Ooh, an edit!EDIT:
Oh… I just looked at your vLC run too. You were definitely being carried there. It’s all good, mate, it happens to everyone, and it happens to me a lot as well, whether I’m running one-bar or two-bar setups. Yep…
How does it feel to have all your achievements only because others carried you for free?

I am a buff boi, big and strong!Ok, ok. So you carry all the others? I’m trying to understand what "carry your own weight" really means, since so many players in 2bar setups always use this argument… So what does it really mean? After all, you’re not just the carry player, you carry them all. Is that it?
@twisttop138 I truly understand that. But low DPS comes from “bad” players, no matter what build they use, right? Bad one-bar players do low DPS, but bad two-bar players do even less. I really understand your point about how diabolical it is for tanks in a low-DPS trial, but how does that put him in the "hate against 1bar players"??
HatchetHaro wrote: »
Easy answer: I was in War Machine.
If you don't know, War Machine is a set from the Halls of Fabrication, and for its 5-piece bonus, it grants the wearer and 5 group members Major Slayer when the wearer casts an ultimate.
Basically, it's a group buff set, where the wearer sacrifices a 5-piece bonus for extra damage for the whole group! I'm sorry you didn't know that before, but now you do!I am a buff boi, big and strong!Ok, ok. So you carry all the others? I’m trying to understand what "carry your own weight" really means, since so many players in 2bar setups always use this argument… So what does it really mean? After all, you’re not just the carry player, you carry them all. Is that it?
twisttop138 wrote: »The problem isn't really that mythic. I see people do great in content, even dlc hm trial content with it or a 1 bar build. The problem is there has been this attitude that became the stereotype for 1 bar players. You see it in this thread. They get a bad wrap for an unwillingness to learn, an attitude that everyone is against them and if you give suggestions or tell them something then you're a gatekeeping elitist. Who wants to play with that? That's not all 1 bar players but the attitude is there, I've experienced it in content. You want to sign up for a vet run in any of my guilds, come with a willingness to learn or to have fun playing the content. That's it. If your dps isn't high enough, no big deal. We can work on it.
HatchetHaro wrote: »
Easy answer: I was in War Machine.
If you don't know, War Machine is a set from the Halls of Fabrication, and for its 5-piece bonus, it grants the wearer and 5 group members Major Slayer when the wearer casts an ultimate.
Basically, it's a group buff set, where the wearer sacrifices a 5-piece bonus for extra damage for the whole group! I'm sorry you didn't know that before, but now you do!I am a buff boi, big and strong!Ok, ok. So you carry all the others? I’m trying to understand what "carry your own weight" really means, since so many players in 2bar setups always use this argument… So what does it really mean? After all, you’re not just the carry player, you carry them all. Is that it?
Of course, you’re in “support sets” like everyone else, right? So no carrying in your runs, only in other players’ runs? Okay, I see… Anyway, the server’s open, so I’m going to level up my new HA character. Kiss and free hugs!
Nah. Double checking the Orphic Shattered Shard fight, everyone else was in Coral Riptide, other than that one guy in Sul-Xan. This was before subclassing, so metas were a bit different back then.HatchetHaro wrote: »
Easy answer: I was in War Machine.
If you don't know, War Machine is a set from the Halls of Fabrication, and for its 5-piece bonus, it grants the wearer and 5 group members Major Slayer when the wearer casts an ultimate.
Basically, it's a group buff set, where the wearer sacrifices a 5-piece bonus for extra damage for the whole group! I'm sorry you didn't know that before, but now you do!I am a buff boi, big and strong!Ok, ok. So you carry all the others? I’m trying to understand what "carry your own weight" really means, since so many players in 2bar setups always use this argument… So what does it really mean? After all, you’re not just the carry player, you carry them all. Is that it?
Of course, you’re in “support sets” like everyone else, right? So no carrying in your runs, only in other players’ runs? Okay, I see… Anyway, the server’s open, so I’m going to level up my new HA character. Kiss and free hugs!


HatchetHaro wrote: »
Easy answer: I was in War Machine.
If you don't know, War Machine is a set from the Halls of Fabrication, and for its 5-piece bonus, it grants the wearer and 5 group members Major Slayer when the wearer casts an ultimate.
Basically, it's a group buff set, where the wearer sacrifices a 5-piece bonus for extra damage for the whole group! I'm sorry you didn't know that before, but now you do!I am a buff boi, big and strong!Ok, ok. So you carry all the others? I’m trying to understand what "carry your own weight" really means, since so many players in 2bar setups always use this argument… So what does it really mean? After all, you’re not just the carry player, you carry them all. Is that it?
Of course, you’re in “support sets” like everyone else, right? So no carrying in your runs, only in other players’ runs? Okay, I see… Anyway, the server’s open, so I’m going to level up my new HA character. Kiss and free hugs!
SilverBride wrote: »twisttop138 wrote: »The problem isn't really that mythic. I see people do great in content, even dlc hm trial content with it or a 1 bar build. The problem is there has been this attitude that became the stereotype for 1 bar players. You see it in this thread. They get a bad wrap for an unwillingness to learn, an attitude that everyone is against them and if you give suggestions or tell them something then you're a gatekeeping elitist. Who wants to play with that? That's not all 1 bar players but the attitude is there, I've experienced it in content. You want to sign up for a vet run in any of my guilds, come with a willingness to learn or to have fun playing the content. That's it. If your dps isn't high enough, no big deal. We can work on it.
In reply to "They get a bad wrap for an unwillingness to learn", why should any player be expected to learn a playstyle they do not enjoy? One bar builds should have their own strengths and should be comparable to 2 bar builds. Then all players will be able to learn the best way to play and how to carry their own weight in a way they enjoy.
JiubLeRepenti wrote: »
The question of being carried is 100% irrelevant when we speak about trifecta runs in optimized groups...
The goal when you do trifecta trials in an optimized roster isn’t to have the highest DPS as it can be in PUG runs. It’s about being a valuable part of a whole, consistent and interdependent group, where everybody depends on every other member.
JiubLeRepenti wrote: »
The question of being carried is 100% irrelevant when we speak about trifecta runs in optimized groups...
The goal when you do trifecta trials in an optimized roster isn’t to have the highest DPS as it can be in PUG runs. It’s about being a valuable part of a whole, consistent and interdependent group, where everybody depends on every other member.
Right… so Organized Discord groups, where the Raid Leader hand-picks the team ahead of time and tells everyone what they should use, that’s all fine. But if someone joins a group through the finder and the trial go easy, suddenly they say, "Hey, let’s try Trifecta, the group isn’t bad." 10s seconds later, they reset and try again, where all we know is what sets tanks have, what sets healers have, and who’s going through the portal… then the last DPS is expected to be carried? Or the last three? I see…
So, carry runs only happen in group finder play, with people who know the mechanics, don’t care about parsing, or whether someone has one bar or two bars, and all that matters is: complete the content. Okay, okay! Yeah, I’ve been carried a lot of times. And honestly? It’s way better than any Discord group I’ve ever been part of. By far!
Funny… because I never see any "free/selling HM carry runs" in the group finder, but I usually seem them in Discord groups.
OK. I already said it twice, but it seems like I’m going for the third time! I’m 100% of the time playing with Pugs in Finder. You may find me there, or just invite @Zaan's PC-EU. Anything else I type in the forum or anywhere else… it’s just words. What else can I do? I type my words, you type your words, and we both end up feeling like someone’s wrong about the whole topic and why people hate 1bar. How do we solve it? In-game.
edit:
But please, don’t ask me to go on voice, because that would be the first step toward me leaving the group.
HatchetHaro wrote: »Good news! I don't see you in any of the raiding Discord servers I'm in, so chances are, we've never met. Let us keep it that way!
If you don't believe me on my skill and achievements, though, that's fine; I walk the talk, and I bring receipts.
Well, like I said: "You may be or may not be the player I’m thinking of."
How much did you pay for all that? The same I paid for my carries? Or did you achieve it all on your own while expecting everyone else to pay? I see…
You won’t find me in Discord groups, and the reason is simple: I’m too tired of all the toxicity about builds in there. I just can’t handle it anymore on Discord.
You pro players go happy in Discord; I go happy with Group Finder. You pros create all this “toxicity” around new players, casual players, and anyone who doesn’t follow your rules, gatekeeping, elitism, and all that. Meanwhile, I play with pugs, just logging in, learning, and trying to improve.
Maybe one day I’ll have all that without paying like you did… I mean… no, I pay, not you.
And I’d definitely love to have all those achievements. But well… I’m too much of a noob to be part of those groups (not enought money), and that’s 100% true.
At the same time, saying that players with 80k DPS can’t do HM trials says a lot about your achievements.
For the record, the run in question only had 1 single support DD: me!There’s usually 2 or 3 support dds and all the others are wearing pure damage sets.HatchetHaro wrote: »
Easy answer: I was in War Machine.
If you don't know, War Machine is a set from the Halls of Fabrication, and for its 5-piece bonus, it grants the wearer and 5 group members Major Slayer when the wearer casts an ultimate.
Basically, it's a group buff set, where the wearer sacrifices a 5-piece bonus for extra damage for the whole group! I'm sorry you didn't know that before, but now you do!I am a buff boi, big and strong!Ok, ok. So you carry all the others? I’m trying to understand what "carry your own weight" really means, since so many players in 2bar setups always use this argument… So what does it really mean? After all, you’re not just the carry player, you carry them all. Is that it?
Of course, you’re in “support sets” like everyone else, right? So no carrying in your runs, only in other players’ runs? Okay, I see… Anyway, the server’s open, so I’m going to level up my new HA character. Kiss and free hugs!
No one's gonna invite you, man. You can beg all you want, but you've already demonstrated yourself to be 1. unknowledgable of trial mechanics, 2. ignorant of group comps, 3. unable to perform, and 4. unwilling to learn.OK. I already said it twice, but it seems like I’m going for the third time! I’m 100% of the time playing with Pugs in Finder. You may find me there, or just invite @Zaan's PC-EU. Anything else I type in the forum or anywhere else… it’s just words. What else can I do? I type my words, you type your words, and we both end up feeling like someone’s wrong about the whole topic and why people hate 1bar. How do we solve it? In-game.
edit:
But please, don’t ask me to go on voice, because that would be the first step toward me leaving the group.
It feels like maybe an easy solution to this is for ZOS to stop balancing new content around current min-maxing DPS numbers. I remember back when something like 50k-60k was more than enough for Vet everything (maybe not Vet HM or Trifectas, but most everything else). Maybe going forward hard DPS checks and the like should be consistently balanced more around...idk 80k, 90k, and focus more on mechanics rather than just how fast things can be burned down. Of course that could affect people doing Speed Run stuff, but perhaps there could be a special mode for that that maybe removes or shortens certain mechanics so they don't artifically add on to a Speed Run?
I don't know but it seems like perhaps normal and Vet Dungeons/Trials shouldn't just constantly be balanced around what a smaller percent of the playerbase can achieve. That's not to say that people should be able to equip all white random gear, use Mag Skills on a character that has 64 Stam and 0 Mag, only spam executes regardless of what health the Boss is at because they like how the Skill looks, and clear all content. What I AM saying is that people should be able to complete a majority of the content (and again I'll repeat I'm not even talking vet HM or Trifectas, just normal and Vet Dungeons and Trials) regardless of whether they use a 1-bar or 2-bar build and regardless of whether it's HA or not.
HatchetHaro wrote: »No one's gonna invite you, man. You can beg all you want, but you've already demonstrated yourself to be 1. unknowledgable of trial mechanics, 2. ignorant of group comps, 3. unable to perform, and 4. unwilling to learn.
HatchetHaro wrote: »No one's gonna invite you, man. You can beg all you want, but you've already demonstrated yourself to be 1. unknowledgable of trial mechanics, 2. ignorant of group comps, 3. unable to perform, and 4. unwilling to learn.
Of course no one will invite me, and I know that. The reasons are everything you said, plus:
1) We all know that in any organized top group, HA builds will be completely useless. That’s just a fact.
2) But for any other vet HM content, especially in pugs from Group Finder or even guild runs, any 1bar build can carry a lot of players and show them how “useless” they are with 2bars.
The real issue for you, and others who talk about 1bar builds is this: in pugs, you might end up performing worse than a 1bar player. And that’s why you don’t invite me, because I can prove it. You hate that, and I love it.
JiubLeRepenti wrote: »HatchetHaro wrote: »No one's gonna invite you, man. You can beg all you want, but you've already demonstrated yourself to be 1. unknowledgable of trial mechanics, 2. ignorant of group comps, 3. unable to perform, and 4. unwilling to learn.
Of course no one will invite me, and I know that. The reasons are everything you said, plus:
1) We all know that in any organized top group, HA builds will be completely useless. That’s just a fact.
2) But for any other vet HM content, especially in pugs from Group Finder or even guild runs, any 1bar build can carry a lot of players and show them how “useless” they are with 2bars.
The real issue for you, and others who talk about 1bar builds is this: in pugs, you might end up performing worse than a 1bar player. And that’s why you don’t invite me, because I can prove it. You hate that, and I love it.
Once again, that’s not the point.
You might outplay some two-bar players who perform poorly. But the potential of two-bar gameplay will always be higher than that of one-bar gameplay.
Can I beat a Bugatti Veyron in a speed race with my BMW i8 if I drive like a pro and the Bugatti driver is very bad? Yeah, sure. But if both drivers are at the same level, the Bugatti will still crush me. And guess what? In a speed race, any good driver will choose the Bugatti over the BMW, even if the BMW wins 10% of the time.
Your potential as a one-bar player is, and will always be, lower than the potential of a two-bar player. The max you can potentially reach will always be lower. That's it.
JiubLeRepenti wrote: »HatchetHaro wrote: »No one's gonna invite you, man. You can beg all you want, but you've already demonstrated yourself to be 1. unknowledgable of trial mechanics, 2. ignorant of group comps, 3. unable to perform, and 4. unwilling to learn.
Of course no one will invite me, and I know that. The reasons are everything you said, plus:
1) We all know that in any organized top group, HA builds will be completely useless. That’s just a fact.
2) But for any other vet HM content, especially in pugs from Group Finder or even guild runs, any 1bar build can carry a lot of players and show them how “useless” they are with 2bars.
The real issue for you, and others who talk about 1bar builds is this: in pugs, you might end up performing worse than a 1bar player. And that’s why you don’t invite me, because I can prove it. You hate that, and I love it.
Once again, that’s not the point.
You might outplay some two-bar players who perform poorly. But the potential of two-bar gameplay will always be higher than that of one-bar gameplay.
Can I beat a Bugatti Veyron in a speed race with my BMW i8 if I drive like a pro and the Bugatti driver is very bad? Yeah, sure. But if both drivers are at the same level, the Bugatti will still crush me. And guess what? In a speed race, any good driver will choose the Bugatti over the BMW, even if the BMW wins 10% of the time.
Your potential as a one-bar player is, and will always be, lower than the potential of a two-bar player. The max you can potentially reach will always be lower. That's it.
And where did I disagree with that? If we compare two endgame 2bar players versus one endgame 1bar player, the 2bar players will always win by far, as I said before. And this is how it should be! A 1bar player should never even come close to matching a 2bar player with a perfect rotation. I agree with this, and I never said otherwise.
And if any player can use 2 bars, they should learn weaving as soon as possible, because at some point they will outperform any 1bar build.
But my point still stands:
This whole discussion is not about endgame content. It’s about "Why the hate for one-bar builds? It needs to stop — some players don’t like weapon swapping." And that’s valid! Because in pugs, Group Finder, guild runs, and most veteran or even HM content, a 1bar build is more than enough to complete it.
Top-tier players, like @HatchetHaro for example, perform incredibly well in fully optimized groups. But in unorganized pug runs, where those ideal conditions don’t exist, their advantage shrinks significantly. In those situations, a simple and consistent 1bar build can sometimes outperform them.
- And this is why you all hate 1bar players. This is why you gatekeep them and this is why my point is 100% valid.
In pugs, Group Finder, or even many guild runs, the main focus should be completing the content with the group you have. But too many players only care about their damn parse numbers in Hodor.
lol!?JiubLeRepenti wrote: »Yea... It "should" be (for you).
JiubLeRepenti wrote: »But the reality is that many people who do PUG runs just want the run to get done as fast as possible, for so many reasons:
- because they're farming sets
- because they've already done this trial 30 times before
- because they're doing the daily dungeon on several toons to farm scripts and don't have time to lose
- etc.
HatchetHaro wrote: »
Easy answer: I was in War Machine.
If you don't know, War Machine is a set from the Halls of Fabrication, and for its 5-piece bonus, it grants the wearer and 5 group members Major Slayer when the wearer casts an ultimate.
Basically, it's a group buff set, where the wearer sacrifices a 5-piece bonus for extra damage for the whole group! I'm sorry you didn't know that before, but now you do!I am a buff boi, big and strong!Ok, ok. So you carry all the others? I’m trying to understand what "carry your own weight" really means, since so many players in 2bar setups always use this argument… So what does it really mean? After all, you’re not just the carry player, you carry them all. Is that it?
Of course, you’re in “support sets” like everyone else, right? So no carrying in your runs, only in other players’ runs? Okay, I see… Anyway, the server’s open, so I’m going to level up my new HA character. Kiss and free hugs!
For me, ZOS could and should remove everything related to DPS sharing, like Hodor Reflexes, logs, and similar tools. That would be a first step toward stopping the kind of nonsense the game has turned into.
In everything you said, where is the reason to hate one-bar players especially those who can parse 100k, handle mechanics, and contribute to the group more than many 2bar players?
Isn’t 100k more than enough to complete all the content you mentioned?
You mention “daily dungeons on multiple toons to farm scripts” what could be more perfect than a simple onebar beam for that?! oO
Or you could do it even faster with 180k parse and only endgame score-push players, right?JiubLeRepenti wrote: »"... Once again: it's not about being able to do it. It's about doing it as fast as possible. You can do it with 100k, but you could do it even faster with 140k on two bars...."
Or you could do it even faster with 180k parse and only endgame score-push players, right?JiubLeRepenti wrote: »"... Once again: it's not about being able to do it. It's about doing it as fast as possible. You can do it with 100k, but you could do it even faster with 140k on two bars...."
So how about this: you and your friends who think like that keep playing with score-push players at 180k parse in Discord, and let new players, casuals, and anyone else who’s “inferior” to you play the way they like in guilds, PUGs, and Group Finder, without gatekeeping them. Cuz, they’re just there to play the game, while you’re there to score-push.
Does that seem fair?[/b]
Or you could do it even faster with 180k parse and only endgame score-push players, right?JiubLeRepenti wrote: »"... Once again: it's not about being able to do it. It's about doing it as fast as possible. You can do it with 100k, but you could do it even faster with 140k on two bars...."
So how about this: you and your friends who think like that keep playing with score-push players at 180k parse in Discord, and let new players, casuals, and anyone else who’s “inferior” to you play the way they like in guilds, PUGs, and Group Finder, without gatekeeping them. Cuz, they’re just there to play the game, while you’re there to score-push.
I read this somewhere and kept it in my signature. I really believe it fits perfectly here:
- "If you don’t want random players, don’t ask for them. Build your roster on Discord, not in Group Finder."
Does that seem fair?
SilverBride wrote: »twisttop138 wrote: »The problem isn't really that mythic. I see people do great in content, even dlc hm trial content with it or a 1 bar build. The problem is there has been this attitude that became the stereotype for 1 bar players. You see it in this thread. They get a bad wrap for an unwillingness to learn, an attitude that everyone is against them and if you give suggestions or tell them something then you're a gatekeeping elitist. Who wants to play with that? That's not all 1 bar players but the attitude is there, I've experienced it in content. You want to sign up for a vet run in any of my guilds, come with a willingness to learn or to have fun playing the content. That's it. If your dps isn't high enough, no big deal. We can work on it.
In reply to "They get a bad wrap for an unwillingness to learn", why should any player be expected to learn a playstyle they do not enjoy? One bar builds should have their own strengths and should be comparable to 2 bar builds. Then all players will be able to learn the best way to play and how to carry their own weight in a way they enjoy.
JiubLeRepenti wrote: »Or you could do it even faster with 180k parse and only endgame score-push players, right?JiubLeRepenti wrote: »"... Once again: it's not about being able to do it. It's about doing it as fast as possible. You can do it with 100k, but you could do it even faster with 140k on two bars...."
So how about this: you and your friends who think like that keep playing with score-push players at 180k parse in Discord, and let new players, casuals, and anyone else who’s “inferior” to you play the way they like in guilds, PUGs, and Group Finder, without gatekeeping them. Cuz, they’re just there to play the game, while you’re there to score-push.
I read this somewhere and kept it in my signature. I really believe it fits perfectly here:
- "If you don’t want random players, don’t ask for them. Build your roster on Discord, not in Group Finder."
Does that seem fair?
It may be your perfect vision of the game. But I'm afraid it'll never happen.It's been 11 years like that and it'll never change, no matter what you think/want.
- Some people will keep leaving the group after a first wipe on the first boss. Or even on the second or the third.
- Some people will keep leaving the group if they consider the group DPS is too low.
- Some people will keep kicking you from the group if they consider your onebar build doesn't meet their expectations.
- Some people will keep leaving a group if they see that several group members have low CPs.
- Some people will keep asking you to share your stuff to check if it's good enough.
- Some people will keep blaming low CP/onebar builds if they don't pass the boss.
- And some people will keep expecting players who join a PUG to bring the best DPS possible to get the run done fast.
That's how an MMO with endgame/HL content works. There's nothing you can change about it. You can surely think/say people who act like that are jerks. But they'll stay on the game and keep flaming onebar players, noobies, casuals, etc.
That's the way it was. That's the way it is. That's the way it'll be.
Plus, you can always tell those people that you want to play your own way. But you can’t force them to accept you into their group.