Although CP is not reflective of skill but rather time played, I think it still good information to know when dealing with an unknown variable of a pug in your group.
At the end of the day, joining guilds is the solution to this issue.
oldbobdude wrote: »aleksandr_ESO wrote: »An achievement link is just a piece of text that you insert into a chat. It can be modified, so it doesn't prove anything.So, tell me; why on earth do you need to see a player's CP if they’ve already linked the achievement? If a player can prove they’ve completed the content, why does CP still matter?
Also, you can be carried through content and still get the achievement.
"The game should be able to automatically detect whether a player have vet achievement before allowing them to join."
How will someone be carried?
oldbobdude wrote: »oldbobdude wrote: »aleksandr_ESO wrote: »An achievement link is just a piece of text that you insert into a chat. It can be modified, so it doesn't prove anything.So, tell me; why on earth do you need to see a player's CP if they’ve already linked the achievement? If a player can prove they’ve completed the content, why does CP still matter?
Also, you can be carried through content and still get the achievement.
"The game should be able to automatically detect whether a player have vet achievement before allowing them to join."
How will someone be carried?
If somebody is asking somebody to link an achievement that doesn’t necessarily mean they weren’t carried to get it to start with.


Come on, you know I’m right! Every guild will ask for parses in Discord, and then they’ll decide whether to gatekeep you or not.
They will gatekeep you even if it’s just a vet run. And they don’t actually care about your CP—they care about your DPS.
If your account is CP 400 but you pull 70k DPS, and they have someone with 91k DPS, they’ll still gatekeep you just because of your low CP… unless there’s no one else available.
You know this is true.
Come on, you know I’m right! Every guild will ask for parses in Discord, and then they’ll decide whether to gatekeep you or not.
They will gatekeep you even if it’s just a vet run. And they don’t actually care about your CP—they care about your DPS.
If your account is CP 400 but you pull 70k DPS, and they have someone with 91k DPS, they’ll still gatekeep you just because of your low CP… unless there’s no one else available.
You know this is true.
Personally, I don't care much about CP either for all the reasons you've mentioned, but this example is just nonsense. The exclusion isn't because of low CP, but because the group has a better option available. So unless this is about a dedicated learning run aimed at new players, it makes no sense to pick a 70k DPS over a 91k one, all other things being equal.
When it comes to organized groups, people really need to stop acting like any selection process is automatically the same as gatekeeping... I'm sure there is a misguided raid lead somewhere who's demanding 100k parses to join a vHRC learning run, but in most cases, raid leads simply try to have the best group they can. And if there's more people than spots, someone will unfortunately be disappointed. Just like in any hiring process or athletic try-out.