Congratulations, it looks like the gold+ antiquities bugs made it to console after having being fixed on PC. After all, wouldn't want you guys to miss out on any of the experience PC gets
Here is a kinda sorta working workaround for this - basically the treasure's actual visuals are misplaced and you have to dig up the shinies, not the chest itself. Mind you, the squares showing you relic location are still functioning correctly, so there will always be a relic under a green one and a relic close to a yellow one.