Flameheart wrote: »For PvE dps I don't think that magicka NBs are that far behind other magicka class dps builds. While I think that magicka templars have the strongest single target dps at moment (which relies to a major amount on their superior execute skill), imho the perceived dps differencies in compare to other classes like a sorc and especially the DK relies on the fact that many boss fights in Trials and vMoL include adds and there a Sorc and a DK just shines. Both have a strong ground dps skill (Liquid Lighting, Eruption) and while the Sorc has curse and additional AoE splash damage (Force Pulse), the DK has Engulfing Flames and to a lesser degree Flames of Oblivion (and is able to pack even more AoE dps with Burning Talons and Draw Essence if he wants). Therefore newer builds advice to use Force Pulse as a NB too, if you want to squeeze the very last part of dps out of your toon.
Add to that, that imho the rota of a NB is not that fluently and simple to play as of other classes, because of Assassins Will and rebuffing and that ESO somehow "forgot" to add a new "meta" monster set for NBs which can rival Grothdarr or Ilambris, you may have lost some ground in compare to other classes, but nothing at a serious degree.
I play all 4 clases as magicka builds in vet trials and I can achieve around the same dps as long it's pure single target with Sorc, NB and DK, maybe just the templar shines a bit more. Add 2 adds to that and I succeed with my Sorc and DK. Add 3 + adds and my DK skyrockets and outperforms all others.
f047ys3v3n wrote: »Flameheart wrote: »For PvE dps I don't think that magicka NBs are that far behind other magicka class dps builds. While I think that magicka templars have the strongest single target dps at moment (which relies to a major amount on their superior execute skill), imho the perceived dps differencies in compare to other classes like a sorc and especially the DK relies on the fact that many boss fights in Trials and vMoL include adds and there a Sorc and a DK just shines. Both have a strong ground dps skill (Liquid Lighting, Eruption) and while the Sorc has curse and additional AoE splash damage (Force Pulse), the DK has Engulfing Flames and to a lesser degree Flames of Oblivion (and is able to pack even more AoE dps with Burning Talons and Draw Essence if he wants). Therefore newer builds advice to use Force Pulse as a NB too, if you want to squeeze the very last part of dps out of your toon.
Add to that, that imho the rota of a NB is not that fluently and simple to play as of other classes, because of Assassins Will and rebuffing and that ESO somehow "forgot" to add a new "meta" monster set for NBs which can rival Grothdarr or Ilambris, you may have lost some ground in compare to other classes, but nothing at a serious degree.
I play all 4 clases as magicka builds in vet trials and I can achieve around the same dps as long it's pure single target with Sorc, NB and DK, maybe just the templar shines a bit more. Add 2 adds to that and I succeed with my Sorc and DK. Add 3 + adds and my DK skyrockets and outperforms all others.
Yea, the llambris not procing on magic damage is a big F-U to NB's. So many other sets also scale well of the 3x hits of force pulse vs the 1x hit of funnel. Sure you can to force pulse with NB but what, I ask, is the point of NB then. You also have fewer good DOT's than any other class so valken is out. There just really isn't a set for NB's. Llambris tested best on mine but it is barely better than a 5x5x1 build and nothing compared to a sorc on Llambris.
There have been a lot of NB nerfs lately. 1x instead of 2x funnel off heals. No funnel double crit heal (that was a huge nerf in practice btw.) The destruction of sap heals by making them a flat instead of scaling heal. 25% increase in the cost of funnel. Cloak delaying instead of removing dot's. Flare to destroy a cloked nb. Making relentless overlap with other things as a buff. No good 2pc monster compared to llambris sorc grothdar dk and templar and krag on anything stam.
I can't say it has been good and I can't say that my mNB is doing competitive dps or is even marginally effective in PvP. I can say that it is still a very clean class to run in vMA and that, at 27k unbuffed on bloodspawn I can still get in less than top tier raids. I can also say that I have been practicing and kitting out a sorc for the last few weeks and just completed vMA with it. Llambris was perhaps the last straw. At a time they certainly should have figured out that they should have been buffing NB they comparatively nerfed it. I am still better on the NB than the sorc so still using it and I do think it's rotation is easier but I am trying to switch. I tell you, if vMA had ever given me those stam weapons I would have gone stam sorc ages ago.
Honestly, I know so many have said magica is doing just fine but I still see stam builds getting all the big dps numbers in every group I have been in.
TotallyNotVos wrote: »
Most competitive raid groups dont even accept stam into them in the current meta. Magicka is just that much better.
The top 3 raids in the game right now are running 0 stam
If you arent seeing any good magicka parses in any of the groups youre in, that isnt magickas fault. Those are just bad dps/your stam dps are alot better players
Mordenkainen wrote: »I think it's hard to disagree that magicka nightblades are currently at the rear end of anything PvE DPS related. Note: I am speaking of PvE and PvE only here, so whatever PvP might look like, I stopped setting foot into cyrodiil a long time ago, I have no idea about that.
So here's hoping for a reply from ZOS if there are any ideas flying around of improving upon that or not. No demands, no whining, nothing attached.
I also would like to ask the Magicka NBs in the community how they are faring. I myself get almost close to 30k dps, but even then - I really have to almost break my fingers on my keyboard to get there.
Magblades are so underrated, even after the update this class is a solo Juggernaut. Can't speak for pvp,but pve it's my go to for any situation.
f047ys3v3n wrote: »TotallyNotVos wrote: »
Most competitive raid groups dont even accept stam into them in the current meta. Magicka is just that much better.
The top 3 raids in the game right now are running 0 stam
If you arent seeing any good magicka parses in any of the groups youre in, that isnt magickas fault. Those are just bad dps/your stam dps are alot better players
I was aware that the big dogs were doing magica. I was to understand that this was basically do to the mechanics involved in some of the content and most specifically to the need for harness in vMoL hard mode. It may well be that the best stam players I regularly play with are simply a lot better than the best magica ones. I do regularly play with some very good stam players. Only one of them started as stam though. All the other got their vMA weps on magic and converted because of how high the dps was and too be fair, the highest mag dps I have ever seen in even those world beater youtube parses is 44k and I have seen 55k from stam dk's a number of times in real life. I get that the elite are playing mag but I really don't think it for the dps. Rather, I think they can live with the dps for certain other advantages.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=182BL1wwpoA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wyfnrooiB8EPvp is a joke being a magblade. I have 52k mag with 10k shields and it's still not enough for all the damage these proc builds are putting out. If you enjoy hiding and watching the enemy then magblade is the build for you.
TotallyNotVos wrote: »TotallyNotVos wrote: »Not to mention funnel is currently broken so they can't even give much support right now
Broken? In what way?
The light attack weave timing is completely off from what its supposed to be
TotallyNotVos wrote: »TotallyNotVos wrote: »Not to mention funnel is currently broken so they can't even give much support right now
Broken? In what way?
The light attack weave timing is completely off from what its supposed to be
That's not a funnel health issue that's a la weave issue. I've been able to replicate the la weaving problems using cripple and other skills. I also have no issues weaving funnel health with destro staffs but when I try to weave with dual wield it borks. They borked it after TG update. Might have something to do with la graphic animation changes they implemented or anti cheat measures. No one knows for sure. However, if you weave in block you can still animation cancel.
I main a magblade, and I have zero issues with LA-weaving Funnel. In fact, I'd say that Force Pulse is the harder one to weave, and I get much more consistent weaves with Funnel than with Force Pulse.TotallyNotVos wrote: »TotallyNotVos wrote: »Not to mention funnel is currently broken so they can't even give much support right now
Broken? In what way?
The light attack weave timing is completely off from what its supposed to be
Magicka NB has been in a terrible spot for a few patches now. In both PvE and PvP. Not to say they're not playable and don't have their use, yet it hurts to play compared to a year ago.
Funnel Health needs a damage buff.
Path needs a damage buff.
Merciless Resolve needs to be reworked.
Concealed Weapon needs a damage buff.
Sap Essence needs a damage buff.
All in all Mageblades have great utility. From their debuffs and buffs to their secondary healing capabilities are all useful. Yet in a meta, both PvE and PvP, where damage is king they're in last place by a large margin. Even if they use Force Pulse as their spammable DPS over Funnel they're still last place compared to the other classes.
Suppose this is what they get when everyone complained about how OP they were for many of patches. They got the nerf hammer hard and ZoS never went back to take a second look.
IzakiBrotheSs wrote: »Pvp is a joke being a magblade. I have 52k mag with 10k shields and it's still not enough for all the damage these proc builds are putting out. If you enjoy hiding and watching the enemy then magblade is the build for you.
If you have 52k magicka and 10k shields you must really be doing something wrong. On my magicka sorc, my Dampen is at around 14k with 51.7k magicka in Cyrodiil. My Hardened Ward is around 15k-16k. Dunno what you're doing wrong but you're doing something wrong.
Magicka NB has been in a terrible spot for a few patches now. In both PvE and PvP. Not to say they're not playable and don't have their use, yet it hurts to play compared to a year ago.
Funnel Health needs a damage buff.
Path needs a damage buff.
Merciless Resolve needs to be reworked.
Concealed Weapon needs a damage buff.
Sap Essence needs a damage buff.
All in all Mageblades have great utility. From their debuffs and buffs to their secondary healing capabilities are all useful. Yet in a meta, both PvE and PvP, where damage is king they're in last place by a large margin. Even if they use Force Pulse as their spammable DPS over Funnel they're still last place compared to the other classes.
Suppose this is what they get when everyone complained about how OP they were for many of patches. They got the nerf hammer hard and ZoS never went back to take a second look.
The only nerf that we got in recent patches was to the distribution and crit of Funnel's heals. Magblades have been the most unchanged and steady-state class since Thieves Guild. The power creep in other classes may make us look weaker in comparison, but magblades are still the most versatile and well-rounded class in the game and still a lot of fun to play, even if we can't top damage charts.
Speaking as someone who mains a magblade, I think there is so much that's being overblown here. Could we use a bit of a buff, to keep up with the rest of the power creep in the game? Sure. But I would not say we're in a "terrible" spot by any means.
TotallyNotVos wrote: »It isnt only about the shields. Its about trial strategies.
Stamina does alot of dps, im not arguing that. But they only have the ability to pull either really high single target dps or really high aoe, they do not have the ability to do both at the same time like magicka does. For instance magicka can focus bosses down while letting their ground dots kill the adds that almost every boss in eso now has, and on top of that almost all of those adds NEED to die. Its because of this that you can now skip lunar on maw hardmode because magicka has enough single target to totally skip the lunar phase while not worrying about any of the adds. I guarantee you stamina cannot do that.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=182BL1wwpoA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wyfnrooiB8E
And it isnt only for maw, the top scores of all trials are groups of almost exclusively magicka. The time that magicka can clear trash beats the time that stamina can kill bosses as well
f047ys3v3n wrote: »TotallyNotVos wrote: »It isnt only about the shields. Its about trial strategies.
Stamina does alot of dps, im not arguing that. But they only have the ability to pull either really high single target dps or really high aoe, they do not have the ability to do both at the same time like magicka does. For instance magicka can focus bosses down while letting their ground dots kill the adds that almost every boss in eso now has, and on top of that almost all of those adds NEED to die. Its because of this that you can now skip lunar on maw hardmode because magicka has enough single target to totally skip the lunar phase while not worrying about any of the adds. I guarantee you stamina cannot do that.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=182BL1wwpoA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wyfnrooiB8E
And it isnt only for maw, the top scores of all trials are groups of almost exclusively magicka. The time that magicka can clear trash beats the time that stamina can kill bosses as well
Ahh, I think being having my primary dps be a magblade was why I did not consider this. The primary attack for templars is, after all, a cleave, pretty much all sorc attacks are either aoe's or do splash, and the DK equally is heavy on aoe dot's. Only the mag blade it rather lacking in this regard.
Those two parses are amazing by the way. I am especially blown away by the sorc one since that toon has range and versatility.
On a different note, I really don't think the mag blade needs some huge general boost to be viable in PvE dps. Simply making twisting path a decent dot would do. Back when we had Ninglenele for testing I worked up a rotation test macro with perfected timings and path was unequivocally a dps loss of around 1k. If you changed path to 8 seconds and gave it damage equivalent to wall that would be all the skill changes needed. NB's simply are short on viable DOT's relative to other mag builds currently. Beyond that change, llambris needs to proc off of magic damage as well as it is the obvious choice for that mag nb in that it is ranged but simply doesn't proc off of much in the NB toolkit currently. With these two small changes NB would be back to running with other mag classes. As some have noted despite the relatively low dps output it otherwise still runs well with a very high amount of utility. It is just that some content now wants a higher dps and it is hampered by lack of good sets and one of it's primary DOT's actually being a damage loss to run.
Magicka NB has been in a terrible spot for a few patches now. In both PvE and PvP. Not to say they're not playable and don't have their use, yet it hurts to play compared to a year ago.
Funnel Health needs a damage buff.
Path needs a damage buff.
Merciless Resolve needs to be reworked.
Concealed Weapon needs a damage buff.
Sap Essence needs a damage buff.
All in all Mageblades have great utility. From their debuffs and buffs to their secondary healing capabilities are all useful. Yet in a meta, both PvE and PvP, where damage is king they're in last place by a large margin. Even if they use Force Pulse as their spammable DPS over Funnel they're still last place compared to the other classes.
Suppose this is what they get when everyone complained about how OP they were for many of patches. They got the nerf hammer hard and ZoS never went back to take a second look.
The only nerf that we got in recent patches was to the distribution and crit of Funnel's heals. Magblades have been the most unchanged and steady-state class since Thieves Guild. The power creep in other classes may make us look weaker in comparison, but magblades are still the most versatile and well-rounded class in the game and still a lot of fun to play, even if we can't top damage charts.
Speaking as someone who mains a magblade, I think there is so much that's being overblown here. Could we use a bit of a buff, to keep up with the rest of the power creep in the game? Sure. But I would not say we're in a "terrible" spot by any means.
Mageblades are in a terrible spot. The numbers are like Shakira's hips, they don't lie.
TotallyNotVos wrote: »
I agree that twisting path specifically needs to do more damage, and I think cripple could be slightly buffed as well. However it seems like alot if people want funnel buffed as well which I don't really understand as it should do less damage since it gives a heal.
We are actually going to start running a magblade for maw hardmode, so I'm probably going to pick it up and maybe I can upload some good parses. We are consistently getting rakkhat to ~55% on hardmode and I think a magblade is what we need to down him