MartiniDaniels wrote: »You all missing key point of all this - this thread won't happen if ice staff was not so inferior to s&b. When devs introduced ice staff it inspired some people for ice tanking and ice builds.. and when they created and honed those builds, they find that this builds are "garbage".
There were dozens of threads with simple solutions to this like additional morph to ele or changes to inner rage - but devs don't even discuss it. Pierce armor is so powerful skill so any tank without it is much weaker by default.
I will agree the ice staff is less efficient. It is certainly not weaker. The block with and ice staff on a templar or sorc is more efficient due to class and staff passives.
But, it does not provide major breach and fracture.
I agree that people should be more approbative towards non meta builds as long as they can carry their own weight and not wipe everyone.
"But why would you run something else that doesn't give maximal dps or isn't the strongest tank or healer build ever?" If higher tier pve community would accept the fact that you don't need 60k single target dps to clear vFG 1 it would make those off meta builds instantly more viable for everyone.
thanoscopter wrote: »Ice staff is pretty close to a sword and board. Really, the only thing it is missing is the major fracture and a little damage reduction. Other classes can provide major fracture anyway. Now a warden or nightblade tank can use an ice staff and provide major fracture with their class skills.
The leader was out of line and disrespected you when a true leader would have sent you private messages. Here's what I would have did OP. I would have put on Plague Doctor + another selfish set like Eternal Yokeda to maximize my own tankiness while not providing any group buffs to those guys. Take the warhorn off too. Finally, when they are wiping make sure you cast a selfish ult to survive a bit longer instead of rezzing them.
thanoscopter wrote: »Ice staff is pretty close to a sword and board. Really, the only thing it is missing is the major fracture and a little damage reduction. Other classes can provide major fracture anyway. Now a warden or nightblade tank can use an ice staff and provide major fracture with their class skills.
The leader was out of line and disrespected you when a true leader would have sent you private messages. Here's what I would have did OP. I would have put on Plague Doctor + another selfish set like Eternal Yokeda to maximize my own tankiness while not providing any group buffs to those guys. Take the warhorn off too. Finally, when they are wiping make sure you cast a selfish ult to survive a bit longer instead of rezzing them.
thanoscopter wrote: »Ice staff is pretty close to a sword and board. Really, the only thing it is missing is the major fracture and a little damage reduction. Other classes can provide major fracture anyway. Now a warden or nightblade tank can use an ice staff and provide major fracture with their class skills.
The leader was out of line and disrespected you when a true leader would have sent you private messages. Here's what I would have did OP. I would have put on Plague Doctor + another selfish set like Eternal Yokeda to maximize my own tankiness while not providing any group buffs to those guys. Take the warhorn off too. Finally, when they are wiping make sure you cast a selfish ult to survive a bit longer instead of rezzing them.
Yes please give the group another reason to kick him....because that is how you get kicked.
thanoscopter wrote: »Ice staff is pretty close to a sword and board. Really, the only thing it is missing is the major fracture and a little damage reduction. Other classes can provide major fracture anyway. Now a warden or nightblade tank can use an ice staff and provide major fracture with their class skills.
The leader was out of line and disrespected you when a true leader would have sent you private messages. Here's what I would have did OP. I would have put on Plague Doctor + another selfish set like Eternal Yokeda to maximize my own tankiness while not providing any group buffs to those guys. Take the warhorn off too. Finally, when they are wiping make sure you cast a selfish ult to survive a bit longer instead of rezzing them.
thanoscopter wrote: »Ice staff is pretty close to a sword and board. Really, the only thing it is missing is the major fracture and a little damage reduction. Other classes can provide major fracture anyway. Now a warden or nightblade tank can use an ice staff and provide major fracture with their class skills.
The leader was out of line and disrespected you when a true leader would have sent you private messages. Here's what I would have did OP. I would have put on Plague Doctor + another selfish set like Eternal Yokeda to maximize my own tankiness while not providing any group buffs to those guys. Take the warhorn off too. Finally, when they are wiping make sure you cast a selfish ult to survive a bit longer instead of rezzing them.
Yes please give the group another reason to kick him....because that is how you get kicked.
I agree that people should be more approbative towards non meta builds as long as they can carry their own weight and not wipe everyone.
"But why would you run something else that doesn't give maximal dps or isn't the strongest tank or healer build ever?" If higher tier pve community would accept the fact that you don't need 60k single target dps to clear vFG 1 it would make those off meta builds instantly more viable for everyone.
Oh look, another post for roleplayers to spout nonsense and bash on “sheeps” running meta builds. I can say for sure with that attitute, you won’t ever be part of a competent raiding guild so I guess you can keep on roleplaying.
thanoscopter wrote: »thanoscopter wrote: »Ice staff is pretty close to a sword and board. Really, the only thing it is missing is the major fracture and a little damage reduction. Other classes can provide major fracture anyway. Now a warden or nightblade tank can use an ice staff and provide major fracture with their class skills.
The leader was out of line and disrespected you when a true leader would have sent you private messages. Here's what I would have did OP. I would have put on Plague Doctor + another selfish set like Eternal Yokeda to maximize my own tankiness while not providing any group buffs to those guys. Take the warhorn off too. Finally, when they are wiping make sure you cast a selfish ult to survive a bit longer instead of rezzing them.
Yes please give the group another reason to kick him....because that is how you get kicked.
Why should he care about being kicked out of a run where the leader started off by publicly shaming him on voice chat without even talking it out with him privately? The leader already proved he was not that knowledgeable. He asked how he doesn't run out of magicka using an ice staff. The OP stacked magicka regen but another way to tank with an ice staff without running out of magicka is to not take the first destruction staff passive. If you don't take the first passive, you block with stamina on an ice staff...most tanks should know this.
I agree that people should be more approbative towards non meta builds as long as they can carry their own weight and not wipe everyone.
"But why would you run something else that doesn't give maximal dps or isn't the strongest tank or healer build ever?" If higher tier pve community would accept the fact that you don't need 60k single target dps to clear vFG 1 it would make those off meta builds instantly more viable for everyone.
Reminds me of a statement in a developer interview I saw from back when there were companies trying to compete with CoH. "Why would you want to be 'Captain Firepants' when you can be Spiderman?" Well maybe I don't want to be Spiderman. Maybe I want to be my own unique character that I can identify with instead of Clone #4978253. Or maybe I just find Spiderman boring as hell to play as. There is more to playing the game than just beating the game. That developer didn't get it and most meta-sheep don't understand it either.
I agree that people should be more approbative towards non meta builds as long as they can carry their own weight and not wipe everyone.
"But why would you run something else that doesn't give maximal dps or isn't the strongest tank or healer build ever?" If higher tier pve community would accept the fact that you don't need 60k single target dps to clear vFG 1 it would make those off meta builds instantly more viable for everyone.
Reminds me of a statement in a developer interview I saw from back when there were companies trying to compete with CoH. "Why would you want to be 'Captain Firepants' when you can be Spiderman?" Well maybe I don't want to be Spiderman. Maybe I want to be my own unique character that I can identify with instead of Clone #4978253. Or maybe I just find Spiderman boring as hell to play as. There is more to playing the game than just beating the game. That developer didn't get it and most meta-sheep don't understand it either.
Lol. They are truly just copies of each other dressed differently.
Clone Builds
thanoscopter wrote: »Ice staff is pretty close to a sword and board. Really, the only thing it is missing is the major fracture and a little damage reduction. Other classes can provide major fracture anyway. Now a warden or nightblade tank can use an ice staff and provide major fracture with their class skills.
The leader was out of line and disrespected you when a true leader would have sent you private messages. Here's what I would have did OP. I would have put on Plague Doctor + another selfish set like Eternal Yokeda to maximize my own tankiness while not providing any group buffs to those guys. Take the warhorn off too. Finally, when they are wiping make sure you cast a selfish ult to survive a bit longer instead of rezzing them.
Yes please give the group another reason to kick him....because that is how you get kicked.
Passive aggressive much. Youre just mad because in fact, you cant logically argue youre position.
You have lost. And thats what people do when they lose.
They change the subject like you did.
.
thanoscopter wrote: »Ice staff is pretty close to a sword and board. Really, the only thing it is missing is the major fracture and a little damage reduction. Other classes can provide major fracture anyway. Now a warden or nightblade tank can use an ice staff and provide major fracture with their class skills.
The leader was out of line and disrespected you when a true leader would have sent you private messages. Here's what I would have did OP. I would have put on Plague Doctor + another selfish set like Eternal Yokeda to maximize my own tankiness while not providing any group buffs to those guys. Take the warhorn off too. Finally, when they are wiping make sure you cast a selfish ult to survive a bit longer instead of rezzing them.
Yes please give the group another reason to kick him....because that is how you get kicked.
Passive aggressive much. Youre just mad because in fact, you cant logically argue youre position.
You have lost. And thats what people do when they lose.
They change the subject like you did.
.
thanoscopter wrote: »Ice staff is pretty close to a sword and board. Really, the only thing it is missing is the major fracture and a little damage reduction. Other classes can provide major fracture anyway. Now a warden or nightblade tank can use an ice staff and provide major fracture with their class skills.
The leader was out of line and disrespected you when a true leader would have sent you private messages. Here's what I would have did OP. I would have put on Plague Doctor + another selfish set like Eternal Yokeda to maximize my own tankiness while not providing any group buffs to those guys. Take the warhorn off too. Finally, when they are wiping make sure you cast a selfish ult to survive a bit longer instead of rezzing them.
Yes please give the group another reason to kick him....because that is how you get kicked.
Passive aggressive much. Youre just mad because in fact, you cant logically argue youre position.
You have lost. And thats what people do when they lose.
They change the subject like you did.
.
Checkmath was meaning that that advice was bad sportsmanship. I would try to cool your head. Things aren't as bad as it seems. You have gotten different types of feedback on the matter. So take it in and decide how you will progress.
You caught Hodor red handed, so much so that i just went to his website to check out his builds.Enemy-of-Coldharbour wrote: »Alcast's builds are for noobs and lazy players who don't want to do a little bit of research. Even he does not use them. There is a reason why Alcast and Hodor don't post their 'personal' builds.
On a different subject you might like pvp better. It has a different kinda of standards and a bit more freedom you might enjoy.
thanoscopter wrote: »thanoscopter wrote: »Ice staff is pretty close to a sword and board. Really, the only thing it is missing is the major fracture and a little damage reduction. Other classes can provide major fracture anyway. Now a warden or nightblade tank can use an ice staff and provide major fracture with their class skills.
The leader was out of line and disrespected you when a true leader would have sent you private messages. Here's what I would have did OP. I would have put on Plague Doctor + another selfish set like Eternal Yokeda to maximize my own tankiness while not providing any group buffs to those guys. Take the warhorn off too. Finally, when they are wiping make sure you cast a selfish ult to survive a bit longer instead of rezzing them.
Yes please give the group another reason to kick him....because that is how you get kicked.
Why should he care about being kicked out of a run where the leader started off by publicly shaming him on voice chat without even talking it out with him privately? The leader already proved he was not that knowledgeable. He asked how he doesn't run out of magicka using an ice staff. The OP stacked magicka regen but another way to tank with an ice staff without running out of magicka is to not take the first destruction staff passive. If you don't take the first passive, you block with stamina on an ice staff...most tanks should know this.
I am well aware of how ice staves function, I do not know if hes previous leader did ( he also just may have tested him with questions. who knows).
But making the whole group angry because of the leader mocking him is not the way to address this. In the end he may get a bad reputation and wont find a group anymore to run trials. Well that is none of my business tough.
I can only repeat, what I already stated: Somebody not willing to wear specific sets, play a specific class or use specific skills to help out the group is not suited for vet trial environment. This may sound hard, but in this content players commit themselves to the group and adjusting your builds also belongs to that. If he thinks of that as cheese, then it is his own personnel problem.
First of all, I wanna say that I don't support the behaviour of the raid leader of that group. It's not a good thing to mock people. It's just childish and doesn't fit the face of raiding community in ESO.
Anyway, ESO is a game where everyone in the group helps each other. Healers help tanks and DDs by restoring their resources, purging negative effects and giving them buffs and debuffing enemies. DDs help each other by utilising Major Slayer sets, buffing each other with different class passives and debuffing enemies. Tanks release pressure from healers by running self heals, help DDs by increasing their damage and reducing their damage taken. Tanks provide synergies for each other. Healers likewise. DDs provide them to tanks. Healers provide to tanks and DDs. This is not a game of buffing DDs. Everyone helps everyone.
All of this effort is an example of how teamwork looks like and the best way to do it has been proven mathematically and in practice by people who give you the "Youtube Builds" for free. They are not forcing you to run them. Everyone in the groups that want you to run a specific build is supporting you directly and indirectly. When you get into a trial group in ESO, you are basically carrying a huge burden that's supposed to be carried by 12 players. When you sit on the burden and watch others carry it, they will have every right to push you off of it and get someone else to help them. Learn to play as a team and for your team.
Of course there are many people who don't care about any of this "giving your best" thing and it's ok to do so. If you insist on not doing that, you should run whatever content you want with them and enjoy the game the way you like to. Just don't expect to sit on the burden if others are expecting you to give it your best.
OblivionNW wrote: »Sorry to break your little bubble, but a Tank is a support role and supporting involves buffing the rest of your group. By not buffing them your bringing down the groups potential, Liofa and others summed it up perfectly. Its a shame you ignore every reasonable counter argument and go on ranting with everything else.First of all, I wanna say that I don't support the behaviour of the raid leader of that group. It's not a good thing to mock people. It's just childish and doesn't fit the face of raiding community in ESO.
Anyway, ESO is a game where everyone in the group helps each other. Healers help tanks and DDs by restoring their resources, purging negative effects and giving them buffs and debuffing enemies. DDs help each other by utilising Major Slayer sets, buffing each other with different class passives and debuffing enemies. Tanks release pressure from healers by running self heals, help DDs by increasing their damage and reducing their damage taken. Tanks provide synergies for each other. Healers likewise. DDs provide them to tanks. Healers provide to tanks and DDs. This is not a game of buffing DDs. Everyone helps everyone.
All of this effort is an example of how teamwork looks like and the best way to do it has been proven mathematically and in practice by people who give you the "Youtube Builds" for free. They are not forcing you to run them. Everyone in the groups that want you to run a specific build is supporting you directly and indirectly. When you get into a trial group in ESO, you are basically carrying a huge burden that's supposed to be carried by 12 players. When you sit on the burden and watch others carry it, they will have every right to push you off of it and get someone else to help them. Learn to play as a team and for your team.
Of course there are many people who don't care about any of this "giving your best" thing and it's ok to do so. If you insist on not doing that, you should run whatever content you want with them and enjoy the game the way you like to. Just don't expect to sit on the burden if others are expecting you to give it your best.
thanoscopter wrote: »thanoscopter wrote: »thanoscopter wrote: »Ice staff is pretty close to a sword and board. Really, the only thing it is missing is the major fracture and a little damage reduction. Other classes can provide major fracture anyway. Now a warden or nightblade tank can use an ice staff and provide major fracture with their class skills.
The leader was out of line and disrespected you when a true leader would have sent you private messages. Here's what I would have did OP. I would have put on Plague Doctor + another selfish set like Eternal Yokeda to maximize my own tankiness while not providing any group buffs to those guys. Take the warhorn off too. Finally, when they are wiping make sure you cast a selfish ult to survive a bit longer instead of rezzing them.
Yes please give the group another reason to kick him....because that is how you get kicked.
Why should he care about being kicked out of a run where the leader started off by publicly shaming him on voice chat without even talking it out with him privately? The leader already proved he was not that knowledgeable. He asked how he doesn't run out of magicka using an ice staff. The OP stacked magicka regen but another way to tank with an ice staff without running out of magicka is to not take the first destruction staff passive. If you don't take the first passive, you block with stamina on an ice staff...most tanks should know this.
I am well aware of how ice staves function, I do not know if hes previous leader did ( he also just may have tested him with questions. who knows).
But making the whole group angry because of the leader mocking him is not the way to address this. In the end he may get a bad reputation and wont find a group anymore to run trials. Well that is none of my business tough.
I can only repeat, what I already stated: Somebody not willing to wear specific sets, play a specific class or use specific skills to help out the group is not suited for vet trial environment. This may sound hard, but in this content players commit themselves to the group and adjusting your builds also belongs to that. If he thinks of that as cheese, then it is his own personnel problem.
Well, everyone makes mistakes, even the group leader. If no one stops the guild leader from putting others down in voice chat and forcing builds upon others then he will continue to do this.
It's kind of like if you order take out and they try to charge you 30 dollars for something the menu said costed 15 dollars. Do you trust the cashier and pay up or do you refer to the menu (the reference) and begin asking questions? The point is, the leader could have just not been lazy and looked at the destruction staff passives (the reference) or considered magicka regen which is the solution for running out of magicka. Ice staff tanking is not a new thing that came out last patch...
Giving out accurate information is important in a leadership role no matter the setting. There is also a distinction between insulting others and testing others. Pull the tank in a private channel and discuss the setup with them. Discuss what sets the tank has available to them and make recommendations, but the theatrics and dramatics in voice chat are really unnecessary if you want to be a leader.
OblivionNW wrote: »Sorry to break your little bubble, but a Tank is a support role and supporting involves buffing the rest of your group. By not buffing them your bringing down the groups potential, Liofa and others summed it up perfectly. Its a shame you ignore every reasonable counter argument and go on ranting with everything else.First of all, I wanna say that I don't support the behaviour of the raid leader of that group. It's not a good thing to mock people. It's just childish and doesn't fit the face of raiding community in ESO.
Anyway, ESO is a game where everyone in the group helps each other. Healers help tanks and DDs by restoring their resources, purging negative effects and giving them buffs and debuffing enemies. DDs help each other by utilising Major Slayer sets, buffing each other with different class passives and debuffing enemies. Tanks release pressure from healers by running self heals, help DDs by increasing their damage and reducing their damage taken. Tanks provide synergies for each other. Healers likewise. DDs provide them to tanks. Healers provide to tanks and DDs. This is not a game of buffing DDs. Everyone helps everyone.
All of this effort is an example of how teamwork looks like and the best way to do it has been proven mathematically and in practice by people who give you the "Youtube Builds" for free. They are not forcing you to run them. Everyone in the groups that want you to run a specific build is supporting you directly and indirectly. When you get into a trial group in ESO, you are basically carrying a huge burden that's supposed to be carried by 12 players. When you sit on the burden and watch others carry it, they will have every right to push you off of it and get someone else to help them. Learn to play as a team and for your team.
Of course there are many people who don't care about any of this "giving your best" thing and it's ok to do so. If you insist on not doing that, you should run whatever content you want with them and enjoy the game the way you like to. Just don't expect to sit on the burden if others are expecting you to give it your best.