spartaxoxo wrote: »

Gabriel_H wrote: »

Edit: Re "ruins immersion" - but killing the same WB over and over doesn't? Or the crag quests? Or the trial quests? Or the holiday quests?

And which quests are more memorable and immersive? The Crag Trial quest? WB? Or the one and done stories found through discoveries that your mind knows it has to focus in on because it can't be repeated? Choices actually mattering adds tension and stakes, which increases immersion. It's why many games separate repeatable quests from ones that aren't.

Additionally, I'd rather they work on new content or least new ways to experience older content rather than just working on a system designed purely for rote repetition.

I understand your point, but I think everyone has experienced this in a game: You have to make a choice, you save, make the choice, look at the outcome, close the game, reload the saved file and make the other choice. I bet we all did this at some point.
Being MMO this isn't doable, but having the possibility to replay the quest once completed would be a nice alternative. Appreciated.

Obviously no one here means to force something on those who don't want it. As always - toggles. Usually having more options is a good thing.