NewBlacksmurf wrote: »mistermutiny89 wrote: »NewBlacksmurf wrote: »mistermutiny89 wrote: »NewBlacksmurf wrote: »mistermutiny89 wrote: »NewBlacksmurf wrote: »mistermutiny89 wrote: »Nice article.
Just an inevitable comment on the tank stamina thing... I use a glyph of absorb stamina on my main weapon and some well-placed champion points to boost my stamina recovery with heavy attacks. I get that tanks are supposed to be blocking "most of the time", but that doesn't mean you have to completely dependent on other peoples skill sets. And there's usually plenty of time in between blocking to leech some stamina back, buff, debuff etc.
But yes... good article for the intended audience, and not critical know-it-alls like me.
Thank you! and of course, I'm too much of a wimp to risk heavy attacks whilst tanking, but thanks to swallow soul being so cheap and siphoning attacks I just spam that out of block to self heal and get back stam. But I'm defs more a dps guy. Tanking is not my forte but I'd like to think I know the role. haha Sort of.NewBlacksmurf wrote: »Please consider this is your personal preference and now that its on the forums...but it differs from the ZOS articles and roles.
I would consider this more of an ideal situation based on a particular experience you want so therefore, I'd say you should never use the PUG an only use manual groups. Then queue when full
Another monstrously opposed reply from Smurf, good to know you haven't changed, and that you aren't on EU haha.
As I'm glad ur on PC and EU.
Another overtly incorrect deduction from Smurf. Feel free to use the "full site" version on your phone to read player signatures. I find your signature with your ideas on a new levelling and gear system particularly amusing and further proof of your short sightedness when it comes to this game's direction a little saddening, but the poll already underlined that. It's always a blast with you smurf. Keep on, keeping on!
I see your sig say Xbox EU but my comment was as off base as your OP.
See there are concepts and expectations that go with roles and MMORPG games but the tone of your post comes off as play this way or gtfo.
To me that's crazy and it also doesn't align with the companies game guide so while this is your perspective and some others agree....I've found that taking and holding this perspective isn't good for the social interactions or enjoying gameplay long term as the circle that holds this mindset is very small in comparison to the vast amount of players who successfully run dungeons in PUGs each night.
Mdiff strokes for diff folks but realize I have changed but perhaps you have not which is why you have this perspective or opinion about me.
Some are already finding my guide helpful. Some find it offensive. As stated in the thread. It's not a build guide, it's a role guide. If your tank can't taunt, you are not a tank. If your healer does nothing but heal, you aren't an effective healer. If your dps spams wrecking blow till kingdom come without any dots or aoes, you are not an effective dps. These are FACTS. Yes? Something you rarely dip your toes in.
You live in this world where you believe you're fighting for employee of the month. But you aren't an employee. You're a fan, with a passion that may match mine for the game, but it's twisted and deluded. And that's a shame. We both read each other's statements poorly but in this instance I stick by the fact that these are really decent guidelines. I'm in sometimes eight pugs a day. I've seen a lot and this guide could help many.
This is not an attack on the pug community, I'm endeavoring to better it. You won't see that though... If I say the sky is blue, you'll say it's red. That's you. You haven't changed.
When you post something using the word "checklist" and instruct ppl to read it before using the vet dungeon tool, you are insulting people, offending people and there are always those who share your points of view as well.
Some things are obvious but this post seeks to encourage the forum community to adhere to a concept that isn't the design intent of the game. Furthermore from hands on you and I know that this "checklist" is completely opinionated.
Tanks- while they should shield the group, stun, block and pull, they don't "have to taunt".
Dps- shouldn't do a lot of aoe unless the group builds allow CC, heals and the other dos and tank to keep order
Healer - should heal but is welcomed to dos while healing as I can throw a heal on me and pop a potion too..
That's a lot of power in one little word. "Checklist". I wonder if I gave a random in the street a "checklist" asking them to give me a pedicure and clean my apartment if they'd do it?
Anyway. Good to know a tank shouldn't taunt. That a dps should focus on attacking one enemy out of the 10 they are attacking and that a healer should focus on themselves. Sounds like an awesome team!
It should be read as tanks shouldnt be required to taunt if they are otherwise effective.
You're making illogical conclusions from reading comments but again....whatever works for you, I just know that there are other ways to have success in those roles without using an old traditional trinity concept.
I am 100% sure you won't have success or be effective as a tank if you don't use taunt.
No matter what else you try to help your team. If the DDs get oneshotted by the boss because you failed to hold aggro, you failed your job as tank.
KoshkaMurka wrote: »
TheDarkShadow wrote: »This thread is not wrong. These are indeed what you should do if you want to fulfill your role in a group. But what people doing "wrong" here is they expect everyone they group with doing what this thread listed. You forgot that you cannot control other people. And you shouldn't. Trying to change people, even to make them better, is a hard task. It's like trying to argue and convince a priest, using all the scientific facts to prove that the Bible is wrong. Sometime you need to ask yourself: "Is it worth the time and the negative feeling? Am I playing this game for fun, to have a relax time, or am I taking a serious deed trying to change the way everyone play the game." Don't let the way other people play ruin your fun. You can always drop group whenever you want, and form your own group with people you prefer to play with rather than random people.
KoshkaMurka wrote: »TheDarkShadow wrote: »This thread is not wrong. These are indeed what you should do if you want to fulfill your role in a group. But what people doing "wrong" here is they expect everyone they group with doing what this thread listed. You forgot that you cannot control other people. And you shouldn't. Trying to change people, even to make them better, is a hard task. It's like trying to argue and convince a priest, using all the scientific facts to prove that the Bible is wrong. Sometime you need to ask yourself: "Is it worth the time and the negative feeling? Am I playing this game for fun, to have a relax time, or am I taking a serious deed trying to change the way everyone play the game." Don't let the way other people play ruin your fun. You can always drop group whenever you want, and form your own group with people you prefer to play with rather than random people.
Its not about being better.
Its about nessesary mechanics. For example, if you queue as a healer, you should cast heals. If you dont, you might be the most fun and awesome person on Earth, but youre not a healer. Same with tanks and dds...
TheDarkShadow wrote: »KoshkaMurka wrote: »TheDarkShadow wrote: »This thread is not wrong. These are indeed what you should do if you want to fulfill your role in a group. But what people doing "wrong" here is they expect everyone they group with doing what this thread listed. You forgot that you cannot control other people. And you shouldn't. Trying to change people, even to make them better, is a hard task. It's like trying to argue and convince a priest, using all the scientific facts to prove that the Bible is wrong. Sometime you need to ask yourself: "Is it worth the time and the negative feeling? Am I playing this game for fun, to have a relax time, or am I taking a serious deed trying to change the way everyone play the game." Don't let the way other people play ruin your fun. You can always drop group whenever you want, and form your own group with people you prefer to play with rather than random people.
Its not about being better.
Its about nessesary mechanics. For example, if you queue as a healer, you should cast heals. If you dont, you might be the most fun and awesome person on Earth, but youre not a healer. Same with tanks and dds...
I didn't say you shouldn't, what I said is if you meet someone who doesn't then just take it easy, carry them or drop the group as you wish. No need to yell at them, then rage quit, feeling bitter for a whole day, and go to forums demand those people must be punished.
Umm how your gear is related to you fulfilling your role?dtm_samuraib16_ESO wrote: »Even more Elitism.
I am a fairly new player, I do not have more than 100k gold, I cannot keep up with gear to my level.
Sue me.
dtm_samuraib16_ESO wrote: »Man, I have 2 blue items, a ring and an ammy.
The rest is green.
And WAY out of date.
I'm level 39 with even parts level 20, since no stuff comes along for my character.
KoshkaMurka wrote: »TheDarkShadow wrote: »KoshkaMurka wrote: »TheDarkShadow wrote: »This thread is not wrong. These are indeed what you should do if you want to fulfill your role in a group. But what people doing "wrong" here is they expect everyone they group with doing what this thread listed. You forgot that you cannot control other people. And you shouldn't. Trying to change people, even to make them better, is a hard task. It's like trying to argue and convince a priest, using all the scientific facts to prove that the Bible is wrong. Sometime you need to ask yourself: "Is it worth the time and the negative feeling? Am I playing this game for fun, to have a relax time, or am I taking a serious deed trying to change the way everyone play the game." Don't let the way other people play ruin your fun. You can always drop group whenever you want, and form your own group with people you prefer to play with rather than random people.
Its not about being better.
Its about nessesary mechanics. For example, if you queue as a healer, you should cast heals. If you dont, you might be the most fun and awesome person on Earth, but youre not a healer. Same with tanks and dds...
I didn't say you shouldn't, what I said is if you meet someone who doesn't then just take it easy, carry them or drop the group as you wish. No need to yell at them, then rage quit, feeling bitter for a whole day, and go to forums demand those people must be punished.
First, Im not expecting high numbers from randoms. I just expect them to play the role they've chosen.
If they dont want to, I dont want to carry them either. Because sure, I can carry, but what if they meet a person who is new and doesnt have crafted sets and capped cps? What they will do, if theyre spoiled by people carrying them? >.> If a player wants to cooperate, he/she is already not bad in my book.
Also, from my experience, players who dont wanna cooperate and players who yell at healers are the same kind of people. Its not about gear, its not about skill even. But not wanting to help your group by playing your role is just outright rude, and people who do that are usually rude in other situations as well. I never, ever saw a player who would be super bad and super friendly at the same time.
And I dont see any reason to be nice to people who are not nice to me and the rest of the group.
TheDarkShadow wrote: »KoshkaMurka wrote: »TheDarkShadow wrote: »KoshkaMurka wrote: »TheDarkShadow wrote: »This thread is not wrong. These are indeed what you should do if you want to fulfill your role in a group. But what people doing "wrong" here is they expect everyone they group with doing what this thread listed. You forgot that you cannot control other people. And you shouldn't. Trying to change people, even to make them better, is a hard task. It's like trying to argue and convince a priest, using all the scientific facts to prove that the Bible is wrong. Sometime you need to ask yourself: "Is it worth the time and the negative feeling? Am I playing this game for fun, to have a relax time, or am I taking a serious deed trying to change the way everyone play the game." Don't let the way other people play ruin your fun. You can always drop group whenever you want, and form your own group with people you prefer to play with rather than random people.
Its not about being better.
Its about nessesary mechanics. For example, if you queue as a healer, you should cast heals. If you dont, you might be the most fun and awesome person on Earth, but youre not a healer. Same with tanks and dds...
I didn't say you shouldn't, what I said is if you meet someone who doesn't then just take it easy, carry them or drop the group as you wish. No need to yell at them, then rage quit, feeling bitter for a whole day, and go to forums demand those people must be punished.
First, Im not expecting high numbers from randoms. I just expect them to play the role they've chosen.
If they dont want to, I dont want to carry them either. Because sure, I can carry, but what if they meet a person who is new and doesnt have crafted sets and capped cps? What they will do, if theyre spoiled by people carrying them? >.> If a player wants to cooperate, he/she is already not bad in my book.
Also, from my experience, players who dont wanna cooperate and players who yell at healers are the same kind of people. Its not about gear, its not about skill even. But not wanting to help your group by playing your role is just outright rude, and people who do that are usually rude in other situations as well. I never, ever saw a player who would be super bad and super friendly at the same time.
And I dont see any reason to be nice to people who are not nice to me and the rest of the group.
Simply drop group.
dtm_samuraib16_ESO wrote: »How kind, good Sir, and yes, I am on Europe (being Belgian).
I am a Summoner, so, I can still go and depend on my Summons, it's just becomes problematic when i have to take on a boss my level, or when I get swarmed by more than 5 NPC's.
The RNG however is to be blamed.
Here's a STUPID example: in my lower levels, I kept getting plate mail with Magicka support.
Me, wearing Light armor, didn't get anything else.
So, at level 19, I got SO frikken tired of it, that I did a full skill reset, and revamped to Heavy Armor.
Only to come to the conclusion, that since the moment I did my reset into HA, the game began to give NOTHING but, INDEED, Light Armor.
Kind of figures, right?
dtm_samuraib16_ESO wrote: »How kind, good Sir, and yes, I am on Europe (being Belgian).
I am a Summoner, so, I can still go and depend on my Summons, it's just becomes problematic when i have to take on a boss my level, or when I get swarmed by more than 5 NPC's.
The RNG however is to be blamed.
Here's a STUPID example: in my lower levels, I kept getting plate mail with Magicka support.
Me, wearing Light armor, didn't get anything else.
So, at level 19, I got SO frikken tired of it, that I did a full skill reset, and revamped to Heavy Armor.
Only to come to the conclusion, that since the moment I did my reset into HA, the game began to give NOTHING but, INDEED, Light Armor.
Kind of figures, right?
dtm_samuraib16_ESO wrote: »Name is @Xogroroth, sir.
If you are to craft, please make it level 40, since like 10% from that level.
Thank you very much.
dtm_samuraib16_ESO wrote: »Man, I have 2 blue items, a ring and an ammy.
The rest is green.
And WAY out of date.
I'm level 39 with even parts level 20, since no stuff comes along for my character.
dtm_samuraib16_ESO wrote: »Man, I have 2 blue items, a ring and an ammy.
The rest is green.
And WAY out of date.
I'm level 39 with even parts level 20, since no stuff comes along for my character.
KoshkaMurka wrote: »TheDarkShadow wrote: »KoshkaMurka wrote: »TheDarkShadow wrote: »KoshkaMurka wrote: »TheDarkShadow wrote: »This thread is not wrong. These are indeed what you should do if you want to fulfill your role in a group. But what people doing "wrong" here is they expect everyone they group with doing what this thread listed. You forgot that you cannot control other people. And you shouldn't. Trying to change people, even to make them better, is a hard task. It's like trying to argue and convince a priest, using all the scientific facts to prove that the Bible is wrong. Sometime you need to ask yourself: "Is it worth the time and the negative feeling? Am I playing this game for fun, to have a relax time, or am I taking a serious deed trying to change the way everyone play the game." Don't let the way other people play ruin your fun. You can always drop group whenever you want, and form your own group with people you prefer to play with rather than random people.
Its not about being better.
Its about nessesary mechanics. For example, if you queue as a healer, you should cast heals. If you dont, you might be the most fun and awesome person on Earth, but youre not a healer. Same with tanks and dds...
I didn't say you shouldn't, what I said is if you meet someone who doesn't then just take it easy, carry them or drop the group as you wish. No need to yell at them, then rage quit, feeling bitter for a whole day, and go to forums demand those people must be punished.
First, Im not expecting high numbers from randoms. I just expect them to play the role they've chosen.
If they dont want to, I dont want to carry them either. Because sure, I can carry, but what if they meet a person who is new and doesnt have crafted sets and capped cps? What they will do, if theyre spoiled by people carrying them? >.> If a player wants to cooperate, he/she is already not bad in my book.
Also, from my experience, players who dont wanna cooperate and players who yell at healers are the same kind of people. Its not about gear, its not about skill even. But not wanting to help your group by playing your role is just outright rude, and people who do that are usually rude in other situations as well. I never, ever saw a player who would be super bad and super friendly at the same time.
And I dont see any reason to be nice to people who are not nice to me and the rest of the group.
Simply drop group.
What if only one person doesnt wanna cooperate and the rest are fine?
TheDarkShadow wrote: »KoshkaMurka wrote: »TheDarkShadow wrote: »KoshkaMurka wrote: »TheDarkShadow wrote: »KoshkaMurka wrote: »TheDarkShadow wrote: »This thread is not wrong. These are indeed what you should do if you want to fulfill your role in a group. But what people doing "wrong" here is they expect everyone they group with doing what this thread listed. You forgot that you cannot control other people. And you shouldn't. Trying to change people, even to make them better, is a hard task. It's like trying to argue and convince a priest, using all the scientific facts to prove that the Bible is wrong. Sometime you need to ask yourself: "Is it worth the time and the negative feeling? Am I playing this game for fun, to have a relax time, or am I taking a serious deed trying to change the way everyone play the game." Don't let the way other people play ruin your fun. You can always drop group whenever you want, and form your own group with people you prefer to play with rather than random people.
Its not about being better.
Its about nessesary mechanics. For example, if you queue as a healer, you should cast heals. If you dont, you might be the most fun and awesome person on Earth, but youre not a healer. Same with tanks and dds...
I didn't say you shouldn't, what I said is if you meet someone who doesn't then just take it easy, carry them or drop the group as you wish. No need to yell at them, then rage quit, feeling bitter for a whole day, and go to forums demand those people must be punished.
First, Im not expecting high numbers from randoms. I just expect them to play the role they've chosen.
If they dont want to, I dont want to carry them either. Because sure, I can carry, but what if they meet a person who is new and doesnt have crafted sets and capped cps? What they will do, if theyre spoiled by people carrying them? >.> If a player wants to cooperate, he/she is already not bad in my book.
Also, from my experience, players who dont wanna cooperate and players who yell at healers are the same kind of people. Its not about gear, its not about skill even. But not wanting to help your group by playing your role is just outright rude, and people who do that are usually rude in other situations as well. I never, ever saw a player who would be super bad and super friendly at the same time.
And I dont see any reason to be nice to people who are not nice to me and the rest of the group.
Simply drop group.
What if only one person doesnt wanna cooperate and the rest are fine?
Send tell to those people, all drop group, invite those you want to group with, use group finder to fill the last spot. Now you have lead, you can kick whoever you don't want.
KoshkaMurka wrote: »TheDarkShadow wrote: »KoshkaMurka wrote: »TheDarkShadow wrote: »KoshkaMurka wrote: »TheDarkShadow wrote: »KoshkaMurka wrote: »TheDarkShadow wrote: »This thread is not wrong. These are indeed what you should do if you want to fulfill your role in a group. But what people doing "wrong" here is they expect everyone they group with doing what this thread listed. You forgot that you cannot control other people. And you shouldn't. Trying to change people, even to make them better, is a hard task. It's like trying to argue and convince a priest, using all the scientific facts to prove that the Bible is wrong. Sometime you need to ask yourself: "Is it worth the time and the negative feeling? Am I playing this game for fun, to have a relax time, or am I taking a serious deed trying to change the way everyone play the game." Don't let the way other people play ruin your fun. You can always drop group whenever you want, and form your own group with people you prefer to play with rather than random people.
Its not about being better.
Its about nessesary mechanics. For example, if you queue as a healer, you should cast heals. If you dont, you might be the most fun and awesome person on Earth, but youre not a healer. Same with tanks and dds...
I didn't say you shouldn't, what I said is if you meet someone who doesn't then just take it easy, carry them or drop the group as you wish. No need to yell at them, then rage quit, feeling bitter for a whole day, and go to forums demand those people must be punished.
First, Im not expecting high numbers from randoms. I just expect them to play the role they've chosen.
If they dont want to, I dont want to carry them either. Because sure, I can carry, but what if they meet a person who is new and doesnt have crafted sets and capped cps? What they will do, if theyre spoiled by people carrying them? >.> If a player wants to cooperate, he/she is already not bad in my book.
Also, from my experience, players who dont wanna cooperate and players who yell at healers are the same kind of people. Its not about gear, its not about skill even. But not wanting to help your group by playing your role is just outright rude, and people who do that are usually rude in other situations as well. I never, ever saw a player who would be super bad and super friendly at the same time.
And I dont see any reason to be nice to people who are not nice to me and the rest of the group.
Simply drop group.
What if only one person doesnt wanna cooperate and the rest are fine?
Send tell to those people, all drop group, invite those you want to group with, use group finder to fill the last spot. Now you have lead, you can kick whoever you don't want.
I have no specific desire to kick anyone, if youre trying to imply that.