Easy fix to bot problem

Pewpie
Pewpie
✭✭✭
Do not allow anyone to farm bosses. There is no reason whatsoever that anyone should do it.

It is as simple as just make a boss mob drop NOTHING and give NO EXP after you have killed it for at least 5 hours. (Killed it means you got a valid kill and received the item loot).

Fixed. You wont see any more bots around public dungeon bosses *** up the game for regular players.
Edited by Pewpie on April 25, 2014 10:35AM
  • badmojo
    badmojo
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    That doesn't fix the bots. They will find another place to be bots.
    [DC/NA]
  • Pewpie
    Pewpie
    ✭✭✭
    badmojo wrote: »
    That doesn't fix the bots. They will find another place to be bots.

    Well then, expand it and make so you cannot farm any mobs. You get no drops and no exp after a certain amount of kills. Forcing you to move on to other adventures/quests. Grinding/farming is 90's *** anyways.

    Preventing bosses and rare drops to be farmed is a first step, and a VERY easy one to implement.

  • badmojo
    badmojo
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Sure, and let's make all the crafting nodes a one time thing, and then make it so monsters just don't respawn. That way nobody would be able to play it any other way then what you think is the correct way.

    But, they wouldn't sell as many copies if they did that. I know I wouldn't play it.
    [DC/NA]
  • Pewpie
    Pewpie
    ✭✭✭
    badmojo wrote: »
    Sure, and let's make all the crafting nodes a one time thing, and then make it so monsters just don't respawn. That way nobody would be able to play it any other way then what you think is the correct way.

    But, they wouldn't sell as many copies if they did that. I know I wouldn't play it.

    Sounds like you are one of the people doing the botting yourself? Since you point out that the "correct way" is also to grind and farm bosses? And you wouldn't play it if you couldn't...
    Your points are taken from thin air and lack substance. I guess you are in fact hurt by a fix that would prevent you from farming, grinding and making the game *** for everyone else?

    I said nothing about crafting nodes and mob respawns. And the fix i propose has nothing to do with that.
    Edited by Pewpie on April 25, 2014 8:54AM
  • Rologue
    Rologue
    ✭✭✭
    Well then, expand it and make so you cannot farm any mobs. You get no drops and no exp after a certain amount of kills. Forcing you to move on to other adventures/quests. Grinding/farming is 90's *** anyways.

    Preventing bosses and rare drops to be farmed is a first step, and a VERY easy one to implement.

    [/quote]

    No man. Leathers are hard enough to stock without being limited too.
    Guildmaster of Decimation Elite
    "Take all that you can, and give nothing back!"
  • KerinKor
    KerinKor
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Pewpie wrote: »
    badmojo wrote: »
    That doesn't fix the bots. They will find another place to be bots.

    Well then, expand it and make so you cannot farm any mobs. You get no drops and no exp after a certain amount of kills. Forcing you to move on to other adventures/quests. Grinding/farming is 90's *** anyways.

    Preventing bosses and rare drops to be farmed is a first step, and a VERY easy one to implement.
    Yeah, let's prevent players playing the game so the RMT can't either.

    And in spite of your expletive reference to grinding, this game demands it too, leveling crafting requires a massive grind in deconning items from drops and leveling clothing of course means grinding beast mobs .. so your oh-so-easy idea means leveling clothing becomes impossible.

    I love those who come her proclaiming they have an EASY solution, and then proceed to post utterly worthless ideas.

    As for your reply to the other poster, your '10-year-old' and 'you bot' comments show the depth of your thinking, I'd use the term 'ad hominem' because that's what those comments of yours are but there's no way you'll know what that means.

    His comment was simply taking your crass solution to the problem and taking it to a logical conclusion since farming bots are bots like bots that kill mobs: of course, to see that you need to be able to follow logical reasoning, I can see that it may be hard for some.

    Edited by KerinKor on April 25, 2014 9:02AM
  • Pewpie
    Pewpie
    ✭✭✭
    Rologue wrote: »
    Well then, expand it and make so you cannot farm any mobs. You get no drops and no exp after a certain amount of kills. Forcing you to move on to other adventures/quests. Grinding/farming is 90's *** anyways.

    Preventing bosses and rare drops to be farmed is a first step, and a VERY easy one to implement.

    No man. Leathers are hard enough to stock without being limited too.[/quote]

    Craft materials do not have to be involved. If people like grinding and farming mobs for craft stuff, well let them and let it drop (but not the real stuff). But bosses do not have to drop that...

  • Rologue
    Rologue
    ✭✭✭
    A bad idea is a bad idea. Better idea is to assign a few game masters to ban.
    Guildmaster of Decimation Elite
    "Take all that you can, and give nothing back!"
  • Pewpie
    Pewpie
    ✭✭✭
    KerinKor wrote: »
    Pewpie wrote: »
    badmojo wrote: »
    That doesn't fix the bots. They will find another place to be bots.

    Well then, expand it and make so you cannot farm any mobs. You get no drops and no exp after a certain amount of kills. Forcing you to move on to other adventures/quests. Grinding/farming is 90's *** anyways.

    Preventing bosses and rare drops to be farmed is a first step, and a VERY easy one to implement.
    Yeah, let's prevent players playing the game so the RMT can't either.

    And in spite of your expletive reference to grinding, this game demands it too, leveling crafting requires a massive grind in deconning items from drops and leveling clothing of course means grinding beast mobs .. so your oh-so-easy idea means leveling clothing becomes impossible.

    I love those who come her proclaiming they have an EASY solution, and then proceed to post utterly worthless ideas.

    Bosses do not have to be grinded to farm craft ***. Let them farm other stuff and not bosses that people need to kill for quests and stuff.

    The fix i propose is first of all to prevent BOSSES from being farmed/exploited in public dungeons.

  • Pewpie
    Pewpie
    ✭✭✭
    Rologue wrote: »
    A bad idea is a bad idea. Better idea is to assign a few game masters to ban.

    That is a bad idea. And it wont work. After they leave, the bots are back.

    Having GMS banning is like trying to make the ocean dry by pouring out water with a glass. It need to be a technical system that actually makes it invalid to even try it in the first place.

  • Pewpie
    Pewpie
    ✭✭✭
    KerinKor wrote: »
    Pewpie wrote: »
    badmojo wrote: »
    That doesn't fix the bots. They will find another place to be bots.

    Well then, expand it and make so you cannot farm any mobs. You get no drops and no exp after a certain amount of kills. Forcing you to move on to other adventures/quests. Grinding/farming is 90's *** anyways.

    Preventing bosses and rare drops to be farmed is a first step, and a VERY easy one to implement.
    Yeah, let's prevent players playing the game so the RMT can't either.

    And in spite of your expletive reference to grinding, this game demands it too, leveling crafting requires a massive grind in deconning items from drops and leveling clothing of course means grinding beast mobs .. so your oh-so-easy idea means leveling clothing becomes impossible.

    I love those who come her proclaiming they have an EASY solution, and then proceed to post utterly worthless ideas.

    As for your reply to the other poster, your '10-year-old' and 'you bot' comments show the depth of your thinking, I'd use the term 'ad hominem' because that's what those comments of yours are but there's no way you'll know what that means.

    His comment was simply taking your crass solution to the problem and taking it to a logical conclusion since farming bots are bots like bots that kill mobs: of course, to see that you need to be able to follow logical reasoning, I can see that it may be hard for some.

    It is an EASY solution, and it will fix boss camping. It wont HURT anyone but bots.

    If it does, please be so very kind and tell me exactly how it would hurt your gameplay?

  • Rologue
    Rologue
    ✭✭✭
    Consistency is key. Every account is 60 Euro. Ban hundreds a day will cause bankruptcy.
    Guildmaster of Decimation Elite
    "Take all that you can, and give nothing back!"
  • Cherryblossom
    Cherryblossom
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Pewpie wrote: »
    Do not allow anyone to farm bosses. There is no reason whatsoever that anyone should do it.

    It is as simple as just make a boss mob drop NOTHING and give NO EXP after you have killed it for at least 5 hours.

    Fixed. You wont see any more bots around public dungeon bosses *** up the game for regular players.

    I respect the fact you like to play your way, why can you not respect the way others like to play?

    This also doesn't stop bots as they will kill Mobs for drops which is easier, unless you are next going to say that mobs should not drop anything or give exp!
    Edited by Cherryblossom on April 25, 2014 9:13AM
  • Pewpie
    Pewpie
    ✭✭✭
    Pewpie wrote: »
    Do not allow anyone to farm bosses. There is no reason whatsoever that anyone should do it.

    It is as simple as just make a boss mob drop NOTHING and give NO EXP after you have killed it for at least 5 hours.

    Fixed. You wont see any more bots around public dungeon bosses *** up the game for regular players.

    I respect the fact you like to play your way, why can you not respect the way others like to play?

    What exactly do you mean, should i respect the way players like to play the game by camping and farming bosses?

    Edited by Pewpie on April 25, 2014 9:13AM
  • Pewpie
    Pewpie
    ✭✭✭
    As I said, if you don't like the idea, feel free to describe how it would hurt your own gameplay not being able to get DROPS from a BOSS more than once per 5 hours. (in public dungeons and other public areas)
    Edited by Pewpie on April 25, 2014 9:16AM
  • Rologue
    Rologue
    ✭✭✭
    Are u kidding me? Criteria would be Notting. I mean, the thread is against botting, right?
    Guildmaster of Decimation Elite
    "Take all that you can, and give nothing back!"
  • Cepeza
    Cepeza
    ✭✭✭
    Pewpie wrote: »
    Do not allow anyone to farm bosses. There is no reason whatsoever that anyone should do it.

    It is as simple as just make a boss mob drop NOTHING and give NO EXP after you have killed it for at least 5 hours.

    Fixed. You wont see any more bots around public dungeon bosses *** up the game for regular players.

    This will cause real players moan about missing loot from boss because of too less damage done, but hit once. Happened to me like 20 times or so. I land one hit and get near no loot, because all the bots kill that boss in less than 1 second. Then you want people wait for 5 hours? Bad idea.
  • zgrssd
    zgrssd
    ✭✭✭✭
    Pewpie wrote: »
    Do not allow anyone to farm bosses. There is no reason whatsoever that anyone should do it.

    It is as simple as just make a boss mob drop NOTHING and give NO EXP after you have killed it for at least 5 hours.

    Fixed. You wont see any more bots around public dungeon bosses *** up the game for regular players.
    1) This is an extensive extra Database table with Timeout values plus extra processing when checking for loot (N:M between all bosses and all Characters)
    2) This was implemented in 1.0.5 according the Patchnotes
    3) Now they are no longer contained to the dungeons. They are now overrunning quest areas faming gold.

    So instead of solving anything it distributed the problem more evenly where fewer can just ignore it till they are so rare you can live with them.
    Thanks a lot. Such haphazard approaches only made the problem worse. I just hope that this at least dropping thier goldincome/account to the point where it stops being worth the effort.
    Cepeza wrote: »
    This will cause real players moan about missing loot from boss because of too less damage done, but hit once. Happened to me like 20 times or so. I land one hit and get near no loot, because all the bots kill that boss in less than 1 second. Then you want people wait for 5 hours? Bad idea.
    Hit them with the first resto staff heal (the big aoe) when boss spawns. Thier damage will count as you damage as long as they are under your hot.
    It's easier to do with the second hot (because it last's longer) if those are only a few normal farmers, but hitting the swarms easier with teh big aoe.
    Elana Peterson (EU), Dominion, Imperial Sorc, Rune & Alchemy Crafting Char
    Leonida Peterson (EU), Daggerfall, Kajiit Nightblade, Tank & main Crafter
    Kurga Peterson (EU), Ebonhart, Ork Dragonknight, Provision Mule
    Coldblood Peterson (EU) Argonian Templer, Daggerfall, Healer
    Incendia Peterson (EU), Dominion, Dunmer Dragonknight, fire DPS & healer
    Haldor Belendor (EU), Ebonhart, Breton Sorcerer, Tank
    Fuliminictus Peterson (EU), Ebonhart, Altmer Sorcerer, Electric DPS

    Me babbling about PvE roles and Armor, Short Guide to Addon Programming (for Programmers)

    If you think anything I or somebody else said violates the Rules of this Forum, you are free to flag my posts. Till I get any notifcaion from this, I just asume you know you have no case against me or Zenimax disagrees with you.
  • Turelus
    Turelus
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ZOS Please remove all farmable nodes, monster drops and gold from the game. Make the only way to achieve any item in this game via quests, but all quest must be six hours long to avoid over farming.

    This will stop all bots in the game.
    @Turelus - EU PC Megaserver
    "Don't count on others for help. In the end each of us is in this alone. The survivors are those who know how to look out for themselves."
  • Moroch
    Moroch
    ✭✭
    So... not only do you want them to take away that 1g we get, but also remove the minuscule XP one would get from killing that one boss once anyway?

    I understand the frustration, I do, but is it REALLY game breaking? I know I know, I am probably about to be accused of botting too, but my point is this; the "drop" is negligible and the XP is already pointless. I for one am very pleased that the bots are mostly sticking to one part of the game, which is huddled around a boss's spawn point in a dungeon (this is as far as my current game play has been effected).

    There are so many bot threads and spam threads, I think they know what they are doing. Apply the following logic: Anything you can think of, they thought of first. They either don't like it, or question its effectiveness.
    "Go fiddling with any locks around here and we're going to have a real problem"
  • Pewpie
    Pewpie
    ✭✭✭
    Moroch wrote: »
    So... not only do you want them to take away that 1g we get, but also remove the minuscule XP one would get from killing that one boss once anyway?

    I understand the frustration, I do, but is it REALLY game breaking? I know I know, I am probably about to be accused of botting too, but my point is this; the "drop" is negligible and the XP is already pointless. I for one am very pleased that the bots are mostly sticking to one part of the game, which is huddled around a boss's spawn point in a dungeon (this is as far as my current game play has been effected).

    There are so many bot threads and spam threads, I think they know what they are doing. Apply the following logic: Anything you can think of, they thought of first. They either don't like it, or question its effectiveness.

    Hmm, what do you mean? If you kill the mob AND receive the drop and exp your timer would kick in. If you did not get a valid kill of course the timer will not kick in.

    The idea is that when you get the drop, the timer starts. Meaning you cant stand around there farming the same drop over and over and over.

  • Pewpie
    Pewpie
    ✭✭✭
    Cepeza wrote: »
    Pewpie wrote: »
    Do not allow anyone to farm bosses. There is no reason whatsoever that anyone should do it.

    It is as simple as just make a boss mob drop NOTHING and give NO EXP after you have killed it for at least 5 hours.

    Fixed. You wont see any more bots around public dungeon bosses *** up the game for regular players.

    This will cause real players moan about missing loot from boss because of too less damage done, but hit once. Happened to me like 20 times or so. I land one hit and get near no loot, because all the bots kill that boss in less than 1 second. Then you want people wait for 5 hours? Bad idea.

    What? Real players wont miss any loot. If you GET the drop your timer will kick in. If you do not get it you can still kill it again and receive it. Not until you actually did get something it would block you from spam killing the mob.
  • badmojo
    badmojo
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Pewpie wrote: »
    Sounds like you are one of the people doing the botting yourself? Since you point out that the "correct way" is also to grind and farm bosses? And you wouldn't play it if you couldn't...
    Your points are taken from thin air and lack substance. I guess you are in fact hurt by a fix that would prevent you from farming, grinding and making the game *** for everyone else?

    I said nothing about crafting nodes and mob respawns. And the fix i propose has nothing to do with that.

    Of course you said nothing about the crafting nodes, because that would affect you.

    I am one of the people that from time to time enjoys filling their bags with loot from dungeon bosses. Why not? The game is setup so enemies respawn, the game is also setup to drop loot for everyone that bothers to hit them. The game rewards boss killing over regular mobs, who in their right mind wouldn't act on that knowledge and focus their efforts there?

    Do I run bots? Hell no! I manually stand there and intelligently attack the boss at a time that will benefit me without hurting the experience of those around me.

    Is manually farming a boss going against the terms of service, in other words do the developers want people to stop doing it? No. They've made this clear in posts on these forums. They obviously don't encourage it, but it's not against the rules, it's not something they looking to stop.

    They have mentioned it not being courteous to other players. But, that goes with just about everything in this game. Some players will go out of their way to be helpful and enhance your experience. Others will go out of their way to ruin it. Dungeon bosses is just another place for this to play out. Some players will instantly attack the boss as soon as it spawns, knowing the guys running in won't even get a chance, others will wait and make sure everyone gets credit.

    When you make changes that punish the friendly players as well as the unfriendly ones, and justify it by saying it's the real way to play, and on top of that, passing it off as a fix for botting. Yeah, I can't support that. Even if I want them to change the solo dungeon boss setup, and make it way better and less farm/bot friendly, I can't support the idea of just gimping it entirely and making it pointless to do twice, or more than once in a row. No way man, the bots would win. DON'T LET THE BOTS WIN! Give people a chance, we're not going to ruin your game like mindless bots, honest. It was good in the first few days, before the machines came, before they became aware. Before skynet.
    [DC/NA]
  • Moroch
    Moroch
    ✭✭
    This has been suggested in lots of other posts though...

    Search: Bots
    "Go fiddling with any locks around here and we're going to have a real problem"
  • Dunhilda
    Dunhilda
    ✭✭✭
    "easy fix" seems like a nightmare if something that is easy it's most likely unsafe ( Construction H&S )
  • Rousseaux
    Rousseaux
    You cannot get credit for killing a boss? Are you slowpoke or somethin'? To get credit you need to use 1 (one) instant ability/cast on mob. You get credit/loot/exp, everyone's happy.
    I agree that there's a problem with bots and bosses. The best solution: phase the dungeon for every player/group. You get your own mobs, your own boss to kill, loot to loot, exp to exp... lol
    You got the idea.
  • Darzil
    Darzil
    ✭✭✭
    Rousseaux wrote: »
    You cannot get credit for killing a boss? Are you slowpoke or somethin'? To get credit you need to use 1 (one) instant ability/cast on mob. You get credit/loot/exp, everyone's happy.

    Sometimes there are so many bots they kill in one instant attack. If the bot is triggering instant attacks with computer reactions based on the packets hitting the PC, and you are using instant attacks with human reactions based on the boss being drawn, you will lose. If there aren't enough to kill in one instant attack then you are correct.

    Most reliable way I've found is to put heal over times on the bots, that way you get credit.
  • bambi52sigb16_ESO
    They really need to fix this, make it a proper instance once picked clean will not allow you to enter for a day, they can allow for group or solo clearing but as it is now it's just destroying the game experience(such as it is)
    If they don't fix how they works it doesn't matter how many they ban or IF they ban them, the just start again bot the bejezus out of one reach a level enough to port to the next and repeat.
    Edited by bambi52sigb16_ESO on April 25, 2014 11:32AM
  • Zeeed
    Zeeed
    ✭✭✭
    I actually enjoy farming mobs and bosses. So no YOU wont tell me how i play my game i pay for.
    Edited by Zeeed on April 25, 2014 11:33AM
  • elderscrollsb16_ESO109
    Easy fix : remove gold from game.
Sign In or Register to comment.