Just stopping by to note that I agree with pretty much all you said, and am happy to see that I am not the only one who thinks the way I do about the state of Templars. Like many others have pointed out, it is amazing how consistent the feedback given by Templar players is. We may not all agree on specific fixes to the issues, but we are very much in unison as to what is wrong with the class and what needs to be done in general.Long story short, templars are a hot mess right now and have plenty of glaring issues that need addressed. Instead of addressing them, we're trying the same tired, useless approach that has repeatedly failed in the past, completely ignoring what the most informed players and biggest names in templars have been saying for years. At the same time, we're being kicked while we're down with a senseless nerf. Thanks, ZOS.
Which brings me to a second thing I want to point - it is also equally amazing how uniform the indifference of ZOS is towards the Templar class. For years now we have been a mess of crappy passives and useless skills. We have never really given any proper buffs along the way. Just nerfs and more nerfs. And if we do get a buff, we will always get a nerf too, to compensate things. And then a patch later the buff will get nerfed but the original "balancing" nerf will also stay.
Remember when the self heals on Puncturing Sweep got nerfed due to the fact that we have such an easy time of keeping Major Mending up. Then they decided that Major Mending made our other heals way too good and it got nerfed to just Minor Mending. But Puncturing Sweep still got to keep the nerf. That's just the way it goes with Templars.
In all the Time that ESO has been live, Templars have been crapped on by ZOS, and usually rank at the bottom when people rate the classes. (Just search the forums for old posts about ranking the classes. Templars will almost always be at the bottom end of the scale.) The few times we actually managed to become effective, and useful as a class, were never due to changes made to the class itself. (Except possibly with the introduction of the very first incarnation of Radiant Destruction. Since that thing was just out of whack in it's initial release form.) When ever Templar performance has improved due to changes made by a patch, it has pretty much always been due to something non-Templar class specific being changed or introduced, that just happened to be very beneficial to Templars in particular. But usually that also meant that few updates later Templars would once more be on the receiving end of the nerf bat.
Like few others have remarked - the only explanation that makes sense to me is that Wrobel hates Templars.
I've never seen a mag sorc struggle to take down a templar, argonian or otherwise. Sorcs have been the golden child of ZOS for a while now and their toolkit just packs so much of a punch that they can substitute well-timed CC and burst in place of defile. At best, a solid mag sorc vs templar fight results in a stalemate.
If you´re dying to a sorc on a classic templar build you´re doing something incredibly wrong - but that´s just me...
I'm not. Usually a stalemate if they don't have help.What are these "DK resistances" of which you speak? I don't want to derail your thread, but DKs and Templars are kind of in the same boat defensively, right?
Similar in terms of spells but better blocking and sustain passives, as well as vastly superior ults. Templars not built specifically for blocking will run out of stamina in a hurry. Stam DKs in particular can shake that off. Mag is more or less in a similar boat.
I'm becoming increasingly confused by what you're saying and what point you're trying to make. Perhaps you ought to proceed carefully with the nebulous class comparisons--it will make this a much cleaner discussion.
I'm saying magicka DKs are in a similar situation to templars but can still get away with a bit more blocking (the aforementioned "resistances") but stamina DKs can get away with a LOT more blocking. Their healing is also far more of a passive act, especially with Battle Roar. The point remains that templars are predominately, if not exclusively, the class without a quintessential escape or mitigation method outside of simply healing through the damage. DK CC also helps considerably to avoid damage entirely, while templars have had their CC gutted time and time again. I cannot comment on how the DK CC changes on the PTS will translate to live, but DKs have roots for days right now.
This is just a ridiculous statement. If you want to keep doing this, I'll go ahead and eviscerate your arguments but it will detract from the purpose of the thread. I dislike many of the Templar changes so I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt, but if you keep posting stuff that displays a startling lack of understanding of basic class mechanics this thread is going to go south real fast.
I'm honestly having trouble figuring out your objection but I know you main a DK and I main a templar so there's also likely some bias at play.
So I'll just say I have a far easier time downing templars than I do DKs. There has to be something causing that. I don't mean to imply that DKs are superior. I'm just saying the unique survival mechanism of the templar being the target of a nerf is silly.
You can shut down any perma DK just using a CC, or a stam poison. Stamina is not eternal
I'm not referring to perma-block DKs, but rather well-built DKs with offensive capability. Perma-block is another issue entirely. I also refuse to use resource drain poisons on principle but I get that I'm robbing myself of an edge by doing that and that's on me.
Joy_Division wrote: »
Joy_Division wrote: »
@Joy_Division that´s why i pointed it to being argonian. They can not be defiled by disease enchant procc.
The secondary effect of elemental dmg does not work on resistant races as in:
no defile/poisoned on woodelf/argonian
no burning on darkelf
no chilled on nord
andreasranasen wrote: »When you've invested time and money into a company, you have the right to be upset over changes that will negatively affect your experience and gameplay.
@Joy_Division
That wasn't the point I guess. OP says that Templars are one Major Defile away from death most times if Ritual is so expensive. @Derra pointed out that Sorcs for example don't have native access to major defile and that enchants don't work on 2 of the best races for mag and stam Templars that you encounter quite often in Cyrodiil in response to that.
I don't think the Templar nerfs have been warranted either. The S&B block casting Healbots warp the picture of the class and are the reason for the recent nerfs I guess.
Idk if the healbots are to blame . I think it's a two fold review of the siphoner CP star. We mentioned that that star was useless even after it's change to 25% max. So they buffed the hell out of it too make it more attractive.
Then they decided that in order to make that star attractive against templars who can remove the debuff altogether, they increased the cost to our class defining skill to make that star stick.
It's following their intent of "buff one, nerf another" mentality we have been seeing this pts cycle.
@Joy_Division
That wasn't the point I guess. OP says that Templars are one Major Defile away from death most times if Ritual is so expensive. @Derra pointed out that Sorcs for example don't have native access to major defile and that enchants don't work on 2 of the best races for mag and stam Templars that you encounter quite often in Cyrodiil in response to that.
I don't think the Templar nerfs have been warranted either. The S&B block casting Healbots warp the picture of the class and are the reason for the recent nerfs I guess.
Idk if the healbots are to blame . I think it's a two fold review of the siphoner CP star. We mentioned that that star was useless even after it's change to 25% max. So they buffed the hell out of it too make it more attractive.
Then they decided that in order to make that star attractive against templars who can remove the debuff altogether, they increased the cost to our class defining skill to make that star stick.
It's following their intent of "buff one, nerf another" mentality we have been seeing this pts cycle.
Templar has always been the only class worth using siphoner on since it eats up one of their purges and will leave other effects still on them
Just stopping by to note that I agree with pretty much all you said, and am happy to see that I am not the only one who thinks the way I do about the state of Templars. Like many others have pointed out, it is amazing how consistent the feedback given by Templar players is. We may not all agree on specific fixes to the issues, but we are very much in unison as to what is wrong with the class and what needs to be done in general.Long story short, templars are a hot mess right now and have plenty of glaring issues that need addressed. Instead of addressing them, we're trying the same tired, useless approach that has repeatedly failed in the past, completely ignoring what the most informed players and biggest names in templars have been saying for years. At the same time, we're being kicked while we're down with a senseless nerf. Thanks, ZOS.
Which brings me to a second thing I want to point - it is also equally amazing how uniform the indifference of ZOS is towards the Templar class. For years now we have been a mess of crappy passives and useless skills. We have never really given any proper buffs along the way. Just nerfs and more nerfs. And if we do get a buff, we will always get a nerf too, to compensate things. And then a patch later the buff will get nerfed but the original "balancing" nerf will also stay.
Remember when the self heals on Puncturing Sweep got nerfed due to the fact that we have such an easy time of keeping Major Mending up. Then they decided that Major Mending made our other heals way too good and it got nerfed to just Minor Mending. But Puncturing Sweep still got to keep the nerf. That's just the way it goes with Templars.
In all the Time that ESO has been live, Templars have been crapped on by ZOS, and usually rank at the bottom when people rate the classes. (Just search the forums for old posts about ranking the classes. Templars will almost always be at the bottom end of the scale.) The few times we actually managed to become effective, and useful as a class, were never due to changes made to the class itself. (Except possibly with the introduction of the very first incarnation of Radiant Destruction. Since that thing was just out of whack in it's initial release form.) When ever Templar performance has improved due to changes made by a patch, it has pretty much always been due to something non-Templar class specific being changed or introduced, that just happened to be very beneficial to Templars in particular. But usually that also meant that few updates later Templars would once more be on the receiving end of the nerf bat.
Like few others have remarked - the only explanation that makes sense to me is that Wrobel hates Templars.
Just stopping by to note that I agree with pretty much all you said, and am happy to see that I am not the only one who thinks the way I do about the state of Templars. Like many others have pointed out, it is amazing how consistent the feedback given by Templar players is. We may not all agree on specific fixes to the issues, but we are very much in unison as to what is wrong with the class and what needs to be done in general.Long story short, templars are a hot mess right now and have plenty of glaring issues that need addressed. Instead of addressing them, we're trying the same tired, useless approach that has repeatedly failed in the past, completely ignoring what the most informed players and biggest names in templars have been saying for years. At the same time, we're being kicked while we're down with a senseless nerf. Thanks, ZOS.
Which brings me to a second thing I want to point - it is also equally amazing how uniform the indifference of ZOS is towards the Templar class. For years now we have been a mess of crappy passives and useless skills. We have never really given any proper buffs along the way. Just nerfs and more nerfs. And if we do get a buff, we will always get a nerf too, to compensate things. And then a patch later the buff will get nerfed but the original "balancing" nerf will also stay.
Remember when the self heals on Puncturing Sweep got nerfed due to the fact that we have such an easy time of keeping Major Mending up. Then they decided that Major Mending made our other heals way too good and it got nerfed to just Minor Mending. But Puncturing Sweep still got to keep the nerf. That's just the way it goes with Templars.
In all the Time that ESO has been live, Templars have been crapped on by ZOS, and usually rank at the bottom when people rate the classes. (Just search the forums for old posts about ranking the classes. Templars will almost always be at the bottom end of the scale.) The few times we actually managed to become effective, and useful as a class, were never due to changes made to the class itself. (Except possibly with the introduction of the very first incarnation of Radiant Destruction. Since that thing was just out of whack in it's initial release form.) When ever Templar performance has improved due to changes made by a patch, it has pretty much always been due to something non-Templar class specific being changed or introduced, that just happened to be very beneficial to Templars in particular. But usually that also meant that few updates later Templars would once more be on the receiving end of the nerf bat.
Like few others have remarked - the only explanation that makes sense to me is that Wrobel hates Templars.
As one who has been here since release, I can only come to the exact same conclusion.
The latest change to empower on barrage actually makes total sense if you assume the person who came up with it plays a NB.
what is cancer about a templar, their ability to heal a good amount? thats just how templars were made. thats just the same as calling a nb cancer for cloaking or a sorc for shield stacking....
Long story short, templars are a hot mess right now and have plenty of glaring issues that need addressed. Instead of addressing them, we're trying the same tired, useless approach that has repeatedly failed in the past, completely ignoring what the most informed players and biggest names in templars have been saying for years. At the same time, we're being kicked while we're down with a senseless nerf. Thanks, ZOS.
Templar and DK are in the same boat. Expected to have good survivability with heals/blocks but have everything taken away from them to make it possible.
I've never seen a mag sorc struggle to take down a templar, argonian or otherwise. Sorcs have been the golden child of ZOS for a while now and their toolkit just packs so much of a punch that they can substitute well-timed CC and burst in place of defile. At best, a solid mag sorc vs templar fight results in a stalemate.
I've never seen a mag sorc struggle to take down a templar, argonian or otherwise. Sorcs have been the golden child of ZOS for a while now and their toolkit just packs so much of a punch that they can substitute well-timed CC and burst in place of defile. At best, a solid mag sorc vs templar fight results in a stalemate.
Not true, whenever I go up any templar that does pvp the first thing they did is cleanse my curse each time because that drops alot of my burst dps potential and makes it a lot harder for me a sorc to get high enough burst to kill a templar before they heal. I'm not saying templar is in a good spot right now, because ZOS did bend it over multiple times in the past couple of patches, but I'm just saying Sorc isn't the this "brokwn class" that ZOS loves.
I've never seen a mag sorc struggle to take down a templar, argonian or otherwise. Sorcs have been the golden child of ZOS for a while now and their toolkit just packs so much of a punch that they can substitute well-timed CC and burst in place of defile. At best, a solid mag sorc vs templar fight results in a stalemate.
Not true, whenever I go up any templar that does pvp the first thing they did is cleanse my curse each time because that drops alot of my burst dps potential and makes it a lot harder for me a sorc to get high enough burst to kill a templar before they heal. I'm not saying templar is in a good spot right now, because ZOS did bend it over multiple times in the past couple of patches, but I'm just saying Sorc isn't the this "brokwn class" that ZOS loves.
Joy_Division wrote: »
I've never seen a mag sorc struggle to take down a templar, argonian or otherwise. Sorcs have been the golden child of ZOS for a while now and their toolkit just packs so much of a punch that they can substitute well-timed CC and burst in place of defile. At best, a solid mag sorc vs templar fight results in a stalemate.
Not true, whenever I go up any templar that does pvp the first thing they did is cleanse my curse each time because that drops alot of my burst dps potential and makes it a lot harder for me a sorc to get high enough burst to kill a templar before they heal. I'm not saying templar is in a good spot right now, because ZOS did bend it over multiple times in the past couple of patches, but I'm just saying Sorc isn't the this "brokwn class" that ZOS loves.
If a templar cleanses your curse, simply curse them again. Your curse is 1000 magicka cheaper.
Joy_Division wrote: »
I've never seen a mag sorc struggle to take down a templar, argonian or otherwise. Sorcs have been the golden child of ZOS for a while now and their toolkit just packs so much of a punch that they can substitute well-timed CC and burst in place of defile. At best, a solid mag sorc vs templar fight results in a stalemate.
Not true, whenever I go up any templar that does pvp the first thing they did is cleanse my curse each time because that drops alot of my burst dps potential and makes it a lot harder for me a sorc to get high enough burst to kill a templar before they heal. I'm not saying templar is in a good spot right now, because ZOS did bend it over multiple times in the past couple of patches, but I'm just saying Sorc isn't the this "brokwn class" that ZOS loves.
If a templar cleanses your curse, simply curse them again. Your curse is 1000 magicka cheaper.
Im sitting at 4k magicka for bol and 3700 for purify in 5H2L seducer armor.
How am i going to sustain this *** lol
CatchMeTrolling wrote: »I don’t like how every argument against a Templar is how well they survive, this is what skews things because zos listens then nerf things but never buff or at least fix our damage.
Honestly I don’t think the devs even know what role they want Templars to be anymore. I enjoy my Templar but I just wish they made up their minds for once.
We have never really given any proper buffs along the way. Just nerfs and more nerfs. And if we do get a buff, we will always get a nerf too, to compensate things. And then a patch later the buff will get nerfed but the original "balancing" nerf will also stay.
Remember when the self heals on Puncturing Sweep got nerfed due to the fact that we have such an easy time of keeping Major Mending up. Then they decided that Major Mending made our other heals way too good and it got nerfed to just Minor Mending. But Puncturing Sweep still got to keep the nerf. That's just the way it goes with Templars.
Joy_Division wrote: »
I've never seen a mag sorc struggle to take down a templar, argonian or otherwise. Sorcs have been the golden child of ZOS for a while now and their toolkit just packs so much of a punch that they can substitute well-timed CC and burst in place of defile. At best, a solid mag sorc vs templar fight results in a stalemate.
Not true, whenever I go up any templar that does pvp the first thing they did is cleanse my curse each time because that drops alot of my burst dps potential and makes it a lot harder for me a sorc to get high enough burst to kill a templar before they heal. I'm not saying templar is in a good spot right now, because ZOS did bend it over multiple times in the past couple of patches, but I'm just saying Sorc isn't the this "brokwn class" that ZOS loves.
If a templar cleanses your curse, simply curse them again. Your curse is 1000 magicka cheaper.
Im sitting at 4k magicka for bol and 3700 for purify in 5H2L seducer armor.
How am i going to sustain this *** lol