Ward morph to stamina would give stam sorcs the ability to go all in on stamina.
Darnathian wrote: »Darnathian wrote: »A stam based shield like hardened ward, would destroy any hope of balance in this game. Imagine a stam NB specced for roll dodge and burst, who could also cast an 11K damage shield. While popping the occasional vigor / rally as extra insurance. 1H is assurance enough for stamina users, it might not be competitive against other stamina users but against a magicka build that's our damage shield.
Magicka builds would cease to exist from competition, much like stamina not too long ago.
EXACTLY. It is not fair. So have all shields stack off health. A class that is designed to do max damage should not get a defense like that. Come on man you are wearing cloth. lol If you want to go offense then keep your CF and what not. BUT NOT SHIELD SCALED OFF IT.
I dont mind dying to a sorc because he outplayed me. I mind dying to a sorc that i was built to fight against, made no mistakes, and still died.
Request Sypher (best DK dueler) fight against a equally good sorc. I will bet 100k he loses.
Sorc is designed to do max damage... do we play the same game ?
ATM yes. Who does more?
Stamina NB and DK and magicka DK.
Darnathian wrote: »Darnathian wrote: »Darnathian wrote: »A stam based shield like hardened ward, would destroy any hope of balance in this game. Imagine a stam NB specced for roll dodge and burst, who could also cast an 11K damage shield. While popping the occasional vigor / rally as extra insurance. 1H is assurance enough for stamina users, it might not be competitive against other stamina users but against a magicka build that's our damage shield.
Magicka builds would cease to exist from competition, much like stamina not too long ago.
EXACTLY. It is not fair. So have all shields stack off health. A class that is designed to do max damage should not get a defense like that. Come on man you are wearing cloth. lol If you want to go offense then keep your CF and what not. BUT NOT SHIELD SCALED OFF IT.
I dont mind dying to a sorc because he outplayed me. I mind dying to a sorc that i was built to fight against, made no mistakes, and still died.
Request Sypher (best DK dueler) fight against a equally good sorc. I will bet 100k he loses.
Sorc is designed to do max damage... do we play the same game ?
ATM yes. Who does more?
Stamina NB and DK and magicka DK.
DK? lol Maybe in PVE.
Darnathian wrote: »Darnathian wrote: »Darnathian wrote: »A stam based shield like hardened ward, would destroy any hope of balance in this game. Imagine a stam NB specced for roll dodge and burst, who could also cast an 11K damage shield. While popping the occasional vigor / rally as extra insurance. 1H is assurance enough for stamina users, it might not be competitive against other stamina users but against a magicka build that's our damage shield.
Magicka builds would cease to exist from competition, much like stamina not too long ago.
EXACTLY. It is not fair. So have all shields stack off health. A class that is designed to do max damage should not get a defense like that. Come on man you are wearing cloth. lol If you want to go offense then keep your CF and what not. BUT NOT SHIELD SCALED OFF IT.
I dont mind dying to a sorc because he outplayed me. I mind dying to a sorc that i was built to fight against, made no mistakes, and still died.
Request Sypher (best DK dueler) fight against a equally good sorc. I will bet 100k he loses.
Sorc is designed to do max damage... do we play the same game ?
ATM yes. Who does more?
Stamina NB and DK and magicka DK.
DK? lol Maybe in PVE.
If you spec both Sorc and DK for damage, DK will do more, but has less utility.
If you don't believe me it won't make sense arguing about it, you'll just go on complaining.
Tintinabula wrote: »yes.."stand there and tank". Many sorcs (especially you @Teargrants with your 5k+ mag regen) can stand there and tank damage..How much does YOUR hardened ward absorb?
So..while I'm dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..with your hardened ward you can literally stand there and target who you please. and fire and fire and fire...or...you can bolt away to never never land..or..you can leave little bolt blobs to absorb ultimates while I am still dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..
shane.roberts25b14_ESO wrote: »Cinnamon_Spider wrote: »Almost forgot. Nerf sorc thread number 586,465,874.
If over half a million players say sorc is op, don't you think that maybe, just maybe, they're on to something?
Tintinabula wrote: »yes.."stand there and tank". Many sorcs (especially you @Teargrants with your 5k+ mag regen) can stand there and tank damage..How much does YOUR hardened ward absorb?
So..while I'm dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..with your hardened ward you can literally stand there and target who you please. and fire and fire and fire...or...you can bolt away to never never land..or..you can leave little bolt blobs to absorb ultimates while I am still dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..
Tintinabula wrote: »yes.."stand there and tank". Many sorcs (especially you @Teargrants with your 5k+ mag regen) can stand there and tank damage..How much does YOUR hardened ward absorb?
So..while I'm dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..with your hardened ward you can literally stand there and target who you please. and fire and fire and fire...or...you can bolt away to never never land..or..you can leave little bolt blobs to absorb ultimates while I am still dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..
This kind of ignorance on display is exactly why I can't take these forums seriously any more.
The worst part is I think he seriously believes what he says....
I think you guys should be happy you got Vigor. Giving Stamina builds a shield would be akin to giving Magicka builds a magicka based Dodge roll. Stamina users who are built right never run out of stamina as it is.
Tintinabula wrote: »yes.."stand there and tank". Many sorcs (especially you @Teargrants with your 5k+ mag regen) can stand there and tank damage..How much does YOUR hardened ward absorb?
So..while I'm dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..with your hardened ward you can literally stand there and target who you please. and fire and fire and fire...or...you can bolt away to never never land..or..you can leave little bolt blobs to absorb ultimates while I am still dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..
This kind of ignorance on display is exactly why I can't take these forums seriously any more.
The worst part is I think he seriously believes what he says....
Tintinabula wrote: »Tintinabula wrote: »yes.."stand there and tank". Many sorcs (especially you @Teargrants with your 5k+ mag regen) can stand there and tank damage..How much does YOUR hardened ward absorb?
So..while I'm dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..with your hardened ward you can literally stand there and target who you please. and fire and fire and fire...or...you can bolt away to never never land..or..you can leave little bolt blobs to absorb ultimates while I am still dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..
This kind of ignorance on display is exactly why I can't take these forums seriously any more.
The worst part is I think he seriously believes what he says....
Don't insult me. Ive seen it done. I watched a Sorc tank 4 people yesterday JUST STANDING THERE. My damage meter ALONE said that in the course of 5 secs he absorbed well over 10k damage from ME with nothing else BUT hardened ward (not even counting the other three people bashing on him )..so yea...try again.
Tintinabula wrote: »Tintinabula wrote: »yes.."stand there and tank". Many sorcs (especially you @Teargrants with your 5k+ mag regen) can stand there and tank damage..How much does YOUR hardened ward absorb?
So..while I'm dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..with your hardened ward you can literally stand there and target who you please. and fire and fire and fire...or...you can bolt away to never never land..or..you can leave little bolt blobs to absorb ultimates while I am still dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..
This kind of ignorance on display is exactly why I can't take these forums seriously any more.
The worst part is I think he seriously believes what he says....
Don't insult me. Ive seen it done. I watched a Sorc tank 4 people yesterday JUST STANDING THERE. My damage meter ALONE said that in the course of 5 secs he absorbed well over 10k damage from ME with nothing else BUT hardened ward (not even counting the other three people bashing on him )..so yea...try again.
Please, what part ofTintinabula wrote: »yes.."stand there and tank". Many sorcs (especially you @Teargrants with your 5k+ mag regen) can stand there and tank damage..How much does YOUR hardened ward absorb?
do you not understand?Teargrants wrote: »If you watched any of my vids you would understand that the real I win button is perma block.
Please tell me how I stand there and target who I please just by having a shield up that gets eaten in 1-2 hits by any decent player, forcing me to stop any dps and recast it.Tintinabula wrote: »So..while I'm dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..with your hardened ward you can literally stand there and target who you please. and fire and fire and fire...
So, my balls absorb ultimates...so over powered.Tintinabula wrote: »or...you can bolt away to never never land..or..you can leave little bolt blobs to absorb ultimates while I am still dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..
Tintinabula wrote: »I'm not saying you're overpowered. I check who I am up against constantly.. I learn from fights (or try to). I read the damage meters to see what they have used. I try to find counters and comparable skills that these good players (like yourself ) use.
Again comparing your BOL which is an escape as well to wings? cmon.
I saw this sorc doing a good job absorbing damage. I immediately went to my skills and started checking to see what shield I had that absorbed that much damage and..the only thing I could find was if I maxed my health and sacrificed dps.
Again I am sure you understand the difficulty in using a bow or sword and board while having to dodge every 4 seconds?
where is your sacrifice in dps to absorb that much damage?
I usually find that the opinions of the masses are wrong. How many people thought the world would end because of the Mayan calendar?shane.roberts25b14_ESO wrote: »Cinnamon_Spider wrote: »Almost forgot. Nerf sorc thread number 586,465,874.
If over half a million players say sorc is op, don't you think that maybe, just maybe, they're on to something?
Tintinabula wrote: »Cinnamon_Spider wrote: »Stam builds already have the equivalent shield to hardened ward. Its called blocking.
this is why we are seeing so many S/B sorcs (best of both worlds)hardened ward is a 8-12k shield depending on your setup.1-2 snipes or wrecking blows and it is down. It is not an I win button. It also does not give immunity to stun. You are focusing to much on the shield itself. I would trade hardened ward for dragonscales in a heartbeat. Far more useful imho.
I dont like playing with my sorc though. Gets tedious. I finally found a magicka built on my temp that I like. 9K blazing shield with infinite magicka, good heals and some fairly good dps. It's good in 1v1-2-3. But no more. 9K blazing shield? 1-2 hits and it is down. Same as hardened ward. Again: no cc immunity. Still need to block stun attacks.
And no. There is no true equivalent for hardened ward as a stam build. But there are other defenses. Such as roll dodge and block. If u get rally + vigor + block + scales and CP in block reduction. No mage can kill you in 1v1. Add to that block casting and well... Sorc QQ incoming. Hell I've seen many sorcs die from: invasion + talons + soul assault. *** hurts
Thankyou for this response. It is good to hear an honest opinion from the other end and Im not too stubborn to see playing a sorc can be tedious. Its just on my end I am trying to balance Mitigation with DPS and when I have to use 3 slots on a skill bar to mitigate what hardened ward does(which takes one slot) that gives me less slots for dps skills. I came to the forums to suggest that perhaps stamina builds could receive a comparable skill.
dont be fooled, i play all 4 classes and your right there is no comparison to hardened ward. Don't let sorcs throw a load of bull at you either.
they compare dodge roll to ward,, but when i,m on my sorc i simply hit bolt at times dodge roll could be used as easily as dodge on my stam classes. dodge doesnt take you well away from certain death by simply pressing it 3 times rapid either.
hardened ward lasts longer is much stronger and costs less that any other shield in the game. you can load an addon that gives u a nice unmissable timer telling you how long before it drops.
in regards to blocking , the biggest damage things in cyrodiil right (not counting ulti's) now are crystal frags, snipe and wrecking blow. now guess which class has one that can be used while holding up sword and board?
cos once again to get maximum mitigation from blocking you want to use sword and board. yep sorcs have the luxury of being able to throw out a couple of instant (non reflectables) like curse or entropy wait for the instant frags to proc and throw out their big damage spell from behind the sword and shield block.
they say block as well. but sorcs can block just fine. yes they have much less stam , but since they have no need to dodge roll (which after all they keep telling you thats the balance for ward) their stam is purely for blocking , not block plus dodge plus dps on a stam character.
but don't take my word for it either. just look around cyrodiil , see how many players are sorcs these days.. folk will change to the most powerfull class in any game like this, right now thats sorcs.. everyone knows it.. just the sorcs on here will attack anyone trying to point out these things.
While I love the idea of a stamina based shield, that would make stam builds way, way too good. I have 24k HP, 26k stam, and almost 2k stamina regen. I keep my build a secret except for friends and guildies for the most part, but it doesn't take rocket science to replicate it. (And imagine if I were a NB lol.) Having 24k HP, 10k+ shielding which cannot be crit, and stamina builds' efficient roll dodging would give stamina way, way too much defensive ability.
The only skill I use my magicka for at the moment is Igneous Shield and sometimes Fossilize anyways . I have no issues using magicka based shielding when I need it. At 24k HP it still gives me a 6k+ shield last I checked.
Nivzruo_ESO wrote: »Tintinabula wrote: »Cinnamon_Spider wrote: »Stam builds already have the equivalent shield to hardened ward. Its called blocking.
this is why we are seeing so many S/B sorcs (best of both worlds)hardened ward is a 8-12k shield depending on your setup.1-2 snipes or wrecking blows and it is down. It is not an I win button. It also does not give immunity to stun. You are focusing to much on the shield itself. I would trade hardened ward for dragonscales in a heartbeat. Far more useful imho.
I dont like playing with my sorc though. Gets tedious. I finally found a magicka built on my temp that I like. 9K blazing shield with infinite magicka, good heals and some fairly good dps. It's good in 1v1-2-3. But no more. 9K blazing shield? 1-2 hits and it is down. Same as hardened ward. Again: no cc immunity. Still need to block stun attacks.
And no. There is no true equivalent for hardened ward as a stam build. But there are other defenses. Such as roll dodge and block. If u get rally + vigor + block + scales and CP in block reduction. No mage can kill you in 1v1. Add to that block casting and well... Sorc QQ incoming. Hell I've seen many sorcs die from: invasion + talons + soul assault. *** hurts
Thankyou for this response. It is good to hear an honest opinion from the other end and Im not too stubborn to see playing a sorc can be tedious. Its just on my end I am trying to balance Mitigation with DPS and when I have to use 3 slots on a skill bar to mitigate what hardened ward does(which takes one slot) that gives me less slots for dps skills. I came to the forums to suggest that perhaps stamina builds could receive a comparable skill.
dont be fooled, i play all 4 classes and your right there is no comparison to hardened ward. Don't let sorcs throw a load of bull at you either.
they compare dodge roll to ward,, but when i,m on my sorc i simply hit bolt at times dodge roll could be used as easily as dodge on my stam classes. dodge doesnt take you well away from certain death by simply pressing it 3 times rapid either.
hardened ward lasts longer is much stronger and costs less that any other shield in the game. you can load an addon that gives u a nice unmissable timer telling you how long before it drops.
in regards to blocking , the biggest damage things in cyrodiil right (not counting ulti's) now are crystal frags, snipe and wrecking blow. now guess which class has one that can be used while holding up sword and board?
cos once again to get maximum mitigation from blocking you want to use sword and board. yep sorcs have the luxury of being able to throw out a couple of instant (non reflectables) like curse or entropy wait for the instant frags to proc and throw out their big damage spell from behind the sword and shield block.
they say block as well. but sorcs can block just fine. yes they have much less stam , but since they have no need to dodge roll (which after all they keep telling you thats the balance for ward) their stam is purely for blocking , not block plus dodge plus dps on a stam character.
but don't take my word for it either. just look around cyrodiil , see how many players are sorcs these days.. folk will change to the most powerfull class in any game like this, right now thats sorcs.. everyone knows it.. just the sorcs on here will attack anyone trying to point out these things.
This ^
Tintinabula wrote: »Tintinabula wrote: »yes.."stand there and tank". Many sorcs (especially you @Teargrants with your 5k+ mag regen) can stand there and tank damage..How much does YOUR hardened ward absorb?
So..while I'm dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..with your hardened ward you can literally stand there and target who you please. and fire and fire and fire...or...you can bolt away to never never land..or..you can leave little bolt blobs to absorb ultimates while I am still dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..
This kind of ignorance on display is exactly why I can't take these forums seriously any more.
The worst part is I think he seriously believes what he says....
Don't insult me. Ive seen it done. I watched a Sorc tank 4 people yesterday JUST STANDING THERE. My damage meter ALONE said that in the course of 5 secs he absorbed well over 10k damage from ME with nothing else BUT hardened ward (not even counting the other three people bashing on him )..so yea...try again.
Tintinabula wrote: »Tintinabula wrote: »yes.."stand there and tank". Many sorcs (especially you @Teargrants with your 5k+ mag regen) can stand there and tank damage..How much does YOUR hardened ward absorb?
So..while I'm dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..with your hardened ward you can literally stand there and target who you please. and fire and fire and fire...or...you can bolt away to never never land..or..you can leave little bolt blobs to absorb ultimates while I am still dodging and rolling here and there and casting defensive shields and buffs and wings and rolling here and there..
This kind of ignorance on display is exactly why I can't take these forums seriously any more.
The worst part is I think he seriously believes what he says....
Don't insult me. Ive seen it done. I watched a Sorc tank 4 people yesterday JUST STANDING THERE. My damage meter ALONE said that in the course of 5 secs he absorbed well over 10k damage from ME with nothing else BUT hardened ward (not even counting the other three people bashing on him )..so yea...try again.
This sounds like a L2P situation.
Personally, admitting I could not dps a sorc down with four people would be the ultimate insult to my skill and game knowledge. The only one insulting you is your own descriptions of your play.