The four-fifth-non-katana katana: what on earth did you do with it, ZoS?

dtm_samuraib16_ESO

To me, this "4/5th Non Katana" Katana, which has a Katana handle, but a frikken curved saber blade, is a fairly disturbing sight.
Especially in fist person view, in which I constant am.
I for one, would like to see this fixed with a "true" Katana blade.
How about you?

Didaco

Are you talking about the soul shriver one?

If so, what's wrong with it?

ADarklore

Nothing like a post about a visual yet there are no pictures to even see what they're talking about.

CasNation

I have no idea which sword you are talking about. There are a couple different swords that look like katanas.

ArchMikem

If no pics, then you should probably give people what style sword you're talking about.

Aren't the Akaviri the ones with the Japanese crafting style?

Duiwel

(has no idea what OP is talking about)

dtm_samuraib16_ESO

Aw, sorry, I thought most would know which one I spoke of: the Akaviri, indeed.
Pic (1st person view):

Mr.Hmm

Yes, it looks rediculous.

dtm_samuraib16_ESO wrote: »

Aw, sorry, I thought most would know which one I spoke of: the Akaviri, indeed.
Pic (1st person view):

Totally doesnt look like a katana.

I dont think Katanas are curved.

lathbury

Mr.Hmm wrote: »

show previous quotes

dtm_samuraib16_ESO wrote: »

Aw, sorry, I thought most would know which one I spoke of: the Akaviri, indeed.
Pic (1st person view):

Totally doesnt look like a katana.

I dont think Katanas are curved.

they are

BigBragg

No, I like the combined Katana/Saber.

Shaped more like a tachi than a katana. The only odd part is that it is being used with a shield.

NovaMarx

Katanas ARE slightly curved.....

Note: and older models seem to be even more curved.

khele23eb17_ESO

Yes, it looks rediculous.

The blades are indeed sabre-like... too long for a sabre tho. Too thin (in proportion to length) and too curved for a katana.

TheShadowScout

No, I like the combined Katana/Saber.

Mixing up real-world styles for a "fantasy/alternate world" look is a classic. As such, I approve. And wouldn't mind seeing more of the sort...

DurzoBlint13

soul shriven are the closest to Katana-like weapons I know of. Akavari swords look nothing like katanas and are double sided. Katanas are supposed to be curved and one sided, and have a slight taper to them as they reach the point. I don't see what the issue is. They look like real katanas. Someone already provided a pic of a real katana, but you can google it if you want other pics

LadyNalcarya

I could care less, really.

Lol there are different types of Japanese swords, some of them have more defined curve than your-typical-katana.
Maybe its based on a tachi sword, not a katana.

P.S. As a weapon aestetics nerd, I would say that animations of melee combat in this game are much more inaccurate than this weapon model.

P.P.S. Oh, and argonian greatsword. Nuff said.

W0lf_z13

Mr.Hmm wrote: »

show previous quotes

dtm_samuraib16_ESO wrote: »

Aw, sorry, I thought most would know which one I spoke of: the Akaviri, indeed.
Pic (1st person view):

Totally doesnt look like a katana.

I dont think Katanas are curved.

katanas are curved a bit.... ive studied kendo for 5 years ... u are most likely thinking of a "ninja sword" which has a square guard and a straight blade

Divinius

I couldn't care less, but that wasn't a poll option.

NateAssassin

Soul shriven sword is good looking and is the best looking sword in the game, and when I think about it ALL of the soul shriven weapons look the best...

waterfairy

I could care less, really.

I like katana swords but I could care less in this game or TES games as you can't wield it right...I mean your picture is katana and shield then you ask if the blade looks ridiculous.

idk

No, I like the combined Katana/Saber.

Wow. Looks like very few don't like the katana swords in game.

Korah_Eaglecry

Could we get a pick that isnt from that angle? Thats not the greatest angle to criticize an object from.

Korah_Eaglecry

Could we get a pick that isnt from that angle? Thats not the greatest angle to criticize an object from.

r.jan_emailb16_ESO

Katanas ARE curved

They're also meant to be wielded with two hands, and the shorter Wakizashi is the one handed/close quarters version. That "ninja sword" someone mentioned was more often than not a shortened Katana. If you want a longer sword (with an even more apparent curve, obviously) you'll want a Tachi, but that one is basically useless outside of open battlefields. Samurai usually carried the Katana (+Wakizashi) when in a civil environment, and the Tachi (+Tanto, a knife) as part of their battle gear.

Also, they are 100% not made to combat opponents in full plate armour and Samurai also didn't carry shields, shame on you.

Daimmyo

Yes, it looks rediculous.

That's why we need real like Katana's in the game, so we can educate them young-ens, and also adapt ESO so we can use all those role playing samurai type characters we had in Morrowind, there was this gigantic thread with all variations constructed.

idk

No, I like the combined Katana/Saber.

Korah_Eaglecry wrote: »

Could we get a pick that isnt from that angle? Thats not the greatest angle to criticize an object from.

OP is only interested in one angle which is obvious from his post and poll choices. He's not exactly interested in what we think.

Talyena

I'm sure they will have true to life katanas when they introduce pandas as a playable race and ninjas as a new class...

khele23eb17_ESO

Yes, it looks rediculous.

KoshkaMurka wrote: »

Lol there are different types of Japanese swords, some of them have more defined curve than your-typical-katana.
Maybe its based on a tachi sword, not a katana.

P.S. As a weapon aestetics nerd, I would say that animations of melee combat in this game are much more inaccurate than this weapon model.

P.P.S. Oh, and argonian greatsword. Nuff said.

What about the argonian greatsword?

NovaMarx wrote: »

Katanas ARE slightly curved.....

I think the idea is that katanas are SLIGHTLY curved. Also, the weapons in game seem too long and too thin.

ToRelax

khele23eb17_ESO wrote: »

show previous quotes

KoshkaMurka wrote: »

Lol there are different types of Japanese swords, some of them have more defined curve than your-typical-katana.
Maybe its based on a tachi sword, not a katana.

P.S. As a weapon aestetics nerd, I would say that animations of melee combat in this game are much more inaccurate than this weapon model.

P.P.S. Oh, and argonian greatsword. Nuff said.

What about the argonian greatsword?

Argonian has two types of mauls instead.

khele23eb17_ESO

Yes, it looks rediculous.

ToRelax wrote: »

show previous quotes

khele23eb17_ESO wrote: »

KoshkaMurka wrote: »

Lol there are different types of Japanese swords, some of them have more defined curve than your-typical-katana.
Maybe its based on a tachi sword, not a katana.

P.S. As a weapon aestetics nerd, I would say that animations of melee combat in this game are much more inaccurate than this weapon model.

P.P.S. Oh, and argonian greatsword. Nuff said.

What about the argonian greatsword?

Argonian has two types of mauls instead.

Technically it IS a sword. Its modelled after the macuahuitl - a wooden sword with obsidian blades (which can be sharper than modern steel scalpels) used by Mesoamerican civilizations (Aztecs for example). It looked like this:

idk

No, I like the combined Katana/Saber.

Talyena wrote: »

I'm sure they will have true to life katanas when they introduce pandas as a playable race and ninjas as a new class...

So glad we can buy extra character slots. A ninja panda character. Eat your heart of khajiits and argonians.

dtm_samuraib16_ESO

Giles.floydub17_ESO wrote: »

show previous quotes

Korah_Eaglecry wrote: »

Could we get a pick that isnt from that angle? Thats not the greatest angle to criticize an object from.

OP is only interested in one angle which is obvious from his post and poll choices. He's not exactly interested in what we think.

I actually, do, but I've been gaming and had ignored the forum a bit.
As for a different angle, I will post one tomorrow.