DaniAngione wrote: »kelly.medleyb14_ESO wrote: »Yes. All stages of vampirism should cause all normal citizens to flee and all guards in the whole town to instantly attack, it's very lore breaking that they don't.
Also casting magicka in town should be frowned upon.
I'd have that way if I could decide...
"Oh but that's a rolepla..."
STOP WHINING. This is the Elder Scrolls. It has FREAKING ROLEPLAYING in the genre name! Go play WoW.
onlinegamer1 wrote: »onlinegamer1 wrote: »onlinegamer1 wrote: »WraithAzraiel wrote: »onlinegamer1 wrote: »Just to be as clear as possible...
Roleplaying has no place in MMORPGs, and never has. Sure, there is a tiny, tiny, tiny minuscule fraction of players in every MMORPG that rant about "the RP stands for Role Playing!!!111!!!one!!!eleven!". But we all know that a Roleplaying Game (like Dungeons and Dragons, GURPS, etc.) is a system of character creation and progression, and that ACTING (you know, the thing that professional Actors in Hollywood do) "in character" is absolutely optional.
But no, these "roleplayers" insist that everyone HAS TO ACT IN CHARACTER because there is "RP in MMORPG".
Well, you're wrong. Sorry to be the one to tell you, but MMORPGs (all of them) would cease to exist due to lack of profit because no one would buy them/play them if "roleplaying" were mandatory.
Its fine that YOU want to roleplay. I would never ask ESO Devs to "Ban people who roleplay and spam chat". Roleplay all you want. If you want Stage 4 Vampires to be KOS by guards, then Roleplay that you're being attacked by guards.
You: "A guard! Oh no! I thusly must flee!" (steal an item in front of a guard, but don't tell your fellow roleplayers you did that)
Guard: "Halt! You are under arrest!"
You: (choose flee option)
Ta da! There you go. You are now "roleplaying" that you are KOS to a guard if you're a stage 4 vamp, and the other 99.999999999999999999999999999999999999% of players aren't saddled with a stupid system that is a waste of time and bad idea.
Salty post is salty. You want a hug, bro? Come on, bring it in.
If you couldn't refute the logic of my post, why did you bother to hit the reply button ?
Your post is based on a false premise, refusing to acknowledge it is illogical in and of itself.
My post, which is that making Guards KOS on Stage 4 Vamps is a purely roleplaying-based idea, and has nothing whatsoever to do with game balance, game mechanics or ability power is 100% factual and irrefutable.
I also irrefutably proved that roleplayers can already achieve this idea in game, right now.
Wrong. Guards KOS to Stage 4 is a proposed solution to the flaw that vampires are able to bypass the feeding mechanic since stage 4 offers greater benefits than drawbacks - shown by the abundance of people who completely ignore the mechanic alltogether. That is a gameplay issue involving a skill line mechanic. No amount of fist waving or illogical associations you make will change that.
That is completely wrong, of course.
First, no one is bypassing a feeding mechanic. There are 4 stages of Vampirism, and players can choose which stage to be in.
Second, no one is ignoring the mechanic - they are using it as designed.
Third, Guard KOS has nothing whatsoever to do with the mechanic, as I have proven:
- Guard KOS does not make vampire abilities more or less powerful in PvP.
- Guard KOS does not change the mechanics of using vampire active skills, ultimate, or passive skills
- Guard KOS does not change the effects of Stage 1, 2, 3 or 4 Vampirism - the abilities are the same
So, I just eliminated game balance, game mechanics, and ability power as reasons for "Guard KOS".
If we're trying to justify KoS for vamps from an RP stand point, and in said RP each and every one of the player characters has heroically saved Nirn from an invasion against Molag Bal, the people in general should not give a damn that you are or are not a vamp. Frankly, you save the planet, you get a free pass on the whole hated blood sucking abomination thing. Hell, if you save my dog from a burning building, you and I are cool. Someone save your whole planet? The only KoS the people should be using is Kiss On Sight.
Seriously, what kinda ungrateful [snip] trys to kill the guy who saved the planet because he disagrees with said guy's dietary needs!? Guards gonna murder every stage 4 Vegan that saved Nirn too!?
...last I checked it was the Guards that are the soulless unkillable immortals everyone is afraid of being attacked by...
...just sayin'.
If we're trying to justify KoS for vamps from an RP stand point, and in said RP each and every one of the player characters has heroically saved Nirn from an invasion against Molag Bal, the people in general should not give a damn that you are or are not a vamp. Frankly, you save the planet, you get a free pass on the whole hated blood sucking abomination thing. Hell, if you save my dog from a burning building, you and I are cool. Someone save your whole planet? The only KoS the people should be using is Kiss On Sight.
Seriously, what kinda ungrateful [snip] trys to kill the guy who saved the planet because he disagrees with said guy's dietary needs!? Guards gonna murder every stage 4 Vegan that saved Nirn too!?
...last I checked it was the Guards that are the soulless unkillable immortals everyone is afraid of being attacked by...
...just sayin'.
I would contest that every single person in the entirety of Nirn would be able to recognize the face of the Vestige, especially when the face is being distorted by vampirism. Much less in Cadwells where the player is experiencing the factions before Molag Bal falls.
smeeprocketnub19_ESO wrote: »Nope, against it.
Besides the reasons I stated in the other thread, the major reason for me are 1) sometimes I just want to idle in a city, and 2) feeding every hour or two is a real pita. For the sake of convenience alone, it's a dumb idea.
People can RP this already. No reason I should be forced to experience it.
If we're trying to justify KoS for vamps from an RP stand point, and in said RP each and every one of the player characters has heroically saved Nirn from an invasion against Molag Bal, the people in general should not give a damn that you are or are not a vamp. Frankly, you save the planet, you get a free pass on the whole hated blood sucking abomination thing. Hell, if you save my dog from a burning building, you and I are cool. Someone save your whole planet? The only KoS the people should be using is Kiss On Sight.
Seriously, what kinda ungrateful [snip] trys to kill the guy who saved the planet because he disagrees with said guy's dietary needs!? Guards gonna murder every stage 4 Vegan that saved Nirn too!?
...last I checked it was the Guards that are the soulless unkillable immortals everyone is afraid of being attacked by...
...just sayin'.
I would contest that every single person in the entirety of Nirn would be able to recognize the face of the Vestige, especially when the face is being distorted by vampirism. Much less in Cadwells where the player is experiencing the factions before Molag Bal falls.
I'm not a vampire in game, but if I were it's unreasonable to suggest that not enough people would be aware that I am with my array of titles. My character has as many credentials as some deities in Tamriel. His very arrival should be trumpeted from the walls and gates of every city he graces with his presence. He counts whole guilds, Daedric Princes, and the very rulers of the three factions among his personal council with whom he is held in high esteem. A skin condition and liquid diet would be barely an issue in the shadow of his tremendous reputation.
If we're trying to justify KoS for vamps from an RP stand point, and in said RP each and every one of the player characters has heroically saved Nirn from an invasion against Molag Bal, the people in general should not give a damn that you are or are not a vamp. Frankly, you save the planet, you get a free pass on the whole hated blood sucking abomination thing. Hell, if you save my dog from a burning building, you and I are cool. Someone save your whole planet? The only KoS the people should be using is Kiss On Sight.
Seriously, what kinda ungrateful [snip] trys to kill the guy who saved the planet because he disagrees with said guy's dietary needs!? Guards gonna murder every stage 4 Vegan that saved Nirn too!?
...last I checked it was the Guards that are the soulless unkillable immortals everyone is afraid of being attacked by...
...just sayin'.
I would contest that every single person in the entirety of Nirn would be able to recognize the face of the Vestige, especially when the face is being distorted by vampirism. Much less in Cadwells where the player is experiencing the factions before Molag Bal falls.
I'm not a vampire in game, but if I were it's unreasonable to suggest that not enough people would be aware that I am with my array of titles. My character has as many credentials as some deities in Tamriel. His very arrival should be trumpeted from the walls and gates of every city he graces with his presence. He counts whole guilds, Daedric Princes, and the very rulers of the three factions among his personal council with whom he is held in high esteem. A skin condition and liquid diet would be barely an issue in the shadow of his tremendous reputation.
Eh, I do have vampires though. And we aren't heralded as a celebrity now so I'm not sure how that can be suggested. At best we can talk to core NPCs like Emerick and he'll say some kind words to us, perhaps an NPC we directly interact with in a quest will recognize us, but the average populace of Nirn probably thinks we're a myth, much less be able to identify us past the vampirism (which is in full on cold-sore mode in Stage 4). We still have NPCs talk to us like a regular person instead of recognize us, guards still insult us as we walk by like we're some stranger strolling the streets. Saying the populace would identify and accept us regardless of the situation doesn't really mesh with the situation presented to us in game.
If we're trying to justify KoS for vamps from an RP stand point, and in said RP each and every one of the player characters has heroically saved Nirn from an invasion against Molag Bal, the people in general should not give a damn that you are or are not a vamp. Frankly, you save the planet, you get a free pass on the whole hated blood sucking abomination thing. Hell, if you save my dog from a burning building, you and I are cool. Someone save your whole planet? The only KoS the people should be using is Kiss On Sight.
Seriously, what kinda ungrateful mother ***er trys to kill the guy who saved the planet because he disagrees with said guy's dietary needs!? Guards gonna murder every stage 4 Vegan that saved Nirn too!?
...last I checked it was the Guards that are the soulless unkillable immortals everyone is afraid of being attacked by...
...just sayin'.
I would contest that every single person in the entirety of Nirn would be able to recognize the face of the Vestige, especially when the face is being distorted by vampirism. Much less in Cadwells where the player is experiencing the factions before Molag Bal falls.
I'm not a vampire in game, but if I were it's unreasonable to suggest that not enough people would be aware that I am with my array of titles. My character has as many credentials as some deities in Tamriel. His very arrival should be trumpeted from the walls and gates of every city he graces with his presence. He counts whole guilds, Daedric Princes, and the very rulers of the three factions among his personal council with whom he is held in high esteem. A skin condition and liquid diet would be barely an issue in the shadow of his tremendous reputation.
Eh, I do have vampires though. And we aren't heralded as a celebrity now so I'm not sure how that can be suggested. At best we can talk to core NPCs like Emerick and he'll say some kind words to us, perhaps an NPC we directly interact with in a quest will recognize us, but the average populace of Nirn probably thinks we're a myth, much less be able to identify us past the vampirism (which is in full on cold-sore mode in Stage 4). We still have NPCs talk to us like a regular person instead of recognize us, guards still insult us as we walk by like we're some stranger strolling the streets. Saying the populace would identify and accept us regardless of the situation doesn't really mesh with the situation presented to us in game.
Agreed. But if we're going to use RP as a basis, we cannot discount the overwhelmingly positive aspects of the characters and use only one negative aspect. Rumours of my characters greatness would have spread far and wide, people who came in direct contact with his heroism would immortalise him in song and poetry, the Daedric princes of oblivion would know him both by name and by reputation as the petty mortal who dominated the very prince of domination. The character is an effin' legend in the flesh.
Yes, the game world doesn't react to the character as if they were anything spectacular. No, it shouldn't cherry pick one being a vampire over the innumerable accounts and harrowing tales of selfless heroism in the face of Nirns annihilation. George Washington didn't do near what my character did, and yet hundreds of years later we still know his name and see paintings and statues depicting him, poetry and stories embellishing his deeds, and history books filled with pages of his accolades.
If we're going to use RP as an excuse for how the world reacts to a player, we have to RP the sum of all the reactions.
For what I've experienced and read on vampirism in the Elder Scrolls universe, not feeding is a completely valid option. As far as I know, you can't - according to lore - die of starvation as you are not a mortal.
People keep using lore as the reason to KOS stage 4 vamps, but must not have played the other games or they would realize there is a severely missing mechanic needed for this to be feasible. See in previous TES games, when you were a vampire, you could simples sneak into an inn and feed on someone sleeping. No bounty, no crime, unless you got caught doing it.
If you feed on an NPC as it is, it doesn't matter if they were sleeping in a house by themselves on top of a mountain with no one around for miles, You're getting a bounty.
Additionally, if you DID get caught by a guard, you could kill them and escape. Now, if you're KOS and happen to get caught in an inn, guild house, ect, I guess they lock the doors and there's no chance of escape.
If those three mechanics (feeding on the sleeping, killable guards, not locking doors) were changed, I would be 100% onboard with Vamp 4 being KOS.
These would add to it and make it more fun, for sure. I feel the need to mention, though, not only the abundance of humanoids easily attainable throughout the world thanks to wayshrines, the fact that there are cities with NPCs inside that aren't protected under the justice system, and the ability to enter refuges from outside the city - making dodging guard patrols to be incredibly simple with the least bit of effort. Finding something to feed on is less than a 60 second commitment, and not only provides a reason to participate in the mechanic but keeps that "incentive" from having even more vulnerabilities stacked.
phreatophile wrote: »For what I've experienced and read on vampirism in the Elder Scrolls universe, not feeding is a completely valid option. As far as I know, you can't - according to lore - die of starvation as you are not a mortal.
Countess Rona Hassildor of Skingrad slipped into a coma because she refused to feed, so according to lore, there are consequences. In TES IV: Oblivion the quest to cure yourself requires you to find a cure for her. By this time she has been unfed and in a coma so long that the cure kills her as well as curing her vampirism.
So no, you cannot actually die from not feeding, you might linger in some sort of undead coma which is close enough.
People keep using lore as the reason to KOS stage 4 vamps, but must not have played the other games or they would realize there is a severely missing mechanic needed for this to be feasible. See in previous TES games, when you were a vampire, you could simples sneak into an inn and feed on someone sleeping. No bounty, no crime, unless you got caught doing it.
If you feed on an NPC as it is, it doesn't matter if they were sleeping in a house by themselves on top of a mountain with no one around for miles, You're getting a bounty.
Additionally, if you DID get caught by a guard, you could kill them and escape. Now, if you're KOS and happen to get caught in an inn, guild house, ect, I guess they lock the doors and there's no chance of escape.
If those three mechanics (feeding on the sleeping, killable guards, not locking doors) were changed, I would be 100% onboard with Vamp 4 being KOS.
Hortator Mopa wrote: »First rule of vampire fan boying, use rp and lore to advantage but ignore that you are hypocritical and dont want guards to attack you.
Now personally I believe the mechanics should have always fit the lore. You should have started stronger, but the longer you went without feeding you should have lost skills and power while the sun damage and other debuffs got stronger as well. I've never understood why they did it the other way.
If people wanted to bore themselves with such menial chores, they would play real life.
Hortator Mopa wrote: »First rule of vampire fan boying, use rp and lore to advantage but ignore that you are hypocritical and dont want guards to attack you.
phreatophile wrote: »For what I've experienced and read on vampirism in the Elder Scrolls universe, not feeding is a completely valid option. As far as I know, you can't - according to lore - die of starvation as you are not a mortal.
Countess Rona Hassildor of Skingrad slipped into a coma because she refused to feed, so according to lore, there are consequences. In TES IV: Oblivion the quest to cure yourself requires you to find a cure for her. By this time she has been unfed and in a coma so long that the cure kills her as well as curing her vampirism.
So no, you cannot actually die from not feeding, you might linger in some sort of undead coma which is close enough.
Hortator Mopa wrote: »First rule of vampire fan boying, use rp and lore to advantage but ignore that you are hypocritical and dont want guards to attack you.
It's kinda hilarious just considering how much you would whine if vampires was 100% like in past ES games =P
I can tell you something with 80% certainty, you would see none but vampires in Cyrodiil at night time, as vampires are overpowered as *** in lore and in past ES games.
In ESO Zenimax made it balanced to the point of vampirism being really bland. Vampires doesn't have the insane weaknesses like sun damage or being Killed-On-Sight, but instead neither do they have their insane power levels.
You can keep cryin' all you want man, but it won't get you anywhere.
Hortator Mopa wrote: »First rule of vampire fan boying, use rp and lore to advantage but ignore that you are hypocritical and dont want guards to attack you.
Well, do you want guards to attack you? Just walk into any town and have the people there try to murder you? I'm guessing no, so you can understand why other players don't want that, either.Now personally I believe the mechanics should have always fit the lore. You should have started stronger, but the longer you went without feeding you should have lost skills and power while the sun damage and other debuffs got stronger as well. I've never understood why they did it the other way.
They did it the other way to not inconvenience the players. The lore on humans, for example, says that if they don't eat or drink, they die. Well, that's not the case in ESO. My totally human sorcerer will never die of starvation. This is a good thing. If people wanted to bore themselves with such menial chores, they would play real life.
Oh. Right. Kill people because it's tradition. Makes perfect sense. Not.