SilverBride wrote: »SilverBride wrote: »I hate bar swapping so I was thrilled when Oakensoul was introduced. But now for some reason there is a stigma attached to using it. The most logical answer I can see is to buff it so that it's comparable to 2 bar builds so we can all play how we enjoy.
Oakensoul isn't the issue, it was the destro staff passives nerfing the cleave and the fact that most other weapon types don't synergize with heavy attacks the same. Since then, ZoS has also nerfed some of the class skills that gave passive buffs. One thing that would help is more sources of higher duration empower. I never understood why scribing didn't help out with that. most non-oakensoul heavy attack builds rely on spamming mages guild abilities which is only like 10 seconds of empower.
I probably have less understanding of how skills affect each other than most players here because theorycrafting makes my head explode. But I will never bar swap so even if Oakensoul isn't the issue why can't it be the solution?
Words… nothing more than words!"...."HatchetHaro wrote: »"...."
And @HatchetHaro , if you’re the player I’m thinking of, we might have already done some trials together in pugs, right? No? If you are the player I’m thinking of, let me tell you, bro, you’re not that special either. lol! You may claim whatever you want on the forums, but in-game? Not anything impressive. And I’m just a casual player too. Everyone’s better than me, and I really don’t care.
What I do care about is: “Call me in-game and show me how good you are.”
If you’re not the person I’m thinking of… well, then I can’t say anything about you. But… how can you say I was carried if you don’t even know me? Hm.
What content actually needs or requires 100k+ DPS to complete? I don't mean "it makes it faster/easier" I mean "this content literally has checks that if you don't have at least 100k+ you won't complete it".
And then if someone can meet those requirements, does it matter what their build is? I've watched a number of one-bar builds the last few days because I wanted to try one (rotations with two bars have ALWAYS been really hard for me to keep up with for a number of reasons, the big one being I get overwhelmed and thrown off even simple rotations REALLY EASILY, frustratingly so, and no amount of 'practice' over the years has changed that) and those people seem to be easily hitting 120-140k.
Good news! I don't see you in any of the raiding Discord servers I'm in, so chances are, we've never met. Let us keep it that way!Words… nothing more than words!"...."HatchetHaro wrote: »"...."
And @HatchetHaro , if you’re the player I’m thinking of, we might have already done some trials together in pugs, right? No? If you are the player I’m thinking of, let me tell you, bro, you’re not that special either. lol! You may claim whatever you want on the forums, but in-game? Not anything impressive. And I’m just a casual player too. Everyone’s better than me, and I really don’t care.
What I do care about is: “Call me in-game and show me how good you are.”
If you’re not the person I’m thinking of… well, then I can’t say anything about you. But… how can you say I was carried if you don’t even know me? Hm.

Do you know the relequen mechanic in vCR? Seems NOT.how can you say I was carried if you don’t even know me? Hm.
Do you know the relequen mechanic in vCR? Seems NOT.how can you say I was carried if you don’t even know me? Hm.
I think they are saying you need to adapt for that one trial. I swapped to arcanist, but now there is the Rakkhat mythic. Honestly I didn't like the feel of the Rakkhat mythic due to needing to source empower, which is fairly limited in longer durations. For +3, arcanist is probably your best bet.
Imagine if critical surge got empower tagged on to it during the rebalance?
HatchetHaro wrote: »Good news! I don't see you in any of the raiding Discord servers I'm in, so chances are, we've never met. Let us keep it that way!
If you don't believe me on my skill and achievements, though, that's fine; I walk the talk, and I bring receipts.
HatchetHaro wrote: »Of course people can play how they want to play. It's just that if they join a group and they underperform in their precious one-bar builds, we get to kick them because we play how we want to play: not carrying some buffoon!
Look, when you join a group, you are expected to carry your own weight. Any amount of damage you aren't able to do, the rest of the group has to deal with in the form of longer fight times, more mechanics, more chances of death, and more chances at wiping. So if you bring your Oakensoul build into a trial and you deal at least around average dps in the group, you're golden. But if you start to fall behind, people will start questioning your build.
Blood_again wrote: »I hope necroing this April 2025 outdated topic really worth it.
I guess they could buff it in a way to make them better with flat generic damage boosts. Did you use heavy attacks before the destro staff nerfs? It was a night and day difference to me. Heavy attack builds are just no longer fun for solo farming, for me. Before everything died at a similar time, now you are killing things one at a time mostly, unless there is a boss or heavy health enemy in the middle to splash from.
The DK reworked fire breath feels better, and obviously even beaming with no crux generated feels better. I guess we'll see if sorcerers get enough love to make them more fun, as they are the most popular heavy attack class. I have tried the reworked DK as a heavy attack, I do like the passive off balance and stamina regen.
Peak was not 75k in U35. U35 buffed the trial dummy in such a way that, while some builds saw less damage, others saw more. And before U35? My ROLEPLAY bleed themed build was hitting 90k and my ROLEPLAY frost themed build was hitting 100k iirc. At the time, those were good numbers… but it was not peak. 75k was bad at the time. I joined in 2019 and I have never seen 65k be considered anything but terrible. My first parse, using a Xynode build incorrectly, was 55k.
Right now, 120k is becoming an increasingly common cutoff value, though it wasn’t unheard of before. Before, I recall a 100k cutoff. Before then, it might have been 80k. But I don’t recall seeing it any lower than that (edit: and reminder, those values are BEFORE the dummy got buffed).
Ok, I could have been wrong about the DP, I made that table off the top of my head, didn’t look at logs or anything. But I still stand by my point: why can’t a group with 640k DPS complete any HM? (80k per player)
Based on current carry prices in one of the guilds I'm in, all the trifectas and side-achievements (not counting Maw of Lorkhaj) in that screenshot would cost me 2,460,000,000 gold.HatchetHaro wrote: »Good news! I don't see you in any of the raiding Discord servers I'm in, so chances are, we've never met. Let us keep it that way!
If you don't believe me on my skill and achievements, though, that's fine; I walk the talk, and I bring receipts.
Well, like I said: "You may be or may not be the player I’m thinking of."
How much did you pay for all that? The same I paid for my carries? Or did you achieve it all on your own while expecting everyone else to pay? I see…
You won’t find me in Discord groups, and the reason is simple: I’m too tired of all the toxicity about builds in there. I just can’t handle it anymore on Discord.
You pro players go happy in Discord; I go happy with Group Finder. You pros create all this “toxicity” around new players, casual players, and anyone who doesn’t follow your rules, gatekeeping, elitism, and all that. Meanwhile, I play with pugs, just logging in, learning, and trying to improve.
Maybe one day I’ll have all that without paying like you did… I mean… no, I pay, not you.
And I’d definitely love to have all those achievements. But well… I’m too much of a noob to be part of those groups (not enought money), and that’s 100% true.
At the same time, saying that players with 80k DPS can’t do HM trials says a lot about your achievements.
You won’t find me in Discord groups, and the reason is simple: I’m too tired of all the toxicity about builds in there. I just can’t handle it anymore on Discord.
Requirements: Tanks and healers should have at least one dps buff set. DPS should be comfortably parsing around 50k+.

Requirements:
Sales: None, Just sell!
4 Person Dungeons/Arenas Vet: CP600 Vet DLC / Arenas CP800
Wednesday Weeklies: CP800 + Specific Experience
Open DLC Vet Trials: CP800
Open Craglorn Vet Trials: CP300
Backups: Who ever is in chat at raid time will be given priority in the order they signed up.

Agree, theory crafting in Kerbal space program was just rocket science so pretty intuitive compared to ESO 😺SilverBride wrote: »SilverBride wrote: »I hate bar swapping so I was thrilled when Oakensoul was introduced. But now for some reason there is a stigma attached to using it. The most logical answer I can see is to buff it so that it's comparable to 2 bar builds so we can all play how we enjoy.
Oakensoul isn't the issue, it was the destro staff passives nerfing the cleave and the fact that most other weapon types don't synergize with heavy attacks the same. Since then, ZoS has also nerfed some of the class skills that gave passive buffs. One thing that would help is more sources of higher duration empower. I never understood why scribing didn't help out with that. most non-oakensoul heavy attack builds rely on spamming mages guild abilities which is only like 10 seconds of empower.
I probably have less understanding of how skills affect each other than most players here because theorycrafting makes my head explode. But I will never bar swap so even if Oakensoul isn't the issue why can't it be the solution?
Where’s the “how much dps is needed per person in Rockgrove” statisticians when you need them…
There are DPS checks. Some are self-inflicted because of the strats chosen. Others are kill-or-wipe. Then there’s the third, secret DPS check and that’s “how long can this fight last before people lose focus, get frustrated with wiping, the supports get tired (support jobs can get exponentially harder the longer the fight goes on), we get swarmed by adds, or we fail to executing mechanics poorly because we’re getting more mechanics than a higher dps group?”. Mind you also, 80k in vCR+3 using old strats? That would work. 80k in OC HM? Well, OC HM is balanced around the current meta. That one might not go so well…
HatchetHaro wrote: »I'm not sure what you're arguing here; I'm agreeing with you, and I'm ready to be that wart in the random dungeon queue. Let us all underperform together! Nothing bad will happen when we all underperform and fail to complete a dungeon together!
If you are not min/maxing, are you really playing?
Jokes aside, as long as you know the mechanics of trials, there are no problems with oak.
Where’s the “how much dps is needed per person in Rockgrove” statisticians when you need them…
There are DPS checks. Some are self-inflicted because of the strats chosen. Others are kill-or-wipe. Then there’s the third, secret DPS check and that’s “how long can this fight last before people lose focus, get frustrated with wiping, the supports get tired (support jobs can get exponentially harder the longer the fight goes on), we get swarmed by adds, or we fail to executing mechanics poorly because we’re getting more mechanics than a higher dps group?”. Mind you also, 80k in vCR+3 using old strats? That would work. 80k in OC HM? Well, OC HM is balanced around the current meta. That one might not go so well…
So we agree that 80k DPS (640k group) is enough to complete any HM trial? Okay… maybe not vOC. But 100k DPS should be enough for vOC, right? Any “casual” player can reach 100k in onebar these days, so no problem there. 800K DPS seems enought.
Will these groups be faster than World Record players? Of course not. So why are we even comparing them to one-bar players?! The point is: "Why the hate for one-bar builds?" if any 1bar with 80k player can complete any HM trial? Sure, it might take more time, but will they get it done? Absolutely. That’s more than enough!
SilverBride wrote: »SilverBride wrote: »I hate bar swapping so I was thrilled when Oakensoul was introduced. But now for some reason there is a stigma attached to using it. The most logical answer I can see is to buff it so that it's comparable to 2 bar builds so we can all play how we enjoy.
Oakensoul isn't the issue, it was the destro staff passives nerfing the cleave and the fact that most other weapon types don't synergize with heavy attacks the same. Since then, ZoS has also nerfed some of the class skills that gave passive buffs. One thing that would help is more sources of higher duration empower. I never understood why scribing didn't help out with that. most non-oakensoul heavy attack builds rely on spamming mages guild abilities which is only like 10 seconds of empower.
I probably have less understanding of how skills affect each other than most players here because theorycrafting makes my head explode. But I will never bar swap so even if Oakensoul isn't the issue why can't it be the solution?
Where’s the “how much dps is needed per person in Rockgrove” statisticians when you need them…
There are DPS checks. Some are self-inflicted because of the strats chosen. Others are kill-or-wipe. Then there’s the third, secret DPS check and that’s “how long can this fight last before people lose focus, get frustrated with wiping, the supports get tired (support jobs can get exponentially harder the longer the fight goes on), we get swarmed by adds, or we fail to executing mechanics poorly because we’re getting more mechanics than a higher dps group?”. Mind you also, 80k in vCR+3 using old strats? That would work. 80k in OC HM? Well, OC HM is balanced around the current meta. That one might not go so well…
So we agree that 80k DPS (640k group) is enough to complete any HM trial? Okay… maybe not vOC. But 100k DPS should be enough for vOC, right? Any “casual” player can reach 100k in onebar these days, so no problem there. 800K DPS seems enought.
Will these groups be faster than World Record players? Of course not. So why are we even comparing them to one-bar players?! The point is: "Why the hate for one-bar builds?" if any 1bar with 80k player can complete any HM trial? Sure, it might take more time, but will they get it done? Absolutely. That’s more than enough!
No, we don’t agree. Some trials would be possible, but as trials come out, they are balanced around current damage. I wouldn’t trust 80k dps in anything DSR HM and onwards.
I don’t think anyone mentioned world record players except for you. I’m not a world record player and my best parse on live is 126K. Once Night Market comes out, I can outfit my roleplay Warden build to hit 130k… and I’m pretty mid by endgame dps standards in terms of personal skill. World record players are the ones hitting 180k.
You should try tanking in a low DPS group, it’ll be enlightening.
Pixiepumpkin wrote: »IMO ZOS needs to buff oakensoul, bring it back to some semblance of its former glory.
My suggestion. Keep the buffs as they are, but allow for one more slot. Use the keybind on PC/console that swaps bars for that extra ability.
The most frustrating thing I find about oakensoul is the lack of that one extra ability
The way I see it, any build should have an
• Execute
• Spamable
• Heal
• Shield
• Dot
• Ult
We should add one for
• Utility (pull, taunt, stun, etc)
Most of my toons are one bar builds, and its not due to disliking bar swapping in as much as my ping is terrible and bar swapping is not reliable.
If the above suggestion is too much for some people who will claim it will be "OP" (which it wont) then the minimum ZOS could do is allow back bar passives to affect the front bar like it used to.
https://youtu.be/O1DeP_mT2rI?si=cKqkDSVPL71A9aNz Ooh, I'll be very happy to answer your questions!@HatchetHaro, Let me ask you this, and please don’t take me the wrong way, my question is simple:
You say everyone needs to carry their own weight, and I agree with that. But, you mentioned "they carry me" because I was in HA, and you assuming, rightly or wrongly, that I was the last DPS. Are you implying that the last 3 DPS is automatically being carried by others? If so…
I watched your Trifecta video, and I noticed your name isn’t the top DPS in the group. In fact, it looks like you weren’t leading DPS on the first and last bosses (Last DPS??). Don’t get me wrong, mate, but if they had swapped you out for someone with higher DPS, wouldn’t the overall score have been better?
So were you being carried as well? If not, I’m genuinely trying to understand the difference here. If you, or anyone else, are the last DPS, in 2bars, that’s considered fine, but if it’s an HA player in a pugs run, it’s suddenly called a carry?







Anyways, what happened to not caring? You seem to care enough to watch at least one of the vods@HatchetHaro
You don’t need to post your videos because I really don’t care. I respect your achievements, I really do, but I don’t care, because our ideas of how the game should go are too different.
@twisttop138 I truly understand that. But low DPS comes from “bad” players, no matter what build they use, right? Bad one-bar players do low DPS, but bad two-bar players do even less. I really understand your point about how diabolical it is for tanks in a low-DPS trial, but how does that put him in the "hate against 1bar players"??
@twisttop138 I truly understand that. But low DPS comes from “bad” players, no matter what build they use, right? Bad one-bar players do low DPS, but bad two-bar players do even less. I really understand your point about how diabolical it is for tanks in a low-DPS trial, but how does that put him in the "hate against 1bar players"??
@twisttop138 I truly understand that. But low DPS comes from “bad” players, no matter what build they use, right? Bad one-bar players do low DPS, but bad two-bar players do even less. I really understand your point about how diabolical it is for tanks in a low-DPS trial, but how does that put him in the "hate against 1bar players"??