LunaFlora wrote: »

whilst it would be nice if they returned i think Grim Harlequin are more likely as they released in 2021 and have never returned.

I disagree. It has been either reaper's harvest or hollowjack every October. Grim Harlequin was released in late September and early December. If they are gonna release Grim Harlequin (which I find likely) they will do it a month or two after whatever they release in October as Grim Harlequin has never been a Halloween crate.

LunaFlora wrote: »

DarthCuddlefluff wrote: »

LunaFlora wrote: »

whilst it would be nice if they returned i think Grim Harlequin are more likely as they released in 2021 and have never returned.

I disagree. It has been either reaper's harvest or hollowjack every October. Grim Harlequin was released in late September and early December. If they are gonna release Grim Harlequin (which I find likely) they will do it a month or two after whatever they release in October as Grim Harlequin has never been a Halloween crate.

Grim Harlequin hasn't been rereleased at all so duh. but it is very obviously Halloween themed

https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Online:Grim_Harlequin_Crate It's sheogorath themed

LunaFlora wrote: »

DarthCuddlefluff wrote: »

LunaFlora wrote: »

DarthCuddlefluff wrote: »

LunaFlora wrote: »

whilst it would be nice if they returned i think Grim Harlequin are more likely as they released in 2021 and have never returned.

I disagree. It has been either reaper's harvest or hollowjack every October. Grim Harlequin was released in late September and early December. If they are gonna release Grim Harlequin (which I find likely) they will do it a month or two after whatever they release in October as Grim Harlequin has never been a Halloween crate.

Grim Harlequin hasn't been rereleased at all so duh. but it is very obviously Halloween themed

https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Online:Grim_Harlequin_Crate It's sheogorath themed

you could say the Reaper's Harvest crates are also Sheogorath themed. it has his costume, banner, and statue.

and the Grim Harlequin crafting motif usually returns in October which literally has the same name as the crates.

what exactly makes Reaper's Harvest more Halloweeny than Grim Harlequin besides that one has returned during October and the other hasn't returned at all?

https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Online:Reaper's_Harvest_Crate Literally says it has a witches festival theme. It comes out every other October, and half the items are skeleton-based. It's really weird that you even want to argue this point. It's not even a question that this year looks like it's gonna have Reaper's Harvest and then Grim Harlequin after that. I see zero reason why they would just randomly replace this Halloween pack that comes out every other year with a pack that's only history suggests that it comes out after for no reason. You seem to kinda want this to happen and idk why. We can both get the crates we want. It's not a competition.

DarthCuddlefluff wrote: »

LunaFlora wrote: »

DarthCuddlefluff wrote: »

LunaFlora wrote: »

DarthCuddlefluff wrote: »

LunaFlora wrote: »

whilst it would be nice if they returned i think Grim Harlequin are more likely as they released in 2021 and have never returned.

I disagree. It has been either reaper's harvest or hollowjack every October. Grim Harlequin was released in late September and early December. If they are gonna release Grim Harlequin (which I find likely) they will do it a month or two after whatever they release in October as Grim Harlequin has never been a Halloween crate.

Grim Harlequin hasn't been rereleased at all so duh. but it is very obviously Halloween themed

https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Online:Grim_Harlequin_Crate It's sheogorath themed

you could say the Reaper's Harvest crates are also Sheogorath themed. it has his costume, banner, and statue.

and the Grim Harlequin crafting motif usually returns in October which literally has the same name as the crates.

what exactly makes Reaper's Harvest more Halloweeny than Grim Harlequin besides that one has returned during October and the other hasn't returned at all?

https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Online:Reaper's_Harvest_Crate Literally says it has a witches festival theme. It comes out every other October, and half the items are skeleton-based. It's really weird that you even want to argue this point. It's not even a question that this year looks like it's gonna have Reaper's Harvest and then Grim Harlequin after that. I see zero reason why they would just randomly replace this Halloween pack that comes out every other year with a pack that's only history suggests that it comes out after for no reason. You seem to kinda want this to happen and idk why. We can both get the crates we want. It's not a competition.

i never made it a competition. it's just very confusing that you don't think Grim Harlequin is Halloween themed despite the motif that only returns in october having the same name as these crates. and that you pointed out it being Sheogorath themed despite Reaper's Harvest crates also having sheo items.

we dont decide what goes into the crown store so it's not certain which crate returns.

these two crates with hollowjack all originally released in September-December. and all have Halloween themed items. i dont know which one returns i just think it would make sense for Grim Harlequin to also be an october crate.