Salvas_Aren wrote: »How about two fake DDs?
No such thing.
Hapexamendios wrote: »Salvas_Aren wrote: »How about two fake DDs?
No such thing.
I’m going line up as DPS on my tank now.
I wouldn't go so far as to say healers are unnecessary or useless. The thing of it is, when you're talking about fake tanks and fake healers, it's usually in the context of PUGs. On top of that, most often it's PUGs formed from the dungeon finder.
Anotherone773 wrote: »People who queue for LFG and then complain about what they get. Sort of like people who buy a lottery ticket and complain they didnt win.What's Worse?
I can deal with trying to heal and the "tank" is a sorc using a light staff. I can deal with trying to tank and doing 40% of the damage. I can deal with being DPS and the healer spends all their time rumbling through their inventory instead of healing. I can deal with trial players who blitz the dungeon and newbies who can barely stay alive...
But my pet peeve... what drives me absolutely nuts... are people who queue for random group content and then complain about the group they are dealt and even try to remove them. That is the worst player in this entire game. And i will take 100 nooblets that cant stay out of the red circle in the white circle or in front of me while i try to catch everyone with prayer any day over the people who complain about other people in random dungeon groups
For what content? Why no fake dds in equation? If "fake tank" holds agro on boss and doesn't die, is it a fake tank? If healer provides eledrain and burst heals, but mainly deals damage, is it a "fake healer"? Please answer the questions above for me to understand the poll better, cause right now i have no idea what it is about
Oh, and by far the most annoying thing is the guy who queues as a fake tank (or fake healer) and immediately runs off ahead of the group to solo the bosses, leaving everyone else in the dust - no matter that they may be new to the dungeon, may not have done the quest yet, etc
When I'm tanking PUGs, I won't be putting up with such nonsense... instant vote to kick by the time it's obvious the moron does not understand what does it mean to be playing in a group.
If you want to solo the dungeon then just enter it from the map yourself, no need to waste the rest of the group's time for your shenanigans.
Has very much to do with it, since it's about a specific type of player who fake queues for the tank or healer role - as opposed to the generic one, who fake queues "merely" to skip the lengthy DPS queue.Uh please. Has nothing to do with the discussion
You know, maybe it's the MAJORITY that's right? The reason that there is a MAJORITY vote to kick?Tbh maybe you are the one that doesn't understand he/she is in group, and wants to procrastinate the run for no reason for 3 others, and should be vote kicked, no need to waste the rest of the group's time for your shenanigans.
Nope.vote kicking people because they are rushing without any communication is a no no. After all, it is an mmo, communication is part of group thing, and usually fixes most unpleasant situations, and please dont answer "they should communicate before doing so", because you are the one that has a bone to pick with them, so you should be the one trying to get them to do it your way.
Has very much to do with it, since it's about a specific type of player who fake queues for the tank or healer role - as opposed to the generic one, who fake queues "merely" to skip the lengthy DPS queue.Uh please. Has nothing to do with the discussionYou know, maybe it's the MAJORITY that's right? The reason that there is a MAJORITY vote to kick?Tbh maybe you are the one that doesn't understand he/she is in group, and wants to procrastinate the run for no reason for 3 others, and should be vote kicked, no need to waste the rest of the group's time for your shenanigans.
One bad apple in a group is a waste of 3 other people's time. Also, one is not a majority by any means.
I have no problem with speedrunning dungeons, IF everyone in the group agrees... good luck with that in PUGs, though.Nope.vote kicking people because they are rushing without any communication is a no no. After all, it is an mmo, communication is part of group thing, and usually fixes most unpleasant situations, and please dont answer "they should communicate before doing so", because you are the one that has a bone to pick with them, so you should be the one trying to get them to do it your way.
If YOU wish to complete the dungeon in an unusual way (skipping bosses, or waiting to read books, etc.), it's on YOU to communicate that to the rest of the group at the start - and the rest of the group may or may not agree to your request.
If you are PUGging a dungeon and expecting everyone else to skip and rush ahead without any communication, then I don't know what to tell you - other than "form your own premade", and then you can do whatever you want.
I don't care about what YOU are doing when you PUG dungeons... but when I do so, anyone who's still AFK by the time we reach the 1st boss, and/or anyone who rushes far ahead without any communication, will get voted to kick.
The group finder frequently fails to find a replacement, but that's OK with me - whoever gets vote kicked was dead weight anyway, so no real loss either way.
A real tank does more than merely taunt the boss and not die in the process: they also control the fights in such a way as to let the healer and DDs do their jobs. (real tanks also provide support to the group - debuffing boss, warhorn, chain and CC adds, etc. - but that's technically optional)Since people that rush i was talking about, dont do any of the things you mentioned, your opinion is also invalid. If you have a problem with a "fake tank" that engages first, keeps the boss on him, and does your damage dealer job for you, it is off topic, because the topic is about fake tanks, that dont even taunt boss, and when boss is on them run like headless chicken/die.
Edit: sorry i missed the part about "specific type of fake tanks and healers" even though i addressed it too in my answer, since op confirmed that as long as "fake tank" doesn't die and keeps boss on him it doesn't count as fake tanking
A real tank does more than merely taunt the boss and not die in the process: they also control the fights in such a way as to let the healer and DDs do their jobs. (real tanks also provide support to the group - debuffing boss, warhorn, chain and CC adds, etc. - but that's technically optional)Since people that rush i was talking about, dont do any of the things you mentioned, your opinion is also invalid. If you have a problem with a "fake tank" that engages first, keeps the boss on him, and does your damage dealer job for you, it is off topic, because the topic is about fake tanks, that dont even taunt boss, and when boss is on them run like headless chicken/die.
Edit: sorry i missed the part about "specific type of fake tanks and healers" even though i addressed it too in my answer, since op confirmed that as long as "fake tank" doesn't die and keeps boss on him it doesn't count as fake tanking
Whether the tank uses an actual tank build, or something like a PvP build (impen gear) with a taunt slotted, has no relevance in this case - as long as they don't storm off to solo the bosses by themselves, but let the rest of the group contribute to the fights as well (as expected of a tank).
Of course we could argue that, for example, a PvP build "tank" who only holds a taunt is an inferior tank, as compared to one that offers much more group utility - but they are not "fake" in the sense of queuing for a role they didn't intend to fulfill at all, as outlined by the OP.
OTOH, someone who queues as a tank and proceeds to rush ahead of the group without saying anything, and soloes the boss(es) while the rest of the group is still dealing with the first packs of trashmobs, is not a real tank by any stretch of the imagination - even if they are technically using a taunt (why - what's the point of taunting a boss you intend to solo???).
Whether they are actually a (decent) DD is completely irrelevant at that point: they queued as a tank, and are not even doing the bare minimum expected of the tank role.
spartaxoxo wrote: »You sign up as a fake tank, then you damn well better be able to carry the ENTIRE group through the dungeon quickly and with zero deaths all by your lonesome, because that's the only way your actions should be even remotely tolerated. Emphasis on tolerated. Don't you dare place any responsibility on anyone else in the group. If the run fails for any reason, it is 110% your fault. Not the DPS who signed up to be DPS. Not the healer who signed up to be a healer. Just you.
If you taunt what your supposed to taunt, and can survive the things you're supposed to survive without help or with no more help than a real tank, then you're not the problem.
You're also not a fake tank.
The tank's job description can be summed up in three simple words. Control the boss. Everything else is just gravy. If you can control the boss and survive doing it, you are a tank, whether you're wearing a metal suit or a bathrobe.
Fake tanks are people who's idea of controlling the boss is to hit it with a really big rock and pray you kill it before it has a chance to do anything. They don't taunt, they can't survive a hit, they run around like a headless chicken when they've got aggro.... Simply put, they don't tank. Which means the boss just does whatever he wants and every battle is complete chaos.
spartaxoxo wrote: »spartaxoxo wrote: »You sign up as a fake tank, then you damn well better be able to carry the ENTIRE group through the dungeon quickly and with zero deaths all by your lonesome, because that's the only way your actions should be even remotely tolerated. Emphasis on tolerated. Don't you dare place any responsibility on anyone else in the group. If the run fails for any reason, it is 110% your fault. Not the DPS who signed up to be DPS. Not the healer who signed up to be a healer. Just you.
If you taunt what your supposed to taunt, and can survive the things you're supposed to survive without help or with no more help than a real tank, then you're not the problem.
You're also not a fake tank.
The tank's job description can be summed up in three simple words. Control the boss. Everything else is just gravy. If you can control the boss and survive doing it, you are a tank, whether you're wearing a metal suit or a bathrobe.
Fake tanks are people who's idea of controlling the boss is to hit it with a really big rock and pray you kill it before it has a chance to do anything. They don't taunt, they can't survive a hit, they run around like a headless chicken when they've got aggro.... Simply put, they don't tank. Which means the boss just does whatever he wants and every battle is complete chaos.
I very much disagree. A real tank is able to debuff bosses and buffs allies so that dungeon can be completed in as safe and quick a manner as possible. And they are able not to just taunt a dangerous mob, but to control the crowds.
Me slotting inner fire on my pet sorc doesn't make me a real tank. I'm just a dps with a taunt
Lady_Linux wrote: »Fake tanks!! never stand still in the normal dungeons anyway.... It why i like having an ice staff for my healer/dps hybrids. That way if i have to, just to keep from getting dizzy in the game, . plus fake tanks waste my aoe and make it harder for me to heal. i can taunt with it if i must.. and do healing and dps and tanking if absolutely necessary... happens often enough on normal dungeons that the ice staff with healing staff plus icy conjurer and jorvulds def come in handy... Being the healer i never have to worry about a fake healer in the group so always its a fake tank issue that drives me crazy...
TBH, I dont mind so much as long as i am prepared for it. no problem here with doing 40% or more of the damage and 70% or more of the healing and tanking a wee bit if need be on normal dungeons. I'm pulling my weight. that's all that's needed... hurts no one to give a bit extra if needed.
AgaTheGreat wrote: »JusticeForJilarga wrote: »This One is curious which one people think is worse, which one is more likely to prevent any success.
This One doesn't promote fake tank or fake healing, unless its a 4 person group you put together and everyone is OK with it.
Why is everyone crying about "fake" tanks here or on facebook? Normal dungeons don't need a tank or a healer. Veteran dungeons don't need a healer and some don't even need a tank tbh.
All this crying stems from people's inability to understand damage avoidance. Most of the times, DDs who happen to have an aggro in a normal dungeon kite the boss like it's going to hurt them. A heavy attack won't even kill you but everyone is free to dodge roll. But you know what? Most DDs don't know they can easily dodge roll the heavy attack. This way, there are some dungeons where you really don't need a tank, but someone who knows how to dodge roll and avoid taking unnecessary damage.
But the real plague of PUG dungeons are poor DDs with noodle deeps. Sometimes I have the need to quickly pug a normal dungeon on a tank to level up a skill or something like that, and the ammount of time it takes the bosses to die is horrible. Same thing happens in veteran dungeons.
I know I can ask for good DDs in a guild like Osiris Scale but sometimes I don't have the time to wait.
That's why when I'm on my DD I always take the role of "tank" if I go to a random normal dungeon. Because I know my deeps is enough to quickly kill what's there and not stretch it god knows how long. Many times the "fake" tanks and healers you're talking about are actually good players who know the dungeons, mechanics and have enough dps to quickly burn stuff before it gets bad.
juhislihis19 wrote: »Salvas_Aren wrote: »How about two fake DDs?
No such thing.
Fake DPS is a "DPS" who does less than 5k damage per second. So probably less than the tank. Thus, a fake DPS. Even if one is a total noob, you have get some kind of dps gear/set up on. Rather than 7 different set pieces.
Normal dungeons don't need tanks to be honest. I always queu with a fake tank for normal randoms, and never had any problems because as a fake tank, I also heal myself and others and usually do more dps than the "noob dps's". So everyone stays alive and burns the Boss in relative quick fashion.
I never fake tank a veteran dungeon though. That's just silly.
SidewalkChalk5 wrote: »Pure healers are 100% unnecessary in all 4-man PvE.
Healers are for trials and PvP.
Correct.
Fake healers are a blessing. Actually healers are a waste of DPS.
starkerealm wrote: »almightyalfo wrote: »Come on, let's be real here, normal dungeons don't even need dedicated tanks...
You also don't need to use a microwave, but it does make life a lot more convenient.
Let's be honest about this: You don't need a tank, but when you don't have one, the boss is going to be all over the place, DPS will be swirling in the bowl, and everything will be way more annoying than it could have been.