I had the achievement way before Zerith-Var became available, and I was able to give to the poor and have it count. So it's not that.
I recently finished Zerith-var's favor on 7/9/2025 for achievement with beggar being the last one needed. I originally earned Give to the Poor on 12/29/2015 and I did both on the character who earned the original achievement. The beggars will still spawn after you have the achievement, but it may take some waiting and I had to wait until after Zenithar's event ended because the Zenithar encounters share a spawn with them. I'm on PC NA, can't speak for other platforms.
I recently finished Zerith-var's favor on 7/9/2025 for achievement with beggar being the last one needed. I originally earned Give to the Poor on 12/29/2015 and I did both on the character who earned the original achievement. The beggars will still spawn after you have the achievement, but it may take some waiting and I had to wait until after Zenithar's event ended because the Zenithar encounters share a spawn with them. I'm on PC NA, can't speak for other platforms.
Same here. Had long had Give to the Poor on my main before companions came out, but I use my main to level all companions and their rapport. I brought Zerith-var to various Give to the Poor spawn points using Map Pins for markers. The random spawns still keep spawning after the Give to the Poor/Lightbringer/etc. are complete. It took a handful of tries to get a beggar spawn. Did it outside of any event, as event spawns don’t seem to count.
You could probably try the one under the bridge in Davons Watch on another char? Can't be that all of your chars talked to him.
And random beggars actually keep spawning, I have the achievement and I see them from time to time.
I had the achievement way before Zerith-Var became available, and I was able to give to the poor and have it count. So it's not that.
When did you do it? Because I'm telling you as of right now, nothing is working. Since they made the achievement account wide, I haven't even seen those guys unless someone else pops them that doesn't have them in my area...
Also, I'm on PS5 and wondering if that is making a difference?
LadyLethalla wrote: »I got the Give to the Poor one despite having completed it before; I'm stuck on the ToT one because I don't like playing it.
LadyLethalla wrote: »I got the Give to the Poor one despite having completed it before; I'm stuck on the ToT one because I don't like playing it.
Yeah me too - I haaate it tbh and don't want. IDK how to just lose fast either.
This isn't true. I got the Give to the Poor achievement only on my main, and I only unlocked Zerith-var for my main and got that particular companion achievement done.1 You need to do this akivement with a character that doesn't already have it.