I made a thread on here asking them to make it and tagged @ZOS_Kevin (the most likely way to get anything passed on to people who make decisions). It was many months ago but unfortunately nothing yet

There's no other DoT,area,ground effect type enchants,so why would bleed be there?I'd also like a Impenetrable mundus,CP perk to increase chance of alchemical poisons to fire,etc,but probaly won't happen.

belial5221_ESO wrote: »

There's no other DoT,area,ground effect type enchants,so why would bleed be there?I'd also like a Impenetrable mundus,CP perk to increase chance of alchemical poisons to fire,etc,but probaly won't happen.

@belial5221_ESO I doubt they’ll add any additional Mundus stones. However there could be an opening if they ever finish hybridization. Warrior and Apprentice should be combined into one, giving both Weapon and Spell Damage. The unused Mundus could then become crit resistance.

The other Damage types is a one hit thing,not an over time or status effect.Though they can trigger status effect I tihnk.I don't think there's anything in game that does bleed damage as one chunk,would kinda make it pointless without being over time.

Lozeenge wrote: »

belial5221_ESO wrote: »

There's no other DoT,area,ground effect type enchants,so why would bleed be there?

Bleed is a damage type. direct damage, single target, damage-over-time, and area-of-effect attacks are separate from this.

Yep what Lozeenge said.
The wording can be confusing but Im talking about one of the Damage Types in this game: Bleed damage.
Im not talking about the status effect Hemmorrhaging or any Damage over Time effects.
There are 4 physical damage types: Physical, Poison, Disease and Bleed
And 4 magical: Magic, Fire, Ice, Lightning

belial5221_ESO wrote: »

But bleed damage is always a physical damage over time(according to every source I could find).So it's one of those hard to categorize things.It's probably why they never made an enchant for it.

bleed is not physical, those are 2 separate dmg types

bleed can proc the status effect hemorrhaging (small burst of dmg + minor mangle)
physical can proc the status effect sundered (small burst of dmg + minor breach)

the poster above you stated what all 8 dmg types are (each also has its own status effect that it can proc)

belial5221_ESO wrote: »

"All player sources of bleeds will now respect a target’s Physical Resistance. Many adjustments have been made to ensure bleeds deal similar damage to other standard Damage Over Time effects." From U23 update notes people don't read.So it is now considered a physical damage over time from players,unless another patch changed this.It still works same as before from NPCs.

that does not make it physical dmg, that change made it so resistances actually counted, the original bleeds were basically oblivion dmg as they ignored resistance

bleed dmg and physical dmg are 2 different dmg types, though "physical" resistance is what resists both

physical resistance applies mitigation to all "martial" dmg (physical, bleed, poison, disease)
spell resistance applies mitigation to all "magic" dmg (magic, fire, lightning, ice)

an example is if you look at cutting dive warden skill, it explicitly says its "bleed" dmg, pillar of nirn proc set is also "bleed" dmg, it is distinct from "physical" dmg, an example which does explicitly physical dmg would be NB surprise attack

ChRiS_the_GaMeR wrote: »

Necrotech_Master wrote: »

belial5221_ESO wrote: »

"All player sources of bleeds will now respect a target’s Physical Resistance. Many adjustments have been made to ensure bleeds deal similar damage to other standard Damage Over Time effects." From U23 update notes people don't read.So it is now considered a physical damage over time from players,unless another patch changed this.It still works same as before from NPCs.

that does not make it physical dmg, that change made it so resistances actually counted, the original bleeds were basically oblivion dmg as they ignored resistance

bleed dmg and physical dmg are 2 different dmg types, though "physical" resistance is what resists both

physical resistance applies mitigation to all "martial" dmg (physical, bleed, poison, disease)
spell resistance applies mitigation to all "magic" dmg (magic, fire, lightning, ice)

an example is if you look at cutting dive warden skill, it explicitly says its "bleed" dmg, pillar of nirn proc set is also "bleed" dmg, it is distinct from "physical" dmg, an example which does explicitly physical dmg would be NB surprise attack

It’s such a shame in my opinion that these informations are not explained in game. I still got issues knowing or identifying which skill counts as what because the skills aren’t marked for being a dot or direct dmg or both and so on ..

yeah a lot of that is getting to know the wording lol

direct dmg is anything that is a "single instance of dmg", skills like impulse or force/crushing shock are direct dmg
dot dmg is dmg that is applied over time (the wording for this is usually "deal X dmg over Y seconds" or "deal X dmg every Y second(s)"

-wall of elements uses the 2nd variation of dot dmg (deals X dmg every 1 second)
-barbed trap has the first variation (deals X dmg over 20 seconds) (this form is a little harder to understand in my opinion because it doesnt specify the tick rate, though because it is a sticky dot it applies dmg every 2 seconds)

channels are where some things tend to overlap, for example jabs and flurry are both channels, but they are direct dmg not dot even though they apply dmg over the channel duration

however there can also be dot channels too such as the jesus beam or arcanist beam

belial5221_ESO wrote: »

"All player sources of bleeds will now respect a target’s Physical Resistance. Many adjustments have been made to ensure bleeds deal similar damage to other standard Damage Over Time effects." From U23 update notes people don't read.So it is now considered a physical damage over time from players,unless another patch changed this.It still works same as before from NPCs.

Physical =/= Martial.

Bleed is a martial damage type. In other words, it is affected by Physical Pen/Resistance.

Physical damage is also a martial damage type.

That does not mean that bleed is physical damage.

OP is simply asking for consistency. There is an enchant for all 4 magical damage types (Magic, Ice, Fire, Shock) but only 3/4 martial damage types (Physical, Poison, Disease). That means there's no way to apply the Hemorrhaging status effect through an enchant; it's the only status effect in the game that you can't apply via enchant.

CameraBeardThePirate wrote: »

Necrotech_Master wrote: »

ChRiS_the_GaMeR wrote: »

Necrotech_Master wrote: »

belial5221_ESO wrote: »

"All player sources of bleeds will now respect a target’s Physical Resistance. Many adjustments have been made to ensure bleeds deal similar damage to other standard Damage Over Time effects." From U23 update notes people don't read.So it is now considered a physical damage over time from players,unless another patch changed this.It still works same as before from NPCs.

that does not make it physical dmg, that change made it so resistances actually counted, the original bleeds were basically oblivion dmg as they ignored resistance

bleed dmg and physical dmg are 2 different dmg types, though "physical" resistance is what resists both

physical resistance applies mitigation to all "martial" dmg (physical, bleed, poison, disease)
spell resistance applies mitigation to all "magic" dmg (magic, fire, lightning, ice)

an example is if you look at cutting dive warden skill, it explicitly says its "bleed" dmg, pillar of nirn proc set is also "bleed" dmg, it is distinct from "physical" dmg, an example which does explicitly physical dmg would be NB surprise attack

It’s such a shame in my opinion that these informations are not explained in game. I still got issues knowing or identifying which skill counts as what because the skills aren’t marked for being a dot or direct dmg or both and so on ..

yeah a lot of that is getting to know the wording lol

direct dmg is anything that is a "single instance of dmg", skills like impulse or force/crushing shock are direct dmg
dot dmg is dmg that is applied over time (the wording for this is usually "deal X dmg over Y seconds" or "deal X dmg every Y second(s)"

-wall of elements uses the 2nd variation of dot dmg (deals X dmg every 1 second)
-barbed trap has the first variation (deals X dmg over 20 seconds) (this form is a little harder to understand in my opinion because it doesnt specify the tick rate, though because it is a sticky dot it applies dmg every 2 seconds)

channels are where some things tend to overlap, for example jabs and flurry are both channels, but they are direct dmg not dot even though they apply dmg over the channel duration

however there can also be dot channels too such as the jesus beam or arcanist beam

There are exceptions to the wording. Pet damage is always counted as direct damage, even though the tooltips state "damaging the enemy every x seconds".

Arcanist beam is also a weird one - even though it is counted as a DoT it is blockable like direct damage.

true, but the pets skills also dont state at all "cant trigger procs"

for the arcanist beam i think if it wasnt blockable it would be insanely OP in pvp lol, i think jesus beam is also technically blockable, which might be the difference between a normal dot and a channeled dot