Mythreindeer wrote: »A lifetime of grief from your kid.
Deservedly so.
16BitForestCat wrote: »All the people saying the equivalent of "give them a real name" can shut up because people have been naming their kids after pop culture characters for millennia. Many names we consider "normal" now were once snickered at because they were the name of a popular character of the time. Just one modern example: Madison has been popular since the 1980s as a girl's name, largely due to the name of the mermaid in the 1984 Disney-Touchstone movie Splash. Most people nowadays have no awareness of this. They just think Madison is a nice name that has "always" been around for girls. I have a young relative named Madison; her parents were very amused to learn they'd unintentionally named her after a movie mermaid.
Name your kid something that has meaning to you, and which you hope will have meaning to the child.Your kid could have the most generic name in the world, and people will still make fun of it, so I've never seen that as a reason to go for the common names. People who want to be awful will invent a reason for it, anyway. Just look at the ESO forums. /salt
I have an unusual first name myself, and I am so glad my parents made up a name and didn't go with their first choice for me (which was the third most common name for babies born in my year, and has been one of the most common for centuries).
The only downside is that no one can ever spell or say my name when they first meet me. I don't actually dislike that. I only dislike having to educate them, only to sometimes have them say, "I can't be bothered to remember that, so I'm gonna call you [Similar But Common Name] from now on." Never works out so hot for them, since I simply don't respond to it. :P That's on them for being stupid jerks who won't respect my name, not on me for having an unusual name, and not on my parents for giving me one.
P.S. ZOS employees Jay Barnes and Jessica Folsom named their child after ESO character Eveli (as in Eveli Sharp-Arrow)--different spelling, but pronounced the same way. https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Online:Eveli_Sharp-Arrow (Look in Notes.)
Ippokrates wrote: »Well, there is a difference between giving a name according to particular tradition, religious custom or in recognition of family relatives AND naming girl Khalessi before 8 season of GoT when she turnout to be fascist murderer ^^
16BitForestCat wrote: »Ippokrates wrote: »Well, there is a difference between giving a name according to particular tradition, religious custom or in recognition of family relatives AND naming girl Khalessi before 8 season of GoT when she turnout to be fascist murderer ^^
When you name someone after another entity real or fictional, you're naming them after the aspects you love (if you're a good person), not the flaws. Sometimes the flaws don't really come out until much later, but that doesn't change that you picked a name that had meaning to you at the time, and that you want the person you named to embody those good traits, despite whatever bad ones may come up related to "the original." When you name your son Harold after your grandpa Harold, I'll bet you aren't naming the baby after Grandpa Harold's tendency to shout bigoted language after he'd had a few drinks. You're instead naming him after all the good memories of Grandpa Harold. Yet people name their children after people who weren't perfect literally every single day.
Personally, I wouldn't name my nonexistent children after (also nonexistent) Grandpa Harold BECAUSE of his bad traits, and I wouldn't name my never-existing kids after a character in a still-ongoing canon if that character runs a real risk of becoming everything I'm against. But there's not actually anything wrong with doing so, if you want to name your kid after the kinder, shy Khaleesi Daenerys of the early books/seasons, or name them after Grandpa Harold's good sides. It's really not going to be something that's going to come up in the kid's everyday life in the end, regardless. People move on from fandoms and forget them over time. Grandpa Harold's bad traits won't be associated with the child named after him, and probably won't be remembered much after he's gone.
It's just a terrible idea to be so afraid of "what society thinks" that you let it color how you identify your own child from birth. It's a game you'll never win because of there always being awful people in the world.
Ippokrates wrote: »So as you can see, naming a child after very specific thing, you are not in control of, could be quite risky -_-
UnkindnessOfRavens wrote: »Stuga. This is the way.
16BitForestCat wrote: »All the people saying the equivalent of "give them a real name" can knock off because people have been naming their kids after pop culture characters for millennia. Many names we consider "normal" now were once considered unusual because they were the name of a popular character of the time. Just one modern example: Madison has been popular since the 1980s as a girl's name, largely due to the name of the mermaid in the 1984 Disney-Touchstone movie Splash. Most people nowadays have no awareness of this. They just think Madison is a nice name that has "always" been around for girls. I have a young relative named Madison; her parents were very amused to learn they'd unintentionally named her after a movie mermaid.
Name your kid something that has meaning to you, and which you hope will have meaning to the child.Your kid could have the most generic name in the world, and people will still make fun of it, so I've never seen that as a reason to go for the common names. People who want to be awful will invent a reason for it, anyway. Just look at the ESO forums. /salt
I have an unusual first name myself, and over four decades later, I am still so glad my parents made up a name and didn't go with their first choice for me (which was the third most common name for babies born in my year, and has been one of the most common for centuries).
The only downside is that no one can ever spell or say my name when they first meet me. I don't actually dislike that. I only dislike having to educate them, only to sometimes have them say, "I can't be bothered to remember that, so I'm gonna call you [Similar But Common Name] from now on." Never works out so hot for them, since I simply don't respond to it. :P That's on them for being stupid jerks who won't respect my name, not on me for having an unusual name and enforcing my boundaries, and not on my parents for giving me an unusual name.
As to what you'll GET? A healthy kid with a cool name, I hope.
P.S. ZOS employees Jay Barnes and Jessica Folsom named their child after ESO character Eveli (as in Eveli Sharp-Arrow)--different spelling, but pronounced the same way. https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Online:Eveli_Sharp-Arrow (Look in Notes.)
16BitForestCat wrote: »Ippokrates wrote: »Well, there is a difference between giving a name according to particular tradition, religious custom or in recognition of family relatives AND naming girl Khalessi before 8 season of GoT when she turnout to be fascist murderer ^^
When you name someone after another entity real or fictional, you're naming them after the aspects you love (if you're a good person), not the flaws. Sometimes the flaws don't really come out until much later, but that doesn't change that you picked a name that had meaning to you at the time, and that you want the person you named to embody those good traits, despite whatever bad ones may come up related to "the original." When you name your son Harold after your grandpa Harold, I'll bet you aren't naming the baby after Grandpa Harold's tendency to shout bigoted language after he'd had a few drinks. You're instead naming him after all the good memories of Grandpa Harold. Yet people name their children after people who weren't perfect literally every single day.
Personally, I wouldn't name my nonexistent children after (also nonexistent) Grandpa Harold BECAUSE of his bad traits, and I wouldn't name my never-existing kids after a character in a still-ongoing canon if that character runs a real risk of becoming everything I'm against. But there's not actually anything wrong with doing so, if you want to name your kid after the kinder, shy Khaleesi Daenerys of the early books/seasons, or name them after Grandpa Harold's good sides. It's really not going to be something that's going to come up in the kid's everyday life in the end, regardless. People move on from fandoms and forget them over time. Grandpa Harold's bad traits won't be associated with the child named after him, and probably won't be remembered much after he's gone.
It's just a terrible idea to be so afraid of "what society thinks" that you let it color how you identify your own child from birth. It's a game you'll never win because of there always being awful people in the world.