Ragnaroek93 wrote: »People need to calm and test it on PTS. It's pretty much the same as old Major Evasion on average.
In which universe is nightblades having the equivalent of old major evasion not OP????
Ragnaroek93 wrote: »People need to calm and test it on PTS. It's pretty much the same as old Major Evasion on average.
Ragnaroek93 wrote: »Ragnaroek93 wrote: »People need to calm and test it on PTS. It's pretty much the same as old Major Evasion on average.
In which universe is nightblades having the equivalent of old major evasion not OP????
In the universe in which Nbs lost 5k pen (or a skill slot or a 5p set), 8% dmg, 10% stamrec, major defile and their snare.
Ragnaroek93 wrote: »People need to calm and test it on PTS. It's pretty much the same as old Major Evasion on average.
In which universe is nightblades having the equivalent of old major evasion not OP????
Ragnaroek93 wrote: »People need to calm and test it on PTS. It's pretty much the same as old Major Evasion on average.
In which universe is nightblades having the equivalent of old major evasion not OP????
The universe where everyone’s a Stam user running bleeds w/5k weapon damage.
Ragnaroek93 wrote: »People need to calm and test it on PTS. It's pretty much the same as old Major Evasion on average.
In which universe is nightblades having the equivalent of old major evasion not OP????
The universe where everyone’s a Stam user running bleeds w/5k weapon damage.
Bleeds have been nerfed and snb is BiS on most things anyway which doesn't have bleeds, just yelling bleeds as an argument isn't valid anymore.
And 5k weapon damage isn't even that high anymore for most stam specs.
So i tested the actual damage mitigation of grim focus. Made sure we always had the exact same buffs etc.
On heavy + minor maim + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 2785
With 5 bow procs: 2399
On med + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 3695
With 5 bow procs: 3183
So in practice it is about 13.85% damage mitigation. I didn't test with a wide variety of buffs/debuffs but from these quick tests you can tell those buffs/debuffs didn't even affect it because the damage mitigation % is virtually the same on both tests.
So in conclusion, it is not 3% or 6% like a lot of people are saying, it is very close to 15%.
So i tested the actual damage mitigation of grim focus. Made sure we always had the exact same buffs etc.
On heavy + minor maim + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 2785
With 5 bow procs: 2399
On med + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 3695
With 5 bow procs: 3183
So in practice it is about 13.85% damage mitigation. I didn't test with a wide variety of buffs/debuffs but from these quick tests you can tell those buffs/debuffs didn't even affect it because the damage mitigation % is virtually the same on both tests.
So in conclusion, it is not 3% or 6% like a lot of people are saying, it is very close to 15%.
So i tested the actual damage mitigation of grim focus. Made sure we always had the exact same buffs etc.
On heavy + minor maim + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 2785
With 5 bow procs: 2399
On med + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 3695
With 5 bow procs: 3183
So in practice it is about 13.85% damage mitigation. I didn't test with a wide variety of buffs/debuffs but from these quick tests you can tell those buffs/debuffs didn't even affect it because the damage mitigation % is virtually the same on both tests.
So in conclusion, it is not 3% or 6% like a lot of people are saying, it is very close to 15%.
The right numbers the wrong conclusion. All mitigation is multiplicative and give diminishing returns. You’re getting 92% of that Focus buff toward total mitigation if Minor Prot is your only other source of mitigation. (Maim is target-side and plays no factor in self-mitigation calculations).
Simply adding block further reduces the effectiveness to 46% of the Focus buff.
Gains to total mitigation are minor, and still don’t have a place on what is supposed to be a damage ability
So i tested the actual damage mitigation of grim focus. Made sure we always had the exact same buffs etc.
On heavy + minor maim + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 2785
With 5 bow procs: 2399
On med + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 3695
With 5 bow procs: 3183
So in practice it is about 13.85% damage mitigation. I didn't test with a wide variety of buffs/debuffs but from these quick tests you can tell those buffs/debuffs didn't even affect it because the damage mitigation % is virtually the same on both tests.
So in conclusion, it is not 3% or 6% like a lot of people are saying, it is very close to 15%.
The right numbers the wrong conclusion. All mitigation is multiplicative and give diminishing returns. You’re getting 92% of that Focus buff toward total mitigation if Minor Prot is your only other source of mitigation. (Maim is target-side and plays no factor in self-mitigation calculations).
Simply adding block further reduces the effectiveness to 46% of the Focus buff.
Gains to total mitigation are minor, and still don’t have a place on what is supposed to be a damage ability
So i tested the actual damage mitigation of grim focus. Made sure we always had the exact same buffs etc.
On heavy + minor maim + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 2785
With 5 bow procs: 2399
On med + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 3695
With 5 bow procs: 3183
So in practice it is about 13.85% damage mitigation. I didn't test with a wide variety of buffs/debuffs but from these quick tests you can tell those buffs/debuffs didn't even affect it because the damage mitigation % is virtually the same on both tests.
So in conclusion, it is not 3% or 6% like a lot of people are saying, it is very close to 15%.
The right numbers the wrong conclusion. All mitigation is multiplicative and give diminishing returns. You’re getting 92% of that Focus buff toward total mitigation if Minor Prot is your only other source of mitigation. (Maim is target-side and plays no factor in self-mitigation calculations).
Simply adding block further reduces the effectiveness to 46% of the Focus buff.
Gains to total mitigation are minor, and still don’t have a place on what is supposed to be a damage ability
Ofc it's multiplicative, if every source of dmg mit was additive no one would take any damage, but people are saying it's weak because it's multiplicative which is absolutely not the case. That 3%-6% people are talking about is based on the dmg before mit which is a massive number. It's not an actual 15% dmg mit but it's far from as bad as some people are trying to make it look with the 3%-6%.
So i tested the actual damage mitigation of grim focus. Made sure we always had the exact same buffs etc.
On heavy + minor maim + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 2785
With 5 bow procs: 2399
On med + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 3695
With 5 bow procs: 3183
So in practice it is about 13.85% damage mitigation. I didn't test with a wide variety of buffs/debuffs but from these quick tests you can tell those buffs/debuffs didn't even affect it because the damage mitigation % is virtually the same on both tests.
So in conclusion, it is not 3% or 6% like a lot of people are saying, it is very close to 15%.
The right numbers the wrong conclusion. All mitigation is multiplicative and give diminishing returns. You’re getting 92% of that Focus buff toward total mitigation if Minor Prot is your only other source of mitigation. (Maim is target-side and plays no factor in self-mitigation calculations).
Simply adding block further reduces the effectiveness to 46% of the Focus buff.
Gains to total mitigation are minor, and still don’t have a place on what is supposed to be a damage ability
Ofc it's multiplicative, if every source of dmg mit was additive no one would take any damage, but people are saying it's weak because it's multiplicative which is absolutely not the case. That 3%-6% people are talking about is based on the dmg before mit which is a massive number. It's not an actual 15% dmg mit but it's far from as bad as some people are trying to make it look with the 3%-6%.
On a standard build with the standard buffs, it only adds about 3% total mitigation.
It’s not worth slotting over something else if you’re looking for a defensive option
Ragnaroek93 wrote: »Ragnaroek93 wrote: »People need to calm and test it on PTS. It's pretty much the same as old Major Evasion on average.
In which universe is nightblades having the equivalent of old major evasion not OP????
In the universe in which Nbs lost 5k pen (or a skill slot or a 5p set), 8% dmg, 10% stamrec, major defile and their snare.
In the universe where stamblade was overperforming in PvP for years and was in desperate need for nerfs. Whether they overnerfed it or not is up for discussion but a lot of stamblade mains have been carried by their class for very long. The nb nerfs doesn't mean it's a dead class. Well stamblade at least, magblade is just collateral damage at this point.
So i tested the actual damage mitigation of grim focus. Made sure we always had the exact same buffs etc.
On heavy + minor maim + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 2785
With 5 bow procs: 2399
On med + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 3695
With 5 bow procs: 3183
So in practice it is about 13.85% damage mitigation. I didn't test with a wide variety of buffs/debuffs but from these quick tests you can tell those buffs/debuffs didn't even affect it because the damage mitigation % is virtually the same on both tests.
So in conclusion, it is not 3% or 6% like a lot of people are saying, it is very close to 15%.
The right numbers the wrong conclusion. All mitigation is multiplicative and give diminishing returns. You’re getting 92% of that Focus buff toward total mitigation if Minor Prot is your only other source of mitigation. (Maim is target-side and plays no factor in self-mitigation calculations).
Simply adding block further reduces the effectiveness to 46% of the Focus buff.
Gains to total mitigation are minor, and still don’t have a place on what is supposed to be a damage ability
Ofc it's multiplicative, if every source of dmg mit was additive no one would take any damage, but people are saying it's weak because it's multiplicative which is absolutely not the case. That 3%-6% people are talking about is based on the dmg before mit which is a massive number. It's not an actual 15% dmg mit but it's far from as bad as some people are trying to make it look with the 3%-6%.
On a standard build with the standard buffs, it only adds about 3% total mitigation.
It’s not worth slotting over something else if you’re looking for a defensive option
but a magicka templar can make my 24k spectral bow hit for 71 damage. Seems legit.
FangOfTheTwoMoons wrote: »For PvE the skill is still bad. This rework doesn't address the fact that we have to use 2 GCDs and get nothing until we play that fun little mini game. As a DPS I'm going to proc my bow so the mitigation isn't even going to help (I trust my healers to keep me alive). So now we're back to where we were week one; cost recourses and getting nothing in return. Tanks don't need the mitigation. Do you think this makes up for the Nerf to NB tanks heal? This is only decent for PVP. Besides the fact that people gotta redo their whole builds cause being a tanky NB is gonna be where it's at.
And despite all these "sources" of mitigation, it means noting when there still isn't enough output to be a threat and not enough healing to overcome pressure. On paper things sound amazing, in practice, 75% of mNB output is dodged or avoided, and they offer nothing to sustain other than hiding in cloak and running away.
FangOfTheTwoMoons wrote: »For PvE the skill is still bad. This rework doesn't address the fact that we have to use 2 GCDs and get nothing until we play that fun little mini game. As a DPS I'm going to proc my bow so the mitigation isn't even going to help (I trust my healers to keep me alive). So now we're back to where we were week one; cost recourses and getting nothing in return. Tanks don't need the mitigation. Do you think this makes up for the Nerf to NB tanks heal? This is only decent for PVP. Besides the fact that people gotta redo their whole builds cause being a tanky NB is gonna be where it's at.
It doesn't have to be good for PVE. Magblade will likely still be top mag dps so??? We get the highest mag dps in return tho.
So i tested the actual damage mitigation of grim focus. Made sure we always had the exact same buffs etc.
On heavy + minor maim + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 2785
With 5 bow procs: 2399
On med + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 3695
With 5 bow procs: 3183
So in practice it is about 13.85% damage mitigation. I didn't test with a wide variety of buffs/debuffs but from these quick tests you can tell those buffs/debuffs didn't even affect it because the damage mitigation % is virtually the same on both tests.
So in conclusion, it is not 3% or 6% like a lot of people are saying, it is very close to 15%.
The right numbers the wrong conclusion. All mitigation is multiplicative and give diminishing returns. You’re getting 92% of that Focus buff toward total mitigation if Minor Prot is your only other source of mitigation. (Maim is target-side and plays no factor in self-mitigation calculations).
Simply adding block further reduces the effectiveness to 46% of the Focus buff.
Gains to total mitigation are minor, and still don’t have a place on what is supposed to be a damage ability
Ofc it's multiplicative, if every source of dmg mit was additive no one would take any damage, but people are saying it's weak because it's multiplicative which is absolutely not the case. That 3%-6% people are talking about is based on the dmg before mit which is a massive number. It's not an actual 15% dmg mit but it's far from as bad as some people are trying to make it look with the 3%-6%.
On a standard build with the standard buffs, it only adds about 3% total mitigation.
It’s not worth slotting over something else if you’re looking for a defensive option
So i tested the actual damage mitigation of grim focus. Made sure we always had the exact same buffs etc.
On heavy + minor maim + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 2785
With 5 bow procs: 2399
On med + minor protection:
With no bow procs: 3695
With 5 bow procs: 3183
So in practice it is about 13.85% damage mitigation. I didn't test with a wide variety of buffs/debuffs but from these quick tests you can tell those buffs/debuffs didn't even affect it because the damage mitigation % is virtually the same on both tests.
So in conclusion, it is not 3% or 6% like a lot of people are saying, it is very close to 15%.
The right numbers the wrong conclusion. All mitigation is multiplicative and give diminishing returns. You’re getting 92% of that Focus buff toward total mitigation if Minor Prot is your only other source of mitigation. (Maim is target-side and plays no factor in self-mitigation calculations).
Simply adding block further reduces the effectiveness to 46% of the Focus buff.
Gains to total mitigation are minor, and still don’t have a place on what is supposed to be a damage ability
Ofc it's multiplicative, if every source of dmg mit was additive no one would take any damage, but people are saying it's weak because it's multiplicative which is absolutely not the case. That 3%-6% people are talking about is based on the dmg before mit which is a massive number. It's not an actual 15% dmg mit but it's far from as bad as some people are trying to make it look with the 3%-6%.
On a standard build with the standard buffs, it only adds about 3% total mitigation.
It’s not worth slotting over something else if you’re looking for a defensive option
How is that true when the numbers were showing 13~%?
Honest question because everyone Mathed so hard and came to wildly different conclusions.
Mitigation is mutliplicative
You can’t just add it all together and call it done. Not to mention anyone using the proc won’t have the full mitigation value most of the time.
Anyone using it regularly will on average have 6% damage mitigation, which in reality only adds 3% or so extra mitigation when you have the usual sources in CP and Major resist buffs
(Talking about PvP) You're not gonna use it when you're under a lot of pressure and it doesn't take long at all to get 5 stacks, so uptime on that 15% is gonna be really high in PvP, so uptime on 5 stacks isn't really an argument in PvP.
5 seconds in PvP is a long time, not sure what you’re on
It's a L2P issue if you use up the stacks when you're about to need the damage mitigation, 5 seconds isn't long if you're smart about using or saving up stacks.
Keep in mind you can't save the stacks in between fights. The second you aren't in combat any more they are gone and you have to rebuild them.
Given how squishy NBs tend to be this is an idiotic change to grim focus. The devs are trying to make a DD burst ability viable for all 3 roles but that just won't happen especially in pvp as a DD NB will be using up the stacks for burst given how long it takes to gain. Between all three roles each of them will only be actively using one half of grim focus at this point which means the skill itself is now lacking a clear identity. Not to mention a medium armor DD will never out last a hvy DK/templar/warden in pvp.
If u take a 100k hit and have 80% mitigation this results in 20k hit taken
If u have grim focus active with it, that last hit will get reduced by 15% wich results in 17k dmg taken.
Your total mitigation is 83% thats true.
But grim did reduce the 20k down to 17kdmg u take, wich is something around 15%.
What grim focus DOES NOT DO is it wont decrease the basehit by 15% before all mitigation, because that would be the gamebreaker we all wait for ^^
Total mitigation calculations are nice, but testing on bosses like olms on pts has shown for me that the skill is really strong, for the basicly nothing u have to do.
Thing is, it adds up, even in fights with a lot of dots ect pp or where u get constant dmg.
For pvp this will be even stronger.
If u take a 100k hit and have 80% mitigation this results in 20k hit taken
If u have grim focus active with it, that last hit will get reduced by 15% wich results in 17k dmg taken.
Your total mitigation is 83% thats true.
But grim did reduce the 20k down to 17kdmg u take, wich is something around 15%.
What grim focus DOES NOT DO is it wont decrease the basehit by 15% before all mitigation, because that would be the gamebreaker we all wait for ^^
Total mitigation calculations are nice, but testing on bosses like olms on pts has shown for me that the skill is really strong, for the basicly nothing u have to do.
Thing is, it adds up, even in fights with a lot of dots ect pp or where u get constant dmg.
For pvp this will be even stronger.
isn't non blocking mitigation limited to 50%?