And we have a right to feel the way we do. and state our position.
if you dont want to play with others that use the addon. create a guild of like minded players.
dont expect us to change the way we enjoy playing the game just because you dont like it.
it aint all about you either.
SilverBride wrote: »Addons are an intended way of eso being played on pc. dont like it. play on console. or play a different game. or convince zos to remove that part of the api.
until they do. using the addon is an allowed way tobplay the game. and none of us are doing anything wrong.
No, you aren't doing anything wrong for using this addon, as long as ZoS allows this. But not being wrong doesn't translate to being right.
How you then use the information is what many of us think is wrong.
spartaxoxo wrote: »perfiction wrote: »spartaxoxo wrote: »specialized tools to read it.spartaxoxo wrote: »You are intercepting information that is NOT made easily publicly available by zos
You have no idea what you are talking about kind sir. Let's say you have your favourite weather synopsis website. That website has public API allowing to get weather information for specific regions. You decide to use that API in your mobile app to get weather info from them and show it on your lock screen (because why not). Does it mean that you are intercepting information that is NOT made easily publicly available?
No more responses to you, you have clearly no clue how ESO API works and how addons utilize it. They can't intercept information without ZOS permission. Addons can do only things that ZOS allows and utilize data that ZOS shares.
It's not about how it functions. It's about what is public or not. It is not public if they aren't the ones making it public. ZOS has it private by default in the game and gives no in-game options to make it public. That by the defintion of privacy, makes it private.
I think you don't know how eso and addons and the public api works.
there are many many thousands of lines of codes and variables and constants in the game. much of it is not accessible at all. it is private to zos.
anything that is in the api that addons can use is put in there on purpose by zos to make it publicly and legally accessible.
They actually ARE the ones making it public.
if y'all could stop targetting us fellow players for using the addon. stating we have no right to access that public information. We do. ZOS gave it to us.
And instead target ZOS. And demand from them they stop making that info public because what drops for you is yours and nobody elses business...
Viewsfrom6ix wrote: »@SilverBride Save your time and brain cells. There is no timeline in the universe where everyone can agreed on this topic.
SilverBride wrote: »Viewsfrom6ix wrote: »@SilverBride Save your time and brain cells. There is no timeline in the universe where everyone can agreed on this topic.
I have plenty of time, and brain cells.
Viewsfrom6ix wrote: »SilverBride wrote: »Viewsfrom6ix wrote: »@SilverBride Save your time and brain cells. There is no timeline in the universe where everyone can agreed on this topic.
I have plenty of time, and brain cells.
What better way than to argue with strangers on the internet over a video game right?
I'm guilty too.
spartaxoxo wrote: »
I personally find it much more reasonable to assume that ZOS is indiferent to the data being used moreso viewing it as being allowed, which implies a level of intent that I don't think is warranted when they have actually welcomed some addons while saying negative things about others and then removing their functionality.
When we have some apps embraced, some repudiated, and some uncommented on, I think it's best to view zos as not having a stance one way or another. Personally. 7 years is a long time tho.
@robertthebardrobertthebard wrote: »Yes, the listening to the drops mechanic, which is background broadcast for the developers to be able to track it. This serves the purpose, as I stated in the post you almost quoted here, of allowing the devs to see when someone is trying to game the system on a drop, or when a legit issue arises with one. This isn't information that we as players need, so it wasn't intended for us to see it. This addon, again, as I pointed out in the post you almost quoted here, changes that functionality, so that we can see it.
BeefcakeManwich wrote: »
Even in a community of nerds playing a video game they liked together. There's still a lack of compassion and empathy.
SilverBride wrote: »
Auth3nticGlitch wrote: »I'm hoping my solution for adding a way to ignore whispers of group members looking for items(with options) will solve everyone's issues, especially for the OP. Those who use the group loot addon can gladly use it and those who don't want to get whispers by those people will simply be ignored with their messages filtered out as if they never even existed. Problem solved IMO, as I mentioned before we should have an option of ignoring/opting out at least this way these discussions will stop because they're never-ending and circular by the looks of it, and they prevent us from doing things we want to do the most, which is play the game the way we want to play the game without anyone telling us how to do that.
Edit: for grammar
Viewsfrom6ix wrote: »spartaxoxo wrote: »SilverBride wrote: »ZOS is. and they are telling us.
most of you are constantly saying "we spy, snoop, illegallily look into your bag, we have no right,...."
these are all targetting us statements like we are doing something bad.
we aint doing any of that ***.
ZoS has a right to snoop into anything we do. You don't.
they sure have a right to snoop. but do they have right to share everything they learn with every other player?
I do not even snoop. zos tells me officially and publicly.
A 3rd party addon is not an official part of the game.
3rd party? ZOS owns our data which we agreed to and made it available through a channel aka API. Read my comments above.
spartaxoxo wrote: »SilverBride wrote: »ZOS is. and they are telling us.
most of you are constantly saying "we spy, snoop, illegallily look into your bag, we have no right,...."
these are all targetting us statements like we are doing something bad.
we aint doing any of that ***.
ZoS has a right to snoop into anything we do. You don't.
they sure have a right to snoop. but do they have right to share everything they learn with every other player?
I do not even snoop. zos tells me officially and publicly.
A 3rd party addon is not an official part of the game.
nope. but it is using an official part of the game that is put there for the express purpose of being used for addons.
spartaxoxo wrote: »Viewsfrom6ix wrote: »spartaxoxo wrote: »SilverBride wrote: »ZOS is. and they are telling us.
most of you are constantly saying "we spy, snoop, illegallily look into your bag, we have no right,...."
these are all targetting us statements like we are doing something bad.
we aint doing any of that ***.
ZoS has a right to snoop into anything we do. You don't.
they sure have a right to snoop. but do they have right to share everything they learn with every other player?
I do not even snoop. zos tells me officially and publicly.
A 3rd party addon is not an official part of the game.
3rd party? ZOS owns our data which we agreed to and made it available through a channel aka API. Read my comments above.
The creator of the app is not ZOS and thus it is by definition a third party app. This is the reason they aren't allowed on consoles.
amm7sb14_ESO wrote: »spartaxoxo wrote: »perfiction wrote: »spartaxoxo wrote: »specialized tools to read it.spartaxoxo wrote: »You are intercepting information that is NOT made easily publicly available by zos
You have no idea what you are talking about kind sir. Let's say you have your favourite weather synopsis website. That website has public API allowing to get weather information for specific regions. You decide to use that API in your mobile app to get weather info from them and show it on your lock screen (because why not). Does it mean that you are intercepting information that is NOT made easily publicly available?
No more responses to you, you have clearly no clue how ESO API works and how addons utilize it. They can't intercept information without ZOS permission. Addons can do only things that ZOS allows and utilize data that ZOS shares.
It's not about how it functions. It's about what is public or not. It is not public if they aren't the ones making it public. ZOS has it private by default in the game and gives no in-game options to make it public. That by the defintion of privacy, makes it private.
I think you don't know how eso and addons and the public api works.
there are many many thousands of lines of codes and variables and constants in the game. much of it is not accessible at all. it is private to zos.
anything that is in the api that addons can use is put in there on purpose by zos to make it publicly and legally accessible.
They actually ARE the ones making it public.
if y'all could stop targetting us fellow players for using the addon. stating we have no right to access that public information. We do. ZOS gave it to us.
And instead target ZOS. And demand from them they stop making that info public because what drops for you is yours and nobody elses business...
ZOS isn't the one in my DM's asking for my staff. I hold people accountable for their actions. Just because something *can* be done doesn't mean it *should* be done.
People *should* know better than to download an add-on that snoops on other people's loot. But they are making a decision to do so anyways.
spartaxoxo wrote: »spartaxoxo wrote: »SilverBride wrote: »ZOS is. and they are telling us.
most of you are constantly saying "we spy, snoop, illegallily look into your bag, we have no right,...."
these are all targetting us statements like we are doing something bad.
we aint doing any of that ***.
ZoS has a right to snoop into anything we do. You don't.
they sure have a right to snoop. but do they have right to share everything they learn with every other player?
I do not even snoop. zos tells me officially and publicly.
A 3rd party addon is not an official part of the game.
nope. but it is using an official part of the game that is put there for the express purpose of being used for addons.
It is not put there for the express purpose of being used for addons unless zos specifically states that. They have had to remove stuff from being used before because it was not what they wanted.
You keep acting as though the having the ability to do something is the same thing as being officially sponsored and that is NOT the case.
This addon is NOT an official part of the game and is instead a third party app. ZoS has never commented on it's legitimacy either way. That is the reason it's unable to be used by console and why you cannot claim official endorsement.
DarcyMardin wrote: »Interesting thread — what strong opinions, often opposing ones, folks have about this! Here’s mine, as a casual, though longtime player: I don’t pug that often, or do dungeons, but when I do, I never check my drops until the end of the dungeon. I rarely look at the chat box while fighting or see whispers until well after they’ve been sent. And I’m still a *long* way from completing my sticker book.
I don’t really like the idea of other players using an add-on to check my loot, although I can see why collectors find it useful. If somebody asks politely at the end of the dungeon if I’m willing to trade them an item that I don’t need, I’ll gladly give it to them. Unless of course, they have speedrun the dungeon, leaving me gasping to catch up, or fake-tanked it, or refused to fight a boss I told the group I needed for the quest or the pledge. People like that I ignore.
spartaxoxo wrote: »spartaxoxo wrote: »SilverBride wrote: »ZOS is. and they are telling us.
most of you are constantly saying "we spy, snoop, illegallily look into your bag, we have no right,...."
these are all targetting us statements like we are doing something bad.
we aint doing any of that ***.
ZoS has a right to snoop into anything we do. You don't.
they sure have a right to snoop. but do they have right to share everything they learn with every other player?
I do not even snoop. zos tells me officially and publicly.
A 3rd party addon is not an official part of the game.
nope. but it is using an official part of the game that is put there for the express purpose of being used for addons.
It is not put there for the express purpose of being used for addons unless zos specifically states that. They have had to remove stuff from being used before because it was not what they wanted.
spartaxoxo wrote: »
SilverBride wrote: »Addons are an intended way of eso being played on pc. dont like it. play on console. or play a different game. or convince zos to remove that part of the api.
until they do. using the addon is an allowed way tobplay the game. and none of us are doing anything wrong.
No, you aren't doing anything wrong for using this addon, as long as ZoS allows this. But not being wrong doesn't translate to being right.
How you then use the information is what many of us think is wrong.
and I do MOST FUNDAMENTALLY disagree with there being anything wrong with asking politely. or even tersely. if another can have somebody elses loot in case they aint using it.
Makes me bloody happy an item doesnt get dusted.
spartaxoxo wrote: »spartaxoxo wrote: »SilverBride wrote: »ZOS is. and they are telling us.
most of you are constantly saying "we spy, snoop, illegallily look into your bag, we have no right,...."
these are all targetting us statements like we are doing something bad.
we aint doing any of that ***.
ZoS has a right to snoop into anything we do. You don't.
they sure have a right to snoop. but do they have right to share everything they learn with every other player?
I do not even snoop. zos tells me officially and publicly.
A 3rd party addon is not an official part of the game.
nope. but it is using an official part of the game that is put there for the express purpose of being used for addons.
It is not put there for the express purpose of being used for addons unless zos specifically states that. They have had to remove stuff from being used before because it was not what they wanted.
You keep acting as though the having the ability to do something is the same thing as being officially sponsored and that is NOT the case.
This addon is NOT an official part of the game and is instead a third party app. ZoS has never commented on it's legitimacy either way. That is the reason it's unable to be used by console and why you cannot claim official endorsement.
It is the same thing as being officially permitted.
The game could and would function perfectly fine and the same. Even if that api were made unaccessible to everybody but zos code.
The fact the api exists as it is. Is implicit permission to use it and write addons. and use those.
If you create an Add-on, You must include the following disclosure in a Readme or similar .txt file: "This Add-on is not created by, affiliated with or sponsored by ZeniMax Media Inc. or its affiliates. The Elder Scrolls® and related logos are registered trademarks or trademarks of ZeniMax Media Inc. in the United States and/or other countries. All rights reserved."
amm7sb14_ESO wrote: »SilverBride wrote: »Addons are an intended way of eso being played on pc. dont like it. play on console. or play a different game. or convince zos to remove that part of the api.
until they do. using the addon is an allowed way tobplay the game. and none of us are doing anything wrong.
No, you aren't doing anything wrong for using this addon, as long as ZoS allows this. But not being wrong doesn't translate to being right.
How you then use the information is what many of us think is wrong.
and I do MOST FUNDAMENTALLY disagree with there being anything wrong with asking politely. or even tersely. if another can have somebody elses loot in case they aint using it.
Makes me bloody happy an item doesnt get dusted.
I'd much rather dust an item than give it to someone who snooped through my loot drops to ask for it.
Goregrinder wrote: »amm7sb14_ESO wrote: »spartaxoxo wrote: »perfiction wrote: »spartaxoxo wrote: »specialized tools to read it.spartaxoxo wrote: »You are intercepting information that is NOT made easily publicly available by zos
You have no idea what you are talking about kind sir. Let's say you have your favourite weather synopsis website. That website has public API allowing to get weather information for specific regions. You decide to use that API in your mobile app to get weather info from them and show it on your lock screen (because why not). Does it mean that you are intercepting information that is NOT made easily publicly available?
No more responses to you, you have clearly no clue how ESO API works and how addons utilize it. They can't intercept information without ZOS permission. Addons can do only things that ZOS allows and utilize data that ZOS shares.
It's not about how it functions. It's about what is public or not. It is not public if they aren't the ones making it public. ZOS has it private by default in the game and gives no in-game options to make it public. That by the defintion of privacy, makes it private.
I think you don't know how eso and addons and the public api works.
there are many many thousands of lines of codes and variables and constants in the game. much of it is not accessible at all. it is private to zos.
anything that is in the api that addons can use is put in there on purpose by zos to make it publicly and legally accessible.
They actually ARE the ones making it public.
if y'all could stop targetting us fellow players for using the addon. stating we have no right to access that public information. We do. ZOS gave it to us.
And instead target ZOS. And demand from them they stop making that info public because what drops for you is yours and nobody elses business...
ZOS isn't the one in my DM's asking for my staff. I hold people accountable for their actions. Just because something *can* be done doesn't mean it *should* be done.
People *should* know better than to download an add-on that snoops on other people's loot. But they are making a decision to do so anyways.
I just don't see how someone knowing what you looted harms you. Do you also care if other people see what you put in your cart when you're shopping at a store?