katanagirl1 wrote: »I don’t have a problem with people buying skyshards for new characters when they got them on previous characters.
However, I don’t think you guys get the point about skyshard achievement when it comes to Cyrodiil. By getting the sub-achievement on 3 separate characters and then buying for the rest, you can obtain an achievement that you did not get on any of them.
It’s an achievement. A simple check mark on a list of pointless tasks to do for a false sense of accomplishment. I literally could not care less if someone gets this achievement by buying it
katanagirl1 wrote: »katanagirl1 wrote: »I don’t have a problem with people buying skyshards for new characters when they got them on previous characters.
However, I don’t think you guys get the point about skyshard achievement when it comes to Cyrodiil. By getting the sub-achievement on 3 separate characters and then buying for the rest, you can obtain an achievement that you did not get on any of them.
It’s an achievement. A simple check mark on a list of pointless tasks to do for a false sense of accomplishment. I literally could not care less if someone gets this achievement by buying it
Perhaps you don’t know how long it takes to get those 4 skyshards from behind the gates of 2 opposing factions
1. Got all sky shards on my main.
2. Bought some zones on an alt to give me more skill points.
3. Expected to be winning a lot more as a result of the many P2W threads.......but
4. Am winning as much as I was before.
5. Have concluded that buying sky shards for skill points is NOT P2W.
RottingAlien wrote: »Hello All!
So, most of you know by now that there will be something called "Skyshard Achievements for Alternate Characters", where if you unlock "a Skyshard Hunter" Achievement, you can unlock those skyshards in an alt character using the crown store. You can read about it in the patchnotes
I want to make it clear, that this is not a discussion on whether it is P2W or not. I'm not saying it is and I do not think it is.
But, being or not being P2W, i think everyone can agree that it is a hell of a shortcut.
Don't get me wrong. I have Eso+, I have crowns, I'm lucky I can click and simply buy stuff. But the fact that people can only get these with crowns worries me about the future of ESO. Not the future of the crown store, but the future of ESO's health and community.
It worries me that this will open doors to more crown bought achievements or "shortcuts".
And most of all, It worries me that it will start to scare people off.
I would say ESO is at its prime right now. Lots of people coming in from other game(s), lots of content, new class coming up. All is great. And I'm really happy that ESO is finally getting the attention it deserves.
But this crown thing might just be what will turn people away. And I don't like the sound of it.
The problem is not this isolated SkyShard thing but if it will start happening with other stuff too.
I would suggest and would like to know how everyone would feel about this, that you'd have something like the Shrine of Srendarr or Shrine of Stuhn but for SkyShards. Where you could unlock skyshards by using the Shrine (or something else) and you would still have the Crown Store option. This would be much more like how ESO does things. This would give everyone a most equal chance to get those skill points. I've always praised ESO on how they treat their paid stuff, but this time... Well this time doesn't really sound like ESO.
TLDR; Being able to buy skyshards with crowns only, can open the precedent to future bought "shortcuts". If this is to be implemented, at least players should be able to buy the skyshards with Gold also. Like when using the shrine of Srendarr or Stuhn.
What are your thoughts on this?
After 4 years, It's the first time I really feel the need to start a discussion on the forums. So this has had some thought put into it. It is something that really worries me as a fan of ESO. I want it to be healthy for many more years to come.
Sorry if formatting could be better.
Happy Adventuring!
EDIT: Typos and added a TLDR
Contaminate wrote: »1. Got all sky shards on my main.
2. Bought some zones on an alt to give me more skill points.
3. Expected to be winning a lot more as a result of the many P2W threads.......but
4. Am winning as much as I was before.
5. Have concluded that buying sky shards for skill points is NOT P2W.
You are able to unlock more skills and passives at low levels than a comparable non-paying player in a PvP environment, creating a clear power imbalance. That’s P2W. Even if you’re not capable of utilizing that advantage it’s still an advantage.
Contaminate wrote: »1. Got all sky shards on my main.
2. Bought some zones on an alt to give me more skill points.
3. Expected to be winning a lot more as a result of the many P2W threads.......but
4. Am winning as much as I was before.
5. Have concluded that buying sky shards for skill points is NOT P2W.
You are able to unlock more skills and passives at low levels than a comparable non-paying player in a PvP environment, creating a clear power imbalance. That’s P2W. Even if you’re not capable of utilizing that advantage it’s still an advantage.
So you're saying I did P2W but I must first L2P ? Harsh.
katanagirl1 wrote: »katanagirl1 wrote: »I don’t have a problem with people buying skyshards for new characters when they got them on previous characters.
However, I don’t think you guys get the point about skyshard achievement when it comes to Cyrodiil. By getting the sub-achievement on 3 separate characters and then buying for the rest, you can obtain an achievement that you did not get on any of them.
It’s an achievement. A simple check mark on a list of pointless tasks to do for a false sense of accomplishment. I literally could not care less if someone gets this achievement by buying it
Perhaps you don’t know how long it takes to get those 4 skyshards from behind the gates of 2 opposing factions
I know exactly how long it can take to get them. I’ve done it on probably 6 of my 14 characters, but I still couldn’t care less if someone else buys it. It has exactly zero impact on my life if someone gets something easier that I got it, and I think the world would be a much better place if more people felt the same way.
RottingAlien wrote: »DjMuscleboy02 wrote: »RottingAlien wrote: »DjMuscleboy02 wrote: »RottingAlien wrote: »Oh god please no.DjMuscleboy02 wrote: »I hope they open this up to purchasing fully leveled character upgrades. If I don't want to level a character, that's my prerogative. This does not affect anyone else.
This is not P2W at all, skyshards don't affect anyone else. Start selling vMA weapons in the crown store and we'll have an issue.
And yes, it might affect someone else if we're talking pvp.
How does me getting skyshards affect a single other player? It's literally the same as mount upgrades. There are absolutely no circumstances in which buying skyshards affects another players game play.
Ok i'll try. So, power levelers used to have a "problem". When you'd try to power level an alt character you would start missing out on skill points. Which is not necessarily a bad thing! It makes you spend more time customizing it, learning it, making the right choices and thinking about what you really want to do with it instead of just creating alts just for the sake of it.
Now, The example to your question may be more prominent in below 50 battlegrounds/pvp, where you can have all the skyshards in a fresh character, let's say, level 40. You can bet you will have an advantage in this situation. This is just one way how it can impact another player directly. Most examples would be PvP. In PvE, everyone is on the same team, nobody cares.
Also, just to make sure you got it right, I wouldn't mind if you could buy the skyshards achiements with gold. Or having both options like you have with so many other things. The fact that crowns will be the only method its what makes me thing about the future of these kind of things in ESO.
But regardless of it I'm level 10 or level 49, I can just as easily run around and collect skyshards, no? I still don't see any issue here. It's not like you'll be level 30 with every skill line at 50 and full leveled skills. From what it sounds like to me, you just have an issue with having to spend money to get these. ZOS is a business still, you may disagree with the fact that it's purchased using crowns, but that doesn't necessarily make it pay-to-win. That said, I'd like to see it available through gold as well.
No, by having to look for skyshards, you will be force to level up because you are discovering new places, or have to kill npcs etc etc. With this system, you can have plenty of skyshards before leveling up. And you will never run out of skill points in the process wich you would if you were leveling and gathering skill points in the conventional way.
And again, no. Fortunately, I can buy plenty of crowns, i have eso + and have all expansions and some dlcs. But also fortunately I don't think only about myself, but also in other people who aren't able to buy crowns as easily or, most important i care about the heatlth state of the game. Wich you can be sure will decline if this becomes a norm.
Contaminate wrote: »Contaminate wrote: »1. Got all sky shards on my main.
2. Bought some zones on an alt to give me more skill points.
3. Expected to be winning a lot more as a result of the many P2W threads.......but
4. Am winning as much as I was before.
5. Have concluded that buying sky shards for skill points is NOT P2W.
You are able to unlock more skills and passives at low levels than a comparable non-paying player in a PvP environment, creating a clear power imbalance. That’s P2W. Even if you’re not capable of utilizing that advantage it’s still an advantage.
So you're saying I did P2W but I must first L2P ? Harsh.
In a matchup of comparably skilled players, you would win because you paid money to have more skills and passives available to add power to your character.
P2W doesn’t and has never meant “If I buy it I win against everyone without exception”
bharathitman wrote: »RottingAlien wrote: »I Love it. As a dad and full time worker i take any timesaver i can get so i have more time raiding when i actually can play
@ErMurazor What do you love if you don't mind me asking? Is it the buying with crowns part or the suggestion of buying with gold? Do you actually agree with shortcuts paid with real money or are you talking about in-game currency?
This question is so leading. You are implying that he is doing something negative by buying those skyshards with real money
SeaGtGruff wrote: »I don't understand what the big deal about 4 skyshards is. That's only 1 and 1/3 Skill Points. How is that going to make a big enough difference to matter?
katanagirl1 wrote: »katanagirl1 wrote: »katanagirl1 wrote: »I don’t have a problem with people buying skyshards for new characters when they got them on previous characters.
However, I don’t think you guys get the point about skyshard achievement when it comes to Cyrodiil. By getting the sub-achievement on 3 separate characters and then buying for the rest, you can obtain an achievement that you did not get on any of them.
It’s an achievement. A simple check mark on a list of pointless tasks to do for a false sense of accomplishment. I literally could not care less if someone gets this achievement by buying it
Perhaps you don’t know how long it takes to get those 4 skyshards from behind the gates of 2 opposing factions
I know exactly how long it can take to get them. I’ve done it on probably 6 of my 14 characters, but I still couldn’t care less if someone else buys it. It has exactly zero impact on my life if someone gets something easier that I got it, and I think the world would be a much better place if more people felt the same way.
Well, I did that on my main character, which is a PvE stamblade. That was a huge deal for me. Thanks for dismissing it completely since you don’t care.
SeaGtGruff wrote: »I don't understand what the big deal about 4 skyshards is. That's only 1 and 1/3 Skill Points. How is that going to make a big enough difference to matter?
katanagirl1 wrote: »SeaGtGruff wrote: »I don't understand what the big deal about 4 skyshards is. That's only 1 and 1/3 Skill Points. How is that going to make a big enough difference to matter?
That’s not the point. The point is that they are very hard to get, a lot of PvP and a lot of luck are involved as far as timing. They are needed to get the Cyrodill skyshard achievement and usually are the ones that keep people from getting it.
I guess if you don’t care for achievements then it doesn’t matter, but lots of players do.
Tan9oSuccka wrote: »DjMuscleboy02 wrote: »RottingAlien wrote: »Oh god please no.DjMuscleboy02 wrote: »I hope they open this up to purchasing fully leveled character upgrades. If I don't want to level a character, that's my prerogative. This does not affect anyone else.
This is not P2W at all, skyshards don't affect anyone else. Start selling vMA weapons in the crown store and we'll have an issue.
And yes, it might affect someone else if we're talking pvp.
How does me getting skyshards affect a single other player? It's literally the same as mount upgrades. There are absolutely no circumstances in which buying skyshards affects another players game play.
The only scenario I could see is someone who plays in Kyne.
I kind of like that everyone is on even ground and nobody has skill points.
I’d like them to tweak it where characters have to be level 50 before they can do this process.
1. Got all sky shards on my main.
2. Bought some zones on an alt to give me more skill points.
3. Expected to be winning a lot more as a result of the many P2W threads.......but
4. Am winning as much as I was before.
5. Have concluded that buying sky shards for skill points is NOT P2W.