VaranisArano wrote: »Right. So my tank can AOE taunt everything and turtle up, while my healer heals just me, and the DDs burn everything.
This would make tanking much simpler...and IMO, boring.
TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »To compensate the aoe taunt could wear off sooner. Most tanks don't have high enough magicka to spam destro abilities. They wouldn't be using it often.

starkerealm wrote: »TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »To compensate the aoe taunt could wear off sooner. Most tanks don't have high enough magicka to spam destro abilities. They wouldn't be using it often.
You want to see how fast that could change? I've got a DK running Lich Weapons and Jewelry. Hell, I've even got a Lich Ice Staff to switch to.
You give them something like this, and you'd start to realize just how many tanks really do have way more magicka than you realize.
Here's the thing, there are a lot of tanks who run with lots of resources. Your builds may not have the magicka to spam Destro abilities, but mine do.
TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »To compensate the aoe taunt could wear off sooner. Most tanks don't have high enough magicka to spam destro abilities. They wouldn't be using it often.
You want to see how fast that could change? I've got a DK running Lich Weapons and Jewelry. Hell, I've even got a Lich Ice Staff to switch to.
You give them something like this, and you'd start to realize just how many tanks really do have way more magicka than you realize.
Here's the thing, there are a lot of tanks who run with lots of resources. Your builds may not have the magicka to spam Destro abilities, but mine do.
Honestly with what you'd have to give up in terms of another 5pc bonus to run lich on a tank I wouldn't even fault you and your extra regen.
paulsimonps wrote: »
starkerealm wrote: »TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »To compensate the aoe taunt could wear off sooner. Most tanks don't have high enough magicka to spam destro abilities. They wouldn't be using it often.
You want to see how fast that could change? I've got a DK running Lich Weapons and Jewelry. Hell, I've even got a Lich Ice Staff to switch to.
You give them something like this, and you'd start to realize just how many tanks really do have way more magicka than you realize.
Here's the thing, there are a lot of tanks who run with lots of resources. Your builds may not have the magicka to spam Destro abilities, but mine do.
Honestly with what you'd have to give up in terms of another 5pc bonus to run lich on a tank I wouldn't even fault you and your extra regen.
Okay, so, here's the line between a tank who knows what they're doing, and one who's just learning.
Get to a certain point, and you have a stupid amount of build freedom. You need to be tough enough to avoid dying, while working the boss's nerves. You need to be able to use CC effectively. And, that's kinda it. Everything after that is gravy. Including group buffs. You don't have to buff the group if you're helping in other ways.
So, your sets need to be things that help you do your job. Lich, or Warlock do that. Even Trappings of Invigoration can be useful (though, I haven't tested that one.)
You can be an extremely selfish tank, go survival on both sets, and let the DPS scramble for buffs. That's entirely up to you. And I won't judge you for leaving your DPS out to dry, I've got a selfish Sorc Tank that slots ebon, and everything after that is up to the DPS and the Healer to avoid dying.
But, you can run Lich. You can run IA if you want, for 4 man content. It's kinda fun. You can run Alkosh, which is a DPS set, in case that was unclear. But, it's nice to see it on the tank. Hell, I do have a Sanctuary + Ebon Christmas Tree build.
You can do a lot with second 5pc bonus on your tank. You're not confined to two survival sets.
Right now, on live, as the game exists, a DK running Plague or Eben + Lich Weapons and Jewlery is a very strong setup.
Hell, you could probably get away with Hatchling's Shell + Lich on a DK now, that'd be disgusting.
TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »To compensate the aoe taunt could wear off sooner. Most tanks don't have high enough magicka to spam destro abilities. They wouldn't be using it often.
You want to see how fast that could change? I've got a DK running Lich Weapons and Jewelry. Hell, I've even got a Lich Ice Staff to switch to.
You give them something like this, and you'd start to realize just how many tanks really do have way more magicka than you realize.
Here's the thing, there are a lot of tanks who run with lots of resources. Your builds may not have the magicka to spam Destro abilities, but mine do.
Honestly with what you'd have to give up in terms of another 5pc bonus to run lich on a tank I wouldn't even fault you and your extra regen.
Okay, so, here's the line between a tank who knows what they're doing, and one who's just learning.
Get to a certain point, and you have a stupid amount of build freedom. You need to be tough enough to avoid dying, while working the boss's nerves. You need to be able to use CC effectively. And, that's kinda it. Everything after that is gravy. Including group buffs. You don't have to buff the group if you're helping in other ways.
So, your sets need to be things that help you do your job. Lich, or Warlock do that. Even Trappings of Invigoration can be useful (though, I haven't tested that one.)
You can be an extremely selfish tank, go survival on both sets, and let the DPS scramble for buffs. That's entirely up to you. And I won't judge you for leaving your DPS out to dry, I've got a selfish Sorc Tank that slots ebon, and everything after that is up to the DPS and the Healer to avoid dying.
But, you can run Lich. You can run IA if you want, for 4 man content. It's kinda fun. You can run Alkosh, which is a DPS set, in case that was unclear. But, it's nice to see it on the tank. Hell, I do have a Sanctuary + Ebon Christmas Tree build.
You can do a lot with second 5pc bonus on your tank. You're not confined to two survival sets.
Right now, on live, as the game exists, a DK running Plague or Eben + Lich Weapons and Jewlery is a very strong setup.
Hell, you could probably get away with Hatchling's Shell + Lich on a DK now, that'd be disgusting.
I have no doubt that you personally can get away with that but for the average player they'd get recked. So what you're describing could realistically happen among skilled players and because most of us on here tend to be of above average ability it'll seem like a broken setup. But it isn't. The avarage random tank will never ever touch lich.
TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »To compensate the aoe taunt could wear off sooner. Most tanks don't have high enough magicka to spam destro abilities. They wouldn't be using it often.
TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »To compensate the aoe taunt could wear off sooner. Most tanks don't have high enough magicka to spam destro abilities. They wouldn't be using it often.
You want to see how fast that could change? I've got a DK running Lich Weapons and Jewelry. Hell, I've even got a Lich Ice Staff to switch to.
You give them something like this, and you'd start to realize just how many tanks really do have way more magicka than you realize.
Here's the thing, there are a lot of tanks who run with lots of resources. Your builds may not have the magicka to spam Destro abilities, but mine do.
Honestly with what you'd have to give up in terms of another 5pc bonus to run lich on a tank I wouldn't even fault you and your extra regen.
Okay, so, here's the line between a tank who knows what they're doing, and one who's just learning.
Get to a certain point, and you have a stupid amount of build freedom. You need to be tough enough to avoid dying, while working the boss's nerves. You need to be able to use CC effectively. And, that's kinda it. Everything after that is gravy. Including group buffs. You don't have to buff the group if you're helping in other ways.
So, your sets need to be things that help you do your job. Lich, or Warlock do that. Even Trappings of Invigoration can be useful (though, I haven't tested that one.)
You can be an extremely selfish tank, go survival on both sets, and let the DPS scramble for buffs. That's entirely up to you. And I won't judge you for leaving your DPS out to dry, I've got a selfish Sorc Tank that slots ebon, and everything after that is up to the DPS and the Healer to avoid dying.
But, you can run Lich. You can run IA if you want, for 4 man content. It's kinda fun. You can run Alkosh, which is a DPS set, in case that was unclear. But, it's nice to see it on the tank. Hell, I do have a Sanctuary + Ebon Christmas Tree build.
You can do a lot with second 5pc bonus on your tank. You're not confined to two survival sets.
Right now, on live, as the game exists, a DK running Plague or Eben + Lich Weapons and Jewlery is a very strong setup.
Hell, you could probably get away with Hatchling's Shell + Lich on a DK now, that'd be disgusting.
I have no doubt that you personally can get away with that but for the average player they'd get recked. So what you're describing could realistically happen among skilled players and because most of us on here tend to be of above average ability it'll seem like a broken setup. But it isn't. The avarage random tank will never ever touch lich.
The average random tank is much more likely to touch lich than an experienced tank. With good trial groups the tank has little say over what sets the wear.
starkerealm wrote: »TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »To compensate the aoe taunt could wear off sooner. Most tanks don't have high enough magicka to spam destro abilities. They wouldn't be using it often.
You want to see how fast that could change? I've got a DK running Lich Weapons and Jewelry. Hell, I've even got a Lich Ice Staff to switch to.
You give them something like this, and you'd start to realize just how many tanks really do have way more magicka than you realize.
Here's the thing, there are a lot of tanks who run with lots of resources. Your builds may not have the magicka to spam Destro abilities, but mine do.
Honestly with what you'd have to give up in terms of another 5pc bonus to run lich on a tank I wouldn't even fault you and your extra regen.
Okay, so, here's the line between a tank who knows what they're doing, and one who's just learning.
Get to a certain point, and you have a stupid amount of build freedom. You need to be tough enough to avoid dying, while working the boss's nerves. You need to be able to use CC effectively. And, that's kinda it. Everything after that is gravy. Including group buffs. You don't have to buff the group if you're helping in other ways.
So, your sets need to be things that help you do your job. Lich, or Warlock do that. Even Trappings of Invigoration can be useful (though, I haven't tested that one.)
You can be an extremely selfish tank, go survival on both sets, and let the DPS scramble for buffs. That's entirely up to you. And I won't judge you for leaving your DPS out to dry, I've got a selfish Sorc Tank that slots ebon, and everything after that is up to the DPS and the Healer to avoid dying.
But, you can run Lich. You can run IA if you want, for 4 man content. It's kinda fun. You can run Alkosh, which is a DPS set, in case that was unclear. But, it's nice to see it on the tank. Hell, I do have a Sanctuary + Ebon Christmas Tree build.
You can do a lot with second 5pc bonus on your tank. You're not confined to two survival sets.
Right now, on live, as the game exists, a DK running Plague or Eben + Lich Weapons and Jewlery is a very strong setup.
Hell, you could probably get away with Hatchling's Shell + Lich on a DK now, that'd be disgusting.
TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »To compensate the aoe taunt could wear off sooner. Most tanks don't have high enough magicka to spam destro abilities. They wouldn't be using it often.
You want to see how fast that could change? I've got a DK running Lich Weapons and Jewelry. Hell, I've even got a Lich Ice Staff to switch to.
You give them something like this, and you'd start to realize just how many tanks really do have way more magicka than you realize.
Here's the thing, there are a lot of tanks who run with lots of resources. Your builds may not have the magicka to spam Destro abilities, but mine do.
Honestly with what you'd have to give up in terms of another 5pc bonus to run lich on a tank I wouldn't even fault you and your extra regen.
Okay, so, here's the line between a tank who knows what they're doing, and one who's just learning.
Get to a certain point, and you have a stupid amount of build freedom. You need to be tough enough to avoid dying, while working the boss's nerves. You need to be able to use CC effectively. And, that's kinda it. Everything after that is gravy. Including group buffs. You don't have to buff the group if you're helping in other ways.
So, your sets need to be things that help you do your job. Lich, or Warlock do that. Even Trappings of Invigoration can be useful (though, I haven't tested that one.)
You can be an extremely selfish tank, go survival on both sets, and let the DPS scramble for buffs. That's entirely up to you. And I won't judge you for leaving your DPS out to dry, I've got a selfish Sorc Tank that slots ebon, and everything after that is up to the DPS and the Healer to avoid dying.
But, you can run Lich. You can run IA if you want, for 4 man content. It's kinda fun. You can run Alkosh, which is a DPS set, in case that was unclear. But, it's nice to see it on the tank. Hell, I do have a Sanctuary + Ebon Christmas Tree build.
You can do a lot with second 5pc bonus on your tank. You're not confined to two survival sets.
Right now, on live, as the game exists, a DK running Plague or Eben + Lich Weapons and Jewlery is a very strong setup.
Hell, you could probably get away with Hatchling's Shell + Lich on a DK now, that'd be disgusting.
I have no doubt that you personally can get away with that but for the average player they'd get recked. So what you're describing could realistically happen among skilled players and because most of us on here tend to be of above average ability it'll seem like a broken setup. But it isn't. The avarage random tank will never ever touch lich.
The average random tank is much more likely to touch lich than an experienced tank. With good trial groups the tank has little say over what sets the wear.
starkerealm wrote: »TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »TheGreatBlackBear wrote: »To compensate the aoe taunt could wear off sooner. Most tanks don't have high enough magicka to spam destro abilities. They wouldn't be using it often.
You want to see how fast that could change? I've got a DK running Lich Weapons and Jewelry. Hell, I've even got a Lich Ice Staff to switch to.
You give them something like this, and you'd start to realize just how many tanks really do have way more magicka than you realize.
Here's the thing, there are a lot of tanks who run with lots of resources. Your builds may not have the magicka to spam Destro abilities, but mine do.
Honestly with what you'd have to give up in terms of another 5pc bonus to run lich on a tank I wouldn't even fault you and your extra regen.
Okay, so, here's the line between a tank who knows what they're doing, and one who's just learning.
Get to a certain point, and you have a stupid amount of build freedom. You need to be tough enough to avoid dying, while working the boss's nerves. You need to be able to use CC effectively. And, that's kinda it. Everything after that is gravy. Including group buffs. You don't have to buff the group if you're helping in other ways.
So, your sets need to be things that help you do your job. Lich, or Warlock do that. Even Trappings of Invigoration can be useful (though, I haven't tested that one.)
You can be an extremely selfish tank, go survival on both sets, and let the DPS scramble for buffs. That's entirely up to you. And I won't judge you for leaving your DPS out to dry, I've got a selfish Sorc Tank that slots ebon, and everything after that is up to the DPS and the Healer to avoid dying.
But, you can run Lich. You can run IA if you want, for 4 man content. It's kinda fun. You can run Alkosh, which is a DPS set, in case that was unclear. But, it's nice to see it on the tank. Hell, I do have a Sanctuary + Ebon Christmas Tree build.
You can do a lot with second 5pc bonus on your tank. You're not confined to two survival sets.
Right now, on live, as the game exists, a DK running Plague or Eben + Lich Weapons and Jewlery is a very strong setup.
Hell, you could probably get away with Hatchling's Shell + Lich on a DK now, that'd be disgusting.
Completely disagree with you, if you get to a certain point in tanking you only focus on utility and support sets since you know how to survive and sustain with the other tools you have. I see few scenarios at end game tanking where ebon + alkosh (PA for offtank instead of ebon) aren't used if you want to contribute maximum for your group. The only thing that's dynamic is the monster sets since different ones can be useful in different scenarios, but that almost always come down to warden or thurvokun anyway (no, blood spawn is not the best tanking set).
But you're maybe talking about vet dungeon non dlc runs, then you could go in naked if you want.