I guess that means the DB line has the same issue? Or did the Litany not affect the skill XP in the first place?
I think Psijic is solely based on the quests so they should be divorced from the achievements, but I do know each Psijic quest gives an achievement. Can someone on PTS check that it levels properly with the quest and not with the achieve?
Also if someone's on PTS, is Undaunted skilling up as intended yet? I know that was bugged as well.
Finally for ZOS, we did get a nice boost to general XP from getting an achievement, so with AwA, it'll also remove a source of character levelling XP. Is there going to be a mitigating factor here? Do account-wide achieves still reward XP? And if so, presumably is it only for the character who pops it (levelling a baby toon instead of earning account CP)?
SirBedevere wrote: »I wanted to test the Alliance story quests, so I started on Stros M'kai. However, I'm already experiencing a bug that locks one of my characters out of a quest.
tomofhyrule wrote: »Ok, so I just went through every achievement in game.
The major bugs/issues with the current Account-wide achievement system are the following:
- Delve/WB/etc. map markers are showing as complete for characters who have never been to a zone.
- Some quests (like the previously-reported Elsweyr queens and Stros M'kai pirates) check achievement states instead of quest states.
- Non-museum achievement-linked events are not triggering because the achievements are shown as complete.
It would be best to delay AwA to address these issues. If AwA must come out this patch, then the achievements which may affect these states (most exploration and quest achievements) should be set to character specific similarly to how the issue with the Museum quests was fixed.
This is a massive list of achievements which could potentially be problematic, but if the patch drops with them set as character-specific and they are later found to be safe, then they could be made account-wide in a later patch. This would also give time for alternate solutions to be found, e.g. if there are events linked to achievements, they could be linked instead to the character's quest journal so the achievement links can be severed and the achievement then made account-wide. If they are released account-wide and they are bugged, however, it would be very difficult to manually fix it for all 20 million players.
What follows is the list of all achievements that may cause problems.
These should all be made Character-specific until testing proves that the achievement state will not affect replayability.ExplorationQuests
- Aldmeri Dominion
- Anarume Bounty Hunter
- Bandit Lord Bounty Hunter
- Barrow Trench Explorer
- Bewan Explorer
- Big Ozur’s Bane
- Black Vine Ruins Explorer
- Bone Grappler’s Bane
- Burroot Kwama Mine Explorer
- Carac Dena Explorer
- Claw’s Strike Explorer
- Dead Man’s Drop Explorer
- Deathsong Deforester
- Del’s Claim Devastator
- Drowned Horde Decimator
- Dugan’s Demolisher
- Entila’s Folly Explorer
- Fardir’s Folly Explorer
- Gathongor Hunter
- Ghost Captain Crusher
- Gravecaller’s Doom
- Green Vanquisher
- Gurzag’s Mine Explorer
- Harridan’s Lair Explorer
- Hoarvor Pit Explorer
- Jode’s Light Explorer
- King of the Hill
- Kuna’s Delve Explorer
- Marines Avenger
- Mehrunes’ Spite Explorer
- Mercy Killer
- Mobar Mine Explorer
- Monsoon Marauder
- Naril Nagaia Explorer
- Ne Salas Explorer
- Nestmother Eradicator
- Nur-dro’s Downfall
- Ondil Explorer
- Peacemaker
- Poacher Pounder
- Roots of Silvenar Explorer
- Rootwater’s Demise
- Scuttle Pit Explorer
- Sea Elf’s Woe
- Shael Ruins Explorer
- Shagura’s Doom
- Skooma Watch
- Skullbreaker
- Snapjaw’s Bane
- Spy Smasher
- Tallatta’s Annihilator
- Thibaut’s Cave Explorer
- Thugrub Dissector
- Tomb of the Apostates Explorer
- Underroot Explorer
- Valanir’s Bane
- Vinedeath Cave Explorer
- Wansalen Explorer
- Water Walloper
- Weeping Wind Cave Explorer
- Wormroot Depths Explorer
- Ysolmarr’s Ruin
- Zymel Chaser
- Daggerfall Covenant
- Aldunz Ruins Explorer
- Asard’s Assassin
- Bearclaw Mine Explorer
- Bloodcaller’s Ruin
- Brood Queen Destroyer
- Coldrock Diggings Explorer
- Cousin Scrag’s Demolisher
- Crestshade Mine Explorer
- Crypt of the Exiles Explorer
- Cryptwatch Fort Explorer
- Darkblood Hunter
- Dayarrus’ Deathbringer
- Divad’s Chagrin Mine Explorer
- Duneripper’s Downfall
- Ebon Crypt Explorer
- Enduum Explorer
- Erokii Ruins Explorer
- Farangel’s Delve Explorer
- Flyleaf Catacombs Explorer
- Gar Xuu Gar’s Bane
- Graufang Hunter
- Hag Hunter
- Hag Upheaval
- Hatespinner Hunter
- Hildune’s Secret Refuge Explorer
- Ilessan Tower Explorer
- Klathzgar Explorer
- Koeglin Mine Explorer
- Korignah’s Bane
- Kruz Control
- Lich Buster
- Limbscather Slayer
- Lonely Papa’s Doom
- Menhir Hunter
- Mines of Khuras Explorer
- Mummy King Murderer
- Nomeg Hyril’s Executioner
- Norvulk Ruins Explorer
- Orc’s Finger Ruins Explorer
- Pariah Catacombs Explorer
- Potrdun Watch Explorer
- Rubble Butte Explorer
- Saint Slayer
- Sandblown Mine Explorer
- Santaki Ruins Explorer
- Silumm Explorer
- Siren Hunter
- Spider Slayer
- Stroda’s Assassin
- Summoner Slayer
- Titanclaw Cracker
- Torog’s Spite Explorer
- Trapjaw Stalker
- Tribulation Crypt Explorer
- Troll’s Toothpick Explorer
- Viridian Watch Explorer
- Werewolf’s Bane
- Wolf-Father Exorcist
- Woodblight Killer
- Yldzuun Ruins Explorer
- Ebonheart Pact
- Abomination Slayer
- Ammabani Ambusher
- Armene’s Bane
- Atanaz Ruins Explorer
- Avanchnzel Explorer
- ***’s Tomb Explorer
- Beralagr Hunter
- Bittergreen Obliterator
- Black Maw Shrine Explorer
- Broken Helm Hollow Explorer
- Broken Tusk Explorer
- Captain Bones Destroyer
- Chid-Moska Ruins Explorer
- Chill Hollow Explorer
- Corpse Garden Explorer
- Dreugh Destroyer
- Druitularg’s Bane
- Emberflint Mine Explorer
- Faldar’s Tooth Explorer
- Fort Greenwall Explorer
- Frigid Grotto Explorer
- Frost Atronach Destroyer
- Gandranen Explorer
- Ghost Banisher
- Giant Slayer
- Haynekhtnamet Hunter
- Hightide Hollow Explorer
- Icehammer’s Vault Explorer
- Inner Sea Armature Explorer
- Khajiiti Hunters’ Bane
- Knife Ear Grotto Explorer
- Lady Llarel’s Shelter Explorer
- Lower Bthanual Explorer
- Mabrigash Shade Destroyer
- Mannskadi’s Mauler
- Memory Masher
- Mephala’s Nest Explorer
- Mummy Lord Murderer
- Netch Wrangler
- Ogre Twin Tormerntor
- Old Sord’s Cave Explorer
- Onkobra Kwama Mine Explorer
- Rageclaw Hunter
- Ratmaster Crusher
- Saintly Slaughter
- Sharpfang Killer
- Shellcracker
- Sheogorath’s Tongue Explorer
- Short-Tusk Hunter
- Shroud Heather Barrow Explorer
- Slave Lord’s Ruination
- Snapleg Cave Explorer
- Softloam Cavern Explorer
- Stormcrag Crypt Explorer
- Strifeswarm Eradicator
- Taleon’s Crag Explorer
- Triple Circle Mine Explorer
- Troll Killer
- Urrai’s Bane
- Wispmother Vanquisher
- Coldharbour
- Aba-Loria Explorer
- Brolsgerbwd’s Bane
- Cave of Trophies Explorer
- Centurion’s Ruin
- Cynhamoth’s End
- Daedroth Trio Hunter
- Forgefire Vault Explorer
- Grotto of Depravity Explorer
- Ice Wraith Hunter
- Mal Sorra’s Tomb Explorer
- Stortha’s Doom
- Wailing Maw Explorer
- Craglorn
- Anka-Ra Consecrationalist
- Anomalous Scholar
- Nirncrux Inspector
- Balamath Explorer
- Buried Sands Explorer
- Chiselshriek Mine Explorer
- Exarch’s Stronghold Explorer
- Fearfangs Cavern Explorer
- Haddock’s Market Explorer
- Hircine’s Haunt Explorer
- Ilthag’s Undertower Explorer
- Loth’Na Caverns Explorer
- Molavar Explorer
- Mtharnaz Explorer
- Rkhardahrk Explorer
- Rkundzelft Explorer
- Ruins of Kardala Explorer
- Serpent’s Nest Explorer
- The Howling Sepulchers Explorer
- Tombs of the Na-Totambu Explorer
- Zalgaz’s Den Explorer
- Earthly Possessions
- Cyrodiil
- Bloodmayne Cave Explorer
- Breakneck Cave Explorer
- Capstone Cave Explorer
- Cracked Wood Cave Explorer
- Echo Cave Explorer
- Haynote Cave Explorer
- Kingscrest Cavern Explorer
- Lipsand Tarn Explorer
- Muck Valley Cavern Explorer
- Newt Cave Explorer
- Nisin Cave Explorer
- Pothole Caverns Explorer
- Quickwater Cave Explorer
- Red Ruby Cave Explorer
- Serpent Hollow Explorer
- Toadstool Hollow Explorer
- Underpall Cave Explorer
- Vahtacen Explorer
- Dark Anchors
- Covenant Anchor Shatterer
- Dominion Anchor Shatterer
- Pact Anchor Shatterer
- Imperial Anchor Shatterer
Blackwood
- Main Quest
- The Harborage
- Daughter of Giants
- Chasing Shadows
- Castle of the Worm
- The Tharn Speaks
- The Halls of Torment
- The Valley of Blades
- The Shadow of Sancre Tor
- Council of the Five Companions
- The God of Schemes
- Aldmeri Dominion
- Maormer’s Bane
- Sunder the First Veil
- Sunder the Second Veil
- Sunder the Third Veil
- Hero of Falinesti
- Reliquary Retriever
- Southpoint Savior
- Court Ranger
- Valenwood Protector
- Veil Lifter
- Hero of Frond and Leaf
- Hound Hinderer
- Silvenar’s Friend
- Clan Mother Inaugurator
- Dark Mane Incarcerator
- Two Moons Pathwalker
- Daggerfall Covenant
- Famed Recruiter
- Faolchu’s Bane
- Savior of Glenumbra
- Wyrd Friend
- Azura’s Ally
- Dreamslayer
- Spirit Warden Champion
- Hero of House Dorell
- Hero of House Tamrith
- Sword of Ravenwatch
- Alasan’s Devastation
- Ash’abah Hero
- Uwafa’s Ruination
- Bangkorai Garrison Liberator
- Evermore Defender
- High King Emeric’s Savior
- Ebonheart Pact
- Hero of Bleakrock
- Balreth’s Bane
- General Serien’s Demise
- Sadal’s Overthrower
- Plague Ender
- Temple Knight
- Vox Slayer
- Egg Protector
- Mnemic Egg Guardian
- Skin-Stealer Destroyer
- Giant-Friend
- Skald-King’s Arrow
- Skald-King’s Salvation
- Reach Crusher
- Wormsquasher
- Ysgramor’s Prodigy
- Coldharbour
- Guardian of the Great Mage
- Light of the Ayleid Kind
- Planemeld Sunderer
Greymoor
- Exploration
- Undertow Cavern Explorer
- Bull-Fighter
- Xi-Tsei Explorer
- Doomvault Porcixid Explorer
- Arpenia Explorer
- Bloodrun Cave Explorer
- Vunalk Explorer
- Tongue Taker
- Sul-Xan Sacker
- Wart-Wacker
- Ruinach Ravager
- Trophy-Taker’s Taker
- Most Admired
- Enticed by Magic
- Quests
- Leyawiin Mercenary
- Blackwood Investigator
- Ambition Acquirer
- Party Crasher
- Ambition’s Advocate
- Disaster Averter
- Daedric Dispeller
Elsweyr
- Exploration
- Beach Battler
- Blackreach Breacher
- Champion’s Champion
- Chillwind Depths Explorer
- Dragonhome Explorer
- Dwarven Disassembler
- Frozen Coast Explorer
- Giant Cheese Conoisseur
- Hunting the Hunters
- Midnight Barrow Explorer
- No Food For You
- Shades of Gray
- Shadowgreen Explorer
- The Scraps Explorer
- Quests
- Friend to Fennorian
- Resolute Reconnoiter
- Threat Ender
- Skyrim Diplomat
- Mining Sample Collector
- Shieldthane of Morthal
- Swordthane of Karthwatch
- Titanborn’s Partner
- Assassin Assassinator
- Hero of the Holds
- Harrowstorms
- Harrowstorm Chaser
Summerset
- Exploration
- Abode of Ignominy Explorer
- Predator Mesa Explorer
- Desert Wind Caverns Explorer
- Tomb of the Serpents Explorer
- Darkpool Mine Explorer
- The Tangle Explorer
- Skullcracker
- Flattened the Nightmare Plateau
- Terror Bird Terminator
- Grave Guardian
- Sword Sunderer
- Red-Handed Vigilante
- Quests
- Tharn’s Aide-de-Camp
- Precarious Parley
- Riverhold Defender
- Rimmen Revolution
- Assassination Cessation
- Betrayer Breaker
- Moonwalker
- Queenmaker
Morrowind
- Exploration
- King’s Haven Pass Explorer
- Eton Nir Grotto Explorer
- Archon’s Grove Explorer
- Tor-Hame-Khard Explorer
- Wasten Coraldale Explorer
- Traitor’s Vault Explorer
- Reef Raider
- Bucking the Matriarchy
- Sea Sload Slugger
- Talon Taker
- Amphibian Agitator
- Keel Hauler
- A Book and its Cover
- Quests
- For the Queen
- Precious Pearl
- Mind Games
- Resolute Guardian
- Sweet Dreams
- Unreliable Narrator
- Enemy of my Enemy
- What Must Be Done
- Abyssal Geysers
- Put a Cork In It
Deadlands
- Exploration
- Ashalmawia Explorer
- Breaker of the Unbroken
- Cheater Defeater
- Consort Killer
- Khartag Point Explorer
- Matus-Akin Egg Mine Explorer
- Nchuleft Explorer
- Pulk Explorer
- Salothan’s Cursebreaker
- Songbird Silencer
- Wuyuvus Slayer
- Zainsipilu Explorer
- Quests
- Ald’ruhn Annalist
- Bearer of the Blessed Staff
- Ebony Enforcer
- Hand of a Living God
- Hand of the Mistress
- Kwama Miner
- Narsis’s Apprentice
- Naryu’s Confidant
- Pilgrim Protector
- Rising Sun
- Scarlet Judge
- Voice of the Failed Incarnates
Markarth
- Exploration
- Brandfire Reformatory Explorer
- False Martyrs’ Folly Explorer
- Unmaker Unmaker
- Scorpion Stomper
- Quests
- Stranger in Town
- Rat Catcher
- Deadlands Jailbreaker
- Deadlands Mountaineer
- Unmasker
- Hopeful Rescuer
- Ambition Collector
- Dagon Defier
- Eternal Optimist
- Friend to the Kalmur
- Spire Sleuth
Dragonhold
- Exploration
- A Friend In Deed
- Briar Rock Ruins Explorer
- Gloomreach Explorer
- Master of Storms
- Offerings to the Old Spirits
- Weaned from Darkness
- Dynastor Deposed
- Quests
- Crow-Eye Savior
- Lothid Clan Liberator
- Nowhere Beyond Your Reach
- Peered into the Abyss
- A Bridge Between Kingdoms
- Ravenwatch Ambassador
- Reach Ritualist
- Subterranean Scholar
- Taking up the Mantle
- Witness to Prophecy
- Nighthollow Explorer
- Protector of Markarth
Murkmire
- Exploration
- Forsaken Citadel Explorer
- Moonlit Cove Explorer
- End of the Exile
- Temple Guardian Terror
- A Hero’s Song
- Quests
- A New Beginning
- Leaves on the Wind
- Lair Locator
- Khenarthi’s Guidance
- Infiltrating the New Moon
- Halls of the Highmane
- Return of the Dragonguard
- The Dragon’s Wrath
- Fall of the Dark Aeon
- Bright Moons over Elsweyr
Clockwork City
- Exploration
- Tsofeer Cavern Explorer
- Teeth of Sithis Explorer
- Fiend of the Fens
- Feller of Thunder
- Swamp Rescuer
- Surreptitiously Shadowed
- Quests
- Cold Blood, Warm Heart
- The Progeny
- Traps and Treasures
- Seeker of the Lost
- Mysteries of the Remnant
- Sap-Sleeper
- Shadows of the Past
- To Chase a Dream
- The River of Rebirth
Dark Brotherhood
- Exploration
- Halls of Regulation Explorer
- Shadow Cleft Explorer
- Imperfection
- Murderer of Crows
- Quests
- Land of Gears and Cogs
- Clockwork Citizen
- Smoke and Mirrors
- Middle-Man
- Birds of a Feather
- Shadow Boxing
- The Real Sotha Sil
- The Burden of Knowledge
- Fortune and Fate
Thieves Guild
- Exploration
- Hrota Cave Explorer
- Garlas Agea Explorer
- Defeat Limenaruus
- Conquer the Kvatch Arena
- Lonely Sentinel
- Quests
- First Blood
- Dark Initiate
- New-Blade
- Sermonizer Subduer
- Brethren Benefactor
- Assassin
- Dark Discovery
- Dark Investigator
- Wrath of Sithis
- Silencer
Orsinium
- Exploration
- Bahraha’s Gloom Explorer
- Shark’s Teeth Grotto Explorer
- Deepest Shallows
- Cutting the Keel
- Quests
- Welcome to the Thieves Guild
- Always Travel Separately
- Iron Wheel Infiltration
- Never, Ever Steal from the Guild
- Wedding Crashers
- Broken Wheel
- A Life Deferred
- Seeds Untilled
- What Price, Freedom?
- Loose Ends
- Exploration
- Nikolvara’s Kennel Explorer
- Coldperch Cavern Explorer
- Argent Mine Explorer
- Thukozod’s Sanctum Explorer
- Watcher’s Hold Explorer
- Zthenganaz Explorer
- Echatere Executioner
- Dolmen Denied
- Regent Removed
- Winterborn Witherer
- Manage the Madness
- Challenge of the Centurion
- Quests
- Kingmaker
- Orc King’s Councilor
- Orc King’s Marshal
- Orc King’s Conqueror
I can also confirm Bleakrock Isle works. I tried all sorts of different combinations of saving different villagers in different orders with different characters, up to and after completing the achievement, but all quest givers were available to both characters, and neither got stuck at any point due to the achievement.tomofhyrule wrote: »Bleakrock does seem to be fine though.
I had one character go to Bleakrock and finish Hoknir's quest on his way to help Darj, and then I stopped. He had the two of them checked off in his achievement. I then went to another character (those two characters still checked in the achievement), but both Hoknir and Darj were still there to give the quest as normal.
tomofhyrule wrote: »Ok, so I just went through every achievement in game.
The major bugs/issues with the current Account-wide achievement system are the following:
- Delve/WB/etc. map markers are showing as complete for characters who have never been to a zone.
- Some quests (like the previously-reported Elsweyr queens and Stros M'kai pirates) check achievement states instead of quest states.
- Non-museum achievement-linked events are not triggering because the achievements are shown as complete.
It would be best to delay AwA to address these issues. If AwA must come out this patch, then the achievements which may affect these states (most exploration and quest achievements) should be set to character specific similarly to how the issue with the Museum quests was fixed.
This is a massive list of achievements which could potentially be problematic, but if the patch drops with them set as character-specific and they are later found to be safe, then they could be made account-wide in a later patch. This would also give time for alternate solutions to be found, e.g. if there are events linked to achievements, they could be linked instead to the character's quest journal so the achievement links can be severed and the achievement then made account-wide. If they are released account-wide and they are bugged, however, it would be very difficult to manually fix it for all 20 million players.
What follows is the list of all achievements that may cause problems.
These should all be made Character-specific until testing proves that the achievement state will not affect replayability.ExplorationQuests
- Aldmeri Dominion
- Anarume Bounty Hunter
- Bandit Lord Bounty Hunter
- Barrow Trench Explorer
- Bewan Explorer
- Big Ozur’s Bane
- Black Vine Ruins Explorer
- Bone Grappler’s Bane
- Burroot Kwama Mine Explorer
- Carac Dena Explorer
- Claw’s Strike Explorer
- Dead Man’s Drop Explorer
- Deathsong Deforester
- Del’s Claim Devastator
- Drowned Horde Decimator
- Dugan’s Demolisher
- Entila’s Folly Explorer
- Fardir’s Folly Explorer
- Gathongor Hunter
- Ghost Captain Crusher
- Gravecaller’s Doom
- Green Vanquisher
- Gurzag’s Mine Explorer
- Harridan’s Lair Explorer
- Hoarvor Pit Explorer
- Jode’s Light Explorer
- King of the Hill
- Kuna’s Delve Explorer
- Marines Avenger
- Mehrunes’ Spite Explorer
- Mercy Killer
- Mobar Mine Explorer
- Monsoon Marauder
- Naril Nagaia Explorer
- Ne Salas Explorer
- Nestmother Eradicator
- Nur-dro’s Downfall
- Ondil Explorer
- Peacemaker
- Poacher Pounder
- Roots of Silvenar Explorer
- Rootwater’s Demise
- Scuttle Pit Explorer
- Sea Elf’s Woe
- Shael Ruins Explorer
- Shagura’s Doom
- Skooma Watch
- Skullbreaker
- Snapjaw’s Bane
- Spy Smasher
- Tallatta’s Annihilator
- Thibaut’s Cave Explorer
- Thugrub Dissector
- Tomb of the Apostates Explorer
- Underroot Explorer
- Valanir’s Bane
- Vinedeath Cave Explorer
- Wansalen Explorer
- Water Walloper
- Weeping Wind Cave Explorer
- Wormroot Depths Explorer
- Ysolmarr’s Ruin
- Zymel Chaser
- Daggerfall Covenant
- Aldunz Ruins Explorer
- Asard’s Assassin
- Bearclaw Mine Explorer
- Bloodcaller’s Ruin
- Brood Queen Destroyer
- Coldrock Diggings Explorer
- Cousin Scrag’s Demolisher
- Crestshade Mine Explorer
- Crypt of the Exiles Explorer
- Cryptwatch Fort Explorer
- Darkblood Hunter
- Dayarrus’ Deathbringer
- Divad’s Chagrin Mine Explorer
- Duneripper’s Downfall
- Ebon Crypt Explorer
- Enduum Explorer
- Erokii Ruins Explorer
- Farangel’s Delve Explorer
- Flyleaf Catacombs Explorer
- Gar Xuu Gar’s Bane
- Graufang Hunter
- Hag Hunter
- Hag Upheaval
- Hatespinner Hunter
- Hildune’s Secret Refuge Explorer
- Ilessan Tower Explorer
- Klathzgar Explorer
- Koeglin Mine Explorer
- Korignah’s Bane
- Kruz Control
- Lich Buster
- Limbscather Slayer
- Lonely Papa’s Doom
- Menhir Hunter
- Mines of Khuras Explorer
- Mummy King Murderer
- Nomeg Hyril’s Executioner
- Norvulk Ruins Explorer
- Orc’s Finger Ruins Explorer
- Pariah Catacombs Explorer
- Potrdun Watch Explorer
- Rubble Butte Explorer
- Saint Slayer
- Sandblown Mine Explorer
- Santaki Ruins Explorer
- Silumm Explorer
- Siren Hunter
- Spider Slayer
- Stroda’s Assassin
- Summoner Slayer
- Titanclaw Cracker
- Torog’s Spite Explorer
- Trapjaw Stalker
- Tribulation Crypt Explorer
- Troll’s Toothpick Explorer
- Viridian Watch Explorer
- Werewolf’s Bane
- Wolf-Father Exorcist
- Woodblight Killer
- Yldzuun Ruins Explorer
- Ebonheart Pact
- Abomination Slayer
- Ammabani Ambusher
- Armene’s Bane
- Atanaz Ruins Explorer
- Avanchnzel Explorer
- ***’s Tomb Explorer
- Beralagr Hunter
- Bittergreen Obliterator
- Black Maw Shrine Explorer
- Broken Helm Hollow Explorer
- Broken Tusk Explorer
- Captain Bones Destroyer
- Chid-Moska Ruins Explorer
- Chill Hollow Explorer
- Corpse Garden Explorer
- Dreugh Destroyer
- Druitularg’s Bane
- Emberflint Mine Explorer
- Faldar’s Tooth Explorer
- Fort Greenwall Explorer
- Frigid Grotto Explorer
- Frost Atronach Destroyer
- Gandranen Explorer
- Ghost Banisher
- Giant Slayer
- Haynekhtnamet Hunter
- Hightide Hollow Explorer
- Icehammer’s Vault Explorer
- Inner Sea Armature Explorer
- Khajiiti Hunters’ Bane
- Knife Ear Grotto Explorer
- Lady Llarel’s Shelter Explorer
- Lower Bthanual Explorer
- Mabrigash Shade Destroyer
- Mannskadi’s Mauler
- Memory Masher
- Mephala’s Nest Explorer
- Mummy Lord Murderer
- Netch Wrangler
- Ogre Twin Tormerntor
- Old Sord’s Cave Explorer
- Onkobra Kwama Mine Explorer
- Rageclaw Hunter
- Ratmaster Crusher
- Saintly Slaughter
- Sharpfang Killer
- Shellcracker
- Sheogorath’s Tongue Explorer
- Short-Tusk Hunter
- Shroud Heather Barrow Explorer
- Slave Lord’s Ruination
- Snapleg Cave Explorer
- Softloam Cavern Explorer
- Stormcrag Crypt Explorer
- Strifeswarm Eradicator
- Taleon’s Crag Explorer
- Triple Circle Mine Explorer
- Troll Killer
- Urrai’s Bane
- Wispmother Vanquisher
- Coldharbour
- Aba-Loria Explorer
- Brolsgerbwd’s Bane
- Cave of Trophies Explorer
- Centurion’s Ruin
- Cynhamoth’s End
- Daedroth Trio Hunter
- Forgefire Vault Explorer
- Grotto of Depravity Explorer
- Ice Wraith Hunter
- Mal Sorra’s Tomb Explorer
- Stortha’s Doom
- Wailing Maw Explorer
- Craglorn
- Anka-Ra Consecrationalist
- Anomalous Scholar
- Nirncrux Inspector
- Balamath Explorer
- Buried Sands Explorer
- Chiselshriek Mine Explorer
- Exarch’s Stronghold Explorer
- Fearfangs Cavern Explorer
- Haddock’s Market Explorer
- Hircine’s Haunt Explorer
- Ilthag’s Undertower Explorer
- Loth’Na Caverns Explorer
- Molavar Explorer
- Mtharnaz Explorer
- Rkhardahrk Explorer
- Rkundzelft Explorer
- Ruins of Kardala Explorer
- Serpent’s Nest Explorer
- The Howling Sepulchers Explorer
- Tombs of the Na-Totambu Explorer
- Zalgaz’s Den Explorer
- Earthly Possessions
- Cyrodiil
- Bloodmayne Cave Explorer
- Breakneck Cave Explorer
- Capstone Cave Explorer
- Cracked Wood Cave Explorer
- Echo Cave Explorer
- Haynote Cave Explorer
- Kingscrest Cavern Explorer
- Lipsand Tarn Explorer
- Muck Valley Cavern Explorer
- Newt Cave Explorer
- Nisin Cave Explorer
- Pothole Caverns Explorer
- Quickwater Cave Explorer
- Red Ruby Cave Explorer
- Serpent Hollow Explorer
- Toadstool Hollow Explorer
- Underpall Cave Explorer
- Vahtacen Explorer
- Dark Anchors
- Covenant Anchor Shatterer
- Dominion Anchor Shatterer
- Pact Anchor Shatterer
- Imperial Anchor Shatterer
Blackwood
- Main Quest
- The Harborage
- Daughter of Giants
- Chasing Shadows
- Castle of the Worm
- The Tharn Speaks
- The Halls of Torment
- The Valley of Blades
- The Shadow of Sancre Tor
- Council of the Five Companions
- The God of Schemes
- Aldmeri Dominion
- Maormer’s Bane
- Sunder the First Veil
- Sunder the Second Veil
- Sunder the Third Veil
- Hero of Falinesti
- Reliquary Retriever
- Southpoint Savior
- Court Ranger
- Valenwood Protector
- Veil Lifter
- Hero of Frond and Leaf
- Hound Hinderer
- Silvenar’s Friend
- Clan Mother Inaugurator
- Dark Mane Incarcerator
- Two Moons Pathwalker
- Daggerfall Covenant
- Famed Recruiter
- Faolchu’s Bane
- Savior of Glenumbra
- Wyrd Friend
- Azura’s Ally
- Dreamslayer
- Spirit Warden Champion
- Hero of House Dorell
- Hero of House Tamrith
- Sword of Ravenwatch
- Alasan’s Devastation
- Ash’abah Hero
- Uwafa’s Ruination
- Bangkorai Garrison Liberator
- Evermore Defender
- High King Emeric’s Savior
- Ebonheart Pact
- Hero of Bleakrock
- Balreth’s Bane
- General Serien’s Demise
- Sadal’s Overthrower
- Plague Ender
- Temple Knight
- Vox Slayer
- Egg Protector
- Mnemic Egg Guardian
- Skin-Stealer Destroyer
- Giant-Friend
- Skald-King’s Arrow
- Skald-King’s Salvation
- Reach Crusher
- Wormsquasher
- Ysgramor’s Prodigy
- Coldharbour
- Guardian of the Great Mage
- Light of the Ayleid Kind
- Planemeld Sunderer
Greymoor
- Exploration
- Undertow Cavern Explorer
- Bull-Fighter
- Xi-Tsei Explorer
- Doomvault Porcixid Explorer
- Arpenia Explorer
- Bloodrun Cave Explorer
- Vunalk Explorer
- Tongue Taker
- Sul-Xan Sacker
- Wart-Wacker
- Ruinach Ravager
- Trophy-Taker’s Taker
- Most Admired
- Enticed by Magic
- Quests
- Leyawiin Mercenary
- Blackwood Investigator
- Ambition Acquirer
- Party Crasher
- Ambition’s Advocate
- Disaster Averter
- Daedric Dispeller
Elsweyr
- Exploration
- Beach Battler
- Blackreach Breacher
- Champion’s Champion
- Chillwind Depths Explorer
- Dragonhome Explorer
- Dwarven Disassembler
- Frozen Coast Explorer
- Giant Cheese Conoisseur
- Hunting the Hunters
- Midnight Barrow Explorer
- No Food For You
- Shades of Gray
- Shadowgreen Explorer
- The Scraps Explorer
- Quests
- Friend to Fennorian
- Resolute Reconnoiter
- Threat Ender
- Skyrim Diplomat
- Mining Sample Collector
- Shieldthane of Morthal
- Swordthane of Karthwatch
- Titanborn’s Partner
- Assassin Assassinator
- Hero of the Holds
- Harrowstorms
- Harrowstorm Chaser
Summerset
- Exploration
- Abode of Ignominy Explorer
- Predator Mesa Explorer
- Desert Wind Caverns Explorer
- Tomb of the Serpents Explorer
- Darkpool Mine Explorer
- The Tangle Explorer
- Skullcracker
- Flattened the Nightmare Plateau
- Terror Bird Terminator
- Grave Guardian
- Sword Sunderer
- Red-Handed Vigilante
- Quests
- Tharn’s Aide-de-Camp
- Precarious Parley
- Riverhold Defender
- Rimmen Revolution
- Assassination Cessation
- Betrayer Breaker
- Moonwalker
- Queenmaker
Morrowind
- Exploration
- King’s Haven Pass Explorer
- Eton Nir Grotto Explorer
- Archon’s Grove Explorer
- Tor-Hame-Khard Explorer
- Wasten Coraldale Explorer
- Traitor’s Vault Explorer
- Reef Raider
- Bucking the Matriarchy
- Sea Sload Slugger
- Talon Taker
- Amphibian Agitator
- Keel Hauler
- A Book and its Cover
- Quests
- For the Queen
- Precious Pearl
- Mind Games
- Resolute Guardian
- Sweet Dreams
- Unreliable Narrator
- Enemy of my Enemy
- What Must Be Done
- Abyssal Geysers
- Put a Cork In It
Deadlands
- Exploration
- Ashalmawia Explorer
- Breaker of the Unbroken
- Cheater Defeater
- Consort Killer
- Khartag Point Explorer
- Matus-Akin Egg Mine Explorer
- Nchuleft Explorer
- Pulk Explorer
- Salothan’s Cursebreaker
- Songbird Silencer
- Wuyuvus Slayer
- Zainsipilu Explorer
- Quests
- Ald’ruhn Annalist
- Bearer of the Blessed Staff
- Ebony Enforcer
- Hand of a Living God
- Hand of the Mistress
- Kwama Miner
- Narsis’s Apprentice
- Naryu’s Confidant
- Pilgrim Protector
- Rising Sun
- Scarlet Judge
- Voice of the Failed Incarnates
Markarth
- Exploration
- Brandfire Reformatory Explorer
- False Martyrs’ Folly Explorer
- Unmaker Unmaker
- Scorpion Stomper
- Quests
- Stranger in Town
- Rat Catcher
- Deadlands Jailbreaker
- Deadlands Mountaineer
- Unmasker
- Hopeful Rescuer
- Ambition Collector
- Dagon Defier
- Eternal Optimist
- Friend to the Kalmur
- Spire Sleuth
Dragonhold
- Exploration
- A Friend In Deed
- Briar Rock Ruins Explorer
- Gloomreach Explorer
- Master of Storms
- Offerings to the Old Spirits
- Weaned from Darkness
- Dynastor Deposed
- Quests
- Crow-Eye Savior
- Lothid Clan Liberator
- Nowhere Beyond Your Reach
- Peered into the Abyss
- A Bridge Between Kingdoms
- Ravenwatch Ambassador
- Reach Ritualist
- Subterranean Scholar
- Taking up the Mantle
- Witness to Prophecy
- Nighthollow Explorer
- Protector of Markarth
Murkmire
- Exploration
- Forsaken Citadel Explorer
- Moonlit Cove Explorer
- End of the Exile
- Temple Guardian Terror
- A Hero’s Song
- Quests
- A New Beginning
- Leaves on the Wind
- Lair Locator
- Khenarthi’s Guidance
- Infiltrating the New Moon
- Halls of the Highmane
- Return of the Dragonguard
- The Dragon’s Wrath
- Fall of the Dark Aeon
- Bright Moons over Elsweyr
Clockwork City
- Exploration
- Tsofeer Cavern Explorer
- Teeth of Sithis Explorer
- Fiend of the Fens
- Feller of Thunder
- Swamp Rescuer
- Surreptitiously Shadowed
- Quests
- Cold Blood, Warm Heart
- The Progeny
- Traps and Treasures
- Seeker of the Lost
- Mysteries of the Remnant
- Sap-Sleeper
- Shadows of the Past
- To Chase a Dream
- The River of Rebirth
Dark Brotherhood
- Exploration
- Halls of Regulation Explorer
- Shadow Cleft Explorer
- Imperfection
- Murderer of Crows
- Quests
- Land of Gears and Cogs
- Clockwork Citizen
- Smoke and Mirrors
- Middle-Man
- Birds of a Feather
- Shadow Boxing
- The Real Sotha Sil
- The Burden of Knowledge
- Fortune and Fate
Thieves Guild
- Exploration
- Hrota Cave Explorer
- Garlas Agea Explorer
- Defeat Limenaruus
- Conquer the Kvatch Arena
- Lonely Sentinel
- Quests
- First Blood
- Dark Initiate
- New-Blade
- Sermonizer Subduer
- Brethren Benefactor
- Assassin
- Dark Discovery
- Dark Investigator
- Wrath of Sithis
- Silencer
Orsinium
- Exploration
- Bahraha’s Gloom Explorer
- Shark’s Teeth Grotto Explorer
- Deepest Shallows
- Cutting the Keel
- Quests
- Welcome to the Thieves Guild
- Always Travel Separately
- Iron Wheel Infiltration
- Never, Ever Steal from the Guild
- Wedding Crashers
- Broken Wheel
- A Life Deferred
- Seeds Untilled
- What Price, Freedom?
- Loose Ends
- Exploration
- Nikolvara’s Kennel Explorer
- Coldperch Cavern Explorer
- Argent Mine Explorer
- Thukozod’s Sanctum Explorer
- Watcher’s Hold Explorer
- Zthenganaz Explorer
- Echatere Executioner
- Dolmen Denied
- Regent Removed
- Winterborn Witherer
- Manage the Madness
- Challenge of the Centurion
- Quests
- Kingmaker
- Orc King’s Councilor
- Orc King’s Marshal
- Orc King’s Conqueror
tomofhyrule wrote: »Also re: the Undaunted levelling - people have been saying it’s not working as intended. Or at least that levelling from Bolgrul dailies and one-time-only dungeon quests is prohibitively slow.
Have there ever been any statements about levelling other skill lines that base from achievements, notably Scrying and Excavating? The Antiquities system levels slowly enough on a second character in the first place, and getting rid of the boosts from achievements will just make things painful.