Spindleslutch 2: Why take final boss to the top?

hcbigdogdoghc

Nearly everytime I play this, we are always expected to take boss to the top door. As a tank if you don't do so people get pissed.

What I don't get is why? Fighting the boss at the top makes no difference.

Everytime I ask people why I can't get a straight answer. Some say he won't heal at the top but that's not even true.

Karm1cOne

Back in the early days, when 15k dps was great, that was the best strategy. The boss wouldn't suck on the captives. These days people still do, mostly because that's how it's always been done even though dps from even the puggiest of pugs is enough to burn through the boss.

hcbigdogdoghc

But the thing is, the boss still suck the captives even if he's on top

Asardes

From my experience hard mode for this dungeon is almost impossible to fail unless you focus the captives on the crosses and constantly damage them. The boss sucking blood from them doesn't kill them and he doesn't seem to get that much healing from it. The best way to do the boss is to stack tightly and simply burn him down where he spawns, only moving slightly when he spawns that blood pool and blocking when he jumps around. Even with low group DPS like 30k or so he dies quite fast.

Brrrofski

I've always done it to make sure AOE etc don't hit the captives and kill them. Or randies don't see them and think "oh, do I kill this". If you kill one, you don't get two keys.

Think it's a habit that's stuck with most even when not doing it for the pledge

hcbigdogdoghc

Brrrofski wrote: »

I've always done it to make sure AOE etc don't hit the captives and kill them. Or randies don't see them and think "oh, do I kill this". If you kill one, you don't get two keys.

Think it's a habit that's stuck with most even when not doing it for the pledge

But the captives are tanky af, it's almost impossible to kill them

Brrrofski

hcbigdogdoghc wrote: »

Brrrofski wrote: »

I've always done it to make sure AOE etc don't hit the captives and kill them. Or randies don't see them and think "oh, do I kill this". If you kill one, you don't get two keys.

Think it's a habit that's stuck with most even when not doing it for the pledge

But the captives are tanky af, it's almost impossible to kill them

Maybe they buffed it?

Maybe there's no reason to.

I just followed what other did when I was new lol. Plus moving up there doesn't impact on you killing him at all. It doesn't make it harder.

code65536

Eww, people still do this?

I always tank the boss where he spawns, and if PUGs complain, then... eh, I don't care. I'm the tank and I'll position the boss where I please. That said, I haven't seen anyone request such a positioning in years.

When I first completed this dungeon way back in 2015, I was told to hold the boss up by the door, to prevent accidentally killing the innocents. After a while, I realized that unless you actively try to focus down and kill the victims, there's zero risk of them dying before the boss does.

But maybe people still hold onto that belief and never bothered to test/verify it?

Brrrofski

code65536 wrote: »

Eww, people still do this?

I always tank the boss where he spawns, and if PUGs complain, then... eh, I don't care. I'm the tank and I'll position the boss where I please. That said, I haven't seen anyone request such a positioning in years.

When I first completed this dungeon way back in 2015, I was told to hold the boss up by the door, to prevent accidentally killing the innocents. After a while, I realized that unless you actively try to focus down and kill the victims, there's zero risk of them dying before the boss does.

But maybe people still hold onto that belief and never bothered to test/verify it?

Yeh, I think it's just one of those things that stuck. It probably isn't needed anymore, but old habits die hard.

Calm_Fury

As others have said, it used to be to avoid killing the innocents.

But to this day, people will complain in PUGs if you as a tank don't do it.

Just the other day I had a couple of DPS literally refusing to fight because I was tanking the boss where he spawns.

It is just one of this things. Like people on CoA II that insist on skipping the adds through the lava, then the whole group spends more time teaching/waiting for one or two to learn to jump then they actually would spend killing the adds.

They see someone doing it, and assume that is the way without ever questioning.

BeefcakeManwich

Calm_Fury wrote: »

As others have said, it used to be to avoid killing the innocents.

But to this day, people will complain in PUGs if you as a tank don't do it.

Just the other day I had a couple of DPS literally refusing to fight because I was tanking the boss where he spawns.

It is just one of this things. Like people on CoA II that insist on skipping the adds through the lava, then the whole group spends more time teaching/waiting for one or two to learn to jump then they actually would spend killing the adds.

They see someone doing it, and assume that is the way without ever questioning.

You can just go up the side before the jumpfest and just sneak by the first skip. Second skip it's way more easy mounted. People won't know if they don't try. Is it major time saving? No. COA2 is a long random daily. So after awhile quicker is better. Just like how I don't bother with delve adds anymore. Need to zoom zoom to the next delve. I've more stuff to do.

Calm_Fury

BeefcakeManwich wrote: »

Calm_Fury wrote: »

As others have said, it used to be to avoid killing the innocents.

But to this day, people will complain in PUGs if you as a tank don't do it.

Just the other day I had a couple of DPS literally refusing to fight because I was tanking the boss where he spawns.

It is just one of this things. Like people on CoA II that insist on skipping the adds through the lava, then the whole group spends more time teaching/waiting for one or two to learn to jump then they actually would spend killing the adds.

They see someone doing it, and assume that is the way without ever questioning.

You can just go up the side before the jumpfest and just sneak by the first skip. Second skip it's way more easy mounted. People won't know if they don't try. Is it major time saving? No. COA2 is a long random daily. So after awhile quicker is better. Just like how I don't bother with delve adds anymore. Need to zoom zoom to the next delve. I've more stuff to do.

In my experience, just killing the adds on the sides takes 1-2 minutes. And I swear I've spent 10 minutes or more trying to teach people the right spots to jump.

It is infuriating. As a tank now, I just go straight ahead and pull the adds.

Seriously, if I had the patience I would do some experiments and try it, but I can bet that 9 times out of 10 with pugs, trying to skip through the lava takes more time than actually killing the adds the proper way there on vCoA II.