Every Whitestrake, the forums are littered with unhappy PvE players voicing their displeasure at feeling forced to into PvP. And similarly, every Whitestrake, PvP players turn out to remind the PvE players that there’s only this one PvP event. You’ll see a lot of “It’s 2025, in a 10 year old game - look up a PvP build and stop complaining”.
I’d like to preface this by saying: I, personally, like PvP in ESO. My main has x2 primary PvP specs. I enjoy Whitestrake’s. I’ve played since Beta. I have my achieves. I got my Golden Pursuit. This isn’t about me.
The problem, in my opinion, with Whitestrake's Mayhem is that it’s the only event that requires preparation, resources, and setup, in order to have any chance of participating and it not being a painful, ruthless, unpleasant grind.
Yes, essentially every other event is PvE. But essentially every other ticketed event is a participation incentive, and little else. I can’t think of another event that requires you to spec into it. Even ones that require (Normal) Dungeons, or Delve/World bosses can be done “suboptimally” without issue in PvP specs and gear. I know because I’ve done it. A lot. On braindead autopilot.
No, you definitely shouldn’t bring your PvP spec into a Veteran Hardmode DLC Dungeon.
But your PvP spec will do just fine in regular Fungal Grotto. You can eat cake, or visit a shrine in any spec. No one cares. It literally doesn’t matter. No one is forcing PvP players to respec for PvE events. PvP players just there for their tickets can do so without issue the vast, overwhelming majority of the time.
And that’s, I think, the key difference. I see so many rude, out of touch, condescending comments from players who have been playing for YEARS telling frustrated PvE players to “just go look up a PvP build”, and, like…
People may not have the right unlocks in their stickerbooks, &/or have the stockpiled Transmute Crystals to Reconstruct or Trait Swap freely.
People may not have a leveled Crafter, in order to make gear or swap traits.
People may not have the money to invest in buying tradeable PvP gear that they lack, or upgrading the gear they do have.
People may not have the appropriate Skill Lines unlocked at the appropriate level for the requested builds. That’s not even touching Scribing, which is another ocean of STUFF people may not have access to.
That’s not even touching practicing a rotation on a brand-new build long enough to be decent at it.
Of course: some of this isn’t as big a deal on an active 10-year old account because that person has likely already unlocked a lot of things to streamline the process.
“Looking up a build” and then implementing it is often costly, both in terms of in-game resources and time spent. It can be an ordeal, putting a single build together. People hate feeling pressured into spending time and resources on a mode of play they don’t even enjoy in the first place.
And I don’t blame anyone for not liking PvP. Simply put: while I’ve met a lot of wonderful PvPers, it also undeniably attracts larger contingent of jerks. “I don’t want to deal with a bunch of jerks” is a perfectly reasonable position for anyone to hold.
On a similar note, I’ve seen it posted that the universal sign for “I’m a PvE player just here for my Tickets/GP/Endeavors/Whatever” is to block and stand still when attacked in Cyrodiil/Imperial City. I enjoy PvP. I’m happy to engage. But on a whim I decided to test that advice while I was working on my Golden Pursuits this past weekend. When attacked, I’d just stand there holding block. No one respected the “universal sign”. That “advice” seems more like trolling, or at least wildly out of touch.
tl;dr - Whitestrake's Mayhem requires time, resources, and setup that the other events simply don’t and exposes people to a ton a griefing that other events simply don’t. PvE players aren’t mad that PvP players get their one singular event. They’re upset they have to invest so much more time and money to effectively participate than a PvP player does to participate in a PvE event, and then they often get treated like garbage by the dedicated PvP contingent for the effort. PvE players want a PvE option for the PvP Event because the investment is not at all on par with the other events, not because they’re whiners.
Edited by Barovia87 on February 25, 2025 3:25PM "Anyone who can play a stringed instrument seems to me a wizard worthy of deep respect." - J.R.R. Tolkien, Letter 142 Dec. 1953