Because there wouldnt be people moaning their class doesnt have dps if we werent forced by the game itself. See Wispmother boss in AA. I mean trials as we see them now are basically zerg fights.. all stack nuke, heal, finish trial in 10 minutes.. I mean.. is it really what we want? Why not make some interesting fight mechanics so people have to actually pay attention to the fight and react correctly. Also whats the point of the DPS requirement.. if someone is low at DPS let them fight the boss for 2 hours.. who cares? I bet downing the boss with guildies or friends after would feel awesome. Instead we are forced to do some boring zerg fests that make no sense. Point is.. why force dps checks on people especially in a game which promotes itself with motto : play the way you want ( as long as its light armor and fire staff ). What do you think people?

Also, if you answered YES, feel free to share on what is your opinion based. Or simply what makes you press YES.

The timer makes no sense for another reason -> in WoW lets say, you have an enrage timer but there is no way to tell how long it took you to defeat the whole raid. So the outcome is either + or -. You beat the raid or you dont. Why have enrage timers in a game that already records your groups time? I mean the hardcore would still have shorter times, but the enrage mechanics simply make the content impossible for people who dont want to play the way the game is forcing on them and that is light armor and fire/resto staff or whatever currently uber setup.

So we can say that the games motto - Play the way you want is a lie at the moment. Or at least needs to be changed to Play the way you want but youll barely make it in solo instances.

It's just a sign of very lazy development, whilst also causing balance headaches that wouldn't otherwise be so evident.

DPs checks already exist and are in game now

The DPS checks just need to be adjusted after the game is better balanced.

Shadowhorn wrote: »

Because there wouldnt be people moaning their class doesnt have dps if we werent forced by the game itself. See Wispmother boss in AA. I mean trials as we see them now are basically zerg fights.. all stack nuke, heal, finish trial in 10 minutes.. I mean.. is it really what we want? Why not make some interesting fight mechanics so people have to actually pay attention to the fight and react correctly. Also whats the point of the DPS requirement.. if someone is low at DPS let them fight the boss for 2 hours.. who cares? I bet downing the boss with guildies or friends after would feel awesome. Instead we are forced to do some boring zerg fests that make no sense. Point is.. why force dps checks on people especially in a game which promotes itself with motto : play the way you want ( as long as its light armor and fire staff ). What do you think people?

What this guy just said goes for me too.

Yes because if you do not have the gear or the ability to kill a boss in a certain amount of time (ie. enrage timers) then you should endeavor to come back when you are ready. Its not like your level 3 toon can kill lvl 49 mobs. It takes time.

Maverick827 wrote: »

Occasional DPS checks that are finely tuned to reward skill while still not requiring class stacking is good.

Universal DPS checks and the entire point of end-game PvE to do it as quickly as possible? Not good.

Trials should be abandoned. Make real raids next time.

Naw I like trials and don't think they should be done away with. That said I do want some large multi wing raids that you can spend a month or two progressing thru

Justiciar wrote: »

Maverick827 wrote: »

Occasional DPS checks that are finely tuned to reward skill while still not requiring class stacking is good.

Universal DPS checks and the entire point of end-game PvE to do it as quickly as possible? Not good.

Trials should be abandoned. Make real raids next time.

Naw I like trials and don't think they should be done away with. That said I do want some large multi wing raids that you can spend a month or two progressing thru

Trials being focused solely on completion time is not healthy for the game.

You know EQLive had DPS checks on EVERY MOB they would actually just enrage the instant their HP hit like 30% and would become harder to kill till their dead.

Luckly their was a few classes dedicated to handling that situation. At the same time their DPS was kept in check by a BRILLIANT system AGRO.

I think they should be there. It helps separate the good players from the bad, and gives players a reason to improve their character.

EDIT: I don't think they are good idea with the current state of some of the builds, but when some balance is achieved.

No, because a group that can avoid all the damage and not take any should be able to still down the bosses with their skill, they just aren't going to top the leader boards.

hk11 wrote: »

I think they should be there. It helps separate the good players from the bad, and gives players a reason to improve their character.

EDIT: I don't think they are good idea with the current state of some of the builds, but when some balance is achieved.

I thought thats why the trial times are recorded. What I am trying to point out in this topic is the following -> If there were no enrage timers on bosses people would be indeed able to play the build they want. But just because "elitists" who hardly ever play any other build than the one with the most DPS say "yeah the bosses were easy, whole place is easy" and the DEVS think everyone should be able to beat it.

This is just so stupid and wrong especially in a game where you can build so many interesting builds. I hope you understand my point. The groups of people testing endgame content running full light armor and destro/resto staves cant speak for the whole community, its nonsense.

No. DPs race bosses are boring. There are other ways to check it a team is ready.

No DPS checks and no timed trials and no damned leaderboards.If you want a an example where a game didn't have DPS checks and required a lot of skill than you have DarkSouls
The trials were the worst thing they did until now.The flood of cries for nerfs and balance is terrible. No rpg will ever manage to create the level of class or build balance required for their trial system unless they add easily reachable dps hard caps that are very close and equal to the no weapon no skill dps.