Apples and oranges for most of your comparisons. Light/heavy attacks were standardized to have 33% proc chance, they're typically only used once every 1s with weaving so that makes sense.

Selene's is based on direct melee damage and truely shines when you can stack them all up. Flurry (5 hits), light attack (1), Jabs (4), so typically it's procced frequently when you actually build for it, more so than a 33% chance every 1s. 5-6 hits a second is about a 56-62% chance to proc if you do the math.

But again, apples and oranges.

Kragh and Stormfist do need a buff though, both of their lower proc chances weren't touched, and their damage was barely improved while still being behind Selene's, Velidreth and Marselok.

The aoe reason falls flat when you consider both Kraghs and Stormfist have very easy to avoid aoes. Because of their large telegraph/small range and low proc chance, imo, their DPS (on paper) should match those 3 sets.

If they're already behind on paper, they'll be even worse in practice.

i also agree taht many Stam Monster set should be reworked. Choices for PvE are limited to Selene. Maarselok isn't bad but you need to dump lot of stamina just to trigger it.