I did this quest 3 times: 2 Angof, 1 Estre, 0 Thalik. Angof is the only reasonable choice for me, because he shows remorse and tries to save the mage assigned to him, tries not to be cruel. Estre is narcissistic witch, as she always was, but one character I had was roleplaying a secret crush on Naemon, so character decided to save her in his memory. As for Thalik, I was having " who is this guy even?" reaction when I saw him, totally forgettable character.
kip_silverwolf wrote: »Angof everytime, because I love his voice!
There is a dialogue about it, she has made more pacts (and broke more pacts) with daedra lords than it is possible to Dovahkiin from Skyrim. She sold her soul to so many powers that they would never agree who should get her soul after all (and if we free her, she returns to life and plan to live on Auridon).phaneub17_ESO wrote: »I got a little confused by why Estre is there, she was a Mehrunes Dagon follower as it was hinted on in Auridon quests, I thought even though she failed and died, she would go to his realm in death not to Molag Bal. Unless there's something about Coldharbour that draws all souls to it?
whichever villain you chose now resides in "House of Darkness" in Coldharbour, at the Shining Star Estre's complaining about not having servants if you chose her, not sure if Angof is anywhere else besides the House.
I can't remember whether it was a persuade or threaten option to release all 3 of the mage guild people as well.
All I remember was it was something like saying I would keep screwing with the observers games till he released them all.