ClowdyAllDay wrote: »This wouldn't be an "improvement" for me. I don't use TTC because I don't sell on traders, and it's pretty rare I buy on them. But the devs spending time on this would mean something I WOULD use might not be added.
Thank you for your input, but I would argue that a significant portion of the population, if not a majority, uses TTC and could benefit from an in-game solution which draws directly from ZOS' own data rather than relying on the players who have installed the tracking add-on and use an unreliable website which serves you advertisements and tracks your browsing habits.
are you just gonna spam us with that singular thought process the whole way down the page then? f so i'll simply move on to another topic. nothing to see here...
LadyLavina wrote: »Well hey @Danikat , haven't seen you around in a while. Thrilled to see you're still at least forum-active. Not common to see folks from the 2014 gang around these days. (I waited...like 3 years to get on the forums so I'm 2017 despite being launch/2014 myself x_x ) . Hope you're well.That's why I'd prefer ZOS to include the functionality in the game itself, they'd be able to do it much better than an addon can. But for now it's the best option available if you don't want to spend ages checking traders basically at random to find an item.
As for this though, I agree. There are many more pressing issues (as important as this one might be to us) that need to be addressed before this is messed with. I hope this is addressed eventually , but it will likely be a back-burner item until the more critical things are sorted.
FelisCatus wrote: »LadyLavina wrote: »Well hey @Danikat , haven't seen you around in a while. Thrilled to see you're still at least forum-active. Not common to see folks from the 2014 gang around these days. (I waited...like 3 years to get on the forums so I'm 2017 despite being launch/2014 myself x_x ) . Hope you're well.That's why I'd prefer ZOS to include the functionality in the game itself, they'd be able to do it much better than an addon can. But for now it's the best option available if you don't want to spend ages checking traders basically at random to find an item.
As for this though, I agree. There are many more pressing issues (as important as this one might be to some) that need to be addressed before this is messed with. I hope this is addressed eventually , but it will likely be a back-burner item until the more critical things are sorted.
Seems like everything has to be a backburner issue 'cos the game has so much spaghetti code.
wolfie1.0. wrote: »WhosTheFancyOneNow wrote: »No thank you. i trust the creators of TTC with their code and no one else.
You trust someone who you've never met, who runs a website chock full of ads and trackers, which frequently asks you to overcome captchas and sometimes doesn't even work over Zenimax Online Studios, the company which built the game you're here to play and discuss? You trust a third-party that is dependent on an in-game add-on for data when that information is readily available to ZOS and could be provided more consistently and dependably?
Why?
Let's be fair here....WhosTheFancyOneNow wrote: »^^ this post above says all and more
It never ceases to baffle me when people boldly step up and demand an inferior solution or nothing at all when someone suggests that ZOS do something to improve the game in some way. This kind of behavior is a big part of why ZOS chooses not to make improvements to the game - they've said as much in letters to the community. Reinforced complacency is equal to stagnation in an MMO, and ESO is suffering for it as far as I'm concerned. Keep in mind, I am not telling you that you can't play with the toys you have now.
Yes, ZOS would have to maintain the system, but it's relatively hands-off once it gets going. The system calls inventory tables and displays them in a form. Players can search and use the form, and then travel to the appropriate vendor to make a purchase. Exactly how TTC works right now, except it's internal and we don't have to deal with ads and trackers. And by the way, I truly do not care that the ads contribute to supporting the site. If I can have an internal system supported by ZOS itself, I will drop TTC in a heartbeat. I understand that it may be this person's livelihood, but it's bonkers that we have to result to this kind of solution when ZOS is more than capable of implementing something as good or better.
And as far as tying it to Plus is concerned, that would be silly because no one would use it. Everyone would continue using TTC anyway.
wolfie1.0. wrote: »We can demand a perfect product, we shouldn't EXPECT a perfect product. As reality has shown quite the contrary. which is why i caution players often here on the forums that what you request often wont be what you get.
personally i think they should remove it from the game. It may be a minority opinion but i think this addon and addons like it only serve to hurt the game, and absolutely go against what was originally intended for trading in this game.
It also allows people to inflate prices, and it removes a lot the "skill" of trading. Sure, knowledge still makes a very big difference but most players just brainlessly post things for whatever TTC tells them to, and sometimes they lose because of it. Im honestly not sure why zos has allowed it to exist for so long. You would think if they wanted a centralized auction house they would have designed the game in that way. This is just the same but run by players with no one from zos to oversee it.
Panderbander wrote: »Be careful what you wish for. I am almost certain the runaway inflation of prices on PC is a result of TTC and similar add-ons that simplify the process of pricing and finding items on traders.
Panderbander wrote: »Be careful what you wish for. I am almost certain the runaway inflation of prices on PC is a result of TTC and similar add-ons that simplify the process of pricing and finding items on traders.
Necrotech_Master wrote: »i dont like TTC in that it only goes off of the listing prices, not what stuff is actually sold for
i would not ever want that to be built into the game
i dont use the TTC website anymore even to just find if something is being sold somewhere for reasons mentioned in thread (too many ads, wont even work at all if you have an adblocker running), and i wouldnt use the addon in game because im not running the external client, and again dont like the data to be based on listings
Judas Helviaryn wrote: »Don't incorporate bugs into your builds, and you won't have [an] issue.
Necrotech_Master wrote: »i dont like TTC in that it only goes off of the listing prices, not what stuff is actually sold for
i would not ever want that to be built into the game
i dont use the TTC website anymore even to just find if something is being sold somewhere for reasons mentioned in thread (too many ads, wont even work at all if you have an adblocker running), and i wouldnt use the addon in game because im not running the external client, and again dont like the data to be based on listings
TTC shows sale average.
I don't think the fact that it shows statistics on listings instead of actual sales is that important, because in the long run, the sales are affected by the listings. Users of the addon will set an initial price based on the listings statistics, then if the item doesn't sell, or takes too long to sell, they lower the price and list the item again. So the listings and sales affect each other.Necrotech_Master wrote: »Necrotech_Master wrote: »i dont like TTC in that it only goes off of the listing prices, not what stuff is actually sold for
i would not ever want that to be built into the game
i dont use the TTC website anymore even to just find if something is being sold somewhere for reasons mentioned in thread (too many ads, wont even work at all if you have an adblocker running), and i wouldnt use the addon in game because im not running the external client, and again dont like the data to be based on listings
TTC shows sale average.
if it is then thats better than it used to be, though the majority of the info in your tooltip is still useless as the TTC suggested, avg, min, and max are all still listings, not sales data
im also assuming for it track sales data, it would only work for your guilds like the other tracking tools, so from my perspective, it makes no sense to use the addon as listing data is meaningless to me
I don't think the fact that it shows statistics on listings instead of actual sales is that important, because in the long run, the sales are affected by the listings. Users of the addon will set an initial price based on the listings statistics, then if the item doesn't sell, or takes too long to sell, they lower the price and list the item again. So the listings and sales affect each other.Necrotech_Master wrote: »Necrotech_Master wrote: »i dont like TTC in that it only goes off of the listing prices, not what stuff is actually sold for
i would not ever want that to be built into the game
i dont use the TTC website anymore even to just find if something is being sold somewhere for reasons mentioned in thread (too many ads, wont even work at all if you have an adblocker running), and i wouldnt use the addon in game because im not running the external client, and again dont like the data to be based on listings
TTC shows sale average.
if it is then thats better than it used to be, though the majority of the info in your tooltip is still useless as the TTC suggested, avg, min, and max are all still listings, not sales data
im also assuming for it track sales data, it would only work for your guilds like the other tracking tools, so from my perspective, it makes no sense to use the addon as listing data is meaningless to me
Necrotech_Master wrote: »with tracking of actual sales, your tracking something that already occurred and you have a record of it, even if the sale happened to be an outlier in terms of being low or high
Necrotech_Master wrote: »with tracking of actual sales, your tracking something that already occurred and you have a record of it, even if the sale happened to be an outlier in terms of being low or high
Yeah, I would imagine ZOS could make this happen if they wanted to.
I never denied that there are statistical outliers in the listings, but it doesn't change the fact that the listings and sales affect each other. I've used the TTC addon for quite a while, and I find it reliable enough when estimating my listing prices.Necrotech_Master wrote: »I don't think the fact that it shows statistics on listings instead of actual sales is that important, because in the long run, the sales are affected by the listings. Users of the addon will set an initial price based on the listings statistics, then if the item doesn't sell, or takes too long to sell, they lower the price and list the item again. So the listings and sales affect each other.Necrotech_Master wrote: »Necrotech_Master wrote: »i dont like TTC in that it only goes off of the listing prices, not what stuff is actually sold for
i would not ever want that to be built into the game
i dont use the TTC website anymore even to just find if something is being sold somewhere for reasons mentioned in thread (too many ads, wont even work at all if you have an adblocker running), and i wouldnt use the addon in game because im not running the external client, and again dont like the data to be based on listings
TTC shows sale average.
if it is then thats better than it used to be, though the majority of the info in your tooltip is still useless as the TTC suggested, avg, min, and max are all still listings, not sales data
im also assuming for it track sales data, it would only work for your guilds like the other tracking tools, so from my perspective, it makes no sense to use the addon as listing data is meaningless to me
if your going off listings, the TTC is a snapshot at a point in time, there is still a possibility that none of the items listed will sell, or all of them could sell
then theres also "bad listings" that throw off those numbers, say an item is valued at 10000 gold, theres 3 cases that could happen:
user could accidentally underlist for 1000 (forgot a 0), or overlist for 100k (extra 0) (thats 2 cases)
the 3rd case that could happen for listings would be someone could list a whole bunch of items for well above the listing amount say 100k each, then upload to TTC, then de-list
those results would still be in TTC until someone else in the guild ran their TTC on their guilds stuff, artificially inflating the "avg listing price" even though no transactions ever took place
with tracking of actual sales, your tracking something that already occurred and you have a record of it, even if the sale happened to be an outlier in terms of being low or high
there was something i was listing the other day that was an avg of 8-12k, but i had 1 outlier sale for 250k, someone actually made a sale in one of my guilds for an item listed at 20x what it normally lists for lol
This wouldn't be an "improvement" for me. I don't use TTC because I don't sell on traders, and it's pretty rare I buy on them. But the devs spending time on this would mean something I WOULD use might not be added.
Thank you for your input, but I would argue that a significant portion of the population, if not a majority, uses TTC and could benefit from an in-game solution which draws directly from ZOS' own data rather than relying on the players who have installed the tracking add-on and use an unreliable website which serves you advertisements and tracks your browsing habits.
NoTimeToWait wrote: »This wouldn't be an "improvement" for me. I don't use TTC because I don't sell on traders, and it's pretty rare I buy on them. But the devs spending time on this would mean something I WOULD use might not be added.
Thank you for your input, but I would argue that a significant portion of the population, if not a majority, uses TTC and could benefit from an in-game solution which draws directly from ZOS' own data rather than relying on the players who have installed the tracking add-on and use an unreliable website which serves you advertisements and tracks your browsing habits.
In Minion you can check the number of downloads of an addon. It's not that big compared to overall number of ESO accounts (even counting potential installs not counted via Minion). I would argue that a single digit percentage of players uses TTC from this data.
I don't mind if there would be an integrated tool like this made by ZOS, but I am fine without it.
I think the integrated tool will have a negative effect on prices (since people would be able to clear the price base line more effectively simply because more people would be able to search for cheaper items), this will result in a significant price inflation
Necrotech_Master wrote: »the only use ive found for TTC is just trying to find if an item is listed and where it is listed when im trying to look for something specific, and i can see how much it is listed for if i want to actually try to go find and buy the item
LadyLavina wrote: »Well hey @Danikat , haven't seen you around in a while. Thrilled to see you're still at least forum-active. Not common to see folks from the 2014 gang around these days. (I waited...like 3 years to get on the forums so I'm 2017 despite being launch/2014 myself x_x ) . Hope you're well.That's why I'd prefer ZOS to include the functionality in the game itself, they'd be able to do it much better than an addon can. But for now it's the best option available if you don't want to spend ages checking traders basically at random to find an item.
As for this though, I agree. There are many more pressing issues (as important as this one might be to us) that need to be addressed before this is messed with. I hope this is addressed eventually , but it will likely be a back-burner item until the more critical things are sorted.
VisitHammerfell wrote: »I think I'm doing fine without it on console. Sure, it's annoying to have to price check multiple cities, but then again I'm sure I've made plenty of sales from people who don't wanna look beyond Mournhold or Elden Root. Sales data would be more interesting than active trader listings, even then I don't want it to mess up the economy too much. And there are other more important QoL things like filtering for unknown in guild traders.
There will always be something critical for ZOS to do or fix. They just need to make it a commitment to do something about it, then do it.
This has been an issue for years that they have chosen to ignore, and it's only getting worse with each land update as they add more and more trading spots. With over 200 spots now, it is really impossible to search all of them on consoles without taking the whole day to do it and handwriting down the information such as price and location. We deserve better!
VisitHammerfell wrote: »I think I'm doing fine without it on console. Sure, it's annoying to have to price check multiple cities, but then again I'm sure I've made plenty of sales from people who don't wanna look beyond Mournhold or Elden Root. Sales data would be more interesting than active trader listings, even then I don't want it to mess up the economy too much. And there are other more important QoL things like filtering for unknown in guild traders.
I'm not on console, but wouldn't having zero data tracking render guild vendors that aren't in major locations practically useless? It seems like they would be even less worthwhile if you're only going to catch the occasional passerby.