I think they would learn and be fine.

It's not like there are biological differences between the two groups. Just learned behaviour that can be relearned.

Gonna agree. As a gamer, I held controllers in my hand from 3 - 4 years old until I was an adult (37 now). PC is the master race, for sure. But, I play on PS4 with my son's account from time to time, and it's not terribly difficult at all. Especially if you setup the controller right.

I think the differences in ability of the player would be negligible if they were given a short time to adjust.

Add ons = 100% carry

I think console people don't realize how limited the information from addons is. Most addons are quality of life or in some cases (minimap) should be base game features. Generally, they just show additional info on screen.

And before anyone states this, no, addons do not play for you.

A good player will be a good player.

It depends on player's fingers abilities))) how good can those be used

tarhele wrote: »

Posing a question that I have been curious about for a while. I play on both PC and Xbox so I know where I stand on this topic. Do you think PC players would be as efficient at end game content (vet trials for example) if they were playing on a console without the ability to have add-ons?

[snip]
[snip]

[Edit to remove personal information.]

No because they world be forced to use a regressive user input system (controller)

Since I play on both PC and Xbox my own admittedly anecdotal experience is that there is no overall difference in skill between PC and Xbox when the PC players don't use the "helper addons" like Raid Notifier, but instead pay attention to what the game itself is communicating (just like you have to do on console).

However, I have heard PC streamers admit that they (for instance) "can't" do new content until their addons are updated. Whether they were being facetious or not, they have very specifically refused to run new dungeons until certain addons are updated.

Further, when a PC player says that they don't know how anyone on console can play without addons (which is another thing I've heard quite a lot) they are actually admitting without realizing it that they do, to some extent, rely very heavily on those addons.

All that said, since PC and console are effectively different ecosystems, it really doesn't matter. PC players will continue to play on PC and should really only be evaluated based on their peer community, whereas console players will continue to play on console and should be evaluated equivalently.

YMMV.

No.
I am and have always been a PC player.

Forget addon's. They are not what makes the difference in play.

For me, being able to keybind actions is what makes PC gaming excel.

That and I totally suck at a controller.

Playing on both xbox & pc...main on xbox, I would say that add-ons are a bit of a carry, both for new players and endgamers, not all players. Some of the QOL stuff would be good to port over to console, things like load out slots...id even be happy to pay some crowns for extra slots, bit like the outfit slots but actually useful

The advantage of addons on the PC is so great that I made the very painful decision to swap to the PC from the PS4 a few months back.

Rebuilding from scratch AND losing my ingame stuff (mounts, housing, even Crowns and Crown Gems) is a very high price.

It is not end game, but so many things are so much better now, though the loss of everything still irks me greatly.

This would not have been as necessary if even a few key addons were integrated into the game:

Lazy Writ Crafter
BeamMeUp
Harvest Map
Tramiel Trade Center (for pricing, not location since the deals are almost all snatched up before you can get them)

Lazy Riding Skill Trainer
Auto Research
Caro's Enchantment Learner
Traitbuddy
Personal Assistent
Urich's Skill Point Finder


to name a few of them. The first set is more important. Those quality of life aspects should be in the game, not limited to an addon.

I agree with the people saying PC players would need to get used to the controls but would then be able to play just as well on console, and I think it's the same the other way around. Also I don't think the addons which tell you what to do during combat are nearly as popular as some people seem to assume. Maybe high-end trial groups aiming for perfect speed runs insist on them but among more casual groups I've never seen them mentioned as anything more than a possible option, if they're considered at all. The game already had indicators for when to block, dodge etc. and a while ago added options to make things even more obvious with big red and green markers.

Some people might struggle with the controls, but I think many would be surprised at how quickly they can adjust. I actually have more trouble going between different types of controller than going between a controller and keyboard & mouse. (For example I keep cancelling things on the Switch by hitting B because it's where the Xbox's A button and the Playstation's X button is.) Or maybe it just seems that way to me because I've been going between keyboard/mouse (or originally just keyboard) and controllers since I was a kid so I'm used to both.

mikemacon wrote: »

Since I play on both PC and Xbox my own admittedly anecdotal experience is that there is no overall difference in skill between PC and Xbox when the PC players don't use the "helper addons" like Raid Notifier, but instead pay attention to what the game itself is communicating (just like you have to do on console).

However, I have heard PC streamers admit that they (for instance) "can't" do new content until their addons are updated. Whether they were being facetious or not, they have very specifically refused to run new dungeons until certain addons are updated.

Further, when a PC player says that they don't know how anyone on console can play without addons (which is another thing I've heard quite a lot) they are actually admitting without realizing it that they do, to some extent, rely very heavily on those addons.

All that said, since PC and console are effectively different ecosystems, it really doesn't matter. PC players will continue to play on PC and should really only be evaluated based on their peer community, whereas console players will continue to play on console and should be evaluated equivalently.

YMMV.

I don't use combat addons except S'rendarr (buff tracking, it's actually in the game now but with less customisation) but I do have some addons I "can't" play without and in my case it's definitely that I could but I don't want to.

For example when Advanced Filters (another addon whose functionality is now part of the game) stopped working I put off properly sorting my character's inventories and the bank until it was updated. I certainly could have done it without the addon but it wasn't worth the hassle compared to waiting and doing it later.

It's the same with the mini map (my other 'must have' addon). I can and have played without a minimap, but I spend a lot more time stopping to check my map to make sure I'm going in the right direction, because my sense of direction is terrible so I'd probably choose to wait until it was working than play without it.

Chips_Ahoy wrote: »

I think a console trial has more merit than a PC trial with the mods they use or the macros they program on their mice and keyboard, it's cheating.

I thought using macros was against the TOS and would get you banned?

Path wrote: »

No.
I am and have always been a PC player.

Forget addon's. They are not what makes the difference in play.

For me, being able to keybind actions is what makes PC gaming excel.

That and I totally suck at a controller.

Same, never owned an console, think this is more of an European thing.
Easier to get your parents to buy an C64 or spectrum as it was educational. And it was in how to pirate bad games
Afterward I dropped out of gaming but needed an pc for university bout am 286 but swapped it out for an 386sx next year, first job and an 486.
Rest is history, played a bit with consoles at friends. But has an 12 core AMD processor, 64GB ram an 3GB/s 2TB SSD
and 12 TB something on drives.
Awesome part, it was free, company home office deal because of covid.
Weak part is an 980ti, but doubling performance cost an grand,
No I'm not paying an grand for something who is 60% better. For the same reason I don't gold most jewelry even if I can.
The render guy at office want an buff and I lobby him for one of the 2080ti cards

[snip] I have played on both, people act like PC players are biologically made differently.

If you are a good player you will be good rather it is console or PC.

[edited for baiting]