My only issue with the AI implementations bit; the mandatory feel of it all.
Already we have guilds that require members to download a certain add-on to be able to participate, and allowing those functions into the game will make it so you have no viable excuse for not using it.
Toggling them off will be the equivalent of intentionally gimping yourself, and because the features are so readily available, people can and will judge your preferences as among the most hazardous play styles and will likely discriminate.
Keeping them restricted to add-ons make even the most commonly used downloaded features actually feel like a choice in use and not an obligation.
Please, also acknowledge that you're not alone in this world and the hundreds of thousands of people who download addons to just make the UI bearable clearly disagree with you.
Nox_Aeterna wrote: »I agree , some ADDONs are must have to me , i actually wouldnt even play this game anymore without them at this point.
While i agree that the reason ADDONs are there is to minimize how the devs have to work on stuff like this (not that the devs here even work much anyway so they have plenty of spare time) , basic features are still the devs responsibility , even more when they break said ADDONs each patch.
You just repeated everything the OP said.Wykkyd's Framework tools have over 1 000 000 downloads.
FTC has around 600 000 downloads.
Here is why these add on systems should not be made part of the game. I don't use them. I don't want them forced on me. It's great that others can use them if they want to.
I use a part of FTC, just to give me numbers on my exp bars (and I think there is another add on that might do that by itself). Everything else on that addon is disabled. Never wanted to use Wykkyds Framework. This is not a commentary on these addons, it is just personal preference. I have 3 map add ons and a crafting research add on. And, that's it. The last thing I want is a bunch of numbers and text all over the screen while I play. It makes for an ugly game. My UI is nicely uncluttered, thank you very much.
The game allows addons, just use the ones that give you the UI experience you want, and let the rest of us play with stock UI or the UI we want to play with. ZOS does not need to make the UI anything else than what it is, moddable.
Besides, as soon as you force a UI onto me, then I can no longer play the way that I want to.
nerevarine1138 wrote: »Love,
Everyone Else
The guilds that currently require addons to accept you in their groups will not accept you if you don't download addon, if you "don't know" or "can't" it's not really an issue since there always are more people that are ready to install the addon and want to take the spot.
Fearing that people will "require" the UI elements to be activated will change nothing to that what so ever.
If you take into account the fact that:
- The addons are already available.
- Some guilds require them allready and the good ones that doubt your skills won't accept "no" for an answer.
- It wouldn't change anything if for people who don't use them since anything could be disabled.
The only logical explanation on why people can be so selfish as too deny the opportunity to other players to play how they want is because they know they suck and they fear other people will realize it if things like a DPS meter are implemented (actually, when people ask for DPS, it's because they suspect you suck, if there was no way to link DPS, those people would just be excluded right away). Thus, just because of one single thing, the whole UI should keep sucking and people's gaming experience hindered because of it.
Dear Zenimax,
Please Zenimax:
Fix your UI, make it so it's fully customizable by the players (move the basic elements around to place them as we want), give us the possibility to see numbers or percentages if we so choose to, let us enable or disable a minimap at will, let us save presets of our skill bars (I know you're working on armor presets which is awesome), allow the API to offer, once again, information about buffs/debuffs, nametags (at least for the same alliance), work with popular addon makers to support their addons and make their work easier since without them and the work they do to complete your game, many people would have left.
Immersion is fine most of the time but there are some times we also want to know what's going on with our character and by forcing us to be ignorant, you're not fulfilling your "Play as you want" promise which I'm sure you regret already.
As stated above, addons are an unreliable and sometimes untrustworthy solution. I could play for a year and suddenly an addon I rely heavily upon could be broken and unsupported. That could seriously impact my enjoyment of the game.
I just can't wrap my head around the rationale of people speaking out against this. It would effect you in absolutely zero ways. It wouldn't even detract from development progression in other areas of the game.
Nobody loses, and yet so many people are so adamant about shooting it down.
Dear Zenimax,
Please Zenimax:
Fix your UI, make it so it's fully customizable by the players (move the basic elements around to place them as we want), give us the possibility to see numbers or percentages if we so choose to, let us enable or disable a minimap at will, let us save presets of our skill bars (I know you're working on armor presets which is awesome), allow the API to offer, once again, information about buffs/debuffs, nametags (at least for the same alliance), work with popular addon makers to support their addons and make their work easier since without them and the work they do to complete your game, many people would have left.
Immersion is fine most of the time but there are some times we also want to know what's going on with our character and by forcing us to be ignorant, you're not fulfilling your "Play as you want" promise which I'm sure you regret already.
Do you realize that your "play as you want" is just a silly fake argument for "play as I want"?
If you get the information about DPS, Achievements etc. by using spy tools like recount then you will dictate how everyone has to play.
Do we really always need to bring the WOW argument here so that you "Elite" players understand that your way of playing is not "play as you want".
When Blizz opened up their API the game died because of Elitism and it hasn't recovered from it since then. Once the Box is opened ESO will suffer under the same issues where innocent people are kicked based on numbers alone.
It forces players to use a pro elite spec, to use pro elite sockets, to use pro elite professions, to even use macros, rotations and all of that. It takes away any type of freedom from players because Elitsts will expect that you play as the tool wants you to play and if you refuse you are insulted and kicked from groups.
Wykkyd's Framework tools have over 1 000 000 downloads.
FTC has around 600 000 downloads.
Here is why these add on systems should not be made part of the game. I don't use them. I don't want them forced on me. It's great that others can use them if they want to.
I use a part of FTC, just to give me numbers on my exp bars (and I think there is another add on that might do that by itself).
Besides, as soon as you force a UI onto me, then I can no longer play the way that I want to.
It forces players to use a pro elite spec, to use pro elite sockets, to use pro elite professions, to even use macros, rotations and all of that. It takes away any type of freedom from players because Elitsts will expect that you play as the tool wants you to play and if you refuse you are insulted and kicked from groups.
Once again, nobody has asked for a recount, then again, if people want to play that way and you don't, nobody is forcing you to team up with them. Many people QQ like you when we talk about addons, a LOT of people do. Nobody has ever mentioned recount or addons to spy on people yet people always bring that to the table.
I wonder why those people never grouped together? There are so many of them I suppose it wasn't hard to find each other and group with a bit of effort no? What's the problem if "Elitits" play together and "I play my way" people play together?
Ah I know, because you couldn't clear the Hard content maybe?you expect people who took hours of work of grind of play to get their sets, their rotation just to bring you alone and carry you out of the kindness of their hearts?
This is like people using stamina builds in trials QQing because no group will take them. Go make a full stamina group and try to clear the content, see how that goes for you...
Its bad enough that there are time trials and people who think that only a stick holder is able to clear content, we don't need to increase the hostility further by allowing said spy tools.
Let's see if I understand this issue. Some players want more UI featuers then are currently provided. Today, they use Addons for this functionality. The 'request' is for Zenimax to ADD these features to the default UI, so that these features will ALWAYS be avaliable (not worries about 3rd party Dev support).
Some players like the UI the way it is and don't want in changed.
OK, my thoughts. I think we can assume that any addon additions to the UI could be turned off, so some players no longer have anything to worry about. Some other players need to ask themselves some tough questions, like:
A) Do we really think Zenimax Devs best use of time is on UI features we already "have"?If we incentivised those 3rd party Devs more, would they stay around? Are you giving them more than a pat on the back?
Summary - send the 3rd party Devs (I'm not one) more love! Problem solved.
The guilds that currently require addons to accept you in their groups will not accept you if you don't download addon, if you "don't know" or "can't" it's not really an issue since there always are more people that are ready to install the addon and want to take the spot.
Fearing that people will "require" the UI elements to be activated will change nothing to that what so ever.
If you take into account the fact that:
- The addons are already available.
- Some guilds require them allready and the good ones that doubt your skills won't accept "no" for an answer.
- It wouldn't change anything if for people who don't use them since anything could be disabled.
The only logical explanation on why people can be so selfish as too deny the opportunity to other players to play how they want is because they know they suck and they fear other people will realize it if things like a DPS meter are implemented (actually, when people ask for DPS, it's because they suspect you suck, if there was no way to link DPS, those people would just be excluded right away). Thus, just because of one single thing, the whole UI should keep sucking and people's gaming experience hindered because of it.
The guilds that currently require addons to accept you in their groups will not accept you if you don't download addon, if you "don't know" or "can't" it's not really an issue since there always are more people that are ready to install the addon and want to take the spot.
Fearing that people will "require" the UI elements to be activated will change nothing to that what so ever.
If you take into account the fact that:
- The addons are already available.
- Some guilds require them allready and the good ones that doubt your skills won't accept "no" for an answer.
- It wouldn't change anything if for people who don't use them since anything could be disabled.
The only logical explanation on why people can be so selfish as too deny the opportunity to other players to play how they want is because they know they suck and they fear other people will realize it if things like a DPS meter are implemented (actually, when people ask for DPS, it's because they suspect you suck, if there was no way to link DPS, those people would just be excluded right away). Thus, just because of one single thing, the whole UI should keep sucking and people's gaming experience hindered because of it.
I disagree with many points here, though many are already up for debate. To be clear, it is not so much the UI I have a problem with so much as it is the community.
Fearing that people will require the UI implementations to be toggled on is, in my humble opinion, a very real fear. Unlike the current set up where you can at leas t say something along the lines of "I don't trust add-ons", "I legitimately can't download stuff from X" and even the ol' "it isn't in the game so I don't think they had it in mind" excuse. Having it implemented into the game where only some sort of bug will hinder it, will leave players essentially feeling that there is no way to escape the mandatory toggle even if it deliberately hinders or otherwise dulls the genuine enjoyment of the game for them.
It is the impression(s) of players rather than the mechanics that are subject to mistreatment. You who want that exemplary UI have the means to implement them into your game, while others who want the minimalist UI have the leisure to not worry (much) over in-game pressure to play a certain way (with DPS meters, mini-map etc.). They suffer a bit from it already, but it still remains that many can still give excuses/reasons that they feel are legitimate.
Conversely, those who want some basic UI functions added and supported by the game currently feel like their own play style is hindered by "forced ignorance" with the current state of the game. As much as I sympathies for a good chunk of them, I am against the UI implementation idea purely because of the social stigma it may incite that can very easily make even the minimalistic UI favor-ists to say "play how you want is really play with the maximum amount of UI possible".
It is easy enough to remedy the ails of those who desire more UI. But for those who feel pressured into that playstyle? Not so much. They can't control the community.
Downloading an Add-On? Easy. Downloading an instant community changer? Impossible.
eventide03b14a_ESO wrote: »The UI is by far the worst thing in this game. I'm now getting messages that I need to reload my UI because I might run out of memory, yet I don't know how to delegate more memory to it. There is no way this game is using 12 GB of system RAM and 2GB of VRAM. I sincerely believe that their reliance on third party addons is the source of many issues. It's not immersive, it's lazy.
I just don't get why some people are so keen to turn ESO into a clone of every other MMO out there with numbers flying everywhere, cluttering up the gorgeous world.