isadoraisacat wrote: »BardokRedSnow wrote: »isadoraisacat wrote: »I'm not sure the linked page is the best guide, it concerns ceramics. In any case, the pronunciation would probably also vary by country: the USA pronunciation would no doubt be very different to the European, UK or Australian (for example).
I’m American born and raised and I say “ar-cane-ist”
So am I lol but I still say Ar ka nist lol, and I’m southern to boot
Even Zos calls it that. The early example where someone used Lorkhan doesn’t work because the emphasis comes from the kh. There isn’t any in arcanist. There’s no e, and the word isn’t arcane. It’s clearly pronounced Ar can ist. Sound it out y’all.
I’m northern too boot. And the dictionary even says ar-cane-ist the root word is arcane not arcan that’s not a word. I did sound it out you all.
BardokRedSnow wrote: »I’m American born and raised and I say “ar-cane-ist”
isadoraisacat wrote: »BardokRedSnow wrote: »isadoraisacat wrote: »I'm not sure the linked page is the best guide, it concerns ceramics. In any case, the pronunciation would probably also vary by country: the USA pronunciation would no doubt be very different to the European, UK or Australian (for example).
I’m American born and raised and I say “ar-cane-ist”
So am I lol but I still say Ar ka nist lol, and I’m southern to boot
Even Zos calls it that. The early example where someone used Lorkhan doesn’t work because the emphasis comes from the kh. There isn’t any in arcanist. There’s no e, and the word isn’t arcane. It’s clearly pronounced Ar can ist. Sound it out y’all.
I’m northern too boot. And the dictionary even says ar-cane-ist the root word is arcane not arcan that’s not a word. I did sound it out you all.
English pronunciation is irretrievably broken. Here, have a laugh at this: http://www.ojohaven.com/fun/crazy.htmlBardokRedSnow wrote: »isadoraisacat wrote: »BardokRedSnow wrote: »isadoraisacat wrote: »I'm not sure the linked page is the best guide, it concerns ceramics. In any case, the pronunciation would probably also vary by country: the USA pronunciation would no doubt be very different to the European, UK or Australian (for example).
I’m American born and raised and I say “ar-cane-ist”
So am I lol but I still say Ar ka nist lol, and I’m southern to boot
Even Zos calls it that. The early example where someone used Lorkhan doesn’t work because the emphasis comes from the kh. There isn’t any in arcanist. There’s no e, and the word isn’t arcane. It’s clearly pronounced Ar can ist. Sound it out y’all.
I’m northern too boot. And the dictionary even says ar-cane-ist the root word is arcane not arcan that’s not a word. I did sound it out you all.
Thats not how pronunciation works. Example, profane- profanity. Its pro fan ity, not pro fane ity. Root words don't dictate pronunciation.
ACamaroGuy wrote: »isadoraisacat wrote: »I’m Italian American from the east coast and I say “ar-cane-ist”Kiralyn2000 wrote: »American north-east, but not New Yawk or Bahstan.
I’m not from either of those places but the place most gavone stereotypes come from on tv.
I'm also an American Italian from the east coast and I say it the same way.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y31jRIhtvqoFeedbackOnly wrote: »ACamaroGuy wrote: »isadoraisacat wrote: »I’m Italian American from the east coast and I say “ar-cane-ist”Kiralyn2000 wrote: »American north-east, but not New Yawk or Bahstan.
I’m not from either of those places but the place most gavone stereotypes come from on tv.
I'm also an American Italian from the east coast and I say it the same way.
I am from the West saying it the same way
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y31jRIhtvqo
Too bad they do not have the only correct way to pronounce Arcanist, at least yet.
Kiralyn2000 wrote: »
isadoraisacat wrote: »I think it comes down to focusing on the root word which is arcane. To me arcane is a magical word.
To me ARCANE-ist makes the most emphasis on the most important part of the word.
Some letters are silent in the English language for whatever silly reason so I don’t even think about the lack of e because an arcan isn’t a thing.
Kiralyn2000 wrote: »
My sister. Who also pronounces "Skyrim" as "Skirr-im". Don't ask me.... I don't know why.
isadoraisacat wrote: »I think it comes down to focusing on the root word which is arcane. To me arcane is a magical word.
To me ARCANE-ist makes the most emphasis on the most important part of the word.
Some letters are silent in the English language for whatever silly reason so I don’t even think about the lack of e because an arcan isn’t a thing.
As others have pointed out (esp. with that profane - profanity example), that's not how English pronunciation works. (Assuming English pronunciation works at all, which I'm not too sure of.) Then there's also "arcana" ( https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/arcanum ).
Now, does that "prove" a certain pronunciation? Certainly not, we're talking about English after all.* But it means that a pronunciation closely following "arcane" doesn't automatically follow.
* If "Arcanist" were some random place in England, it would probably be pronounced "knayst".
P.S. In "arcane", the E may be silent, but it has a function. The E that suggests that the previous syllable (-can-) is a long glide, so pronounced like "cane". Notice how you differentiate between "can" and "cane" by adding a silent E.
isadoraisacat wrote: »BardokRedSnow wrote: »I’m American born and raised and I say “ar-cane-ist”isadoraisacat wrote: »BardokRedSnow wrote: »isadoraisacat wrote: »I'm not sure the linked page is the best guide, it concerns ceramics. In any case, the pronunciation would probably also vary by country: the USA pronunciation would no doubt be very different to the European, UK or Australian (for example).
I’m American born and raised and I say “ar-cane-ist”
So am I lol but I still say Ar ka nist lol, and I’m southern to boot
Even Zos calls it that. The early example where someone used Lorkhan doesn’t work because the emphasis comes from the kh. There isn’t any in arcanist. There’s no e, and the word isn’t arcane. It’s clearly pronounced Ar can ist. Sound it out y’all.
I’m northern too boot. And the dictionary even says ar-cane-ist the root word is arcane not arcan that’s not a word. I did sound it out you all.
Thats not how pronunciation works. Example, profane- profanity. Its pro fan ity, not pro fane ity. Root words don't dictate pronunciation.