frogthroat wrote: »Oakensoul isn't really a great mythic, even for HA one bar builds it gets outperformed by Velothi.
You sure? Are you really saying that whichever damage skills you can pack on your one bar using Velothi, the 15% damage increase and 99% decrease on your heavy attacks will be more dps than what Empowered heavy attacks are on Oakensoul build?
Just a quick calculation: Let's say you have 5x skills and they do on average 5k dps each. That 5k dps from a skill would become 5.75k with Velothi. If you pack 5 of those on your 1 bar, with Velothi your advantage from skills would be 750x5 over Oakensoul. We ignore here all the damage buffs Oakensoul gives that you would not have on your Velothi HA build just to give Velothi more advantage. In this scenario, Oakensoul heavy attacks should do less than 3.75k x 1.01 = 3787 dps for a Velothi HA one bar build to come on top. Even if you would be wearing nothing else but Oakensoul and a Lightning Staff, your HA dps would be more than 3787.
Are you sure you meant Velothi one bar HA build would outperform Oakensoul HA build?
I also mixed up things, for HA 1-bar builds I meant to say Rakkhat's is better, not Velothi. As Velothi caps 99% of your heavies, so you were right to be skeptical.
Though Velothi does outperform Oakensoul 1-bar beam builds for example, anything not reliying on heavies.

ShutUpitsRed wrote: »
This community is so weird about Oakensoul. I genuinely don't understand why the naysayers don't get it: it's not about meta, it's not about "being better," it's not about efficiency, it's about having fun! Even accessibility aside, you can throw on Oakensoul and LITERALLY ANYTHING ELSE and have a workable build that will get you through normal content. Funny sounding set you're picking up while questing? Try it out with Oakensoul, nothing to lose. Subclassing giving you a headache and you just want to mix and match and try things out without sitting on a parse dummy all day? Oakensoul! "Oh but you can get XYZ buffs from all these other sources" ok? I don't want to cast Ulfsild's every ten seconds or whatever. I don't want to buy a new DLC. I don't want neon green arcanist skills polluting my eyes. In fact I kind of hate the visual effects of most buff skills and Oakensoul lets me actually enjoy the aesthetics of my characters! Themed builds and aesthetic skill sets and all kinds of PvP shenanigans are made so much easier (and more fun, imo) with Oakensoul.
Also, 100% uptime minor heroism is no joke, especially in PvP where you're never out of combat.
Meta and endgame etc is its own consideration, but the vast majority of players don't give a single hoot about veteran content, and when they do, then people can be pushy about what they're running when playing video game.
I think the main issue with this ring is that its fans take any criticism of effectiveness of oakensoul builds as an attack on 1 bar setups , casual players and accesibility-centered options in general.
BretonMage wrote: »I think the main issue with this ring is that its fans take any criticism of effectiveness of oakensoul builds as an attack on 1 bar setups , casual players and accesibility-centered options in general.
Tbh I have not seen this in quite some time, these days it's quite the opposite. You tend to get mass downvoted on reddit if you bring up Oakensoul.
Also, a lot of players do really love this mythic, so it's natural they might have wanted to push back on criticism against it. Imagine if there was a single item that opened the door to a huge amount of content in the game. It's not hard to see why they'd appreciate it so much.
I personally just don't like how it is being advertized to new players as this awesome thing, almost like a cheat code to the game. And they just beeline to Oakensoul, without even looking into other options that maybe could've worked better for them (even in terms of accessibility, like the aforementioned pale order ring).
The whole comment was great but I think this summarises the yay-sayer side quite nicely.ShutUpitsRed wrote: »This community is so weird about Oakensoul. I genuinely don't understand why the naysayers don't get it: it's not about meta, it's not about "being better," it's not about efficiency, it's about having fun! Even accessibility aside, you can throw on Oakensoul and LITERALLY ANYTHING ELSE and have a workable build that will get you through normal content.
tbh, Oakensoul was a mistake to be added after so many years of the game. It created such a rift in a community that was not very needed especially after disaster of U35. On one side you had established players that spent months of their time perfecting their skills, just to be matched with people equipping one singular item giving quadrillion constant buffs and just holding one button all the time, having both amazing trash clear and boss dps at the same time. On the other side you had less skilled and disabled players that could comfortably reach content they could not play before, opening trials and difficult achievements for them.
When these groups clash, it was quickly realized that Oak players are stuck on their specific level, while "traditional" builds could hone their skills further and improve. This lead to both exclusion by top groups that wanted all the power they could get and feeling of entitlement from subsection of Oak users demanding to be included in these groups.
This could all be avoided if instead of Oak, Rakkhat only would be added. Sure, its still would be less powerful than LA build, but less of a stigma of "just wanting rewards without effort" or "item for the disabled".
Personally I don't mind it, but I'd never use it, even with my arthritis. Tried it few times and the combat just felt boring with it, but if people find it fun then go ahead. I just feel it causes unnecessary drama that could easily be avoided if Rakkhat was added instead.
ShutUpitsRed wrote: »
This community is so weird about Oakensoul. I genuinely don't understand why the naysayers don't get it: it's not about meta, it's not about "being better," it's not about efficiency, it's about having fun! Even accessibility aside, you can throw on Oakensoul and LITERALLY ANYTHING ELSE and have a workable build that will get you through normal content. Funny sounding set you're picking up while questing? Try it out with Oakensoul, nothing to lose. Subclassing giving you a headache and you just want to mix and match and try things out without sitting on a parse dummy all day? Oakensoul! "Oh but you can get XYZ buffs from all these other sources" ok? I don't want to cast Ulfsild's every ten seconds or whatever. I don't want to buy a new DLC. I don't want neon green arcanist skills polluting my eyes. In fact I kind of hate the visual effects of most buff skills and Oakensoul lets me actually enjoy the aesthetics of my characters! Themed builds and aesthetic skill sets and all kinds of PvP shenanigans are made so much easier (and more fun, imo) with Oakensoul.
Also, 100% uptime minor heroism is no joke, especially in PvP where you're never out of combat.
Meta and endgame etc is its own consideration, but the vast majority of players don't give a single hoot about veteran content, and when they do, then people can be pushy about what they're running when playing video game.
No no no... See? You're not getting the point - if you defend Oakensoul you are simply, objectively wrong. Period. /s
Jokes aside, I appreciated the meme XD gave me the laugh I neededbut maybe I didn't really need it, 'cause I could have sourced it elsewhere XP
I'm having too much fun; I'll stop here...
ShutUpitsRed wrote: »
This community is so weird about Oakensoul. I genuinely don't understand why the naysayers don't get it: it's not about meta, it's not about "being better," it's not about efficiency, it's about having fun! Even accessibility aside, you can throw on Oakensoul and LITERALLY ANYTHING ELSE and have a workable build that will get you through normal content. Funny sounding set you're picking up while questing? Try it out with Oakensoul, nothing to lose. Subclassing giving you a headache and you just want to mix and match and try things out without sitting on a parse dummy all day? Oakensoul! "Oh but you can get XYZ buffs from all these other sources" ok? I don't want to cast Ulfsild's every ten seconds or whatever. I don't want to buy a new DLC. I don't want neon green arcanist skills polluting my eyes. In fact I kind of hate the visual effects of most buff skills and Oakensoul lets me actually enjoy the aesthetics of my characters! Themed builds and aesthetic skill sets and all kinds of PvP shenanigans are made so much easier (and more fun, imo) with Oakensoul.
Also, 100% uptime minor heroism is no joke, especially in PvP where you're never out of combat.
Meta and endgame etc is its own consideration, but the vast majority of players don't give a single hoot about veteran content, and when they do, then people can be pushy about what they're running when playing video game.
I think the main issue with this ring is that its fans take any criticism of effectiveness of oakensoul builds as an attack on 1 bar setups , casual players and accesibility-centered options in general.
It's really confusing..1 bar and HA builds existed before Oakensoul and can perform well with other mythics. Like the others have said, velothi, pale order and rakkhats are really useful even for solo casual setups and can be great for accesibility as well. For example, pale order takes away the pressure of having to heal your char, which is great when you are fighting something like a dragon or a world boss. Even monster sets can be good and are far easier to get for a beginner (plus you can choose one that fits your character thematically if that's your thing).
In general, I would recommend people to explore different options instead of just focusing on this specific ring. Obviously, jumping from not having a build to using an oakensoul build would feel like an awesome power boost, but it doesn't mean that this mythic is god mode like some youtubers suggest.
SwordOfSagas wrote: »Oaken soul is awesome, I have basically every role that uses oaken soul and also all there 2 bar counterparts. I'm not physically disabled and don't need it but it's nice not having to keep buffs up tbh.
BlackTearsOfHope wrote: »I have nerve damage and my hands hurt and go numb, especially switching 2bars over and over.
If I play this game without it for any extended time I can't enjoy the game and feels like a chore; having to take long breaks from it.
Oakensoul is a life saver, after 20+ years of playing games, pc and console, I just can't anymore.
With it, I can enjoy arenas, dungeons, trials, ect.
It's not a game killer like people exaggerate, even when it first came out; although I wish it was like it was when it came out but still good.
I'm sure this is what they intended it for and it's wonderful.
BretonMage wrote: »I think the main issue with this ring is that its fans take any criticism of effectiveness of oakensoul builds as an attack on 1 bar setups , casual players and accesibility-centered options in general.
Tbh I have not seen this in quite some time, these days it's quite the opposite. You tend to get mass downvoted on reddit if you bring up Oakensoul.
Also, a lot of players do really love this mythic, so it's natural they might have wanted to push back on criticism against it. Imagine if there was a single item that opened the door to a huge amount of content in the game. It's not hard to see why they'd appreciate it so much.
rhythmsuji wrote: »YEP! And there should be zero reason to attack you or any Oaken/HA user like some of the elitists do. Because enjoyment of the game is literally the most important aspect of gaming. If it's how you enjoy playing, then it aint wrong. No matter how much they demand their perspective is "objectively" right.
rhythmsuji wrote: »https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NhiZPuoC7Mc
Why Oakensoul is an important part of our game & community, why you should check it out and might need it, what DLC or game access you need to get it, where to find the leads. etc