thankyourat wrote: »Strider_Roshin wrote: »thankyourat wrote: »Strider_Roshin wrote: »Strider_Roshin wrote: »Kidz_BeAstx wrote: »I'd have to say MagDK just because they're damage is garbage in open world. They do not make good 1vxers, my friend plays stamina dragonknight and I keep telling him that MagDK is not good open world but he always has to say "Oh but Deltias said this, or SypherPk said that", I made him a build for his stamdk, he is poor as hell, this build is successful, then guess what he does? He switches builds 4 times in one week which really pisses me off because the one that I told him to wear was working, and also because he is always begging me for materials. I'm getting kind of tired of it.
MagDK > stamDK in every aspect
Sometimes I wonder if we're all playing the same game.
Open world, by definition, implies you're rarely/never fighting 1v1, almost always 1vX or small group.
1vX, stamDK is worlds better than mDK, like...not even remotely close. Even 1v1 is close, but stamDK imo is superior here as well.
mDKs are very strong in small groups, but probably marginally ahead of stamDK.
mDKs got a nice buff but overall they're still just 'meh.' Very little burst and any decent player will proactively heal through all of your DoT damage.
So you think a tanking proc set stamDK is more effective at 1vX than a tanky Destro Ult + Enhale + Talons spamming magDK? Yeah there's a world of a difference alright, and it's in the magDKs favor.
I think stam dk is better than mag dk. Every Stam class will be better than their magicka counterpart for solo PvP because the dynamics of solo PvP better fit the stamina playstyle. It's easier for stamina builds to reposition and they have better more easily accessible burst damage. Which are two of the most important things when playing solo PvP. As for what makes Stam dk better than mag dk for solo PvP is it hits twice as hard while being just as tanky and has acsess to a gap closer and a execute. This is just for solo play I feel group play is the complete opposite with magicka being much better
You are either incredibly bias or ignorant. The magDK is stupid OP and the stamDK is garbage in comparison.
I think stam dk is the best class in the game. I can kite a mag dk all day. Mag dk still has open world problems it's op in duels and great in group play but it's not all that great for solo play. But I agree mag dk is op. I been thought it was op before the buffs. I just think stam dk is on another level than the rest of the classes it's just so solid. it also has twice the burst damage as a mag dk, better healing and mobility, and an execute. The only thing mag dk had over Stam is crowd control. Both classes are op. But there is no way to counter a stam dk it literally has everything
Magsorc with its limited and easily countered play style is far too predictable and easy to counter in open world. 2 or 3half decent players that know how to do decent burst can *** on a magsorc, and it leaves very little counterplay for the magsorc
Strider_Roshin wrote: »thankyourat wrote: »Strider_Roshin wrote: »Strider_Roshin wrote: »Kidz_BeAstx wrote: »I'd have to say MagDK just because they're damage is garbage in open world. They do not make good 1vxers, my friend plays stamina dragonknight and I keep telling him that MagDK is not good open world but he always has to say "Oh but Deltias said this, or SypherPk said that", I made him a build for his stamdk, he is poor as hell, this build is successful, then guess what he does? He switches builds 4 times in one week which really pisses me off because the one that I told him to wear was working, and also because he is always begging me for materials. I'm getting kind of tired of it.
MagDK > stamDK in every aspect
Sometimes I wonder if we're all playing the same game.
Open world, by definition, implies you're rarely/never fighting 1v1, almost always 1vX or small group.
1vX, stamDK is worlds better than mDK, like...not even remotely close. Even 1v1 is close, but stamDK imo is superior here as well.
mDKs are very strong in small groups, but probably marginally ahead of stamDK.
mDKs got a nice buff but overall they're still just 'meh.' Very little burst and any decent player will proactively heal through all of your DoT damage.
So you think a tanking proc set stamDK is more effective at 1vX than a tanky Destro Ult + Enhale + Talons spamming magDK? Yeah there's a world of a difference alright, and it's in the magDKs favor.
I think stam dk is better than mag dk. Every Stam class will be better than their magicka counterpart for solo PvP because the dynamics of solo PvP better fit the stamina playstyle. It's easier for stamina builds to reposition and they have better more easily accessible burst damage. Which are two of the most important things when playing solo PvP. As for what makes Stam dk better than mag dk for solo PvP is it hits twice as hard while being just as tanky and has acsess to a gap closer and a execute. This is just for solo play I feel group play is the complete opposite with magicka being much better
You are either incredibly bias or ignorant. The magDK is stupid OP and the stamDK is garbage in comparison.
Anti_Virus wrote: »
Nah not at all noy based on its own kit, if you run Tremorscale/Viper etc it doen't even compete with stam sorc.
Those are sets that any class can run and do way better.
Anti_Virus wrote: »thankyourat wrote: »Strider_Roshin wrote: »thankyourat wrote: »Strider_Roshin wrote: »Strider_Roshin wrote: »Kidz_BeAstx wrote: »I'd have to say MagDK just because they're damage is garbage in open world. They do not make good 1vxers, my friend plays stamina dragonknight and I keep telling him that MagDK is not good open world but he always has to say "Oh but Deltias said this, or SypherPk said that", I made him a build for his stamdk, he is poor as hell, this build is successful, then guess what he does? He switches builds 4 times in one week which really pisses me off because the one that I told him to wear was working, and also because he is always begging me for materials. I'm getting kind of tired of it.
MagDK > stamDK in every aspect
Sometimes I wonder if we're all playing the same game.
Open world, by definition, implies you're rarely/never fighting 1v1, almost always 1vX or small group.
1vX, stamDK is worlds better than mDK, like...not even remotely close. Even 1v1 is close, but stamDK imo is superior here as well.
mDKs are very strong in small groups, but probably marginally ahead of stamDK.
mDKs got a nice buff but overall they're still just 'meh.' Very little burst and any decent player will proactively heal through all of your DoT damage.
So you think a tanking proc set stamDK is more effective at 1vX than a tanky Destro Ult + Enhale + Talons spamming magDK? Yeah there's a world of a difference alright, and it's in the magDKs favor.
I think stam dk is better than mag dk. Every Stam class will be better than their magicka counterpart for solo PvP because the dynamics of solo PvP better fit the stamina playstyle. It's easier for stamina builds to reposition and they have better more easily accessible burst damage. Which are two of the most important things when playing solo PvP. As for what makes Stam dk better than mag dk for solo PvP is it hits twice as hard while being just as tanky and has acsess to a gap closer and a execute. This is just for solo play I feel group play is the complete opposite with magicka being much better
You are either incredibly bias or ignorant. The magDK is stupid OP and the stamDK is garbage in comparison.
I think stam dk is the best class in the game. I can kite a mag dk all day. Mag dk still has open world problems it's op in duels and great in group play but it's not all that great for solo play. But I agree mag dk is op. I been thought it was op before the buffs. I just think stam dk is on another level than the rest of the classes it's just so solid. it also has twice the burst damage as a mag dk, better healing and mobility, and an execute. The only thing mag dk had over Stam is crowd control. Both classes are op. But there is no way to counter a stam dk it literally has everything
Um I don't know man, Stam DK has nothing special going for it, using proc sets/Weapons skills/Trap beast etc are not DK skills these can easily be used on other classes way more effectively.
CatchMeTrolling wrote: »Yeah the poll is bias cause you can't even compare solo and small group play so it's inaccurate in that regard. Anyone thinking magplar is a solo class is out of their mind, then on top of that some of the classes people are saying is bad doesn't make sense such as sorc & stam dk.
On top of that people are proving my point when I say they judge a class by wanting it to be a jack of all trades saying things like "Well we have good damage, sustain, mobility but we're squishy"
This jack of all trades mentality ruins the game, no class should have everything & that's one of the biggest problems with balance & broken builds.
HEBREWHAMMERRR wrote: »Mageblade..too many reasons to list but I'll settle for a nightblade buff in general of old cloak purge and a buff to swallow soul damage to align with the recent cost increase and concealed weapon increase to align with the already high cost. Plz and ty!
Lol so far 1 class alone vs the other 3 got 62% vote worst, and magblade itself got 42%.
And I actually think it's not fair it should be like 80% saying magblade is the worst.
That's true of concealed weapon..I suppose it is good and was a staple when using my old lich / Julianos back in the day since you could spam it but then heavy armor meta took over..thankyourat wrote: »HEBREWHAMMERRR wrote: »Mageblade..too many reasons to list but I'll settle for a nightblade buff in general of old cloak purge and a buff to swallow soul damage to align with the recent cost increase and concealed weapon increase to align with the already high cost. Plz and ty!
I think it would be better for pvp if they increase the healing instead of the damage of moves like strife and path. Make the hots actually useful in light armor. Because as of now they are kind of weak. Idk what to do with concealed weapon. It hits pretty hard but it cost so much magicka. it hits most medium armor builds for like 7k with crits, but what's the point of using this over strife when strife is cheaper and has increased healing. I don't think they could buff concealed weapon damage because it does hit hard against medium and light builds. it's just some heavy armor builds take no damage. I think that's a different problem all together though
Magsorc with its limited and easily countered play style is far too predictable and easy to counter in open world. 2 or 3half decent players that know how to do decent burst can *** on a magsorc, and it leaves very little counterplay for the magsorc
LeifErickson wrote: »Strider_Roshin wrote: »Kidz_BeAstx wrote: »I'd have to say MagDK just because they're damage is garbage in open world. They do not make good 1vxers, my friend plays stamina dragonknight and I keep telling him that MagDK is not good open world but he always has to say "Oh but Deltias said this, or SypherPk said that", I made him a build for his stamdk, he is poor as hell, this build is successful, then guess what he does? He switches builds 4 times in one week which really pisses me off because the one that I told him to wear was working, and also because he is always begging me for materials. I'm getting kind of tired of it.
MagDK > stamDK in every aspect
Sorry but what? Stam dk is one of the best classes in the game.
arkansas_ESO wrote: »This is the part where everybody votes for the class they play the most, lol
Strider_Roshin wrote: »They're pretty solid, but their magicka counterpart is superior.
Strider_Roshin wrote: »We've been nerfed since homestead (evasion, unchained, and cost increase for Incap). Whereas all of magicka got buffed, and Stamplars got a strong buff. Stamblades were comparable to the other classes pre-homestead, but when everyone else got buffed, stamblades became subpar in comparison.
arkansas_ESO wrote: »This is the part where everybody votes for the class they play the most, lol
naahh...Iplaying as stamblade and as I see nb is just the worst class to open world pvpe especially when cloak doenst work but at all magblade is much worse than stamblade as I see it...stamblade have chance to run away on rolldodge build will maglade...no good heals except healing wart and jsut weak swallow soul HoTStrider_Roshin wrote: »They're pretty solid, but their magicka counterpart is superior.
in 1v1 yes they are but in 1vX is harder to play in compare to stam dk and whaaat?? overall dk is the best to 1vX and survive very long with still killing those nubsStrider_Roshin wrote: »We've been nerfed since homestead (evasion, unchained, and cost increase for Incap). Whereas all of magicka got buffed, and Stamplars got a strong buff. Stamblades were comparable to the other classes pre-homestead, but when everyone else got buffed, stamblades became subpar in comparison.
evasion using moslty by stupid tankly sick heavy armors while medium armor is seriousily squishy and this evasion mfrom medium armor skill line should be alboe to use while wearing minimum 5 medium armor parts, not while you are on full have, please stop QQ about evasion while you are wearing heavy
unchained nerf alosis mostly hurtin into heavy armor because sick meta for this and incap const increase I feel fore huing in pve stamblade than on pvp
arkansas_ESO wrote: »This is the part where everybody votes for the class they play the most, lol
naahh...Iplaying as stamblade and as I see nb is just the worst class to open world pvpe especially when cloak doenst work but at all magblade is much worse than stamblade as I see it...stamblade have chance to run away on rolldodge build will maglade...no good heals except healing wart and jsut weak swallow soul HoTStrider_Roshin wrote: »They're pretty solid, but their magicka counterpart is superior.
in 1v1 yes they are but in 1vX is harder to play in compare to stam dk and whaaat?? overall dk is the best to 1vX and survive very long with still killing those nubsStrider_Roshin wrote: »We've been nerfed since homestead (evasion, unchained, and cost increase for Incap). Whereas all of magicka got buffed, and Stamplars got a strong buff. Stamblades were comparable to the other classes pre-homestead, but when everyone else got buffed, stamblades became subpar in comparison.
evasion using moslty by stupid tankly sick heavy armors while medium armor is seriousily squishy and this evasion mfrom medium armor skill line should be alboe to use while wearing minimum 5 medium armor parts, not while you are on full have, please stop QQ about evasion while you are wearing heavy
unchained nerf alosis mostly hurtin into heavy armor because sick meta for this and incap const increase I feel fore huing in pve stamblade than on pvp
Anti_Virus wrote: »
Nah not at all noy based on its own kit, if you run Tremorscale/Viper etc it doen't even compete with stam sorc.
Those are sets that any class can run and do way better.
What? The class has an amazing kit. Igneous shield and battle roar are respectively two of the best active and passive skills in the entire game. Venom claw is one of the strongest DoT's in the entire game, and noxious breath gives major fracture with any weapon. These give stam dk the ability to stack DoT's in a way that no other class can. DoTs are hella good in PvE and PvP. Stam DK can get up to 37% extra healing. Igneous Shield+Hardened Armor can give a 4-6k damage shield on a stam build, something no other class can do. They get 3k spell resist as a passive and block more damage than any other class. Take Flight is a gap closing AoE stamina burst with a 20k tooltip that is undodgable and has a CC. Corrosive makes you invincible, tops off your resources, and lets you completely ignore armor resist.
Almost every single passive in the DK tree is relevant to stamina builds, which is something you can't say about the other classes.
Seriously, what are you talking about? Also, Bloodspawn>Everything on DK.
These kinda threads are very insightful in revealing who's input on balance to never take seriously. Cus stam DK is bad for solo play and worse than magicka DK.
thankyourat wrote: »Anti_Virus wrote: »thankyourat wrote: »Strider_Roshin wrote: »thankyourat wrote: »Strider_Roshin wrote: »Strider_Roshin wrote: »Kidz_BeAstx wrote: »I'd have to say MagDK just because they're damage is garbage in open world. They do not make good 1vxers, my friend plays stamina dragonknight and I keep telling him that MagDK is not good open world but he always has to say "Oh but Deltias said this, or SypherPk said that", I made him a build for his stamdk, he is poor as hell, this build is successful, then guess what he does? He switches builds 4 times in one week which really pisses me off because the one that I told him to wear was working, and also because he is always begging me for materials. I'm getting kind of tired of it.
MagDK > stamDK in every aspect
Sometimes I wonder if we're all playing the same game.
Open world, by definition, implies you're rarely/never fighting 1v1, almost always 1vX or small group.
1vX, stamDK is worlds better than mDK, like...not even remotely close. Even 1v1 is close, but stamDK imo is superior here as well.
mDKs are very strong in small groups, but probably marginally ahead of stamDK.
mDKs got a nice buff but overall they're still just 'meh.' Very little burst and any decent player will proactively heal through all of your DoT damage.
So you think a tanking proc set stamDK is more effective at 1vX than a tanky Destro Ult + Enhale + Talons spamming magDK? Yeah there's a world of a difference alright, and it's in the magDKs favor.
I think stam dk is better than mag dk. Every Stam class will be better than their magicka counterpart for solo PvP because the dynamics of solo PvP better fit the stamina playstyle. It's easier for stamina builds to reposition and they have better more easily accessible burst damage. Which are two of the most important things when playing solo PvP. As for what makes Stam dk better than mag dk for solo PvP is it hits twice as hard while being just as tanky and has acsess to a gap closer and a execute. This is just for solo play I feel group play is the complete opposite with magicka being much better
You are either incredibly bias or ignorant. The magDK is stupid OP and the stamDK is garbage in comparison.
I think stam dk is the best class in the game. I can kite a mag dk all day. Mag dk still has open world problems it's op in duels and great in group play but it's not all that great for solo play. But I agree mag dk is op. I been thought it was op before the buffs. I just think stam dk is on another level than the rest of the classes it's just so solid. it also has twice the burst damage as a mag dk, better healing and mobility, and an execute. The only thing mag dk had over Stam is crowd control. Both classes are op. But there is no way to counter a stam dk it literally has everything
Um I don't know man, Stam DK has nothing special going for it, using proc sets/Weapons skills/Trap beast etc are not DK skills these can easily be used on other classes way more effectively.
Yea but all stamina classes are like that because there are very few stamina options for in class abilities. Stam dk can still use it's magicka class skills and passives making it absurdly tanky and get really good burst from weapon skill lines. Stam dk's also have amazing ultimates and are Demi-gods with sword and board. 2hand and bow is still great for open world as well
Anti_Virus wrote: »-Igneous shield and Battle roar are also Mdk skills
- Venomous Claw is a great dot only good for PVE
Purges, Shields and Cloak exist in PVP to negate it
- Noxius breath misses half the time in PVP and applies major fracture a debuff that tanks apply most of the time in PVE
- No Stam DK is getting a large shield like that unless you have a high HP 15% of 25K is 3K /2 = 1.5K shield, but then you're just a tank.
- Templars also get about 3K spell resist passive(Balanced Warrior) check yourself.
- DBoS >>> Tank Flight(especially against vampires) and you get 3% WD
- Templars have a block passive( Spear wall) as well check yourself
- Corrosive armor is bugged in PVP it doesn't give you invincibility like it should Armor pen is good I'll give you that
- Yes I can other classes have great passives for stam builds, NBs has amazing ulti gen, armor buffs for using any shadow skill regen, Sorcs get cost reduction etc.
So no Stam DK is not a complete class and Other classes are way better with just Monster sets/ Weapons
Want mobility? Stam sorc
Want high burst? Stam NB/ Stam Templar
Want to be a troll tank/ Cheese with proc sets? Stam DK with its terrible dots for PVP.